Three brave Dublin sisters waive anonymity to name ex-priest brother caged for rape after ‘sickening abuse'
Richard Brennan's sisters, Catherine Wrightstone, Yvonne Crist and Paula Faye, waived their anonymity so he could be named.
4
4
4
Brennan, 64, previously of Rathfarnham, now living in the United States, pleaded guilty at the Central Criminal Court to 24 counts against his three sisters, including 18 of indecent assault and six charges of rape.
He entered the guilty pleas after each of the three women had given evidence before a jury and before the final woman was about to be cross-examined.
He pleaded guilty to four sample charges of indecent assault and four rape charges against Paula Faye on dates between January 1978 and December 1981 when she was aged between 13 and 17 years old.
Brennan also pleaded guilty to 13 sample incidences of indecent assault and two charges of rape against a second sister, Catherine Wrightstone, on dates between June 1980 and December 1984 while she was aged between nine and 14 years old.
He finally pleaded guilty to indecent against the oldest of the sisters, Yvonne Crist, when she was about 20 years old on dates between June 1979 and June 1980.
Brennan was between 17 and 24 years old at time of the offending.
Brennan has no previous convictions. He was ordained as a priest in 1989 and moved to the US, but later married and had a family. He returned from the US for questioning and the trial.
Earlier this month, another brother Bernard Brennan, 67, formerly of Rathfarnham, Dublin, but most recently residing in the United States, was jailed for four and half years after he admitted to sexual abuse of both Yvonne Crist and Paula Faye.
Bernard Brennan pleaded guilty to 11 counts of indecent assault in various locations within the State between 1972 and 1975. He has no previous convictions.
Sentencing Richard Brennan today, Mr Justice David Keane said it was heartening to hear the three women in victim impact statement describe themselves as survivors.
BRAVE SISTERS
The judge said the sisters had made the 'truly courageous' decision to report their brother's crimes to the gardai.
Mr Justice Keane said he had the most 'immense admiration' for the determination shown by the three women in bringing the case before the courts and hoped that they would get something from their brother's 'belated acceptances of guilt'. He wished them well for the future.
Mr Justice Keane said the aggravating features of the case included the particularly young ages of both Ms Faye and Ms Wrightstone at the time of the abuse against them and the fact that the abuse occurred in a place where the sisters should have felt secure. Instead, Brennan created an environment of fear and confusion, he said.
The judge also took into account the fact that there was a pattern of frequent assaults against the younger two sisters over a lengthy period of time and that Brennan was a seminarian at the time, with particular familial responsibilities to his younger sisters.
EACH CAUSED HARM
Finally, Mr Justice Keane said there were three separate victims in the case who each have been psychologically damaged and that Brennan caused each of them significant harm.
He set headline sentences of 12 years for the rapes committed against Ms Wrightstone, and headline sentences of 10 years for the rapes committed against Ms Faye.
He set headline sentences of six years against the indecent assaults against Ms Wrightstone and headline sentences of 21 months and 18 months for the indecent assaults against Ms Faye and Ms Crist.
Mr Justice Keane said he must take into consideration mitigation including what he said was a late plea entered on the ninth day of the trial. He acknowledged that Brennan has shown deep remorse and that he has apologised to each of his victim.
CO-OPERATED WITH COPS
He said Brennan was also entitled to significant credit for his lack of previous convictions and the fact that he co-operated with gardai.
Mr Justice Keane said he accepted evidence that Brennan appears to have been present during some incidences of abuse carried out by his brother Bernard Brennan on both Ms Faye and Ms Crist.
He said he was also taking into account the character evidence given during the sentence hearing by Brennan's wife and testimonials handed into court by a number of other people.
Mr Justice Keane imposed a term of nine years for the rape offences carried out by Brennan against Ms Wrightstone.
CONCURRENT TERMS
He imposed concurrent terms of seven and half years for the rape offences committed against Ms Faye and four and half years for the indecent assaults against Ms Wrightstone.
He imposed further concurrent terms of 16 months and 14 months for the indecent assault offences committed against Ms Faye and Ms Crist.
A global sentence of nine years was backdated to March 18 last when Brennan first went into custody.
Mr Justice Keane noted that a report from the Probation Service indicated that Brennan is willing to engage with offence focused work as deemed suitable by them and said he must 'consider the prospect of rehabilitation' upon his ultimate release from prison.
'SICKENING ABUSE'
He suspended the final 12 months of the nine-year term on condition that Brennan engage with the Probation Service for a year upon his release.
He did not impose a post release supervision order after acknowledging that Brennan intends to return to the States when he leaves Ireland.
The Dublin Rape Crisis Centre commended the 'immense courage' shown by survivors.
