Quebec coroner calls for tougher controls over diphenhydramine sales after 2023 death
The young man, whose identity is not revealed in the report made public, died of acute diphenhydramine poisoning at his home in St-Mathias-sur-Richelieu.
On the morning of Dec. 11, 2023, the man was found by his mother in his bed, unconscious and laying on his back. Toxicological analysis found the man had a lethal level of diphenhydramine in his blood.
The drug is the sedating ingredient in some over-the-counter antihistamines including the brand Benadryl, among others.
The coroner found the circumstances surrounding the death raise questions about the uncontrolled availability of a potentially lethal over-the-counter substance. He noted there is consensus about the risks of poisoning among scientific bodies, but it's not stored behind the counter.
Story continues below advertisement
'I cannot understand why the sale of diphenhydramine … is not better controlled,' coroner Vincent Denault wrote. 'I can't understand why diphenhydramine is available over the counter, especially since Gravol, which also contains diphenhydramine, isn't available.'
Get daily National news
Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
In a report dated from late April but released this week, the coroner wrote the man's death is attributed to the acute toxicity of diphenhydramine, a central nervous system depressant which if consumed in sufficient quantities causes fatal respiratory depression and irregular heartbeat, which can lead to fatal cardiac arrhythmias.
The coroner noted there were previously used empty jars and blister packs of diphenhydramine tablets in the man's bedroom.
'Was he taking them to sleep better? Could he have taken pills in the same way, but in larger quantities, during the night of December 10-11, 2023?' the coroner asked.
Denault noted it wasn't the first time deaths have occurred due to the drug. The coroner has already weighed in on three previous Quebec investigations.
There was an uptick around in 2020 after the so-called Benadryl TikTok challenge on social media invited users to consume large quantities of medication tablets containing diphenhydramine.
'The deaths of children have put a face to this dangerous trend,' Denault wrote. 'The scientific literature confirms that diphenhydramine is consumed in high doses for its euphoric and hallucinogenic effects, and that people have used it to commit suicide.'
Story continues below advertisement
Denault's recommendation was for the provincial office of professions to take steps to amend regulations involving the sale of medicinal products, to classify diphenhydramine intended for oral administration in a section that requires more management by pharmacists.
That management would include creating a file, noting the sale and carrying out a pharmacological study of the file.
Denault also asked the coroner's office to share the report with the Collège des médecins du Québec — the province's College of Physicians — and the Ordre des pharmaciens du Québec, the body that oversees pharmacists in the province.
Jean-François Desgagné, president of the pharmacists' order, said this week the order would review the coroner's recommendation to reclassify the drug to assess the appropriateness of moving it behind the pharmacist's counter.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Number of Mounties on long-term sick leave poses 'significant operational challenges': report
The proportion of Mounties on long-term, off-duty sick leave has reached an all-time high and become a critical issue for the national police force, according to a new outside report. The Management Advisory Board (MAB), an oversight body that advises the RCMP commissioner, is warning that the existing model of unlimited sick leave at full pay is unsustainable and in need of a rethink in order to get more officers back on patrol — recommendations that are already garnering vehement disagreement from the RCMP union. "The rapid increase over the past fifteen years in the number of RCMP employees on [leave] presents an area of well-being concern at the individual level and poses significant operational challenges at the organizational level," said the report from the board's well-being task force. "It also has the potential to impact public safety writ large," the report continued. "This increase also comes with significant associated financial costs." Long-term, off-duty sick status is used for absences due to illness, injury or disability that exceed 30 consecutive days. According to the task force's figures, the number of RCMP regular members on leave has increased by 184 per cent over a 14-year period. As of Dec. 31, 2024, about seven per cent of the regular members were on long-term, off-duty leave at an approximate cost of $58 million, the task force estimated in its report. It also raised concerns about the number of Mounties on extended leave for more than a year. As it stands, the task force — which said it talked to regular members, supervisors and senior leadership — found the model "offers no incentive to return to work." The task force said it recognizes Mounties put their lives on the line and many will face injury and trauma during their careers. "These injuries, whether mental, physical, or otherwise, need appropriate recovery time," said the report. However, it also recommends the RCMP rethink its unlimited sick leave regime at full pay, and consider incorporating a reduction in pay after a pre-established period on leave. "The task force heard repeatedly that the current unlimited sick leave at full pay model used by the RCMP is unsustainable in its current state, places undue pressure on the organization and has an adverse impact on the RCMP's human, financial and technical resources," it said. RCMP says it's reviewing recommendations The union representing thousands of RCMP officers vehemently disagrees with the report's findings. Brian Sauvé, president of the National Police Federation, said