‘Gone Girl' kidnap hoaxer Sherri Papini now claims she really WAS abducted by ex & didn't tell cops truth for key reason
Keith Papini quickly took measures to find the 34-year-old mum of two, tracing her phone to her last location and driving straight there, but his panic soon turned to horror when he found her phone lying on the side of the road.
7
7
It was November 2nd, 2016, in California, and Keith, who was the prime suspect in her disappearance at the time for police, was doing the media rounds begging for his wife's return to him and their two children.
'If she is listening, I want to say, 'We are trying. We are trying the best we can, and I am sorry I'm not there,' he said in a tearful interview.
'I'm doing everything I can, and I love you.'
News of the disappearance dominated the news across the world, as hundreds of local residents took time out of their lives to find the mum and bring her home.
Three weeks later, on Thanksgiving, Sherri was miraculously discovered 150 miles away from her home running across a church car park with a chain around her waist.
Her hands were zip-tied together, her body was bruised and burned, her nose was broken, and she had been branded with a hot iron.
Sherri spent weeks with police going over the details of her kidnapping, claiming two Hispanic women had taken her and put her in a small dark room, beating her and starving her until the abductors had an argument and one decided to release Sherri.
Her memory was foggy, and the trauma she endured seemed severe, as she recounted the incident to police, her husband stood by her every step of the way.
Sherri claimed to have overheard a conversation about a 'buyer', implying the two women intended to sell her into sex trafficking.
It seemed like a miracle that Sherri was let go, considering the extent of the abuse she endured, and law enforcement was quick to hunt for the perpetrators as they feared it was part of a larger pattern of human trafficking.
7
Sherri Papini admits she's 'embarrassed' she staged kidnapping during tearful police interrogation
7
Web of lies
But after years of dead ends, the two women were never caught, in fact, they never even existed.
Now, 42, Sherri has been dubbed the real life 'Gone Girl' after faking her own kidnapping to run away with her ex-partner.
In 2020 police found DNA on her clothes that matched with her ex James Reyes.
She knew what she was doing in that moment. And to this day, I remember that time, and it hurts. I'll forever remember that.
Keith PapiniSherri's Husband
When they tracked him down, he was quick to reveal that Sherri had asked him to pick her up at a staged abduction site, then to take her back to his home in Costa Mesa, hundreds of miles down the coast.
She'd even asked him to help her injure herself to bolster her kidnapping claims by branding her and holding a hockey stick up so she could run into it and break her nose.
Sherri's 'Gone Girl' Timeline
2 November 2016: Sherri Papini was reported missing after failing to return from a jog near her home in Mountain Gate, California. She also missed picking up her children from daycare.
24 November 2016 (Thanksgiving Day): Papini was found around 146 miles away in Yolo County, near Woodland, California. She was discovered with injuries and restraints, claiming she had been abducted by two Hispanic women.
August 2020: Papini was interviewed by a federal agent and a Shasta County Sheriff's detective, where she continued to maintain her story of being kidnapped by two Hispanic women.
3 March 2022: Sherri Papini was arrested on charges of making false statements to federal law enforcement and mail fraud. Authorities revealed she had been staying with a former boyfriend in Costa Mesa, California, and had inflicted injuries on herself.
April 2022: Papini signed a plea agreement.
19 September 2022: Sherri Papini was sentenced to 18 months in prison, followed by 36 months of supervised release. She was also ordered to pay $309,902 in restitution.
8 November 2022: Papini reported to federal prison at the Victorville Federal Correctional Complex in Adelanto, California, to begin serving her 18-month sentence.
James was never tried for a connection to the crime and three weeks after he 'kidnapped' Sherri, she wanted to return home as she missed her kids.
Before dropping her off, Sherri asked him to brand her with the word 'EXODUS' using a wood burning tool.
Looking back, Keith reveals the heartbreak he felt when his wife Sherri came home, telling him, 'I have to live with the fact that you never found me.'
'I remember I was pleading with her,' Keith says now. 'Like, 'I did everything I could, I'm so sorry you had to go through that.''
