Thomson View's $810 million sale put on hold after lawyers submitted ‘incomplete' documents
SINGAPORE - The $810 million sale of Thomson View condominium was put on hold by a High Court judge after the lawyers representing the collective sale committee (CSC) submitted 'incomplete' documents.
At least 25 residents and parties related to the Thomson View sale packed the courtroom on May 22, awaiting the High Court's ruling on the fate of the $810 million sale, potentially the biggest residential collective sale since Chuan Park's $890 million sale in May 2023.
High Court Judge Audrey Lim spent a better part of the hearing dressing down the lawyers of the Thomson View CSC for errors in documents, including submitting an 'incomplete' affidavit, and told them 'it is important you do the proper due diligence'.
Thomson View was sold to UOL, Singapore Land (SingLand) and CapitaLand Development (CLD), after at least 80 per cent of owners (206 units) consented to lower their reserve price to $808 million, allowing them to accept the $810 million offer that was below their original reserve price of $918 million.
UOL, SingLand and CLD signed a conditional call-and-put option in October 2024 to acquire the 99-year leasehold development at $810 million. On Nov 25, 2024, UOL announced that it had exercised the call option for the purchase.
In trying to determine if the 80 per cent threshold was met, Justice Lim sought clarifications on the number of signatures in the collective sale agreement (CSA) dated Jan 4, 2024, and the number of signatures in a supplementary collective sale agreement.
The judge pointed out that 'the first time period to obtain all the signatures to cross the 80 per cent threshold is 12 months from the first signature, which means that all 206 signatures must be obtained between Jan 8, 2023, and Jan 7, 2024.
'Some of the signatures are signed out of the time period in October and November 2024,' Justice Lim noted.
CSC lawyer Hui Choon Wai, a partner at Wee Seow Teow LLP, told the court that 'there were 211 unit holders' signatures on the CSA, of which 206 signed the supplementary agreement'.
Justice Lim then asked Ms Hui to explain in another affidavit 'how the CSA and the supplementary CSA differs, in that the CSA contained 211 unit holders' signatures and the supplementary CSA contained 206 of these unit holders' signatures.'
'For the supplementary affidavit, it should only exhibit the extra five unit holders' signatures which are not found in the CSA already exhibited in (CSC member) Cecilia Koh's first affidavit.
'The affidavit should also explain how many of these unit holders signed between Jan 8, 2023, and Jan 7, 2024, and what proportion in terms of shares and plot size they comprise, and whether the 80 per cent requirement was met within the 12-month period,' the judge said.
'The affidavit should also explain that for those signatures that I have pointed out, that are after Jan 7, 2024, how many units they comprise and what is the proportion in terms of shares and plot size,' Justice Lim added.
'If the 80 per cent threshold is not made out, counsel is to file written submissions to explain why the court should grant this application' to approve the sale, Justice Lim said.
'It is important you do the proper due diligence,' the judge said.
'You spent a lot of time trying to get the requisite (80 per cent) threshold... and you have errors all over the place,' she added.
A group of dissenting homeowners had filed objections to the Strata Titles Boards (STB) , which stopped the en bloc process after mediation efforts failed. It is unclear on what grounds they objected to the sale.
Two of the six dissenting homeowners – Goh Mia Song and Lim Choe San – who had withdrawn their objections on March 29, were at the hearing.
When asked by The Straits Times why they had objected initially, both declined to comment.
The other four dissenting parties did not attend the hearing. They had withdrawn their objections one day before the CSC applied to the High Court on March 28 to seek approval for the sale.
Apart from the stop order issued on March 19 for Thomson View, there have been no other stop orders issued for collective sales so far in 2025, an STB spokesperson told ST.
The next court mention is July 1.
Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
a day ago
- Business Times
UOL has enough catalysts to remain a top pick despite the stock's 39% gain year to date
[SINGAPORE] Property developer UOL has been on a bull run recently. And it might be entering a new growth phase. In the year to Tuesday (Aug 19), the stock is up 39 per cent at S$7.19, after hitting a multi-year high of S$7.30 on Aug 14. Already, Singapore's largest developer by market capitalisation has been busy building up its pipeline of prime residential sites, completing major asset enhancement initiatives and redeveloping its Central Business District (CBD) assets. UOL launched Watten House in March last year, Meyer Blue last October, Parktown Residences this February and Upperhouse this July. These projects all sold between 50 and 87 per cent of their units over their launch weekends. The group has a Holland Drive project, Skye at Holland, for which it is planning to start previews in September. UOL will also be redeveloping Thomson View Condominium, which it bought together with CapitaLand Development in October 2024, into a 1,240-unit project at a later date. So far, UOL has spent close to S$4.2 billion together with its joint venture partners to acquire land for these six projects. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The developer had been comparatively subdued in the period from 2020 to 2023, when it launched one residential project a year in Singapore. Even before the Covid-19 pandemic, it was not as active, with only two launches a year between 2018 and 2019. In its latest financial results for the first half of 2025, UOL reported a 58 per cent increase in net profit to S$205.5 million. Revenue from property development increased by 40 per cent to S$210 million compared to the year-ago period, due to progressive revenue recognition from Pinetree Hill, Watten House and Meyer Blue. In the second half of the year, revenue recognition from UOL's four newest condominium launches will likely start trickling in, which should bode well for the developer's full-year results. Parktown Residences will likely deliver a big boost. The integrated development sold more than 87 per cent of its 1,193 units during its launch in February 2025. This remains one of the highest take-up rates for a new launch this year. Upperhouse at Orchard Boulevard, which was launched in July, also did well. It was the best-selling Core Central Region project since Midtown Modern was launched in 2021, moving 162 or more than 53.8 per cent of its 301 units at an average price of S$3,350 per square foot (psf). This record has since been beaten by Wing Tai's River Green, which sold 88 per cent of its units at an average of S$3,130 psf in the same month. UOL's success with its recent projects is testament to how the developer is able to appeal to both the mass market and luxury segments of buyers. Some of these projects, such as Upperhouse and the redevelopment of Thomson View, are also located along the newly opened Thomson-East Coast Line, bringing connectivity which buyers will appreciate. CGS International, Citi and DBS Research all ranked UOL as their top pick among listed Singapore developers in reports published earlier this year. Solid margins DBS analysts Derek Tan and Tabitha Foo rated UOL a 'buy', with a target price of S$8.50 in March. They noted how both Upperhouse and Skye at Holland were sites acquired at significantly lower land costs, which could drive an expansion in UOL's development margins and support higher profitability in the medium term. The site on which Upperhouse sits was acquired for S$1,616 psf per plot ratio (ppr) in February 2024. This is 32 per cent lower than the S$2,377 psf ppr that SC Global and Hong Kong-listed FEC Properties and New World Development paid in May 2018 for a nearby site, which is now Cuscaden Reserve. UOL bought the site on which Skye at Holland will be built at S$1,285 psf ppr in May 2024. This was 32 per cent lower than the S$1,888 psf ppr paid by a consortium led by Far East Organization for the site next to it – which has since been developed into One Holland Village. For Skye at Holland, as long as UOL is able to move its units at S$2,700 psf, it should be able to achieve a comfortable 20 per cent margin, DBS Research estimated. Recurring income, diversified streams UOL's diversified portfolio and its strong presence in the commercial and hotel industries allow the group to generate recurring income streams, OCBC Investment Research said in August after the group reported earnings for H1. Besides its property development business, UOL also has its hospitality business, which it controls through its subsidiary Pan Pacific. Its other subsidiary Singapore Land Group (SingLand) owns an extensive portfolio of prime office and retail assets in Singapore, Australia, China and the UK. In H1, UOL's Singapore office portfolio had a committed occupancy of 96.6 per cent, while its retail portfolio had a committed occupancy of 97.3 per cent. Hotel occupancy edged up to 77 per cent in H1. Now that the developer has mostly completed its asset enhancement initiatives for Singapore Land Tower, this should lead to positive rental reversions as the supply of Grade A office space remains tight in the CBD. Piling works also began last year for SingLand's redevelopment of its iconic Clifford Centre. When completed in 2028, the premium Grade A asset will have more than 52,000 square metres of office and retail space and will be directly connected to the Raffles Place MRT station. And if UOL and SingLand proceed with the proposed redevelopment of Marina Square, DBS Research believes the gross development value of the asset could increase to 4.5 times its existing value of S$1.05 billion upon completion. 