the issues don't lie with the sick leave pay model, but with how it's managed. He believes the report missed the union's warnings that the RCMP's disability management accommodation program is not properly funded. "They never looked at the fact that there's a shared responsibility here, and half that responsibility rests with management," Sauvé said in an interview. "Members fall through the cracks, are not contacted by their employer — sometimes for six months or longer — for return-to-work programs or disability management accommodation programs." The MAB report pointed to models used by other police forces to reduce pay for members on leave. For example, it said the Edmonton Police Service reduces pay to 90 per cent or 75 per cent, at the chief's discretion, after 85 days of sick leave. Sauvé countered that RCMP members are in a unique position as they fall outside of any provincial or territorial worker compensation scheme. He also said sick leave is something that must be decided through collective bargaining, and any proposal to modify it must be brought to the union. "So you can provide advice all you want to the RCMP commissioner. If they want to bring it to the bargaining table, they can." The RCMP said the board's report "is currently under comprehensive review," and it will deliver a more substantive response to the advisory body shortly. "The RCMP welcomes the MAB's engagement on this important issue, as the need to improve how the RCMP manages long term off-duty sick cases has been identified as a key area of concern by employees and by management at the RCMP," said spokesperson Camille Boily-Lavoie
Global News
8 hours ago
- Global News
Nanaimo mayor pushes back after province rules out ‘sober' housing project
The mayor of Nanaimo, B.C., is pressing the province to reconsider, after it ruled out making a proposed new 50-unit supportive housing a sober-only facility. Nanaimo Mayor Leonard Krog and city council voted recently to write the province, advocating for the planned 250 Terminal Ave. project to be a 'dry' facility. The proposal is to build a five-storey building with 50 studio homes, targeted at people currently experiencing or at risk of homelessness in Nanaimo. 2:05 Nanaimo temporary housing unit program expands Krog said the city wants to see the project used to house people who have already made the leap to sobriety. Story continues below advertisement 'We're just saying, look, those folks that have managed to quit using for whatever reason and with whatever assistance, please give them a place to live where they're not subject to seeing their friends, their neighbours consuming substances every day,' he said. Get weekly health news Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'In order to save lives you have to provide safe places for people and a safe place when you're trying to remain clean and sober is not to be surrounded by people in active addiction, not to be in a place where drug dealers and others can come and annoy you or take advantage of your vulnerabilities.' Housing Minister Christine Boyle said that recovery-oriented housing is an 'important piece of the housing continuum,' and that the province is building another 78-space facility called 'The Sparrow' in Nanaimo that will serve people who want to minimize exposure to alcohol and drugs. But she said the Terminal Avenue project has always been planned under the province's 'housing first' model. 'Which means being able to bring people indoors and then support them in accessing the health service supports that they need, wherever along their journey they are,' she said. 1:58 Nanaimo RV residents granted bylaw reprieve Boyle acknowledged that the Sparrow facility won't be 100 per cent dry either, saying that model would risk kicking people back out onto the street if they relapse. Story continues below advertisement 'If you relapse, which is a common part of the journey. And you risk also losing your housing, that it becomes that much harder to get back on that path,' she said. Krog said the province has become too focused on the housing first model, arguing, 'it's not the 10 Commandments.' 'It's a rule, the province can change it. It's a policy, the province can change it,' he said. 'For heaven sakes, open your minds up a little bit on this and stop sticking to what I would call an ideologically-based position that is parroted by many in the health community, but sometimes I wonder if any of them have any real experience with the people who've managed to get out of addiction.' Boyle said bringing people indoors into housing is a key first step in cutting down on the street disorder and open drug use that have become major points of public contention in communities like Nanaimo. She said the province will be working closely with the city and service providers to ensure safety at the facility.
Global News
10 hours ago
- Global News
Nutrien Wonderhub increases prices, reduces hours due to funding shortfall
Saskatoon's Nutrien Wonderhub is reducing hours and increasing prices next month, after it was unable to attain operating funding from the provincial government. As a result, the non-profit is facing a $300,000 shortfall due to inflation, rising costs, and a lack of core operational funding. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Saskatchewan's Ministry of Parks, Culture and Sport said, in a statement: 'Nutrien Wonderhub is requesting $300,000 in annual funding from the province to reduce their operating deficit, with a commitment of up to five years. 'While the Ministry of Parks, Culture, and Sport is unable to provide the requested funding outside of its approved budget, Nutrien Wonderhub's request will be considered alongside other priorities across government as part of the budget process for next year.' As Global's Nicole Healey explains in the video above, it's not just parents that are upset by the cost, but Nutrien Wonderhub itself for not being able to stay affordable for all families.
