Scotland's fire service 999 response times hit 10-year high
The Scottish government has increased the SFRS capital budget to £47m but there are calls for this to be increased to resolve issues with the ageing fleet and estate issues.
READ MORE:
A firefighters' union has also warned the service is "already on its knees" as proposals to close more than a dozen stations in Scotland is currently being considered.
The latest data outlines that responses to 999 calls have slowed almost every consecutive year between 2014 and 2024, including for calls where it was considered there was a high risk of casualty.
In 2014, it took an average of six minutes and 51 seconds for a 999 call to result in the fire service arriving on site. By 2024, this had increased to a median of eight minutes and 20 seconds – an increase of 21%.
There was a similar increase among cases classified as 'possible life risk incidents', meaning there was a high risk of encountering a casualty.
In 2014, it took a median of 7 minutes and 13 seconds for a 999 call to result in the fire service arriving on site. By 2024, this had increased to 8 minutes and 42 seconds – a 20% increase.
Scottish Tory MSP Sharon Dowey condemned the SNP's 'continual contempt' for the fire service and public safety, describing their cuts as 'an abject dereliction of duty'.
The party's community Safety spokesperson Ms Dowey MSP said: 'Our firefighters do an incredible job, but the SNP's savage and sustained budget cuts are putting public safety in jeopardy.
'It's little wonder that emergency response times have hit their slowest rate in ten years, when the nationalists have imposed a real terms cut of £57million and the number of firefighters has dropped by one thousand within a decade.
'On the SNP's watch, 18 fire stations have no running water, most fire engines are over 10 years old, and many stations are in poor condition with several set to be closed.
'Their continual contempt for our fire service and failure to maintain crucial firefighter numbers is an abject dereliction of duty which will almost certainly have resulted in lives being lost.
'It is crucial that SNP ministers step in now and urgently protect the public by giving the fire service the resources they desperately need.'
House fires have fallen to an all-time low and over the last two decades, deaths caused by fire have fallen from 89 to 42. The casualty rate has also dropped from 1,951 to 815.
However, in contrast, firefighters are dealing with more floods, wildfires and rescues.
Wildfire incident in Scotland. (Image: Peter Jolly) A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'We continue to support the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) with substantial year-on-year budget increases that enable our firefighters to deliver a high standard of services and keep our communities safe.
"This year's Budget includes £412.2 million for SFRS – an increase of £18.8 million and Scotland continues to have more firefighters per capita than other parts of the UK.
'Whilst the deployment of SFRS resources is an operational matter for the Chief Fire Officer, their targeted approach to risk and allocation of resource overtook the focus given to response times some years ago - and the service continues to respond to every emergency incident with the appropriate level of resource.'
The SFRS has been contacted for comment.
The figures come as the SFRS is proposing the closure of up to 13 stations across Scotland, new arrangements for night and weekend cover at others and the permanent withdrawal of 10 appliances nationwide.
Five stations in Dundee, Glasgow, Edinburgh and Musselburgh could be shut down or merged.
The 23 options, being published on Wednesday, involve more than 30 fire stations in 14 local authority areas, and the service has warned that more change is likely in years to come.
The consultation will remain open for 10 weeks, with the SFRS saying it wants 'as many people as possible' to submit their views on the proposed changes.
The Fire Brigades Union (FBU) says the service is 'already on its knees' after a decade of what it calls real-terms cuts.
Responding to the proposals, FBU Scottish secretary John McKenzie previously said: 'Our members and the Scottish public have suffered more than enough cuts to the fire service.
'For over a decade, real-terms budget cuts have increased risks to public safety, with firefighter numbers slashed and response times increasing as a result.
'The service is already on its knees because of these cuts. That has led to increases in response times and when this time is lost, tragically lives will also be lost.
'This is unacceptable and any proposals to further compromise our service and public safety must be rejected."
