Judge rules against decision not to protect Joshua tree
A Los Angeles federal judge has ruled that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's decision not to provide Endangered Species Act protections for the imperiled Joshua tree is unlawful, according to court papers obtained on Thursday.
U.S. District Judge Wesley L. Hsu ruled Monday that the USFWS decision to not provide ESA protections for the Joshua tree is illegal and sidesteps climate science.
WildEarth Guardians sued the USFWS twice in Los Angeles to secure federal projections for the Joshua tree after initially petitioning to list the Joshua tree as 'threatened' in 2015. The two species of Joshua tree, Yucca brevifolia and Yucca jaegeriana, face severe climate impacts that will cause the desert icon to become functionally extinct by the end of the century without immediate and robust action, according to the environmental organization.
'The agency's decision, for a second time, reflected a massive disconnect from what the best available science shows — that climate change and wildfire will prevent Joshua trees from successfully recruiting new generations over the coming years,' Jennifer Schwartz, managing attorney for WildEarth Guardians, said in a statement. 'I feel hopeful that a federal court recognizes the need to actually assess these risks to the Joshua tree's survival. Now it's up to the service to actually follow the court's order.'
Hsu agreed with conservationists on all claims, determining 'that the service has not provided a rational explanation as to why climate change alone does not threaten the species to become threatened or endangered.'
WildEarth Guardians said the USFWS' analysis failed to adequately take into account climate change modeling that clearly shows Joshua trees run the risk of extinction due to increasing temperature, drought and wildfire.
The court order states that the USFWS 'provides no explanation as to why it did not use current trends and standards regarding greenhouse gas emissions as a basis for its decision, when this data currently is available.'
WildEarth Guardians has been fighting for federal protections for the Joshua tree since the organization's initial petition to list the species as 'threatened' under the ESA in September 2015, citing the severe impacts of climate change on the native succulent.
In August 2019, the USFWS first denied listing protection for what it clarified were actually two distinct species of Joshua tree — eastern Joshua tree (Yucca jaegeriana) and western Joshua tree (Yucca brevifolia) — because it believed neither species was likely to face a danger of extinction in the next 80 years, according to WildEarth Guardians.
This article originally appeared on Palm Springs Desert Sun: Joshua tree protection ruling
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Sunday hunting is up for debate again in the state House
A white-tailed deer is seen at Seedskadee National Wildlife Refuge in Wyoming on Aug. 8, 2015. (Tom Koerner/USFWS/CC BY 2.0) The latest effort to expand hunting on Sundays in Pennsylvania passed a key House committee with bipartisan support Tuesday. State Rep. Mandy Steele (D-Allegheny), sponsor of House Bill 1431, described the effort to repeal Pennsylvania's Sunday prohibition on hunting as a 'groundbreaking collaboration' of the Pennsylvania Farm Bureau, Pennsylvania Game Commission, and multiple advocacy groups. The bill passed by a 18-8 vote in the House Game & Fisheries Committee, with every Democrat voting in favor and four Republicans supporting. It will next be considered by the full House. 'In my busy family with four active kids, Sundays are often our only free day of the week,' Steele said. 'Sunday could be an opportunity to educate our children about the great American tradition of protecting wild places and the deep connection to the land that comes through responsible and respectful hunting, a core value among hunters.' Steele said when delving into the issue, she learned that farmers and wildlife biologists think expanding hunting on Sundays would reduce crop damage and help the state's woods by better managing the deer herd. 'We must heed this call from so many so intimately connected with the land,' Steele said, while asking for support to end what she described as the state's 'archaic and harmful prohibition on Sunday hunting.' Gov. Tom Wolf signed a law in 2019 to allow deer hunting on three Sundays: One during archery season, one during rifle season, and one selected by the Game Commission. That law was sponsored by Sen. Dan Laughlin (R-Erie), who authored Senate Bill 67, a companion bill to Steele's proposal. Both Steele and Laughlin's bills would require at least one member of the Pennsylvania Game Commission's Board of Commissioners to have an agriculture background. For years, Pennsylvania's 'blue law' prohibition of hunting on Sundays has been a hot-button issue. Supporters argue that expanding hunting on Sundays could help grow the sport, while organizations representing hikers and horseback riders have made the case that Sundays are best left without it, so they can enjoy the outdoors without concerns for their own safety from those hunting. The House passed Steele's proposal to repeal Pennsylvania's Sunday hunting ban last June by a 129-73 vote, although it did not pass the Senate. Laughlin and Steele told the Capital-Star earlier this year they're optimistic this is the session the bill could get across the finish line. State Rep. David Maloney (R-Berks), minority chair of the House Game and Fisheries Committee, voted against the proposal on Tuesday and spoke at-length about his concerns. He discussed his issues with the language about trespassing penalties, the requirement for a member of the agriculture community to be on the Game Commission Board, questioned the effectiveness of the law combatting crop damage and protecting forests, and free time. 