'She knew what she was doing in that moment. And to this day, I remember that time, and it hurts. I'll forever remember that.'
Sherri was ultimately charged with 34 counts of mail fraud and one count of making false statements in 2022, and spent ten months in jail.
Her husband, Keith, divorced her soon after she was sentenced and has custody of the children.
7
Bold new claims
Now, Sherri has claimed all is not as it seems in a new Investigation Discovery's docuseries, Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie.
"Haven't you ever lied? And then, has the lie been blown up?" Sherri said in the trailer.
"I went missing in 2016, was gone for 22 days. I was tortured; I was branded; I was chained to a wall. All that is true. I did keep some secrets from you, though."
Now, the mum-of-two claims she was in fact kidnapped by her lover James Reyes but made up the two Hispanic women as she was terrified about what her husband would do if he found out about the affair.
"I was concealing an affair from my husband, who (was) threatening to take everything from me if he found out that I was having any involvement with another man," she said.
Now she claims she went to meet James to break things off, but alleges he soon turned violent.
"I remember waking up briefly in the back of the vehicle and not being able to even keep my eyes open," she said.
She claims the next thing she knew it was dark and she was being carried out of the car into a house.
"I just remember thinking, 'This is not where I'm supposed to be. I'm supposed to be picking my kids up from day care. I am not supposed to be here,'" she adds.
"The injuries that occurred… the bites on my thigh, the footprint on my back, the brand, the melting of my skin — I am telling you there was no consent."
Sherri alleges that James then had her chained up to a pole inside his home so she could not escape.
'I wanted to leave,' Sherri claimed. 'So I tried to pull one of the boards off the window and James came in and hit me in the face. And that's the first bruise that I got ... And after being knocked out and waking up, that's when the chain was around my waist, secured with a padlock attached to a cable that was attached to a pole in the closet.'
Every injury, every incident, the description of the room down to every last bit of fragment, was not a lie.
Sherri Papini
Just before she 'escaped,' Sherri says she had a conversation with James, who agreed to let her go on the condition she lied about what really happened and blamed two Hispanic women for the abduction.
Her claims continued: 'James had let me off the chain.
"I said, my husband's going to find me. He's never going to stop looking for you ... You need to let me go. He was like, 'Well, there's too much has happened.'
"So it all came down to me. It all came down to my cover-up, and that's [when] I agreed to ... make up that someone else did it.'
"I lied about James' identity. I lied about the man who abducted me to keep him a secret," she said in the docuseries. James denies these claims.
"It wasn't the right choice and I know that... I wish I would've told the truth from the day I was in the hospital — that it was James," she continued.
7
"I wasn't thinking about my neighbor that was searching for me. I wasn't thinking about the churches that were lighting candlelit vigils," she continued. "I was thinking about myself."
"Every injury, every incident, the description of the room down to every last bit of fragment, was not a lie," she adds.
Mother knows best?
Keith, who has full custody of the children they share, was accused by Sherri throughout the show of being abusive; he heavily denies these claims.
And it seems even Sherri's own mum doesn't believe her new story.
Speaking to the filmmakers, Loretta Graeff said: "No, it wasn't a kidnapping."
"My daughter was very, very unhappy in her marriage. She wanted some kind of happiness.
"When he showed up and Sherri went with him, it wasn't a kidnapping, it was more 'I want to have a little bit of happiness in my life because it's been very, very hard.'"
"She needed to get away from him and she didn't abandon her children," Graeff told People.
Where is Sherri now?
Sherri was released from prison in August 2023 and transferred to a residential reentry facility in Sacramento County, California.
