Federal judge blocks Trump administration efforts to stop congestion pricing
A Manhattan federal judge has blocked the federal government from ending congestion pricing before the end of an ongoing lawsuit — issuing a preliminary injunction against Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and the U.S. Department of Transportation on Wednesday.
The order, issued by Judge Lewis Liman, comes one day after he issued a temporary restraining order in the case, blocking any such action for two weeks.
The injunction indefinitely prevents Duffy or his agency from acting on their claims that they can unilaterally revoke authorization toll — and blocks any of the so-called 'compliance actions' Duffy has threatened — until Liman rules on the legality of USDOT's efforts to end the congestion pricing program.
'For the avoidance of doubt, [Duffy and the USDOT] are enjoined from taking any of the 'compliance measures' … including withholding federal funds, approvals, or authorizations from New York state or local agencies to enforce compliance with or implement … [their] purported termination of the Tolling Program,' the 109-page order concludes.
Speaking to reporters shortly after the order was filed Paige Graves, MTA's general counsel, said she hadn't yet read the injunction in full.
'I have not looked at the details of his decision, but it's positive news,' Graves said.
The congestion toll first began in January — a requirement of New York State's 2019 Traffic Mobility Act, meant to both reduce congestion and back $15 billion in bonds toward specific MTA projects.
Duffy first claimed the authority to unilaterally end the toll weeks later, in February. When the MTA sued, Duffy gave Gov. Hochul a March 21 deadline to end the toll. Duffy then extended the deadline to April 20, then to May 21.
As the toll remained in place on May 21, Duffy — in a letter to Hochul — threatened to withhold federal funds for any highway project in Manhattan, refuse to approve Manhattan projects under the National Environmental Policy Act, and refuse to greenlight any funding amendments from the New York Metropolitan Transportation Council — unless Hochul ended the toll.
In issuing Tuesday's restraining order, Liman said New York stood to suffer irreparable harms from the feds' demands, including the 'delay of numerous public works projects,' 'harm to the bond market' and the 'undermining [of] the authority of a sovereign state' that had democratically passed the law requiring the toll.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Air traffic controller says its ‘safe to fly' but ‘avoid Newark'
Veteran air traffic controller Jonathan Stewart affirmed to the public during a recent television appearance that it is 'safe to fly,' but added that he would avoid the embattled Newark Liberty International Airport. 'It's safe to fly. I would probably avoid Newark until something else is done,' Stewart, a supervisory air traffic controller, said during his Friday night appearance on NewsNation's 'Elizabeth Vargas Reports.' Stewart's remarks come as the New Jersey airport has dealt with communication blackouts and ongoing staff shortages, prompting concerns from travelers and public officials. The airport, one of the largest near New York City, had at least two radar outages this month, shining a spotlight on outdated technology, and has a deficit of air traffic controllers. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said this week that 16 new air traffic controllers were placed in training to boost staffing figures. The workers were moved to the Philadelphia Terminal Radar Approach Control (TRACON), where Newark airport's operations are situated. Additionally, he said a new runway would be opened at the airport soon to combat congestion. 'The concrete has been laid. I think they're just striping. They are just striping right now,' Duffy told reporters during a press conference on Wednesday. 'We have a target date of June 15 of bringing the runway online.' The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) said earlier this month it would slash the number of flights coming in and taking off from Newark to help reduce congestion and prevent delays. Until the construction of Runway 4-Left/22-Right is completed, the number of arrivals and departures will be limited to 28 per hour. President Trump and Duffy have vowed to overhaul the FAA, including launching a new program to promote the recruitment and retention of air traffic controllers and investing in more modern technology. Stewart outlined the stress and the responsibilities that air traffic controllers deal with daily while on the job and detailed a near incident on May 4 where two planes nearly collided. 'So, what led to that incident was basically fatigue in general, and that was due to a lack of staffing,' the air traffic controller said on Friday. 'I was using a combination of non-radar and radar rules, which is a completely different way of doing things than I'm used to doing normally.' Stewart noted that because he knew the radar would eventually go out — though he did not know the exact timing — he started writing down planes' flight data and call signs 'It's like knowing you're going to get into a car wreck. You just don't know when, so you better keep your seatbelt on just to, you know, be safe,' Steward told host Elizabeth Vargas. The air traffic controller said the FAA does not need more managers, but more leadership from the 'top.' 'So, there's an old saying to the military, which is, 'lead, follow or get out of the way.'' Stewart said. 'So, somebody needs to do something.' His words come after Duffy also admitted that he once changed his wife's ticket to avoid Newark — citing delays, not safety issues. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
NYC subway assaults up 19% — with many of the attacks coming against police officers, stats show
