'No evidence': charity appeals decision in bid to keep shelter open
Homeless Project Scotland said the complaints depend on claims there has been a 'deterioration in local amenity and an alleged rise in anti-social behaviour'.
In its appeal, the charity said there is no evidence to back up the claims linking the shelter to the harms cited.
READ NEXT:'Frightened' homeless Glasgow teenager put in hostel dorm 'full of men'
The Shelter has been operating in Glassford Street since December 2023 with a free food service in the evenings.
Local residents and nearby businesses have said the shelter has led to more anti-social behaviour and said the queues outside before it opens are detrimental to the character of the area.
The charity in its submission states: 'Allegations of disorder, intimidation, and criminality are generalised in tone and speculative in content, often lacking dates, photographs, or incident reports.'
It also said it is significant that the police have not objected to the shelter.
The charity states it believes it has been refused permission on 'the basis of perception, prejudice, and an unevidenced fear of crime'.
READ NEXT:Mother and new baby turned up at homeless shelter needing help
It states: 'This omission carries substantial evidential and legal weight. In planning terms, the views of police are often determinative when objections relate to crime, public safety, or anti-social behaviour.
It adds that a named police officer confirmed there is no causal link between the shelter and crime trends in the area.
The ongoing wrangle has developed since the charity moved into the premises and operated without planning permission.
The council issued orders to close with a deadline to comply but the charity, in the meantime, applied for permission which was subsequently refused.
Homeless Project Scotland has now exercised its right to appeal the decision allowing it to continue operation until the process is exhausted.
The basis of its appeal is that the shelter is an essential part of the solution, not the cause of a persistent problem in Glasgow city centre.
The appeal states: 'These are long-standing urban challenges, rooted in structural factors such as economic deprivation, housing undersupply, public health inequalities, and mental illness.
'The shelter is not a source of the problem; it is an emergency intervention designed to alleviate its most dangerous manifestations.'
The organisation said that without the shelter, many people would be out on the streets overnight.
It said: 'The benefits of the night shelter are not speculative, they are verifiable and substantial.'
It added: 'The shelter's operation is consistent with the Ending Homelessness Together Action Plan, supports Glasgow City Council's statutory duties under the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987.'
A spokesperson for Glasgow City Council, said: 'An appeal has been received in respect of this application and it will be considered by the Planning Local Review Committee in due course.
'It would be inappropriate to comment further while this appeal is in place.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Nicola Sturgeon: 'Alex Salmond confessed to one of the complaints against him'
Nicola Sturgeon has revealed Alex Salmond 'effectively admitted' he was guilty of one of the complaints about his behaviour towards women which led to his split from the SNP. Ms Sturgeon said that her former mentor confessed during a meeting on April 4, 2018, when he showed her the contents of a letter from then-Permanent Secretary to the Scottish Government Leslie Evans, detailing the range of the allegations against him. She said she 'felt sick' at the nature of the complaints, one which particularly shocked her. Salmond insisted the allegation he had admitted to was a 'misunderstanding'. Mr Salmond, who publicly maintained his innocence, would later face trial on 14 charges of sexual assault. He was acquitted on 12 of the charges, while another was found not proven and one was dropped. In a second extract from her forthcoming memoir 'Frankly', published by The Times newspaper, former First Minister Sturgeon said her failure to protect her old boss led to him 'thirsting for revenge', and that he was 'determined' to bring her down her afterwards. She also claims that Salmond would rather have destroyed the SNP than see it succeed without him. Alex Salmond would later stand trial on 14 charges, mostly of sexual assault (Image: NQ) She writes: 'In the dining room of my house in Glasgow on April 4, 2018, with just him and me across a table, Alex showed me a copy of the letter he had received from the Scottish government's permanent secretary, Leslie Evans, informing him of the complaints against him. 'The substance of the complaints, one in particular, shocked me. I felt sick. After appearing to be upset and mortified by the allegations, Alex became cold. 