The SFRS has said any changes would only be made if they ensured safety.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
3 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Senedd gives green light to Wales' tourism tax plans
Senedd members voted 37-13 for the tourism tax bill , which will see people charged £1.30 each, plus VAT, for stays in hotels, B&Bs and self-catering accommodation. People staying in hostels and campsites would pay 75p per person per night, with under-18s exempt from the lower rate of the tax, which would be introduced in 2027 at the earliest. The tax would raise around £33m a year if implemented across the country, but the 22 councils in Wales will be given powers to decide whether to introduce a levy locally. Only two councils, Cardiff and Anglesey, have so far indicated plans to bring in a levy, but other authorities had yet to make a decision or had 'no plans' to introduce a tax. A register of visitor accommodation providers operating in Wales will also be established by the bill, laying the groundwork for licensing plans set to be brought forward separately. Proponents argue the levy will ensure visitors contribute to the cost of services with revenue reinvested, while detractors warn the tax will put tourists off and damage Wales' economy. Tourism taxes are commonplace on the continent and, closer to home, Scottish councils will gain similar powers next year and Manchester introduced a visitor charge in 2023. Leading a debate before the key vote on July 8, Mark Drakeford told the Senedd: 'By passing this bill, we will give councils the choice to introduce a modest additional charge which would be reinvested to support a thriving, sustainable tourism industry.' The finance secretary said the visitor levy will be the first local tax for more than 500 years to have been designed and made in Wales, marking an important step for devolution. Prof Drakeford said the Welsh Government wants to ensure the pressures and opportunities of tourism are fairly balanced, with visitors contributing to infrastructure and services. The former first minister pointed to evidence 'from Iceland to New Zealand' of the revenue generated contributing significantly to challenges without deterring tourism. He argued the bill would strengthen communities and build democratic accountability, putting tourism in Wales on a new and sustainable footing.
Times
3 hours ago
- Times
SNP punishing voters opposed to independence, claims David Mundell
The SNP government 'cynically and systematically' punishes voters who oppose independence by starving their public services of funding, a former Scottish secretary has alleged. David Mundell, who served in government under David Cameron and Theresa May, said NHS boards and councils in heavily unionist areas were 'struggling to provide basic services' due to what he suggested was a deliberate 'politically motivated' ploy by nationalist politicians. He cited Dumfries and Galloway, and the Scottish Borders, as parts of Scotland that were particularly struggling as a result of voters' 'pro-UK' constitutional views. While a majority of voters in 28 of Scotland's 32 council areas voted against independence in 2014, the idea was opposed in the south of the country, where two thirds supported remaining in the UK. Mundell made the incendiary allegation that SNP ministers were deliberately punishing pro-UK communities in the Commons, at a session of Scottish questions. While public services across Scotland have complained of being under financial pressure, Dumfries and Galloway council said in March that it had been forced to plug an 'unprecedented' shortfall of £30 million over three years. NHS Dumfries and Galloway has recently cut back on mowing lawns due to a need to deliver £23 million in savings. Mundell, the long-serving MP for Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale & Tweeddale, asked Ian Murray, the current Scottish secretary, whether he shared his view that unionist areas were being deliberately targeted. Mundell said: 'Whatever the budget SNP Scottish government have, they have cynically and systematically deprived funding from areas that do not support independence, leaving councils like Dumfries and Galloway and Scottish Borders and their health boards struggling to provide basic services.' Following his remarks in the Commons, Mundell claimed that his constituents felt they were being deliberately punished for their 'pro-UK views'. He added: 'The deeply damaging impact of the SNP's politically motivated decisions can be seen right across my constituency. Our NHS is in a state of permanent crisis, schools are being earmarked for closure and vital roads like the A75 and A76 have been left in a state of disrepair on the SNP's watch. 'I was speaking on behalf of many people in my constituency who are sick and tired of the SNP government ignoring this area and putting money into public services and major projects across Scotland. 'This area is long overdue its fair share and shouldn't be missing out for wanting to keep our close ties with our neighbours.' According to Audit Scotland, councils across Scotland face a £647 million gap between expenditure and the funding they expect to receive this year. As a percentage of their total revenue budget, Scottish Borders and Dumfries and Galloway councils did not have a disproportionately large funding gap compared with other local authorities. However, Glasgow, Dundee and North Lanarkshire, three of the four areas to back independence in 2014, had below average budget gaps. The fourth, West Dunbartonshire, had a slightly higher shortfall than average. Responding to Mundell in the Commons, Murray said: 'The whole of Scotland voted against independence in 2014. And it seems to me that the SNP government strategy is to starve all of Scotland's public services of the vital funding they require.' The Scottish government has been approached for comment.
Times
3 hours ago
- Times
Ross Greer bid to be Greens co-leader will deepen rift with rebels
The controversial Green MSP Ross Greer will stand to be the party's next co-leader. The West of Scotland MSP was elected to the Scottish parliament in 2016, at the age of just 21, making him the youngest politician yet elected to the legislature. Greer, 31, has emerged as a central figure in an increasingly bitter factional rift within the party, in which he has been criticised for his part in passing SNP budgets that cut council funding. 'This is probably the worst-kept secret at Holyrood,' his spokesman said. 'Over the past few weeks he has been approached by many colleagues encouraging him to run.' His campaign is likely to lead to a bitter battle within the Greens. He faces a potential challenge from rebel members who want a more radical shift in direction and fear Greer will adopt more of the same approach, in which he would seek compromise with the more centrist SNP.
