After Declaring NAEP Off-Limits, Education Department Cancels Upcoming Test
One of three long-term studies that has measured student performance in math and reading since the 1970s, the assessment was set to begin in March and run through May.
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
But Westat, a research organization handling the assessment for the National Center for Education Statistics, notified state officials Wednesday that the department had canceled the test.
'The U.S. Department of Education has decided not to fund the NAEP 2024-2025 Long-Term Trend Age 17 assessment,' Marcie Hickman, project director of the NAEP Support and Service Center, said in the email, which was shared with The 74. 'All field operations and activities will end today, February 19, 2025.'
A long-term trend assessment of 13 year olds was conducted last fall. The age 9 administration is currently underway through March 14 and will continue. Age 17 data, however, hasn't been collected since 2012, creating a significant gap in understanding older students' academic performance.
The tests, which are mandated by law, were set to be administered during the 2019-20 school year, but were canceled due to the COVID outbtreak.
This year's data would have set a new baseline for understanding how older students are recovering 'from pandemic-era learning losses,' said Andrew Ho, an assessment expert at Harvard University and former member of the National Assessment Governing Board, which sets policy for NAEP.
The cancellation, he said, could undermine the nation's trust in the assessment program.
'This is just the first direct evidence that executive actions have weakened NAEP and its 'gold standard' infrastructure for monitoring educational progress.'
Related
Every two years, NAEP tests fourth and eighth graders in math and reading. While results from 12th graders, collected last year, are expected this summer, they won't be tested again until 2028.
'NAEP's biggest gaps already are at the end of high school, telling us what kids do [or] don't know and can [or] can't do as they prepare to enter the real world,' said Chester Finn, president emeritus of the conservative Thomas B. Fordham Institute and former chair of the board. The long-term trend study has 'helped fill the gap.'
The move contradicts what department officials said last week when they canceled nearly $900 million in contracts for the Institute of Education Sciences, which includes NCES and NAEP. Madison Biedermann, a spokeswoman for the department, said at the time that work related to NAEP would not be canceled.
But Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency continues to cancel contracts it deems either wasteful or contrary to President Donald Trump's executive order related to diversity, equity and inclusion.
The fact that the test was not administered in 2016 or 2020 'does not make it a very effective longitudinal study,' Biedermann told The 74 Thursday. She did not indicate whether it would be rescheduled.
The department has also canceled a contract for conducting background checks on field staff who administer NAEP tests in schools. Biedermann did not provide details on the vendor or the amount of the contract.
'We're going to try to re-scope and re-evaluate these contracts,' she said. If they are 'absolutely necessary,' they will be re-bid, she said. 'A lot of these contracts, in our evaluation, are not cost effective and not meeting the standards.'
Biedermann maintained that the core NAEP program in fourth and eighth grade reading and math 'is not being touched.'
Results released last month showed that students continue to lose ground in reading. Eighth grade results in math were flat, and while fourth graders saw gains in math, those results were driven by the highest-performing students.
Related
The long-term trend program is different from the primary NAEP assessment because it has tested students on essentially the same items for over 50 years.
'It's important that we have the long-term trend because of the consistency of the test,' said Dan Goldhaber, director of the Center for Analysis of Longitudinal Data in Education Research at the American Institutes for Research. Measuring performance on the same test items allows officials to monitor changes across generations.
He added that at least the results from 12th graders, collected last year, will provide 'information about how kids are doing at the end of high school.'
