Glasgow City Council and its 'golden goodbyes' explained
Ms O'Donnell will therefore receive normal pension arrangements with no additional cost to the Strathclyde Pension Fund or Glasgow City Council.
Here's how we got to this point.
Read More:
What is the background?
In February 2024, the chief executive of Glasgow City Council, Annemarie O'Donnell, announced that she would step down later that year.
She had been in post for more than a decade, and spent more than 30 years in local government in Glasgow.
Annemarie O'Donnell (Image: GCC) When she stepped down she received a £357,845 "in year" contribution to her pension, with a number of other council figures receiving so-called 'golden goodbyes'.
Elaine Galletly, former director of Legal and Administration, received a £223,065 pension contribution and £59,971 for 'compensation for loss of office'.
Carole Forrest, a former solicitor to the council, got a redundancy payment of £95,000 and Anne Connolly, a former principal advisor to the chief executive got a pension and redundancy package of £191,767.
Robert Anderson, head of human resources, got a pension and redundancy deal worth £147,654.
Why has it proven controversial?
Glasgow City Council has been struggling to balance its budget in recent years, and has done so by cutting services and raising revenues through things like remortgaging council owned buildings.
Five senior staff being given exit deals worth over £1million would be controversial in that circumstance anyway, but it has proved even more so given there was no political oversight.
Legal firm Brodies conducted an investigation into the payments and found no evidence of officials having acted "improperly" but concluded that Ms O'Donnell's exit was not "lawfully approved" in line with council rules.
The payments, which came as part of a restructuring exercise, were "in accordance" with Glasgow City Council policies but were approved solely by council officers with no input from elected members.
Given that the officers involved in approving the Restructure Report benefited from it by being proposed for early retirement or severance packages it could give the "appearance of a conflict of interest", Douglas Ross KC said.
What has the reaction been?
Susanne Millar, who succeeded Ms O'Donnell as chief executive, said it wasn't "credible" that the officials couldn't have known approving early retirement deals without it being referred to committee would be controversial.
Councillor Greg Hepburn said: "Is it credible that no one would think this would be something that would be politically controversial? That they wouldn't think to take it to committee?
"It's not something that would have passed a committee, I feel confident in saying."
Jim Cavanagh of Labour said: "There are people out there on the streets, poverty-stricken beyond belief. People's opinions of this council are at rock bottom, and we as councillors are taking the flack for it.
'We didn't know anything. Nobody told us anything. We never knew at any stage what was happening.'
Audit Scotland, which audits public bodies, said it would be opening its own investigation.
What will happen next?
So far Ms O'Donnell is the only one of the five officials to have agreed to repay her 'golden goodbye'.
It remains to be seen whether any others will follow suit, and what Audit Scotland will say in its report.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
a day ago
- STV News
Rennie Mackintosh building to be sold and turned into museum
A Charles Rennie Mackintosh-designed former school in Townhead is set to be sold by Glasgow City Council and turned into a Scottish Catholic museum. The Bishops' Conference of Scotland are expected to take over the old Martyrs' School on Parson Street if a £250,000 deal is backed by councillors this week. It is planning to invest £1.75m in the A-listed property to create a 'public museum of Scottish Catholic archives to house artefacts and artworks', a council report reveals. While not the highest bid received, council officials have recommended it for approval 'given the overall merits'. They add the unconditional offer of £250,000 has the 'benefit of certainty, being a cash offer and not being subject to any suspensive conditions'. Two other bids met the same criteria but were for commercial letting of workshop space, with some public exhibition space, and their occupation was 'not guaranteed'. Cllr Ruairi Kelly, SNP, the council's convener for housing and development, said the plan was 'great news for an important piece of Glasgow's built heritage'. 'Without marketing this building, we would not have found such a positive outcome that not only secures investment but opens it to the public,' he said on social media. The three-storey school building was designed for the School Board of Glasgow by Charles Rennie Mackintosh while he was an assistant at architectural firm Honeyman and Keppie and completed in 1898. It is of 'considerable architectural and cultural significance, being one of the earlier buildings attributed to Mackintosh', the council report adds. Used as a school and college until the early 1970s, the building has since been an arts centre and then council offices. The Bishops' Conference of Scotland's plan for the property also includes some office space, and 'proposes to link the subject to their existing ownership on the opposite side of the street'. Marketing of the building began in October last year after it had sat empty for 'a considerable time'. Five compliant bids were received by the closing date in March this year. The council report adds: 'It is proposed the subject will undergo a sensitive restoration and will have the prospect of a meaningful future as part of its local community.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The National
a day ago
- The National
Glasgow's skyscraper vision sparks split over city's skyline future
