Singaporeans shocked by S$52K/month rental for Tampines clinic
SINGAPORE: On Sunday (Jun 1), a doctor shared on LinkedIn that a rental clinic in Tampines is going for a monthly rental rate of more than S$52,000 per month.
Dr. Hisham Badaruddin posted a screenshot of the final result for the bid of S$52,188 for Block 954C, Tampines Street 96, indicating that Lum Sian Wei Shaun was the successful tenderer. Its closing date was Jan 14, 2025.
'This is obscene … S$52K per month rental for a clinic in a HDB area? Madness…,' wrote Dr Hisham, whose LinkedIn bio says he is a Longevity Medicine Physician, in the caption to his post, adding that he believes the Ministry of Health might say that rentals in the private sector are out of their purview. Screenshot
His post has since garnered many reactions and shares, with some commenters expressing concern that the high rental rate could be passed on to patients, who might find themselves saddled with higher consultation fees.
In response to a question about the clinic's size, Dr Hisham guessed that it's likely to be less than 1,000 square meters.
'That's crazy! Can't believe this is a HDB tender!!' a commenter wrote.
'Rent in Singapore is abhorrently high, especially when it comes to businesses, and let's not talk about renewal of leases once you have invested your hard-earned money in renovation. The landlord knows you are stuck between a rock and a hard place!' wrote another LinkedIn user.
Over on Reddit, where the post was shared, the top comment pointed out that 'Caring Pte Ltd, who was second in this bid, won two other bids with a S$25K/mo rent. In the same doc, there are two clinics in the North that went for S$4.2K and S$5K each.
If the outlets were listed at these rates, Hisham might have a point, but in a closed bidding system, if he's literally bidding twice the amount as the next person, then either he's spoiling the market, or there's something special about that location that guarantees crazy good business.' See also Has the Wage Gap in Singapore Really Been Closing?
Another agreed saying, 'There will always be these opportunistic people who'll try to ruin the playing field for market share & supposedly future gains.'
'Location is at a new BTO estate that recently TOP-ed, winning bid is essentially paying over the top to get a first mover advantage by trying to lock their patients in,' a commenter pointed out.
A Reddit user wrote, 'S$52k is absolutely insane. It is double or triple the current market rate to rent in a populated HDB area. How do they even sustain? It doesn't seem right unless they are open for long hours or 24/7.'
Some commenters on LinkedIn and Facebook, however, wrote that the renter may be planning an aesthetic clinic instead of a GP clinic, a practice that can be very lucrative indeed. /TISG
Read also: Resident tells Jamus Lim her industry is being killed by high rental costs
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AsiaOne
an hour ago
- AsiaOne
$52k bid to rent Tampines clinic 'highest' psf received for GP, dental clinics of this size: HDB, Singapore News
The $52,188 monthly rental bid for a general practitioner (GP) clinic in Tampines is the highest per square foot rent that the Housing Development Board (HDB) has received for GP and dental clinics of this size to date. Responding to AsiaOne's queries on Thursday (June 5), HDB said that the tender for the Tampines clinic attracted 13 bids in total. It was awarded to Dr Shaun Lum, the co-owner of I-Health Medical Holdings, in March 2025, at $52,188 a month. The unit at Block 954C Tampines Street 96 in March is reportedly 52 sqm, which is about 560 sq ft big. "This is significantly higher than the average tendered rent of around $9,800 per month for similar-sized clinics let by HDB in 2024 and it is also the highest per square foot rent that HDB has received for GP and dental clinics of this size to date," said HDB. The housing board added that all tenders awarded for GP clinics thus far are based on tendered price. And that bids submitted by tenderers — including private clinic operators — are business decisions influenced by various factors including location, shop size, trades, and prevailing market conditions. "The rental for this Tampines clinic does not set any price requirements for future tenders by HDB, and it also will not affect the rentals that HDB is charging other existing clinics," it said. "HDB and our partner agencies are committed to ensuring that residents have access to affordable and quality healthcare services in the heartlands." Ong Ye Kung 'dismayed' at bid Separately, Minister for Health Ong Ye Kung said in a Facebook post on Wednesday (June 4), that he was "dismayed" at the bid, which he stated was over $1,000 psm. He expressed concerns about the high rental cost leading to higher healthcare costs for residents, which would negate the Ministry of Health's (MOH) efforts to keep primary healthcare affordable. Ong added that higher rental bids do not necessarily translate to the best healthcare needed for the community. "The role of a GP is increasingly important, as our population ages," he said. "The GP is key in developing a relationship of trust with patients, and to guide them towards better health. He or she is the vital link to connect patients to acute hospital care, preventive community care and social prescriptions." In his post, Ong also highlighted that bids for future HDB GP clinics will be assessed using the Price-Quality evaluation Model (PQM), which focuses less on price (30 per cent), and more on quality of care (70 per cent). This model was first launched by MOH and HDB at the Bartley Beacon development in May. Pointing out that the Bartley unit was twice the size of normal clinics, Ong stated that it would be suited for clinics intending to provide multi-disciplinary care and try out new models of care. "Through this PQM, we can shift the competitive focus away from rental rates, to better care models, including preventive care, chronic disease management and mental health," he said. The Bartley Beacon tender closed on May 29 with a total of 18 tenderers. MOH and HDB are in the process of evaluating the tender and aim to award the tender by August this year. The health minister noted that the Tampines clinic was tendered in December last year and awarded in March this year, before the PQM model came into effect. "Going forward, and given the encouraging response to the Bartley Beacon site, we will make the new PQM approach the norm, when tendering our GP clinics in our HDB heartlands," said Ong. "It will be a meaningful shift, both in improving primary care, and ensuring greater affordability." We're not trying to 'squeeze' patients: I-Health I-Health Medical Holdings' co-owner Andrew Chim told CNA that instead of trying to "squeeze" patients for every bill, building long-term relationships is key to the firm's business model. He reassured that when the Tampines