The 74's Senior Writer Greg Toppo contributed to this report.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
14 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump Cuts ‘Lifeline' for 80,000 California Migrant Students
This article was originally published in CalMatters. This story was originally published by CalMatters. Sign up for their newsletters. When Yvette Medina was growing up in the labor camps of California's Central Valley, she'd often accompany her father to the bank to cash checks. 'He'd tell me, 'You should be a bank teller. You're inside all day, out of the sun,'' Medina recalled. 'For me, growing up, there weren't a lot of options or things to aspire to. My parents just didn't know what was out there.' Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter A program called Mini-Corps changed all that. Mini-Corps, part of the state's Migrant Education program, sends bilingual tutors to schools and labor camps to help children whose parents work in California's agricultural fields, dairies, fisheries and timberlands. Medina credits Mini-Corps tutors with getting her through high school and helping her enroll in college, where she ultimately earned a teaching credential. But now the Migrant Education program is defunded, at least temporarily, after President Donald Trump withheld its grant money on July 1. Several other education programs were also halted, including after-school centers, English learner programs and professional development for teachers. In California, the cuts totaled more than $810 million. The U.S. Department of Education said it would not release the money until it completed a review of the programs to ensure 'taxpayer resources are spent in accordance with the President's priorities and the Department's statutory responsibilities.' Last week it released the after-school grants, but nothing else. The department didn't say when that review would happen. Meanwhile, California and 23 other states have sued, saying that Trump had no right to withhold the money because it had already been appropriated by Congress. Almost every county in California has Migrant Education programs. Kern has the largest number of migrant students — nearly 5,000 — but even urban counties like San Francisco have at least a few dozen. Now, programs for those students have been put on hold or cut back. Some school districts scraped together money to keep the programs running through summer, but others canceled programs altogether and laid off staff. The Butte County Office of Education, which oversees the Mini-Corps program for the state, laid off more than 400 employees as a result of the cuts. The Santa Clara County Office of Education laid off 22 staff and shuttered many services for migrant students, including college visits, a math and science program, a debate tournament and summer programs. 'Our hope is that we find some other finding source,' said Tad Alexander, deputy superintendent of the Butte County Office of Education. 'But right now it feels like they're trying to bleed it out.' On the move with the harvest Nearly 80,000 students in California are migrants, moving every few months with their parents for work, according to a recent report by West Ed, an educational research and development organization. That could mean winter in Porterville for the orange harvest, spring in Salinas for strawberries, summer in Madera for peaches, fall in Oroville for almonds. Some families even venture to Washington for cherry season, or to Mexico between harvests. The majority of migrant farm workers are legally authorized to live and work in the U.S., according to WestEd. Although most migrant students are in school at least part of the time, some aren't enrolled in school at all. They're either working in the fields themselves, caring for younger siblings or otherwise helping their families. Migrant students, many of whom are English learners, tend to struggle academically. Of those who are enrolled in school, only 16% met the state's math standard and 24% met the English language arts standard last year. But migrant students had relatively high graduation and college-going rates – primarily community college – in part thanks to the Migrant Education program. Students can get help with reading, math, science, English language skills, one-on-one tutoring, health and social-emotional support, and help enrolling in college and navigating life after high school. For nearly a century, the U.S. has offered services and protections to farm laborers from other countries. The Bracero program, an agreement between the U.S. and Mexico starting in 1942, allowed Mexican laborers to legally work in U.S. agricultural fields. That program ended in 1964, but President Lyndon Johnson stepped in to enact a host of other programs that benefitted migrant laborers, including the landmark Immigration and Nationality Act and the Migrant Education program. Early in his career, Johnson had worked as a teacher at a school along the Texas-Mexico border where most of his students were the children of immigrants. He helped teach them English, started sports and literary clubs and drove them to nearby towns for athletic and speech competitions. He used his first paycheck to buy playground equipment. That experience was the inspiration for the Migrant Education program as well as Johnson's other anti-poverty programs from that era, according to the National Archives. The Migrant Education program served about 270,000 students nationwide last year, and is among the smallest of the federal education grants. Of all the programs Trump defunded on July 1, Migrant Education has the lowest price tag: $121 million for California, $375 million nationwide. 'Dark times' De-funding the program has had a chilling effect on migrant families everywhere, said Debra Benitez, director of migrant education services for WestEd. Most migrant families deeply value education, she said, and are willing to make extraordinary sacrifices for their children to go to school. The Migrant Education program allows that to happen, she said. 