'I don't really buy into this idea that another weekend day is going to clear up all the woes of the sportsmen and the Game Commission,' Maloney said. He added that he has never taken a position about whether or not he'd hunt on Sunday, but asked for a no-vote, believing the legislation 'complicates the issue.' In response to Maloney's concerns, Steele emphasized that the bill is being backed by a wide variety of organizations that include the Pennsylvania Game Commission, the Pennsylvania Farm Bureau, Backcountry Hunters & Anglers, the Pennsylvania Federation of Sportsmen and Conservationists, and Hunter Nation. The committee also unanimously approved House Bill 1507, authored by Steele, to allow out-of-state college students living in Pennsylvania to purchase a hunting license for the same price as residents. Steele argued it could boost hunting participation in Pennsylvania. The Game Commission, Backcountry Hunters and Anglers, and the Pennsylvania Federation of Sportsmen and Conservationists support the bill. The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission also offers fishing licenses to out-of-state college students for the same price as residents, but Game Commission license fees must be approved by the General Assembly, according to a co-sponsorship memo. 'For a student surviving on ramen noodles … this could be a deciding factor between participating in the great American outdoor tradition or being priced out entirely,' she added.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Mexican gray wolf Asha gives birth to litter of pups
NEW MEXICO (KRQE) – Asha, a Mexican gray wolf caught wandering around New Mexico in 2023, gave birth to her first litter in mid-May, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service recently announced. Asha (wolf F2754) and her mate (wolf M1966) welcomed five Mexican wolf pups. She came to fame as a wandering wolf, making multiple trips outside the Mexican wolf recovery area. Asha was captured and paired with her mate at the Sevilleta Wolf Management Facility in New Mexico in December 2023 — a decision that some environmentalists disagreed with, saying it would have been better for the wolves to roam. 'Asha' the Mexican grey wolf featured in children's book The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service said there are plans in place to release the full pack onto private land in New Mexico this summer. The announcement of Asha's litter came just days before the Arizona Game and Fish Department reported that the Mexican wolf fostering efforts for 2025 wrapped up. A total of 17 wolf pups were placed into wild dens across New Mexico and Arizona, six of which were fostered into a single den in Arizona and 11 into three different dens in New Mexico. 'The fostering program is achieving these goals faster than was predicted, with 21 of the 22 required fosters having reached breeding age,' Clay Crowder, assistant director with the Arizona Game and Fish Department, said in part in a news release. 'Also of note from the foster program is that we now have at least 13 fosters having produced 31 litters, all of which are important to contributing to the genetic health of the wild population. With these successes, we are approaching the criteria to begin evaluating potential downlisting of Mexican wolves.' The Mexican wolf is listed as endangered, and efforts to grow the population have been ongoing since 1998 in the two southwestern states. A 2024 population survey revealed a minimum of 286 Mexican wolves were distributed across New Mexico and Arizona. Fostering Mexican wolf pups from captivity into the wild helps manage the genetic diversity of the wild population and allows the pups to learn how to live successfully in the wild from an experienced pack, according to the Arizona Game and Fish Department. Since 2016, a total of 146 fostered pups have been introduced into wild dens The goal for 2025 was to place a larger number of pups into dens in Arizona, which was relatively successful, with twice as many pups going to Arizona compared to last year, the Arizona Game and Fish Department said in the news release. Conservationists worry Mexican grey wolves could be threatened by cuts to recovery programs U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Arizona Game and Fish Department, New Mexico Department of Game and Fish, Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Forest Service, and the Saving Animals From Extinction program collaborated on the fostering effort. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
National Geographic
a day ago
- National Geographic
Bald eagle
Scientific Name: Haliaeetus leucocephalus Average Life Span In The Wild: 20 to 30 years Size: Body: 28 to 38 inches; Wingspan: 80 inches Size relative to a 6-ft human: The bald eagle is a large, powerful bird of prey that has been the national symbol of the United States since 1782. That year, it appeared with outspread wings on the country's Great Seal as a sign of strength. Bald eagles don't actually have bare heads. Their name comes from the old English word 'balde,' which means white—a nod to the snowy-white feathers that cover their heads and tails. Most of these majestic, dark brown-bodied creatures live in Alaska and Canada. But there are also eagles in the lower 48 states (except Hawaii) and Mexico. Bald eagles are famous in the U.S. However, they almost disappeared in the middle of the 20th century from decades of sport hunting and habitat destruction. DDT, a pesticide that became popular after World War II, also wreaked havoc on bald eagles. They ate contaminated fish, which