clinic opens later this month, patients will not pay above what other GPs are charging for consultations and medicine. "The idea is to focus on patients who stay with the clinic for decades and return for annual health screenings, vaccinations and chronic disease management," he said to CNA. "This is where we make our bread and butter – by looking after people over their entire lifetime." Chim also told The Straits Times that their bid was based on the attractive attributes of the area, pointing out that it is in the middle of Tampines West and near five Build-To-Order projects (with 5,000 households) as well as other upcoming developments like a new mixed-use project and a shopping mall. "Our assessment is based on our understanding of the number of units in the area and the surrounding competition," he said, adding that there are around five other clinics in the vicinity. Clinic has monopoly if it's the only one: Expert Speaking to AsiaOne, Professor Sing Tien Foo from the Department of Real Estate in NUS Business School said that while the bid amount is high for an HDB shop, the bidder may have taken other factors into consideration while making the bid. These factors could be the size of the shop, market coverage, and location — including the presence of other competing clinics nearby, he added. Prof Sing also pointed out that being adjacent to Our Tampines Hub (OTH) could also impact the rental price of the unit in question. When asked if this rent was sustainable, Prof Sing said: "It would depend on the business model and the operator's expected return." "A business operator may be able to generate higher revenue for the store, such as operating a 24-hour clinic or co-sharing the clinic with several doctors, which could not be done in OTH." "In this way, they could generate higher revenue to offset the high rental costs. If there are no other GP clinics in the estate, they could also enjoy a monopoly catchment area until other competing clinics enter." Experienced folks who understand the costs: Ho Ching Chairman of Temasek Trust Ho Ching also weighed in on the issue via a Facebook post on Thursday, stating that the owners of I-Health ware not "newbies", with three other operating clinics in other locations. "These are folks who have experience and know the operating costs," she explained. Ho also pointed out that I-Health Medical would likely keep its consultation fees affordable at $30 to $35 — "comparable to the general GP rates". She also provided a back of the envelope calculation, noting that at 100 patients a day, at $33 per consult, it'll work out to be $3300 per day, or about $99,000 a month of top line. "This topline revenue also excludes other services such as medication, etc," she added. "So from a patient's perspective, the winning bidder dollar does not translate to higher consult costs." She echoed similar theories to Prof Sing, suggesting that the clinic could even evolve to provide 24/7 urgent care provided they "demonstrate the ability to deliver good care affordably". [[nid:700274]] khooyihang@
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Indonesia allowing nickel industry abuses to go unchecked: Report
A local river is said to have been contaminated by nickel mining operations in Central Halmahera, North Maluku. PHOTO: AFP JAKARTA – The Indonesian government is allowing environmental damage, including deforestation and violations against indigenous people, to go unchecked around a multibillion-dollar industrial park on a once-pristine eastern island, a report said on June 5. Indonesia is both the world's largest nickel producer, and home to the biggest-known reserves, and a 2020 export ban has spurred a domestic industrial boom. Operations have grown around Weda Bay, the world's largest nickel mine by production, on Halmahera island as Indonesia exploits the metal reserves used in everything, from electric vehicle batteries to stainless steel. Climate Rights International (CRI) said companies had caused a spike in air and water pollution and deforestation around the industrial park, accusing the government of ignoring their conduct. 'The Indonesian government is giving a green light to corporate practices that prioritise profits over the rights of local communities and the environment,' Ms Krista Shennum, a researcher at Climate Rights International, told AFP. 'The Indonesian government should immediately hold companies accountable. This could include civil penalties, criminal prosecutions or rescinding permits.' Much of the park's nickel is sourced by Weda Bay Nickel (WBN), a joint venture of Indonesian mining firm Antam and Singapore-based Strand Minerals, with shares divided between French mining giant Eramet and Chinese steel major Tsingshan. An AFP report last week detailed how the home of the nomadic Hongana Manyawa tribe was being eaten away by the world's largest nickel mine, with members issuing a call for nickel companies to leave their tribal lands alone. 'Criminalisation, harrasment' Locals have reported a rise in air pollution from nickel processing smelters and rivers polluted by nickel tailings in soil brought down by heavy rain. Water tests by Indonesian NGOs AEER, Jatam, and Nexus3 Foundation in 2023 and 2024 'revealed dangerously high levels of nickel and hexavalent chromium, among other pollutants,' the report said. '(Companies) are failing local communities by not making information about the safety of important drinking water sources publicly available and accessible,' said Ms Shennum. Both WBN and Eramet told AFP last week that they work to minimise impacts on the environment, including conducting water tests. CRI also said Indonesian and foreign companies in coordination with police and military personnel had 'engaged in land grabbing, coercion and intimidation' of indigenous peoples and other communities. Local activists and students opposing the industrial park have 'faced criminalisation, harassment and smear campaigns', the report said. WBN and the Indonesian government did not immediately respond to a request for comment. But Indonesia's energy ministry told AFP last week that it was committed to 'protecting the rights of indigenous peoples and ensuring that mining activities do not damage their lives and environment'. AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
CNA938 Rewind - Paw-ssibly the Future: The Dog Grocer's Sustainable Take on Pet Nutrition
CNA938 Rewind In 'Made in SG', Melanie Oliveiro speaks with the founder of The Dog Grocer, a Singapore pet food manufacturer that's also touted as the country's first sustainable pet food store. Founder Soo Ming Hui, together with marketing manager Nicole Chong, will recall what jumpstarted the brand's creation, how they strive to produce optimal nutritious pet food in their AVS-licensed kitchen, how sustainable the brand is, and the different eats popular with furkids: from freeze-dried treats to marinated jerkies.
