logo
'In my country, murder is normal': Man who is in jail for his niece's honour killing sues ITV for accusing him of ordering her rape

'In my country, murder is normal': Man who is in jail for his niece's honour killing sues ITV for accusing him of ordering her rape

Daily Mail​27-05-2025

A man serving life in jail for ordering the murder of his niece in a so called 'honour killing' is suing ITV over claims he also allowed her rape.
Banaz Mahmod was aged 20 when she was killed on the orders of her father Mahmod Mahmod and uncle Ari Mahmod after she left an abusive arranged marriage.
Other family members and friends were recruited to carry out the murder and she was raped by three of her cousins before being strangled.
Uncle Mahmod, 69, is now suing over a 2020 drama called Honour, starring Keeley Hawes, and a 2012 documentary on the killing.
He claims that in his Iraqi Muslim culture that 'honour' murders are acceptable but accusation of rape have destroyed his reputation, the Sun reports.
While representing himself, he told the High Court that he been attacked in jail and that his family were victims of reprisals.
'In my country murder is normal — after served time you have a new opportunity,' he said speaking via videolink from HMP Whitemoor in Cambridgeshire earlier this month
'In my culture the main things they react against me was the rape allegation.'
Speaking about himself in the third person, he added: 'Almost all statements left no doubts the allegation of rape was with Ari's blessing. In the Islamic community rape is taboo — it is the highest level of crime.'
Banaz fled an abusive arranged marriage, which she had at the age of 17, after being continuously raped and beaten by her husband, who was ten years older.
She returned to live in the family home in south London and then fell in love with a Kurdish man, Rahmat Suleimani.
In the months leading up to her disappearance, Banaz reported to police five times that her family wanted her dead, but no action was taken.
She was deemed to have brought 'shame' on the family with her father and uncle hatching an evil plan to have her killed in the most savage way possible to restore their 'honour' and 'reputation' within the community.
Banaz suffered horrific sexual violence prior to being strangled to death at the family home in January 2006.
Her body was then stuffed into a suitcase and taken to Birmingham , where it was buried in the garden of an abandoned home.
Following the discovery of her body, Banaz's father, uncle and other relatives and family associates were charged with her murder or for conspiring in it.
In 2007, following a three-month trial at the Old Bailey, her father Mahmod Mahmod, was found guilty of murder and sentenced to 20 years in prison.
Her uncle, Ari Mahmod, was also found guilty of murder and sentenced to 23 years.
Her cousin, Mohamad Hama also admitted murder and was sentenced to at least 17 years in prison.
Three years later, Banaz's cousins Omar Hussain and Mohamad Saleh Ali, who carried out the killing, were extradited from Iraq and given life sentences of 22 years and 21 years respectively after being found guilty of murder.
Honour tells the story of DCI Caroline Goode's investigation into the young woman's fate after she was reported missing from her home by Mr Suleimani.
Keely Hawes plays the role of DCI Goode and graphically captures the police officer's dedication to catching the culprits, the obstacles she faced and how the chance sighting of a freezer from a helicopter led to their convictions.
Speaking to MailOnline in August 2024, DCI Goode said: 'This was the most complex and difficult investigation I have ever been involved in. From the outset we were met by a conspiracy of silence from the Iraqi-Kurdish community in the UK and had very little evidence to go on.
'The case was unusual because normally when you investigate a murder you are trying to get justice for the family. But in this instance, the family weren't interested in getting justice as they were the ones who ordered her killing.'
It is unclear why Ari Mahmod was allowed to sue the television network as convicted murderers usually have no reputation to defend.
Representing ITV, Barrister Ben Gallop said: 'The claimant is a convicted murderer. This is rare for a claim of libel as the possibility of any damage to his reputation is limited due to his pre-existing bad reputation.'
A judgement in the case is expected next month.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Sick robbers who broke into war veteran's home and threatened him with a knife before taking off with his MEDALS are jailed
Sick robbers who broke into war veteran's home and threatened him with a knife before taking off with his MEDALS are jailed

Daily Mail​

time34 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Sick robbers who broke into war veteran's home and threatened him with a knife before taking off with his MEDALS are jailed

A pair of robbers who broke into the home of a vulnerable war veteran and threatened him with a knife before stealing his medals have been jailed. Peter Ratcliffe, 48, and Ann Marie Simpson, 38, broke into the pensioner's accommodation in South Shields in July 2023. They pushed the elderly man to the floor and threatened him with a knife before stealing his prized possessions including his bank cards, his passport and his wedding ring. The robbers also made off with the veteran's war medals. The victim was not left with any serious injuries but was extremely shaken and traumatised from the robbery, a court heard. Ratcliffe and Simpson were identified by CCTV and were arrested just hours later. Officers found clothing which matched the outfits being warn by the robbers on the CCTV footage, Chronicle Live reported. They were both charged with robbery and remanded into custody the following day. Earlier this year, both pleaded guilty at Newcastle Crown Court. Ann Marie Simpson, 38, was sentenced to five years and four months imprisonment after pleading guilty to robbery and witness intimidation Simpson also admitted one count of witness intimidation after she sent a letter to the victim telling him to drop the charges against them. On Friday, both were both jailed at a sentencing hearing at Newcastle Crown Court. Ratcliffe, of Trinity Walk, South Shields, was sentenced to seven years and four months behind bars. Simpson, of Johnson Street, also South Shields, was sentenced to five years and four months imprisonment. Both were given a ten-year restraining order, preventing them from contacting the victim. Sergeant Kimberley Ball, of Northumbria Police said: 'This was a cruel and targeted attack on an elderly man in his own home – because of his vulnerabilities. 'I want to thank the victim for his patience and courage throughout this entire process, which I know has been extremely difficult. 'I have no doubt the streets of South Tyneside are safer now these two criminals are behind bars where they belong.'