'This is a population of individuals who've dedicated their lives to agricultural labor, very difficult work which we know historically no one else is willing to do,' said Benitez, whose grandparents were migrant laborers in the San Joaquin Valley. 'All they want is for their children to be educated.' She believes that defunding Migrant Education will ultimately hurt the economy because immigrants play such a crucial role in farming, dairy, fishing and other industries. 'These families who have historically worked as migratory farm laborers, their plight has long been hard and arduous. But they're proud to contribute to California's economy,' Benitez said. 'And then there's the human side of it. It's painful. These feel like dark times.' Bilingual teacher pipeline Mini-Corps works with 28 colleges and universities in the state to train tutors to work in schools and camps. Tutors earn $17.25 an hour and gain classroom experience that can give them a leg up for a teaching career. Most are bilingual Spanish speakers, but some speak Punjabi, Chinese, Hmong and other languages of California migrants. The idea is to help migrant children while also creating a pipeline of bilingual teachers. Daniel Martinez-Osornio worked as a Mini-Corps tutor for migrant children when he was a student at Cal State San Marcos. He spent his time at schools in Vista and San Marcos, helping students with classwork but also 'building connections, helping kids so they didn't feel called out or uncomfortable,' he said. Having grown up in Salinas, Martinez-Osornio understood the challenges that migrant students faced. Although his family didn't move frequently for work, many of his cousins and friends did. With more than 4,300 migrant students, Monterey County has one of the highest percentages of migrant students in the state. 'I know it's tough. The parents are working all day, and kids have to be home to take care of their siblings — or be taken care of by siblings,' he said. 'The kids just want someone to talk to about their day, what's going on, express their feelings. They just want to have some happiness.' Martinez-Osornio was so inspired by his work in the Mini-Corps program that he decided to become a teacher. He recently earned his credential at Stanford and hopes to be a bilingual elementary teacher in Salinas. He was shocked when he heard that the federal government stopped funding the program. 'It breaks my heart,' he said. 'I just couldn't believe it, considering the impact it has on kids and families. It's generational impact.' Waiting and hoping Some counties have been able to salvage their summer migrant programs without laying off staff, at least for now. The Fresno County Office of Education, which has the state's third-largest migrant program with 6,300 students, has converted half of its summer programming to a hybrid virtual format. Instead of two weeks at an outdoor education camp called Scout Island, students will spend one week there and one week on other activities, including online learning. Fresno County Superintendent of Schools Michele Cantwell-Copher said her office would continue to help migrant students as best it can, but it will likely have to make deep program cuts. '(This program) is a lifeline for thousands of students in Fresno County,' she said. 'The students who are impacted by cuts to migrant services are the same students whose families put food on our tables. We will continue to advocate fiercely to ensure these young people get the support they deserve.' Imperial County, which has 3,543 migrant students, received nearly $5 million last year for its migrant education program. Nonetheless, the county doesn't plan any layoffs or program cuts, in part because County Superintendent of Schools Todd Finnell said he's confident that the federal money will come through eventually. Also, the program is worth keeping even without the federal resources, he said. 'Our students and families benefit significantly from the program and any reduction or elimination would certainly be a loss in our mission to improve the quality of life in Imperial County,' Finnell said. 'Hope that you didn't have before' Yvette Medina, whose parents are laborers from Mexico, moved every few months as a child. Her parents picked cherries, tomatoes, watermelon, asparagus and apricots, sometimes working in packing plants in Stockton or Tracy. Medina didn't spend an entire year at one school until her senior year in high school, when she stayed with an aunt in Manteca. Mentors in the Migrant Education program helped her enroll at Sacramento State, and inspired her to become a Mini-Corps tutor herself. 'In a world where you feel lost, it's another person who speaks your language, reflects your culture,' Medina said. 'They're in college, they're role models. You think, oh my gosh, I want to be like that too.' Medina worked as an elementary school teacher for several years after graduating, and now runs the Mini-Corps program at the Butte County Office of Education. In addition to running that program, the office oversees Migrant Education for 22 counties between Sacramento and the Oregon border. 'Mini-Corps changed my life, it changed my family's life,' Medina said. 'It introduced me to a profession where I'd have access to a salary, benefits, networks. It gives you hope that you didn't have before.' This article was originally published on CalMatters and was republished under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives license. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
EU strikes trade deal with US but final decision still to be made on alcohol