More subway riders have reported being punched, kicked and stabbed so far this year than last — and many of them were police officers, the NYPD said. Felony assault is up 19% in transit, from 214 incidents at this point in 2025, to 255 as of Sunday, according to NYPD statistics. Out of the 255 assaults so far this year, 93 — or 36% — were on city police officers and MTA workers. In the same span of 2019, 44 of the 154 people assaulted — or nearly 30% — were performing law enforcement duties, the spokesperson said. Such incidents have skyrocketed a stunning 66% when compared to 2019, before the pandemic, when 154 straphangers reported being assaulted. Retired NYPD detective and John Jay College adjunct professor Michael Alcazar blamed the uptick in assaults on the number of mentally ill in the subway and the criminal justice system. 'It's all these things, the homeless population, the EDPs (Emotionally Disturbed People), the warmer weather, prosecutors not able to keep them in jail,' he said. 'It emboldens the criminals. They get out and they're back at it the next day.' A woman-hating goon with 20 busts under his belt was the perfect example of a recidivist assaulter when he allegedly shoved a 70-year-old grandmother to the ground in a Midtown subway station on May 12. 'What are you doing here?' Sherlock Arana sneered at Janet Parvizyar, an LA resident before shoving her into a wall and to the floor, she said. 'I don't understand, why did they let them go like this,' Parvizyar told The Post after learning of her attacker's criminal history. 'I mean, they have to do something about this. He's going to kill somebody.' Arana, 37, was arrested two days later after cops recognized him. He remains locked up at Rikers Island correctional facility on a second degree assault charge in lieu of $45,000 bail, records show. He pleaded guilty to assaulting two women inside separate Queens subway stations nearly a decade ago because he thought they were of Indian descent, prosecutors said. At least one was actually Bangladeshi. The most recent of his nearly two dozen prior arrests was in 2023 for a robbery, law enforcement sources said. The disposition of the case was unknown. The notable increase in assaults come as other transit crime has dropped 6% so far this year, including murders, shootings, robbery, burglaries and grand larcenies, the data showed. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch has attributed the crime drops in transit to an increased police presence underground, including the addition of two cops on every train overnight and hundreds more working overtime shifts. A longtime Bronx police officer attributed the increase in assaults to mental illness and crowding on trains which have been busier since congestion pricing went into effect in January. 'You have a lot more unstable people who are on the trains,' the cop with more than 20 years on the job said. 'Congestion pricing plays a part because the trains are also more crowded.' The police presence could also be adding to the uptick in the number of assaults, especially those against officers, a retired NYPD detective said. 'People don't like when police enforce drinking and minor offenses and they get aggressive,' the retired officer said.
The Hill
a day ago
- The Hill
Air traffic controller says its ‘safe to fly' but ‘avoid Newark'
Veteran air traffic controller Jonathan Stewart affirmed to the public during a recent television appearance that it is 'safe to fly,' but added that he would avoid the embattled Newark Liberty International Airport. 'It's safe to fly. I would probably avoid Newark until something else is done,' Stewart, a supervisory air traffic controller, said during his Friday night appearance on NewsNation's 'Elizabeth Vargas Reports.' Stewart's remarks come as the New Jersey airport has dealt with communication blackouts and ongoing staff shortages, prompting concerns from travelers and public officials. The airport, one of the largest near New York City, had at least two radar outages this month, shining a spotlight on outdated technology, and has a deficit of air traffic controllers. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said this week that 16 new air traffic controllers were placed in training to boost staffing figures. The workers were moved to the Philadelphia Terminal Radar Approach Control (TRACON), where Newark airport's operations are situated. Additionally, he said a new runway would be opened at the airport soon to combat congestion. 'The concrete has been laid. I think they're just striping. They are just striping right now,' Duffy told reporters during a press conference on Wednesday. 'We have a target date of June 15 of bringing the runway online.' The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) said earlier this month it would slash the number of flights coming in and taking off from Newark to help reduce congestion and prevent delays. Until the construction of Runway 4-Left/22-Right is completed, the number of arrivals and departures will be limited to 28 per hour. President Trump and Duffy have vowed to overhaul the FAA, including launching a new program to promote the recruitment and retention of air traffic controllers and investing in more modern technology. Stewart outlined the stress and the responsibilities that air traffic controllers deal with daily while on the job and detailed a near incident on May 4 where two planes nearly collided. 'So, what led to that incident was basically fatigue in general, and that was due to a lack of staffing,' the air traffic controller said on Friday. 'I was using a combination of non-radar and radar rules, which is a completely different way of doing things than I'm used to doing normally.' Stewart noted that because he knew the radar would eventually go out — though he did not know the exact timing — he started writing down planes' flight data and call signs 'It's like knowing you're going to get into a car wreck. You just don't know when, so you better keep your seatbelt on just to, you know, be safe,' Steward told host Elizabeth Vargas. The air traffic controller said the FAA does not need more managers, but more leadership from the 'top.' 'So, there's an old saying to the military, which is, 'lead, follow or get out of the way.'' Stewart said. 'So, somebody needs to do something.' His words come after Duffy also admitted that he once changed his wife's ticket to avoid Newark — citing delays, not safety issues.