Chief Executive Rachel Morrogh said: 'Yvonne Crist, Paula Fay, and Catherine Wrightstone suffered sickening abuse at the hands of their siblings."
'LIFELONG IMPACT'
She added: 'All these women were denied their most basic human rights by the very people they should have been able to trust.
'Sexual abuse has a devastating, lifelong impact for child victims. The fear and terror it creates is compounded when it happens in the family home, a place where every child should feel safe and should be safe.
'It can be particularly challenging to report offending within a family, but it is a devastatingly common occurrence.
'Dublin Rape Crisis Centre stands in solidarity with every survivor of sexual violence.
'We encourage anyone affected by this issue in any way to call the National Rape Crisis Helpline at 1800 77 88 88 for completely confidential and free information and support, available 24 hours a day.'
4
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Female BMW driver struck and killed pedestrian - then told cop 'It was only a homeless person,' police say
A Florida woman who killed another woman in a hit-and-run later told police that she didn't think it mattered because the victim was 'just a homeless person,' authorities claim. Ivana Gomez, 32, was speeding through Little Havana in her BMW while intoxicated in the early morning hours of May 30 when she allegedly struck 41-year-old Kathryn Kipnis before attempting to flee the scene. Kipnis was hit with such force that her head shattered the windshield, leaving strands of hair embedded in car's passenger seatbelt. More than four months after the deadly crash, newly released bodycam footage revealed the moments following Gomez's fatal strike - and her alleged chilling disregard for human life, according to NBC 6 Miami. 'It was just a homeless person that I hit and it is just an accident,' Gomez allegedly stated while being placed in the back of a cop car, according to the arrest report. It remains unclear why Gomez believed the victim was homeless - or why she thought that fact, if true, would justify or lessen the severity of what happened. Just after 1am on May 30, an officer spotted Gomez speeding through Southwest 22nd Avenue and 8th Street in Miami, driving a 2019 blue BMW. The officer, who tried to catch up with Gomez at speeds over 100mph after spotting her reckless driving, tragically witnessed her slam into Kipnis, according to the report. Kipnis's family said their loved one was walking home along Southwest 21st Avenue after a night out with friends, as reported by the outlet. 'No one ever expects their child to go before them,' Daniel Kipnis, the victim's father, told NBC Miami. Yet even after violently mowing down the 41-year-old, Gomez didn't stop, according to the arrest report. Instead, she allegedly ignored the flashing lights and blaring sirens of the officer in pursuit with her foot still on the gas. The brief chase ended when Gomez hit a red light and got boxed in behind two stopped cars, leaving her with nowhere to run. Photos of the wrecked BMW showed a gaping hole in the shattered windshield, glass strewn across the hood, and the front bumper mangled and peeling away. According to the arrest report obtained by NBC, the officer noted a strong smell of alcohol on Gomez's breath, bloodshot, watery eyes, and visible difficulty completing a field sobriety test. Investigators also noticed fresh vomit in her car, according to the report obtained by WSVN News. After allegedly stumbling through the initial test, Gomez refused to take any further sobriety tests and instead requested a lawyer. 'It was just a homeless person that I hit and it is just an accident,' Gomez allegedly stated while being placed in the back of a cop car As she was being placed in the cruiser, police wrote in their report that Gomez blatantly admitted to feeling no remorse. Authorities said she 'spontaneously' told the arresting officer it was an accident - and besides, the victim was 'just a homeless person.' Nearly five hours after the crash, Gomez's blood tests revealed a staggering BAC well above the legal limit - registering .112 and .109, officers wrote. Even six hours after the crash, around 7am, her blood alcohol level remained just above the legal limit at .088, according to the arrest report. 'The defendant's flagrant disregard for human life by striking the victim and fleeing the scene demonstrates a willful and wanton disregard for the safety of others,' the document said. On May 31, Gomez made her first court appearance, where the judge confronted her about her shocking remarks dismissing the woman she killed as 'just a homeless person.' 'Your Honor, I never said that,' Gomez responded, according to WSVN. 'I did not say that whatsoever. That's false.' Prosecutors doubled down, emphasizing that Gomez remains a danger to Miami's streets, showing blatant disregard for the consequences of her actions. They requested her bond to be set at $1 million. Rachel Kipnis, the victim's cousin, also appeared via Zoom during the hearing, passionately condemning the recklessness that so abruptly and undeservedly took her loved one's life. 'I just want Your Honor to be aware of what a shining light has been taken out of this world by the incredible irresponsibility of this defendant,' she told the court, according to WSVN. Gomez was initially charged with leaving the scene of a fatal crash and resisting an officer without violence. However, the judge set her bond at $251,500 - well below the $1 million prosecutors requested. Records show Gomez remained in custody at Turner Guilford Knight Correctional Center in West Miami-Dade as of Tuesday. If Gomez does manage to post bond, she won't walk away completely unscathed - she'll be locked under house arrest, stripped of her passport, and ordered to steer clear of alcohol and driving. Meanwhile, prosecutors are digging deeper, awaiting crucial data from the BMW's black box and toxicology reports - evidence that could lead to additional charges, including vehicular homicide. 'My daughter was vivacious, lovable, everyone really liked her,' Daniel Kipnis told Local 10 News after the crash.