weakened their eggshells so much, they would crack during incubation. In 1972, the U.S. banned DDT use and began intensive population management strategies. These conservation efforts helped them recover in the wild and led to their removal from the Endangered Species Act list in 2007. (Most U.S. eagles suffer from lead poisoning, study suggests.) Today the population estimate for bald eagles is about 316,700. The numbers continue to soar despite threats like illegal hunting and electrocution from power lines. A 2019 survey by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service found that the bald eagle population quadrupled since 2009. Bald eagle habitat and diet Bald eagles occasionally live in dry areas. However, most reside in woods by rivers, lakes, and other bodies of water. These areas tend to be rich with fish—their main food source. Their diets also include birds, turtles, and small mammals, such as squirrels and rabbits. To conserve energy, these opportunistic creatures sometimes eat dead animals. They also steal prey from birds and other animals, even though they are skilled hunters themselves. Bald eagles are raptors, like hawks and falcons, with special features that help these predatory birds chase their prey. Razor-like talons puncture and can carry prey up to half the eagle's body weight, roughly eight to 13 pounds. A large wingspan conserves energy by soaring. A dense coating of light-detecting cells on their retinas helps them spot prey from up to a mile away. (Winter is prime time for watching bald eagles—here's where to spot them.) Once an eagle has captured a meal, it uses the sharp edges of its curved beak to slice through flesh or scales. Bald eagle breeding and family life Most bald eagles reach sexual maturity at age four or five and breed in early spring. Breeding pairs bond by performing dance-like air displays. In one example, during the 'cartwheel courtship flight,' a pair flies high into the sky. They lock talons and spin downward, then break off just before hitting the ground. Those teamwork skills come in handy when it's time to build nests. These stick structures lined with grass and other materials can take several months to construct. Most couples choose the tops of tall trees for nesting sites, where there's enough support for these enormous structures. At about six feet wide and four feet deep, bald eagle nests are the largest of any bird in North America. Pairs living in treeless areas build nests on cliffs or, on rare occasions, the ground. (See photographs depicting the everyday lives of this national symbol.) Bald eagle couples mate for life and return to these sturdy homes each year to care for a new pair of baby eagles, called eaglets. Both parents play an active role in rearing. They deliver prey, place torn-up food into eaglet beaks, and fiercely guard little ones from predators, such as raccoons and ravens. Like golden eagles, baby bald eagles are completely brown. They don't develop the distinctive white markings of their parents until they reach five years of age. They begin to fly at about 10 to 12 weeks and permanently leave the nest a month later. Bald eagle behavior Untethered to a breeding site, young eagles tend to roam far from their nests in directions that appear random. Adult birds are more intentional, migrating only as far as necessary to find sustenance. When lakes and rivers freeze, for example, Northern bald eagles fly to the coast or south to open water. These territorial birds typically travel alone. However, during non-breeding times, such as in the winter, eagles often roost together in groups ranging from several to hundreds of birds. Scientists think they congregate to socialize or gain information about the location and availability of prey. To communicate, bald eagles emit a variety of whiny, high-pitched vocalizations that may sound surprising coming from such brawny bodies. 5 interesting facts about bald eagles Like other birds of prey, bald eagles exhibit 'reverse sexual size dimorphism,' which means that females are larger than males. —Audubon Center for Birds of Prey Bald eagles swim by moving their wings in a rowing motion that looks similar to the butterfly stroke. —NPR Bald eagles store excess food in a crop, a muscular pouch below their throat that looks like a bulge from the outside. —American Eagle Foundation In 1784, Benjamin Franklin wrote a letter to his daughter saying the bald eagle was a poor choice for the U.S. national symbol because of its thieving tendencies. —The Franklin Institute Female bald eagles lay one to three eggs. Both parents take turns incubating them, which takes about 35 days. —U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service How rare is it to see bald eagles?Thanks to conservation efforts, bald eagles were removed from the endangered species list in 2007. You can see them in wildlife refuges throughout North America and in the wild. In Alaska, bald eagles are almost a common sight. —U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service What is the penalty for killing a bald eagle? The Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act, enacted in 1940, prohibits anyone from harming bald eagles in any way. Doing so risks a $100,000 fine ($200,000 for organizations) or imprisonment, or both. The act defines harm in many ways, including pursuing, capturing, and even disturbing their nests or nesting sites outside of breeding season. —U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service Can a bald eagle pick up a 25lb. dog? No, bald eagles cannot pick up a 25-pound dog. They can carry up to half their body weight, roughly eight to 13 pounds. —American Eagle Foundation This story originally published on September 23, 2019. It has been updated.