'He effectively admitted the substance of one of the complaints, but claimed that it had been a 'misunderstanding', for which he had apologised at the time.' READ MORE: Nicola Sturgeon: 'I have never considered my sexuality to be binary' Nicola Sturgeon: 'Israel's war in Gaza is genocide' Kevin McKenna: 'A warm welcome by Sturgeon confessions leave me cold' She adds: 'He made it obvious that he considered the whole process to be illegitimate. He would later claim differently, of course, but it was evident that he wanted me to intervene and to stop the investigation in its tracks or divert it into some kind of siding. 'I knew that I shouldn't do that. I didn't realise it then, but this decision made the break-up of one of the most successful partnerships in modern British politics all but inevitable.' Ms Sturgeon has already shared a first extract from her book, where she detailed her belief that her sexuality is not binary, her despair at the probe into the SNP's finances which saw her and then-husband Peter Murrell arrested, and the heartache following her miscarriage in 2010. In this second section, she goes over the behind-the-scenes breakdown of her relationship with Mr Salmond, and her grief at the end of their partnership. Ms Sturgeon discusses the fallout from the botched investigation into the complaints carried out by the Scottish Government, which a judicial review launched by Salmond concluded had been "tainted with apparent bias" because the official who carried out the investigation had had contact with the complainers prior to the probe. Alex Salmond later claimed that a "malicious and concerted" attempt to remove him from public life had occurred, in papers published ahead of his appearance at a Holyrood inquiry into the Scottish government's mishandling of the investigation. Nicola Sturgeon and Alex Salmond were once thought to have had an unbreakable partnership (Image: PA) In her memoir, Ms Sturgeon rejects the conspiracy claim, saying it was impossible. She writes: "In Alex's narrative, he wasn't just a victim any more, he was now a vindicated victim. It was also at this point that his animus towards me was cemented. "He was reportedly furious that I hadn't demanded the resignation of Leslie Evans. Leslie was the head of the civil service that had 'botched' the process. It was not unreasonable to say that the buck stopped with her. "But I knew that, for him, Leslie's resignation was not about accountability. It was about vengeance. He wanted her punished for allowing him to be investigated in the first place. He would then have used her quitting as further 'proof' that he had been a victim all along." She adds: "A conspiracy against Alex would have needed a number of women deciding to concoct false allegations, without any obvious motive for doing so. "It would then have required criminal collusion between them, senior ministers and civil servants, the police and the Crown. "That is what he was alleging. The 'conspiracy' was a fabrication, the invention of a man who wasn't prepared to reflect honestly on his own conduct. This is what I found hardest to come to terms with." She says that the breakdown of their relationship with the man who was her political mentor, and who she served as deputy leader of the party, left her "bereft". However, the ex-SNP leader hits out at Mr Salmond's lack of concern over the damage his actions would have on the SNP and the Scottish Government he once led. She writes: "There was also never the merest hint of concern about the damage he did to the party he previously led. Indeed, it felt to me that he would have rather destroyed the SNP than see it succeed without him. "He impugned the integrity of the institutions at the heart of Scottish democracy — government, police, Crown Office. He was prepared to traumatise, time and again, the women at the centre of it all." Ms Sturgeon says she still remains under Salmond's shadow (Image: NQ) She adds: "For a while I told myself that the bonds between Alex and me would be stronger than his thirst for revenge. Eventually, though, I had to face the fact that he was determined to destroy me. "I was now engaged in mortal political combat with someone I knew to be both ruthless and highly effective. It was a difficult reality to reconcile myself to. So too was losing him as a friend. "I went through what I can only describe as a grieving process. For a time after we stopped speaking I would have conversations with him in my head about politics and the issues of the day. I had occasional, vivid dreams in which we were still on good terms. I would wake up from these feeling utterly bereft." Ms Sturgeon concludes that her relationship with Salmond, who died in 2024, never recovered, and that she still remains under his shadow. She writes: "And now? Before he died, I thought I had reached the point of feeling nothing and that I had come to terms with it, wholly and completely. The emotions I felt on hearing of his death suggested otherwise. "Yes, I have made peace with how things are, but it is an uneasy peace. I know I will never quite escape the shadow he casts, even in death."