BBC News
20 minutes ago
- BBC News
Reckoning for Australia's childcare sector after onslaught of abuse cases
Twice a week, Ben Bradshaw drops his young son off at a Sydney childcare centre before heading off to thousands of parents and carers across Australia, the 40-year-old had always been confident that the staff have his child's best interests at in recent months, that trust in the childcare system has been "eroded", the father-of-two says, after several high-profile cases of alleged sexual and physical abuse at centres across Australia."It's that old adage of cockroaches - if you see one in your house, there's 10 that you don't see. These are the ones that get caught. It's more scary the ones that you can't see," he tells the the past few weeks, 2,000 children in Victoria have been urged to undergo infectious disease testing after a childcare worker was charged with the mass sexual abuse of babies; police have named a Sydney man who worked for 60 after-school-care providers and is accused of taking "explicit" images of children under his supervision; a Queensland woman has faced court over allegations she tortured a one-year-old boy; and another two workers in Sydney have been charged after a toddler was left covered in comes as the nation is still reeling from the crimes of childcare worker Ashley Paul Griffith - dubbed "one of Australia's worst paedophiles" - who was late last year sentenced to life in prison for raping and sexually abusing almost 70 series of allegations have sparked panic and fear among parents, child safety advocates have demanded action to fix what they call a dangerously incompetent system, and politicians have promised reform to keep Australia's most vulnerable safe."Some childcare centres are still safe, but the current childcare system is definitely not working to protect children or prioritise their safety," says Hetty Johnston, a leading child protection advocate. "It fails at every step." Rapid growth, greater risks In recent years, there has been a nationwide push to give more children access to early childhood education and care, which research indicates has many positive long-term of dollars have been poured into the sector from federal and state governments, including funding to guarantee three days of childcare for low and middle-income families. Such measures have prompted rapid growth in the sector, with a rush of new centres opening which has deepened a shortage of qualified growth has led to "significant vulnerabilities", says Prof Leah Bromfield, director of the Australian Centre for Child Protection."Whenever you grow something really quickly, that comes with risks," she says, listing off a lack of regulation and monitoring, limited training for managers, and the disparate and casual nature of the workforce."You put all that together and you've created a weak system from the perspective of a predatory perpetrator… a system where it's easier to infiltrate."In the wake of the Melbourne child sexual abuse case where Joshua Dale Brown was charged with 70 counts of abuse against eight babies, the federal government gave itself greater powers to strip funding from providers that breach quality and safety Education Minister Jason Clare said the measure was not designed to "shut down centres" but rather increase pressure for them to "raise standards".But Mr Bradshaw wants more. He says taking away funding from a centre "doesn't stop the crime, it just punishes it"."You have to do things that are proactive in nature." Knee-jerk reactions The spate of alleged crimes have sparked a heated national conversation about how to better protect kids. Limiting the role of men in childcare is one of the most controversial was a public call to ban men from certain tasks such as changing nappies and taking children to the toilet – though some warned this could place extra pressure on female staff."It's not about banning male educators, but about providing families with agency and informed choice," says Louise Edmonds, an advocate for child sex abuse case prompted G8 Education – who owned the centre where he worked - to introduce so-called "intimate care waivers", giving parents and carers the opportunity to choose who carried out private and sensitive duties. It also pledged to install CCTV at all of its centres. Ms Johnston - who founded child protection group Bravehearts - says these are natural responses, but cautioned that, though "men are definitely a higher risk", women do abuse children too and offenders can do so in all kinds of settings."They are opportunistic… when others don't pay attention, when they are distracted, complacent, disinterested or too trusting, they create 'opportunities' for offenders."Other practical measures centres could adopt to improve child safety include having two educators with direct line of sight of children at all times and getting rid of blind spots in centres - replacing solid doors with glass panes, eliminating windowless walls, and putting more mirrors up to create "incidental supervision"."It's all about reducing opportunities for predators to isolate or conceal in nooks and crannies," Ms Johnston says. Hiding in plain sight But massive system reform is also long overdue, experts 2017, more than 400 recommendations emerged from a years-long royal commission into child sex abuse in institutional settings – like churches, schools and childcare - but critics say progress has stalled on some of the most significant of those outstanding recommendations, to be discussed by the country's attorneys-general at a meeting this month, is to overhaul Australia's checks on those who work with each state and territory complete what is essentially a police