The United States and European Union have agreed a trade deal in which a 15% tariff is set to be placed on most EU exports entering the US market, though a final decision is yet to be made on alcohol. Yesterday (27 July), the EU Commission announced that besides the 15% levy, the US and EU had also agreed on "zero-for-zero tariffs" on several goods, including "certain agricultural products". When asked in a press conference following the deal whether the zero-for-zero agreement included alcohol, spirits and wine, president of the Commission Ursula von der Leyen said "no decision' had been made yet. She added that the topic was something that would be discussed in the 'next days". In the Commission's statement, the president added that the deal creates "more predictability for our businesses". She added: "We are ensuring immediate tariff relief. This will have a clear impact on the bottom lines of our companies. And with this deal, we are securing access to our largest export market. At the same time, we will give better access for American products in our market. "This will benefit European consumers and make our businesses more competitive. This deal provides a framework from which we will further reduce tariffs on more products, address non-tariff barriers, and cooperate on economic security." Secretary general of The Brewers of Europe, Julia Leferman said that the United States is the "second most significant export market for European breweries, accounting for over a quarter of total European beer exports." She added: 'As it emerges that no decision has yet been taken on the treatment of alcoholic beverages and negotiations continue on the list of products - including agri-food, that could be covered by a zero-for-zero arrangement - The Brewers of Europe calls on EU and US negotiators to put beer on this list and also remove beer from the aluminium derivatives tariffs set by the US." Reflecting on the news, president of the European wine trade body Comité Européen des Entreprises Vins (CEEV) Marzia Varvaglione said: "We are still awaiting the full details of the agreement reached today and are watching with great anticipation the outcome of the upcoming negotiations regarding the list of products that will be included under the zero-for-zero tariff arrangement, among them some agricultural products' "We truly believe the trade of wine is of great benefit for both EU and U.S. companies, and it must be included in the zero-for-zero tariff arrangement. "And it's not just the EU side saying this - our U.S. counterparts have also been strong advocates for protecting this vital exchange" Varvaglione added. Meanwhile, secretary general of CEEV, Ignacio Sánchez Recarte said that it is "encouraging to know that we may be just days away from putting an end to the trade uncertainty that has weighed on our sector in recent months." He added: 'However, the consequences of failing to include wine in the final zero-for-zero deal would be severe. "We therefore call on negotiators to take decisive action: Include wine in the zero-for-zero agreement and safeguard a trade that has always delivered value, growth, and cooperation," Recarte said. President and CEO of the Distilled Spirits Council (DISCUS), Chris Swonger said the deal was "great news for US and EU relations, and we greatly appreciate President Trump's leadership." He added: 'We are optimistic that in the days ahead this positive meeting and agreement will lead to a return to zero-for-zero tariffs for US and EU spirits products". Just Drinks has also contacted spiritsEurope and FoodDrinkEurope for comment. "EU strikes trade deal with US but final decision still to be made on alcohol" was originally created and published by Just Drinks, a GlobalData owned brand. The information on this site has been included in good faith for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely, and we give no representation, warranty or guarantee, whether express or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Experts issue dire warning about disturbing plan proposed by White House: 'Difficult — if not impossible — to reverse'
Experts issue dire warning about disturbing plan proposed by White House: 'Difficult — if not impossible — to reverse' The National Petroleum Reserve-Alaska may sound like a high-security fuel depot, but it's actually a massive stretch of land home to millions of animals and a vital player in keeping the planet cool. And now, it's under serious threat. What's happening? On June 17, the Trump administration proposed opening nearly 82% of the NPR-A to oil and gas drilling. This includes areas specifically designated for their ecological and cultural significance. The plan would expand development from 11.7 million acres to 18.5 million, forever altering regions vital to the survival of Arctic caribou herds, nesting grounds for over 4.5 million shorebirds, and denning sites for polar bears and wolverines. "The decisions made today will shape the future of the Arctic," conservation biologist and molecular ecologist Mariah Meek warned in an article for The Conversation, calling the plan "difficult — if not impossible — to reverse." Why is this concerning? This part of Alaska is one of the last intact ecosystems in the United States, and disrupting it could cause ripple effects far beyond its borders. Drilling infrastructure such as roads and pipelines fragments habitats, alters water flows, and weakens the very permafrost that supports it. This means greater erosion and the release of large amounts of heat-trapping pollution locked in soil. And that's before factoring in the pollution added by the oil operations themselves. Even animals that survive the direct effects often suffer indirect ones. A study published in the journal Ecology and Evolution found caribou mothers avoid calving near roads, while research shared in the journal Nature described how industrial noise can stop birds from nesting. Similar concerns are playing out across the Arctic. Sea ice has plummeted to near-record lows, and heat advisories have even been issued in Alaska, a state once defined by its cold. What's being done to push back? The Biden administration supported scaled-back drilling in this region, such as with the Willow project, which was met with significant outcry. Public pressure and scientific reports helped reduce the scope of that plan. The same tactics can be used again. As an individual, the best thing you can do is stay informed through groups such as The Wilderness Society, which released a report outlining the reserve's ecological value. You can also contact your representatives to express concern about drilling expansion. Do you worry about air pollution in your town? All the time Often Only sometimes Never Click your choice to see results and speak your mind. Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the the daily Crossword