She left the home that October — eight months early — and will remain on supervised release until late 2026.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
26 minutes ago
- The Independent
Frank Caprio, Rhode Island judge who drew a huge online audience with his compassion, dies at age 88
Frank Caprio, a retired municipal judge in Rhode Island who found online fame as a caring jurist and host of ' Caught in Providence,″ died. He was 88. His official social media accounts said Wednesday the he "passed away peacefully" after 'a long and courageous battle with pancreatic cancer.' Caprio billed his courtroom as a place 'where people and cases are met with kindness and compassion." He was known for dismissing tickets or showing kindness even when he handed out justice. Last week, Caprio posted a short video on Facebook about how he had 'a setback," was back in the hospital and was asking that people 'remember me in your prayers.' Caprio's show was filmed in his courtroom and featured his folksy humor and compassion. Clips from the show have had more than 1 billion views on social media. During his time on the bench, Caprio developed a persona at odds with many TV judges — more sympathetic and less confrontational and judgmental. In his bite-sized segments on YouTube, Caprio is often seen empathizing with those in his courtroom. Many of the infractions are also relatively minor, from failing to use a turn signal to a citation for a loud party. Caprio also used his fame to address issues like unequal access to the judicial system. 'The phrase 'With liberty and justice for all' represents the idea that justice should be accessible to everyone. However it is not,' Caprio said in one video. 'Almost 90% of low-income Americans are forced to battle civil issues like health care, unjust evictions, veterans benefits and, yes, even traffic violations, alone.' Caprio's upbeat take on the job of a judge drew him millions of views. His most popular videos have been those where he calls children to the bench to help pass judgment on their parents. One shows him listening sympathetically to a woman whose son was killed and then dismissing her tickets and fines of $400. In another clip, after dismissing a red-light violation for a bartender who was making $3.84 per hour, Caprio urged those watching the video not to duck out on their bills. 'If anyone's watching I want them to know you better not eat and run because you're going to get caught and the poor people who are working hard all day for three bucks an hour are going to have to pay your bill," he said. On social media, his family described Caprio 'as a devoted husband, father, grandfather, great grandfather and friend.' 'Beloved for his compassion, humility, and unwavering belief in the goodness of people, Judge Caprio touched the lives of millions through his work in the courtroom and beyond,' the family wrote. 'His warmth, humor, and kindness left an indelible mark on all who knew him.' State and local politicians mourned his passing and celebrated his life. 'Judge Caprio not only served the public well, but he connected with them in a meaningful way, and people could not help but respond to his warmth and compassion,' Rhode Island Gov. Dan McKee said in a statement. 'He was more than a jurist — he was a symbol of empathy on the bench, showing us what is possible when justice is tempered with humanity.' Robert Leonard, who co-owned a restaurant with Caprio, said he was 'going to be sorely missed' and was 'all around wonderful.' 'There is nothing he wouldn't do for you if he could do it,' Leonard said. Caprio retired from Providence Municipal Court in 2023 after nearly four decades behind the bench. According to his biography, Caprio came from humble beginnings, the second of three boys growing up in the Federal Hill neighborhood of Providence, Rhode Island. 'I hope that people will take away that the institutions of government can function very well by exercising kindness, fairness, and compassion in their deliberations. We live in a very contentious society,' he said in 2017. 'I would hope that people will see that we can dispense justice without being oppressive.' ___ LeBlanc, an Associated Press journalist who retired in January, was the primary writer of this obituary. Associated Press writers Michael Casey in Boston and Audrey McAvoy in Honolulu contributed to this report.
Daily Mail
26 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Shocking report reveals Chiefs coach Andy Reid's office was shot at while he sat 15 feet away
Andy Reid 's office at the Kansas City Chiefs' practice facility was shot at in May 2024, a bombshell new report has revealed. According to the Kansas City Star, the bullet struck a wall just 15 feet from where Reed was sat. Nobody inside was struck or injured when the incident occurred shortly after midnight on May 4, 2024. No arrests have been made and the shooting is still under investigation as an aggravated assault. Police insist there is no evidence to suggest Reid was specifically targeted but his office now has bulletproof glass. More to follow.