Innocent Arizona grandmother arrested and hauled away to jail while gardening after being mistaken for fugitive
Innocent Arizona grandmother arrested and hauled away to jail while gardening after being mistaken for fugitive

Daily Mail​

time2 hours ago

  • Daily Mail​

Innocent Arizona grandmother arrested and hauled away to jail while gardening after being mistaken for fugitive

An innocent Arizona grandmother wrongfully arrested by US Marshals is suing the government after she was bundled into the back of an unmarked car while gardening. Penny McCarthy, 67, had been working in her front yard last March when six agents approached her with their guns drawn and arrested her. The 67-year-old had been misidentified by the authorities as a 'Carole Rozak' and despite her desperate pleas she was taken in. In a federal lawsuit filed June 10, McCarthy says she spent the next 24 hours in their custody as she begged with agents they had the wrong person. According to the filing, McCarthy said she was fingerprinted and had her DNA taken before she was bused to a federal detention center in Florence. McCarthy said in the filing that over the course of those 24 hours she was strip searched three times. During a press conference in which she recalling the incident McCarthy started to cry and described to reporters how she is a survivor of domestic child abuse. She said: 'I have to be strip searched by one woman for something I didn't do, and then I'm told I'm going to be detained.' She filed her suit under the Fourth Amendment which protects citizens from unreasonable false arrests. The filing says she has asked for compensatory and punitive damages against the US Marshals Service for their 'tortious and unconstitutional acts and omissions'. She is also filing under the Federal Tort Claims Act, which allows people to sue the federal government when federal officers cause them harm. McCarthy says she was kept in a 'cold cell' overnight before being back in court the next day for an identity hearing, the complaint adds. Her attorneys said in the filing: 'Eventually the government confirmed that Penny's fingerprints and DNA do not match Rozak's and ended the proceedings.' The judge released her after prosecutors asked for more time to get the results of her fingerprints and DNA. The government then dismissed the case against her. She now says she fears being left alone and taking her dog for a walk. McCarthy added that the psychological effects from the ordeal caused her to sell her home and move out of the state. She said: 'I'm still afraid that one day I will be pulled over and again mistaken for a criminal. 'I'm suing because I don't want this to happen to anyone else. Unless someone is held responsible, someone else will go through this same nightmare.' McCarthy spoke with ABC15 after the incident, telling the outlet: 'I truly felt like I was being kidnapped.' Terrifying body camera video showed the moment she was arrested by rifle-wielding officers who barked commands at her. The federal agents rolled up to McCarthy's Phoenix home with guns drawn and immediately told her to put her 'hands up!'. 'We have an arrest warrant,' a federal agent is heard saying on the video. 'For me?' McCarthy responded. 'Yes. For you,' the officer said. 'Who am I?' she asked, seemingly wanting the officers to confirm that she was in fact the person they were looking to apprehend. Multiple agents can be heard in the clip screaming at her and giving her conflicting orders. 'Turn away. Turn around. Turn away. We'll discuss it later. Turn away. You're gonna get hit,' they said. McCarthy is being represented by the Institute for Justice, a nonprofit law firm, who specialize in cases involving abuses of power. Senior Attorney Paul Avelar said: 'The officers' misidentifying Penny was inexcusable and violated state and federal law. 'To make matters worse, even if Penny had been the fugitive they were looking for, the officers' over-the-top display of force was uncalled for, given that the fugitive was wanted only for failing to check in with a probation officer after being released from prison twenty-five years ago for nonviolent crimes.' Rozak, the woman agents said Penny was, was wanted for an outstanding parole violation from 1999. All the crimes she served time for were non-violent in nature, but after her release, she failed to meet with any federal probation officer, according to records. In a statement the US Marshals Service in Arizona said: 'The US Marshals Service acknowledges that Ms Penny McCarthy was mistakenly arrested.'

'A big win for everyone': Harvey Weinstein accusers express relief after guilty verdict
'A big win for everyone': Harvey Weinstein accusers express relief after guilty verdict

The Guardian

time4 hours ago

  • The Guardian

'A big win for everyone': Harvey Weinstein accusers express relief after guilty verdict

Weinstein was found guilty of sexually assaulting Miriam Haley, but was acquitted of a second charge of sexually assaulting Kaja Sokola by a jury in Manhattan on Wednesday. After a three-week trial, Hayley and Sokola told the press they hoped their testimonies would encourage other victims of sexual assault to speak up. The verdict delivered against Weinstein follows two earlier convictions on similar charges, one of which was overturned on appeal

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store