Skye power line approved despite council and resident objections
SSEN has said the line needs to be strengthened to maintain electricity to homes and businesses in Skye and the Western Isles, as well as renewable energy developments which are set to rely on the new line to carry electricity into the national grid.
READ MORE: Zonal pricing could save Scottish glass sector £20 million, report says
However, campaigners have said extensive surveys were carried out on SSEN's "preferred route" and no others without informing communities.
It has also renewed calls against a large camp for up to 350 workers which will move to the Skye during the construction of the new electricity line, adding to the population of the town of around 1000 people for an estimated five years.
Food and facilities company Sodexo is seeking permission from Highland Council for a camp for SSEN workers in Broadford, Skye.
To meet the required increased capacity of the replacement line, steel structures will be required from Fort Augustus to Edinbane, extending the existing steel structures where they currently terminate at Broadford; with wooden poles remaining from Edinbane to Ardmore.
Around 15km of the circuit will be undergrounded as it passes the Cuillin Hills and another 9km where it connects to Fort Augustus substation.
The planning submission was submitted to the Scottish Government's Energy Consents Unit in September 2022.
Rob McDonald, managing director of SSEN Transmission, said: 'We welcome this positive decision. The Skye reinforcement project is crucial to maintaining local network reliability and will play an important role in helping the UK achieve its energy security and clean power ambitions.
'This project and our wider investment programme will also be a major driver of jobs and economic growth locally and across the north of Scotland, bringing substantial opportunities for communities and businesses.
'We trust that the Scottish Government's new guidance, setting out a 52-week determination period, will see future projects progress in line with the acceleration needed to achieve the country's clean power mission.
"As we now move to the delivery phase of the project, we are committed to working constructively with local communities and businesses to minimise and mitigate construction impacts, alongside maximising the economic, infrastructure and job opportunities this investment will bring."
The Skye Wind Farm Information Group said they were "deeply disappointed" to learn that the Scottish Government granted planning permission, with Dr Andrew Robinson stating: 'The Highland Council objected to the plans in November 2023. As the local planning authority, such an objection would normally trigger a public inquiry, but, instead planning consent has been given and the council's objection ignored. This is a failure of democracy."
A second camp has also been proposed by Balfor Beauly. It is believed the accommodation could see another 350/400 people in the town.
READ MORE: Views sought on plans for major renewable 'energy park' in Perthshire
Robinson added: "The power line brings with it pylons, quarries, trenches and giant substations at Edinbane and Broadford. The two workers camps proposed either side of Broadford village, housing up to 800 workers are only needed to build the power line and the substations.
"These should have been included in the original planning paperwork for the OHL but instead have been salami sliced into separate applications.
"Whilst SSEN told us the existing line is old and needs replacing, their new power line will be much larger, at a size only necessary to take the electricity from all the wind farms proposed for Skye.
"Other options to build a smaller scale line, replacing the existing infrastructure and allowing some extra capacity for smaller scale community owned wind farms were never properly considered.
"This decision today could be seen as a presumption from the Scottish Government that all the wind farms proposed for Skye will be built.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
11 hours ago
- The National
Scottish farm fumes as council gives milk contract to German dairy giant
Mossgiel Organic Dairy teamed up with the local authority back in 2021 to provide every school in the area with its organic milk. The farm in Mauchline, where Robert Burns once ploughed the fields and wrote many of his famous verses, aims to provide sustainable, organic milk while challenging the dominance of the bigger dairy companies and their negative impact on the industry. READ MORE: Scottish 85-year-old pens scathing letter to Keir Starmer over immigration rules The farm has won multiple awards and is known for providing a high quality product whilst also being environmentally friendly. For example, it was the first dairy farm in the UK to ditch single-use plastics But, The National can now confirm that the council has decided to award the contract to Müller – a German multinational firm which is considered the largest dairy brand in the UK. Mossgiel took to social media to hit out at the move. In a statement, they claimed: 'On paper, the council saves £6500 a year. In reality, here's the rest of the bill: "Recycling costs: Single-use milk packaging could add £2000–£5000 a year to waste bills, even if they pour from bigger supermarket jugs instead of little cartons. "Jobs lost: Two full-time equivalent local roles gone; £50–55k removed from Ayrshire's economy, plus around £5k less in National Insurance contributions for public services. "Local milk value: £61,000 less per year for our farm and the co-op of organic family farms we work with." They then added: 'Best case? They save a couple of grand up front, but lose around £111,000 from the East Ayrshire economy. Worst case? No saving at all plus the loss of jobs, farm income and the circular economy on top. 'Either way, that's over £100,000 stripped out of our community every year, diesel fumes back in playgrounds, and a prayer that milk cartons actually make it into recycling instead of landfill. Oh, and profits? Straight to a German-owned company. We respect the council's decision but we don't agree with it.' In a statement to The National, East Ayrshire Council confirmed that Mossgiel Milk's bid to keep the contract was unsuccessful and that Müller will replace them. 'The Council remains committed to providing healthy nutritious school meals, and has for the past 20 years, issued fresh and organic food contracts. The contracts are designed to provide a range of produce that meets higher welfare, and health and nutritional value. The successful tenderers have committed to maintain these standards,' the council said. 'The council also has strong links through the Ayrshire Economic Forum that engages with the wider local market to promote opportunity; and there is also direct support from the council's business support team and the Supplier Development Programme, which delivers grant support and expertise to businesses exploring public sector procurement opportunities.'