'This key value-unlocking activity is expected to drive the share prices of both groups higher,' DBS said. As for its hotel segment, UOL recently completed asset enhancement initiatives for Parkroyal Parramatta in Sydney and Pan Pacific Perth in May 2025. Both hotels are expected to benefit from the Australian Trade and Investment Commission's projected 41 per cent increase in tourism arrivals in Australia between 2024 and 2028, which makes UOL's strategic expansion into the Australia hospitality market timely. Will UOL maintain its lead? UOL's latest financial results have been strong, but chief executive Liam Wee Sin said the group will remain disciplined in its approach to portfolio management, project execution and capital deployment in a world adjusting to a new trade order. In May, Citi analyst Brandon Lee flagged several downside risks for UOL, such as cap rates expanding should interest rates rise, an economic slowdown, fall in tourism arrivals and the continuation of cooling measures for a prolonged period. For H1, Singapore's gross domestic product growth averaged 4.2 per cent year on year, but the Ministry of Trade and Industry foresees 'significant uncertainty and downside risks' in H2, given the lack of clarity over the US' tariff policies. There is, however, a silver lining in sight, as interest rates have been falling since the start of the year. In January, the three-month compounded Singapore Overnight Rate Average was around 3.02 per cent. As at Tuesday, it was around 1.7 per cent. The rate may moderate further, as the US Federal Reserve is expected to cut interest rates in September. Lower interest expenses could drive UOL's return on equity (ROE) higher. DBS Research estimates that a decline of 100 basis points in floating debt could lead to a 13 percentage point increase in ROE for UOL based on a sensitivity analysis. Given the low interest rate environment and the value that can be unleashed, perhaps it is a good time for UOL to redevelop Marina Square, should it obtain written permission from the Urban Redevelopment Authority to do so. While its net gearing ratio has inched up slightly in H1 to 0.25 from 0.23, the group's balance sheet still remains healthy, which should allow it to maintain its strong momentum for the rest of the year.
Business Times
a day ago
- Business Times
UOL could have enough catalysts to remain a top pick among property stocks
[SINGAPORE] Property developer UOL has been on a bull run recently. And it might be entering a new growth phase. Already, Singapore's largest developer by market capitalisation has been busy building up its pipeline of prime residential sites, completing major asset enhancement initiatives and redeveloping its Central Business District (CBD) assets. UOL launched Watten House in March last year, Meyer Blue last October, Parktown Residences this February and Upperhouse this July. These projects all sold between 50 and 87 per cent of their units over their launch weekends. The group has a Holland Drive project, Skye at Holland, for which it is planning to start previews in September. UOL will also be redeveloping Thomson View Condominium, which it bought together with CapitaLand Development in October 2024, into a 1,240-unit project at a later date. So far, UOL has spent close to S$4.2 billion together with its joint venture partners to acquire land for these six projects. The developer had been comparatively subdued in the period from 2020 to 2023, when it launched one residential project a year in Singapore. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Even before the Covid-19 pandemic, it was not as active, with only two launches a year between 2018 and 2019. In its latest financial results for the first half of 2025, UOL reported a 58 per cent increase in net profit to S$205.5 million. Revenue from property development increased by 40 per cent to S$210 million compared to the year-ago period, due to progressive revenue recognition from Pinetree Hill, Watten House and Meyer Blue. In the second half of the year, revenue recognition from UOL's four newest condominium launches will likely start trickling in, which should bode well for the developer's full-year results. Parktown Residences will likely deliver a big boost. The integrated development sold more than 87 per cent of its 1,193 units during its launch in February 2025. This remains one of the highest take-up rates for a new launch this year. Upperhouse at Orchard Boulevard, which was launched in July, also did well. It was the best-selling Core Central Region project since Midtown Modern was launched in 2021, moving 162 or more than 53.8 per cent of its 301 units at an average price of S$3,350 per square foot (psf). This record has since been beaten by Wing Tai's River Green, which sold 88 per cent of its units at an average psf of S$3,130 psf in the same month. UOL's