Daily Mail
26 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The EncoChats that led cops to 'treatment room' torture chamber: Cops uncover drug gang's sound-proofed shipping container hiding dentist chair, pliers, scalpels and hedge cutters
After blasting their way inside with explosives, the sight greeting armed police was impossibly grim: a dentist's chair with leather straps by the arms and legs. Nearby, a pair of handcuffs, alongside pliers, scalpels and hedge cutters. The gangland torture chamber, located inside a sound-proofed shipping container near the Dutch village of Wouwse Plantage, could hardly have been more gruesome. Yet, as well as horror, police would have been feeling something else too - satisfaction. For the discovery was an early sign that one of the biggest international police operations in history was sure to be a triumph. The find would be one of first following a three-year investigation that successfully infiltrated EncroChat, an encrypted messaging platform used by organised criminals - many of them British. The network was breached by French and Dutch police in March 2020 and the data shared with forces across Europe, who scrambled to gather evidence on gang bosses before EncroChat users were told of the hack on June 13. Many are continuing to face their days in court, with feared Manchester gang boss Jamie Rothwell, 38, jailed just last week. Gangsters were so confident in EncroChat's encryption that they openly discussed assassinations, revenge attacks and multi-million-pound drug deals - providing a treasure trove of evidence for police to use in court. Suggestions something dark was going on at the compound near Wouwse Plantage emerged in EncroChat exchanges referring to a 'treatment room', with one message stating: 'We need cutting pliers for fingers and toes'. There were further hints to torture, including, 'We must have enough belts and tie-wraps to tie them' and, 'If I've got him on the chair, more will come. I wasn't a fan of kids. S***, by Allah, kids are allowed too.' Another text referred to the torture chamber's sound insulation, with the user writing: 'It's triple isolated. Even if you're standing next to it, you'll hear nothing.' Other worrying interceptions spoke of the 'ebi,' a reference to a high security Dutch prison. Gang members even exchanged photos of the torture room and dentist's chair with belts attached to the arm and foot supports. After putting the compound under surveillance, police spotted several men working to kit out the prison cells. When police eventually raided the site on June 22, 2020, six other containers were set up to hold prisoners, all lined with foil in an effort to deter the victims from being spotted on thermal imaging cameras. Mercifully, neither the torture chamber nor the makeshift prison were ever used, and 11 men were sentenced in 2022 to jail terms of between one and nine years. The ringleader, named by Dutch media as Roger P, 50, had previously been jailed for 15 years for cocaine trafficking and received an additional 33-month sentence. He is one of hundreds of kingpins who have been brought to justice using EncroChat evidence. Crucially, malware installed by telecoms experts allowed messages to be recovered in real time, allowing last-minute interventions that undoubtedly saved lives. While users hid under anonymous handles, many implicated themselves by sharing personal details, and even selfies. Manchester gang boss Jamie Rothwell was identified as the user 'Live Long' after sharing a photo of himself with two fingers raised to the camera. A leading member of Manchester's Anti A-Team gang, Rothwell fled abroad after a gunman sprayed bullets at him at a car wash in 2015 as part of a murderous gang feud with their rivals, the A Team. But he continued directing drug and gun smuggling operations into the UK from his bolthole in Barcelona. When shown a picture of an AK-47 rifle with magazines and ammunition, Rothwell retorted: 'Makes me hard that bro'. He also bragged of moving 300 guns, having rocket-propelled grenades, machine guns and an anti-tank gun, writing: 'I sell a lot of Glocks'. In other messages, Rothwell described his hatred for a gang rival, Leon Cullen. He wrote: 'I've give Leon a way out….he a grass…he turned on me for nothing 'Tried kill me….while my daughter there…he my only enemy….when he lands in UK that's when it starts.' And revelling in his life of crime, he told a friend: 'When you have fire in your heart you don't stop. You get addicted. You lose everyone. You turn cold, no emotions.' Rothwell was arrested by Spanish police in 2020, with video footage showing him dancing a bizarre jig after being led away. He was jailed for 43 years at Manchester Crown Court last week. He