Last week, Glasgow City Council revealed its Tall Buildings Design Guide, which outlined areas in the city like Charing Cross, Anderston Quay, Trongate, and Cowcaddens as potential sites for taller buildings. The guide, which marked a departure from decades of previous rules where building heights were restricted, also provided expectations for building quality, design, and aesthetics. Norry Wilson, who is behind the popular social media account Lost Glasgow, which aims to document, discuss, and appreciate the city's architecture and its community from the last few centuries, is skeptical of the new guidelines. READ MORE: Former SNP MP's critique of UK defence review was a missed opportunity He claimed that there is 'no clamor from developers to build skyscrapers in Glasgow' and that he doubts any plans to build any will ever come to fruition. However, Labour MSP for the Glasgow region, Paul Sweeney, who has a keen interest in the city's architecture, welcomed the guidelines as he hopes the change in policy will help address the growing need for housing. 'Glasgow has not built as many tall buildings as comparable British cities in recent years, and there is a pressing need to repopulate its urban core – which is the least populated of all major British cities,' he said. 'At present, Glasgow has no buildings taller than 100 metres, while Manchester has 26 with eight more under construction.' Sweeney added that whilst the principles outlined in the tall buildings design guide are of a 'high level,' he would like to see more of a 'house style' developed for Glasgow. (Image: Newsquest) He said that the guideline does try to address some 'fundamental deficiencies' that have 'plagued previous generations of tall buildings' in the city, such as slab form, lack of ground floor activation, isolated locations, and a lack of elegance on the skyline. Sweeney added: 'I hope these principles will now be robustly implemented and provide greater certainty for architects, developers, and local communities on what Glasgow expects in the design of such buildings. 'We certainly must never repeat that atrocious design of the Clayton Hotel and Virgin Hotels on Clyde Street, which saw their designs diluted to cut costs, resulting in cheap, clunky-looking cladding, a removal of a feature crown structure from the roof design, a blank facade facing Union Street and poor-quality landscaping at the base. 'Perhaps the design guide could also benefit from a rogues gallery of what hasn't worked well in Glasgow as well as examples that we are rightly proud of.' However, Wilson has said that he has 'absolutely no idea' where the demand for skyscrapers is coming from, as most people would rather live in family homes instead of massive buildings. The freelance journalist pointed out that back in March, three tower blocks dating back to the 60s at Wyndford Road were destroyed using controlled explosions to make way for nearly 400 new homes. (Image: Robert Perry) The four 26-storey blocks and several smaller high-rise buildings at one point provided homes for around 6000 people but were deemed by the owners, Wheatley Homes housing association, as not fit for purpose. 'It's a very strange one because, as far as I'm aware, there is no clamor from developers to build skyscrapers in Glasgow,' Wilson said. 'I mean, even in just the last few weeks, Glasgow's just demolished pretty much the last of our own skyscrapers at Winford and Maryhill because there's no demand for skyscrapers in Glasgow.' He added: 'I've got a sneaking suspicion this is really just a sort of paper exercise.' Wilson, whose father and grandfather were architects who contributed to Glasgow and the greater area's skyline, explained that the city's historic height restrictions were implemented by the fire department. He said that because the water pressure from their hoses could only reach about six or seven stories, they implemented a building height restriction so that fire crews could reach any possible blazes. Wilson said that he hasn't noticed many people discussing the need or want for skyscrapers in the city on any of his Lost Glasgow pages. He said: 'Most folks that looked at it think it's the council talking shop again, and unless it gets rubber stamped, it's not going to change anything.' He added: 'Everyone piles into Lost Glasgow and says, 'why don't they build more social housing' and you've got to point out, well, Glasgow doesn't build social housing anymore. 'That's the job of housing associations and all the rest of it. 'Where the demand is for skyscrapers, where that demand's coming from, I have absolutely no idea.'
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Rennie Mackintosh building in Glasgow to be turned into Catholic museum
A former school designed by Charles Rennie Mackintosh is set to be sold by Glasgow City Council and turned into a Scottish Catholic Bishops' Conference of Scotland is expected to take over the old Martyrs' School on Parson Street in Townhead if a £250,000 deal is backed by councillors this is planning to invest £1.75m in the 19th Century A-listed property to create a "public museum of Scottish Catholic archives to house artefacts and artworks", according to a council it is not the highest bid, council officials have recommended it for approval "given the overall merits". They said the unconditional offer of £250,000 had the "benefit of certainty, being a cash offer and not being subject to any suspensive conditions".Two other bids met the same criteria but were for commercial letting of workshop space, with some public exhibition space, and their occupation was "not guaranteed". 'Architectural and cultural significance' Ruairi Kelly, the council's convener for housing and development, said the plan was "great news for an important piece of Glasgow's built heritage"."Without marketing this building, we would not have found such a positive outcome that not only secures investment but opens it to the public," he said in a social media three-storey school building was designed for the School Board of Glasgow by Charles Rennie Mackintosh while he was an assistant at architectural firm Honeyman and Keppie and was completed in is of "considerable architectural and cultural significance, being one of the earlier buildings attributed to Mackintosh", the council report as a school and college until the early 1970s, the building has since been an arts centre and council Bishops' Conference of Scotland's plan for the property also includes some office space, and "proposes to link the subject to their existing ownership on the opposite side of the street" (St Mungo's RC Church).Marketing of the building began in October last year after it had been sitting empty for "a considerable time". Five compliant bids were received by the closing date in March this council report added: "It is proposed the subject will undergo a sensitive restoration and will have the prospect of a meaningful future as part of its local community."Reporting by Local Democracy journalist Drew Sandelands.