success with its recent projects is testament to how the developer is able to appeal to both the mass market and luxury segments of buyers. Some of these projects, such as Upperhouse and the redevelopment of Thomson View, are also located along the newly opened Thomson-East Coast Line, bringing connectivity which buyers will appreciate. CGS International, Citi and DBS Research all ranked UOL as their top pick among listed Singapore developers in reports published earlier this year. Solid margins DBS analysts Derek Tan and Tabitha Foo rated UOL a 'buy', with a target price of S$8.50 in March. They noted how both Upperhouse and Skye at Holland were sites acquired at significantly lower land costs, which could drive an expansion in UOL's development margins and support higher profitability in the medium term. The site on which Upperhouse sits was acquired for S$1,616 psf per plot ratio (ppr) in February 2024. This is 32 per cent lower than the S$2,377 psf ppr that SC Global and Hong Kong-listed FEC Properties and New World Development paid in May 2018 for a nearby site, which is now Cuscaden Reserve. UOL bought the site on which Skye at Holland will be built at S$1,285 psf ppr in May 2024. This was 32 per cent lower than the S$1,888 psf ppr paid by a consortium led by Far East Organization for the site next to it – which has since been developed into One Holland Village. For Skye at Holland, as long as UOL is able to move its units at S$2,700 psf, it should be able to achieve a comfortable 20 per cent margin, DBS Research estimated. Recurring income, diversified streams UOL's diversified portfolio and its strong presence in the commercial and hotel industries allow the group to generate recurring income streams, OCBC Investment Research said in August after the group reported earnings for H1. Besides its property development business, UOL also has its hospitality business, which it controls through its subsidiary Pan Pacific. Its other subsidiary Singapore Land Group (SingLand) owns an extensive portfolio of prime office and retail assets in Singapore, Australia, China and the UK. In H1, UOL's Singapore office portfolio had a committed occupancy of 96.6 per cent, while its retail portfolio had a committed occupancy of 97.3 per cent. Hotel occupancy edged up to 77 per cent in H1. Now that the developer has mostly completed its asset enhancement initiatives for Singapore Land Tower, this should lead to positive rental reversions as the supply of Grade A office space remains tight in the CBD. Piling works also began last year for SingLand's redevelopment of its iconic Clifford Centre. When completed in 2028, the premium Grade A asset will have more than 52,000 square metres of office and retail space and will be directly connected to the Raffles Place MRT station. And if UOL and SingLand proceed with the proposed redevelopment of Marina Square, DBS Research believes the gross development value of the asset could increase to 4.5 times its existing value of S$1.05 billion upon completion. 'This key value-unlocking activity is expected to drive the share prices of both groups higher,' DBS said. As for its hotel segment, UOL recently completed asset enhancement initiatives for Parkroyal Parramatta in Sydney and Pan Pacific Perth in May 2025. Both hotels are expected to benefit from the Australian Trade and Investment Commission's projected 41 per cent increase in tourism arrivals in Australia between 2024 and 2028, which makes UOL's strategic expansion into the Australia hospitality market timely. Will UOL maintain its lead? UOL's latest financial results have been strong, but chief executive Liam Wee Sin said the group will remain disciplined in its approach to portfolio management, project execution and capital deployment in a world adjusting to a new trade order. In May, Citi analyst Brandon Lee flagged several downside risks for UOL, such as cap rates expanding should interest rates rise, an economic slowdown, fall in tourism arrivals and the continuation of cooling measures for a prolonged period. For H1, Singapore's gross domestic product growth averaged 4.2 per cent year on year, but the Ministry of Trade and Industry foresees 'significant uncertainty and downside risks' in H2, given the lack of clarity over the US' tariff policies. There is, however, a silver lining in sight, as interest rates have been falling since the start of the year. In January, the three-month compounded Singapore Overnight Rate Average was around 3.02 per cent. As at Tuesday (Aug 19), it was around 1.7 per cent. The rate may moderate further, as the US Federal Reserve is expected to cut interest rates in September. Lower interest expenses could drive UOL's return on equity (ROE) higher. DBS Research estimates that a decline of 100 basis points in floating debt could lead to a 13 percentage point increase in ROE for UOL based on a sensitivity analysis. Given the low interest rate environment and the value that can be unleashed, perhaps it is a good time for UOL to redevelop Marina Square, should it obtain written permission from the Urban Redevelopment Authority to do so. While its net gearing ratio has inched up slightly in H1 to 0.25 from 0.23, the group's balance sheet still remains healthy, which should allow it to maintain its strong momentum for the rest of the year.