had earlier pleaded guilty to a raft of firearms and drugs charges, alongside conspiracy to cause grievous bodily harm with intent. Nine associates were jailed for a combined 163 years and 11 months. Another kingpin hauled back to Britain using EncroChat evidence was James Harding, who ran a vast £100million cocaine empire alongside his 'loyal right-hand man', Jayes Kharouti, 39. The 34-year-old, who claimed to be a high-end watch sales executive, was living in luxury at the The Nest apartment complex in Al Barari, Dubai, staying in five-star hotels and driving Bugatti and Lamborghini sports cars. But messages showed him trying to recruit a hitman to put an unnamed rival courier 'permanently out of business', arming him with a gun and ammunition for the 'full M', meaning murder. The pair were also shown to be behind a vast cocaine smuggling operation that brought a metric tonne of cocaine into the UK and generated £5m in profit in just 10 weeks. Like Rothwell, Harding openly identified himself in a series of preening selfies he sent on the same phone he used to arrange his hit. He even used his EncroChat handle to book a table for his family at the Nusr et Steakhouse in Dubai - the creation of Internet personality Nusret Gökçe, better known as 'Salt Bae'. Harding was arrested in Switzerland before being brought by private jet to London, where he was met by armed officers. His Old Bailey trial was also held under tight security before he was jailed for life with a minimum term of 32 years in June. Operation Venetic - the name for the UK's response to the EncroChat hack led by the National Crime Agency (NCA) - exposed the shocking violence drug bosses used to protect their turf. Few were more sadistic than Liverpool's hated Huyton Firm, led by lifelong gangster Vincent Coggins - supported by his savage enforcer, Paul Woodford. EncroChat messages showed Coggins and Woodford discussing their plans to murder the men they believed responsible for a 2020 raid on a house they were using to hide drugs. Coggins messaged Woodford to say he was planning to use a 'pineapple' (hand grenade) on the men, to which he replied: 'I kill him with u m8'. In another exchange, Woodford asked Coggins if he should buy a 'belter', meaning a gun. Coggins replied with: 'M8 just bought load more, we cool for tools'. Coggins went on to be jailed for 28 years for drug trafficking and blackmail, while Woodford received 24 years and six months. Vincent's brother, Francis, was arrested by police in the Netherlands earlier this year after a five-year manhunt. The ability of police to lift the lid on a previously hidden world allowed them to gather evidence to prosecute kingpins previously considered 'untouchable'. These included Jamie 'the Iceman' Stevenson, who spent decades as one of the UK's most notorious gangsters and was once accused of murdering fellow gangster Tony McGovern, the best man at his wedding. Stevenson originally rose up through the Glasgow underworld in the 1990s and became close friends with McGovern, whose family ran the so-called McGovernment mob in the north of the city. However, the pair would later fall out amid a vicious power struggle and Stevenson narrowly survived a botched attempt on his life. In 2000, McGovern himself died in an assassination that many blamed on his former friend - although the charges against him were dropped. The moment that would lead to Stevenson's final downfall came on Valentine's Day 2020, when the gangster was unwittingly caught in a police surveillance operation in Spain. Officers had been watching the bar of Alicante's four-star Melia Hotel after the arrival of David Bilsland, a Glaswegian fruit seller accused of smuggling drugs. Spanish officers tipped off by their British counterparts sent surveillance images of the meeting back to Scotland. But when photographs from the Alicante bar arrived in Scotland, investigators were stunned to see the man Bisland had been meeting was Stevenson, then one of the UK's most wanted criminals. In a T-shirt and jeans the gangster, once the key suspect in a murder case involving his own best man, was confident he passed off as just another British tourist - and completely unaware he was under surveillance. The summit was the beginning of the end for Stevenson. Until then detectives had had no idea where he was after he fled the country on police bail. They later used EncroChat messages to link Stevenson to a plot to use Bisland's Glasgow fruit business to smuggle £100m worth of cocaine into Glasgow inside boxes of bananas. Deputy Crown agent Kenny Donnelly, from the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, said the messages made it clear Stevenson had 'directed the group' and he is now serving a 20 year sentence.