The Herald Scotland
11 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Alarm as women-led businesses 'fail to thrive' in Scotland
WES has found that while women-led start-ups have increased to 54% of the total, the post-start-up pipeline has an attrition rate of 61%. Women-led employer businesses have dropped to just 20% of all employer businesses, its research shows. According to the organisation, the declining trend in Scotland stands in contrast to the global increase in established women-led businesses. This 'exposes a key disconnect' between Scotland's 'thriving' start-up culture and the inability of many such businesses to make it to the growth phase. WES declared that improving the current outcomes for female-led start-ups has the potential to unlock an estimated £17 billion boost to the Scottish economy every year. Read more: Carolyn Currie, chief executive of Women's Enterprise Scotland, said: 'A perfect storm of economic conditions and structural inequalities is halting the progress of women-led businesses, despite their start-up successes. What we are seeing is an alarming number of new women-led businesses failing to thrive. They are simply falling into an abyss, leaving their economic potential and the ambitions of their founders unfulfilled. The WES survey reveals a clear demand for needs-based business support, with the majority of respondents advocating for a Women's Business Centre model. 'Many of the issues - and suggested actions that need to be taken - have been highlighted in research numerous times over the past 30 years. We can continue to watch talented women entrepreneurs leave the market, taking billions in economic potential with them, or we can implement the evidence-based solutions this study provides. The choice is clear - the community has spoken, and we need to listen. The time for action is now.' WES noted that successive governments in Scotland have committed to inclusive growth and women's entrepreneurship, most recently in response to the Pathways Report, with up to £2.6m released for support in 2024 to 2025 and at least £4m in 2025 to 2026. However, it said women's entrepreneurship has not benefited from long-term investment in support provision that is comparable to other areas of business, despite the economic opportunity represented by women as 51% of the population. The WES survey found that economic conditions are threatening business sustainability and reveals a 'devastating' cost for women-led businesses; 78% cannot recover all their increased costs, 41% cannot recover any cost increases, 55% are using personal savings to capitalise their businesses, and 52% are making no pension provision, threatening retirement security.
STV News
13 hours ago
- STV News
David Martindale hailed as ‘great manager' after signing new Livingston deal
Livingston owner Calvin Ford described David Martindale as 'one of the great managers in Scottish football' after the Lions boss signed a new contract. Martindale has committed his future to Livi until the summer of 2027 with the option for a further season open to both parties. The 51-year-old initially joined Livi as a volunteer coach in 2014 and took over as manager in 2020, making him the longest-serving manager in the William Hill Premiership. Chairman Ford, who purchased a majority stake in the club in May, said: 'David Martindale has left an indelible mark on the recent chapter of the history of Livingston FC. 'Despite multiple challenges over the past several years, Davie's commitment to the club – including promoting back to the Premiership after just a single year in the Championship – have only further cemented his legacy as one of the great managers in Scottish football.' The American added: 'As we move into this next chapter at Livingston, there is only one man properly suited to lead us forward, and that's Davie. 'His unwavering commitment to the club, his partnership with and mentorship to his players, and his love and tireless work ethic of the game make this an easy decision. 'We are thrilled to have Davie leading us on the pitch as we look to make Livingston a threat in Scotland and beyond.' Martindale revealed earlier this week that he was considering leaving the club in the summer if he secured promotion, but had been 'rejuvenated' by the arrival of Ford, which has allowed him to focus on football. After signing the deal, Martindale said: 'I knew when Calvin and the board made it known that they would like me to remain at Livingston, there was only going to be one outcome. 'During the previous seasons it had been very hard for us all at the club and I will remain forever grateful to Dave Black, John Ward and John McIlvogue for allowing me the opportunity to try and take the club back to the Premiership. 'I did have it in my head that if we could take the club back to the Premiership, it would probably be my last season with Livingston and allow me to leave the club in the best position possible. 'But when Calvin and his team came in, it gave everyone at the club a massive lift and the more we all spoke and worked together, the more my appetite grew to be part of this – so long as they felt that they wanted me remain at Livingston. 'So when Calvin and the board got in touch and intimated that they would like me to stay at the club, it was a very easy decision and a very easy process.' Meanwhile, Martindale is facing some selection issues in defence when his side host Hibernian in the Premier Sports Cup second round on Sunday. Daniel Finlayson was missing for last weekend's win over Falkirk and fellow full-back Cammy Kerr is a long-term absentee. Left-back Adam Montgomery and centre-back Danny Wilson both went off with muscle injuries during the game, while midfielder Graham Carey was also forced off. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