check required for those who work alongside children, but they don't share the information with each other. Advocates have called for a nationalised system, but some say the checks themselves don't go far enough."It's inconsistent, relies too heavily on prior convictions," Ms Edmonds instance, many say, the system should capture red flags such as formal complaints, workplace warnings, police intelligence, and people identified as alleged abusers in confidential applications to the national redress scheme set up after the royal a broader net is important, experts argue, as child abuse allegations can be difficult to stand up in court. Often the witnesses are young children, who are either non-verbal or have limited vocabulary, may struggle with memory, and often have a lack of situational understanding."Catching someone red-handed and being able to prove it beyond reasonable doubt is almost impossible," Ms Johnston says. That's why Prof Bromfield is among those calling for a national registration scheme for the childcare sector – like those that exist for doctors or teachers. It would require workers to prove their qualifications, could provide a detailed work history, and would bind them all by a code of argue the system could also capture many of the things the working- with-children checks currently do not."Often in child sexual abuse cases, when you look back, you see lots and lots of red flags," Prof Bromfield says."There might be a pattern, but [at the moment] we just don't see that because they are moving between states or between sectors or between providers."Mr Bradshaw says having access to more information about staff would help parents like him make informed is a necessity for his family, he explains, as he works full-time and his wife, a high school teacher, works four days a often, there's little detail about the childcare centre's staff "beyond the pictures on the wall" of the teachers and educators, so parents often have to assess a provider "based on vibes"."It's a bit of a blackbox and you're bound because you need to have your kids in childcare so you can pay for living in a big city."That's where greater education for parents is needed too, Prof Bromfield says, so they know what questions to ask and, in the worst-case scenarios, how to spot signs of grooming include enquiring about a provider's child safety policies, asking about its staff turnover, and assessing the physical spaces for any visibility issues. There also needs to be better, more regular training for managers in the sector on how to prevent and identify problematic behaviour or patterns, experts Prof Bromfield - who was part of the team which conducted the royal commission into child sex abuse – these are conversations she has been having for over a she is hopeful the current crisis will shock Australia into taking greater action."Perhaps one of the things that will happen is there will be greater political will to prioritise safety for children," Prof Bromfield says."The big lesson is that we can never rest on our laurels when it comes to children's safety."Perpetrators just keep getting smarter, working around the systems we've got. We can't forget the lessons of the past… and we can't assume that this is a problem that's gone away."
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Denise Richards' daughter Sami Sheen shares chilling claim she 'almost got sex trafficked'
' daughter Sami Sheen has claimed she had a close call with a suspected sex trafficker. OnlyFans star Sheen, 21, whose father is actor Charlie Sheen, shocked fans with a chilling TikTok video in which she said she was approached by two suspicious men in a parking lot late at night. She said: 'I think I almost got sex trafficked tonight. We were at this restaurant pretty late. We didn't leave until midnight and we were outside taking photos in the parking lot, we were there for five minutes. 'This man came up to us asking for money, I said "sorry I don't have any cash on me". 'He's being persistent, I'm like, "sorry no" and he goes "ok have a good night". Sheen said she then turned her head to see 'another man in front of us.' 'The second I saw this man I had the worst feeling in my stomach, like get the f**k away from me right now', she said. 'He comes up to me and asks "do you speak Spanish?" 'He starts to reach into his back pocket and I reach into my purse and pull out my pepper spray, and I open that b***h and he saw that and he started to pull a card out. 'We immediately book it, get in my car and lock the doors.' Sheen said she was disturbed to see one of the men in the background of her photos from earlier in the evening, saying: 'I feel like they're working together. The man was watching us the whole time, he was staring at us. 'I'm usually very aware of my surroundings and I didn't notice this man 'I don't think this man had good intentions at all.' The video comes days after Sheen revealed her intense battle with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). The model — whose mom is in the midst of divorcing her estranged husband Aaron Phypers — started the recording by saying: 'Nothing aggravates me more than when someone is like, "Oh, my god. I'm so OCD I need to keep my room clean and organized."' She contrasted that statement with her own experience, explaining, 'I'm so OCD that even if I buy something from the grocery store that day and I read the expiration date over and over and over and over again, somehow I will convince myself it's a fake expiration date and it's actually expired a year ago.' Engaging her 192,000 followers, she continued, 'And if I eat it I'm going to get violently ill, so I have to throw it away and starve.'