Straits Times
5 days ago
- Straits Times
Pan Pac, Parkroyal owner UOL makes first move into student housing
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Data also showed that applications for British study visas by international students rose in the first quarter of 2025. SINGAPORE – The real estate company that owns Pan Pacific and Parkroyal hotels has made its first move into student housing, expanding its business beyond hospitality, residential and commercial properties. Singapore-listed UOL Group on Aug 14 said it had made successful inroads into Britain's student accommodation sector with the acquisition of Varley Park in Brighton for £43.5 million (S$75.6 million). The 22-block complex is located on more than 2.8ha of land, or the size of four football fields, and comprises 771 student beds. It includes an amenity block with modern conferencing facilities and a dining hall. The property will be leased back to the University of Brighton under an agreement that ensures steady rental income. UOL chief executive Liam Wee Sin said demand for purpose built student accommodation (PBSA), or lodging equipped with amenities and services catered to students' needs, is rising in Britain as more are now able to afford better facilities. Data also showed that applications for British study visas by international students rose in the first quarter of 2025. 'We see strong potential in the PBSA segment as it is a resilient asset class with strong fundamentals and provides opportunities for us to grow the portfolio in key markets,' he said, adding that the group could leverage its hospitality and residential development expertise to expand into the broader living sector. The purchase will be funded through a mix of internal resources and external borrowings, in line with UOL's strategy to diversify and strengthen its recurring income base. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. World No peace deal, but 'great progress' made in meeting with Putin over Ukraine war: Trump World Made-for-TV pageantry in Alaska as Trump brings Putin in from the cold Singapore Nowhere to run: Why Singapore needs to start protecting its coasts now Singapore Using nature, multi-use structures among solutions being studied to protect Singapore coastlines Singapore ICA to review Ong Beng Seng's PR status after he is fined for abetting obstruction of justice Singapore HSA evaluating rapid urine test kits to enable faster detection of etomidate, found in Kpods Singapore Drug trafficker gets death sentence commuted after President Tharman grants clemency UOL is not the first company on the Singapore Exchange eyeing growth opportunities in the PBSA market. Accommodation provider Centurion Corp in July launched a new PBSA brand, Epiisod, in Sydney, marking its second student housing property in Australia. It already runs eight such properties in Britain. The assets, expected to deliver steady rental returns, will eventually be spun off into a real estate investment trust that Centurion expects to launch in late 2025. The other company operating PBSA assets is Wee Hur. The company has eight such properties in Australia, where a cap on foreign students will be raised by 9 per cent to 295,000 in 2026, the government said on Aug 4. A limit on places were announced last year as a way to rein in record migration that had contributed to a surge in housing prices, but the cap is now being tweaked after the policy successfully curtailed growth in the number of international student numbers in Australia. For UOL, the Varley Park deal will also be its fourth property in Britain after Pan Pacific London, and mixed-use properties 120 Holborn Island and 110 High Holborn. The company on Aug 14 reported a 58 per cent rise in net profit to $205.5 million for the first half of 2025, on the back of strong performances from property development and investments.