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Salmond may have leaked sexual misconduct inquiry details, claims Sturgeon
Alex Salmond may have leaked details about an investigation into allegations of sexual misconduct against him, Nicola Sturgeon has claimed. In an excerpt of her new memoir, Frankly, published by The Times, Ms Sturgeon insisted she was not the one who had leaked the outcome of the Scottish government investigation into her predecessor as first minister to the press. She said: 'It crossed my mind many times that it might have been Alex himself or someone acting on his behalf. 'To those with no experience of the dark arts of media manipulation, I know this will sound preposterous. However, in many ways it would have been classic Alex. 'I had known him to make these kinds of calculations in the past. If there is damaging information certain to emerge about you and there is nothing you can do to stop it, get it out in a way that gives you the best chance of controlling the narrative.' Mr Salmond, who died last year, was investigated by the Scottish government in 2018 after two women made allegations of sexual misconduct against him. The findings of that investigation were leaked to The Daily Record on the day before they were due to be published, prompting Mr Salmond to launch a judicial review of the handling of the inquiry. The Scottish government initially defended the judicial review, before dropping its defence. But a separate police investigation resulted in a criminal trial in 2020 in which Mr Salmond was cleared of all 14 charges, being found not guilty on 12 counts while prosecutors withdrew another charge and one was found not proven. The next year Mr Salmond, who had been Scottish first minister between 2007 and 2014 as leader of the SNP, founded the pro-independence Alba Party. In her memoir, Ms Sturgeon said Mr Salmond had informed her that he was being investigated in April 2018 and initially appeared to be 'upset and mortified' before he 'became cold'. Claiming he 'effectively admitted the substance of one of the complaints, but claimed that it had been a 'misunderstanding'', Ms Sturgeon said it had been 'evident' that Mr Salmond 'wanted me to intervene' to stop or divert the investigation. She added that her refusal to do so turned him against her and 'made the break-up of one of the most successful partnerships in modern British politics all but inevitable'. Ms Sturgeon also accused Mr Salmond of attempting to 'cast himself as the victim' and being 'prepared to traumatise, time and again, the women at the centre of it all'. She said: 'A conspiracy against Alex would have needed a number of women deciding to concoct false allegations, without any obvious motive for doing so. 'It would then have required criminal collusion between them, senior ministers and civil servants, the police and the Crown. 'That is what he was alleging. The 'conspiracy' was a fabrication, the invention of a man who wasn't prepared to reflect honestly on his own conduct.' In other extracts, published on Friday, Ms Sturgeon discussed her arrest in 2023, describing it as 'mental torture', her miscarriage in 2010 and her sexuality. Nicola Sturgeon served as Scottish first minister between 2014 and 2023. Her memoir, Frankly, will be published on Thursday.
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Three people in their 40s arrested at Oasis concert in Edinburgh
Three people in their 40s were arrested at Friday's Oasis concert in Edinburgh, police have confirmed. The band was playing the first of three concerts in the capital on Friday evening, which saw an estimated 70,000 people packed into a sold-out Murrayfield Stadium. Police have confirmed that two women and one man were arrested for a variety of offences at the event, including assault, drug offences and abusive behaviour. A Police Scotland spokesperson said: 'Three people were arrested at an event at Murrayfield Stadium on Friday August 8 2025. 'A 49-year-old man was arrested and charged in connection with assault, drug offences and abusive behaviour. 'He is due to appear in court at a later date. 'A 46-year-old woman was arrested in connection with abusive behaviour and issued a recorded police warning. 'A 45-year-old woman was arrested and charged in connection with assault and drug offences. 'She is due to appear in court at a later date.' Friday's concert was the first time in 16 years that Oasis have played in Scotland, and they are set to follow it up with two more performances at Murrayfield on Saturday and Tuesday evenings. The band, which includes brothers Liam and Noel Gallagher, is then set to head to Ireland, Canada, the US, South Korea, Japan, Australia, and South America.
