Epic Games wins partial victory in Australian court against Google and Apple
Federal Court Justice Jonathan Beach on Tuesday upheld key parts of Epic's claim that the tech giants breached Australian competition laws by misusing their market power against app developers and using restrictive trade practices.
Google and Apple 's dominance of the app market had the effect of substantially lessening competition and breached Australian law, Beach found.
But the judge rejected some of Epic's claim including that Google and Apple engaged in unconscionable conduct as defined by Australian law.
Sweeney is also challenging Google and Apple dominance in the app markets through the courts in the United States and Britain.
The litigation began in August 2020 when Apple's App Store and Google's Play Store expelled Fortnite because Epic installed a direct payment feature in the extraordinarily popular game.
The court ruled both companies pressured app developers including Epic through contracts and technology to sell their products through the two dominant app stores.
Epic posted online that the judgment was: 'Another HUGE WIN for Epic Games!'
Apple said the company 'faces fierce competition in every market where we operate.'
'We welcome the Australian court's rejection of some of Epic's claims, however, we strongly disagree with the Court's ruling on others,' Apple said in a statement.
Google said it would review the judgment. Google and Apple could potentially appeal the ruling before the Federal Court full bench.
'We disagree with the court's characterisation of our billing policies and practices, as well as its findings regarding some of our historical partnerships, which were all shaped in a fiercely competitive mobile landscape on behalf of users and developers,' a Google statement said.
Beach has yet to release a 952-page judgment on Epic's case against Apple or his 914-page judgment on the case against Google.
The judge gave an oral summary of his findings during a 90-minute hearing Tuesday.
Lawyers will return to court on a date yet to be set to argue what Epic is entitled to in terms of damages.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
32 minutes ago
- New York Times
Elon Musk Threatens to Sue Apple Over Claims It Favors OpenAI
Elon Musk claimed late Monday that Apple gave preferential treatment to OpenAI, a prominent competitor of his artificial intelligence company, and he threatened to sue the consumer tech giant for 'an unequivocal antitrust violation.' Mr. Musk's A.I. company, xAI, released a new version of its chatbot, Grok, last month. Mr. Musk has recently posted on his social media platform X about how well his chatbot was doing with rankings in Apple's App Store. But on Monday, Mr. Musk started posting that Apple was intentionally favoring OpenAI instead. Apple has a partnership with OpenAI to integrate its chatbot, ChatGPT, into Apple products. 'App Store, why do you refuse to put either X or Grok in your 'Must Have' section when X is the #1 news app in the world and Grok is #5 among all apps?' Mr. Musk wrote. 'Are you playing politics?' Hours later, Mr. Musk posted that 'Apple is behaving in a manner that makes it impossible for any AI company besides OpenAI to reach #1 in the App Store.' 'xAI will take immediate legal action,' he added. Mr. Musk frequently turns to legal threats against competitors and critics over perceived injustice, sometimes resulting in lawsuits and other times fizzling out after a few social media posts. As of Tuesday afternoon, xAI did not appear to have filed a lawsuit in federal court. Representatives for xAI and Apple did not respond to requests for comment. A fact-checking feature run by X users, called Community Notes, added a note to Mr. Musk's post that said chatbot apps made by companies other than OpenAI have reached the number one spot on the App Store. Mr. Musk has feuded with OpenAI and Apple before. Mr. Musk previously criticized Apple in 2022, when he said the company had threatened to remove his social media app from its App Store altogether after he relaxed content moderation rules. Apple's policies prohibit apps that include hateful speech or content. Mr. Musk later met with Tim Cook, Apple's chief executive, and clarified it was a 'misunderstanding.' Mr. Musk co-founded OpenAI, but left the company in 2018, citing disagreements with the other co-founders over the company's direction. He sued OpenAI last year, claiming that the company and two of its founders, Sam Altman and Greg Brockman, had breached its founding contract by putting commercial interests ahead of the public good. (The New York Times has also sued OpenAI for copyright infringement. The company has denied wrongdoing.) Mr. Altman, who remains the chief executive of OpenAI, has denied the allegations.
Entrepreneur
an hour ago
- Entrepreneur
Perplexity AI Makes $34B Bid for Google Chrome
Perplexity AI, an $18 billion startup whose AI-powered search engine links out to original sources, just made an unsolicited offer to buy Google's Chrome browser for $34.5 billion, the Wall Street Journal was first to report. According to the WSJ report, Perplexity said its offer to buy Chrome is "designed to satisfy an antitrust remedy in highest public interest by placing Chrome with a capable, independent operator." "Multiple large investment funds have agreed to finance the transaction in full," Perplexity Chief Business Officer Dmitry Shevelenko said, per Bloomberg. Related: Everyone Wants to Buy Google's Chrome Browser — Including OpenAI, According to a Top ChatGPT Executive Chrome could be valued anywhere between $20 to $50 billion according to analysts, but it isn't exactly for sale. Google might not have a choice, though. In August 2024, a federal judge ruled that Google illegally monopolized the online search and search ads markets, writing in a 286-page opinion that "Google is a monopolist, and it has acted as one to maintain its monopoly" through exclusive agreements. One remedy suggested by the DOJ was for the tech giant to sell its Chrome browser. A judge is expected to decide by the end of August what Alphabet must do. Google is appealing part of the rulings and has indicated they are not interested in selling Chrome. But that doesn't mean there isn't a slew of potential buyers. In April, a judge asked ChatGPT's Head of Product Nick Turley if OpenAI would try to buy Chrome if parent company Alphabet was forced to divest, and he said a definite yes. Related: Firefox Would Like to Remind Everyone It Exists and 'Isn't Backed By a Billionaire' "Yes, we would, as would many other parties," Turley said in court, adding that ChatGPT and Chrome combined would give his company the chance to offer an "incredible experience" that's "AI-first." Perplexity AI is based in San Francisco and was founded in 2022. The startup is preparing the wide release of its own browser, Comet, though the company said it wouldn't make any "stealth modifications" to Chrome if the deal went through. Perplexity's formal bid also said it would "extend offers to a substantial portion of Chrome talent." At press time, Google Chrome has around 68% of the web browser market share (Safari is No. 2 with nearly 16%, Microsoft Edge has 5%, and Firefox has 2.5%). Perplexity AI also submitted a bid of at least $50 billion to buy TikTok in January, per CNBC. Join top CEOs, founders and operators at the Level Up conference to unlock strategies for scaling your business, boosting revenue and building sustainable success. Related: A Big Tech CEO Just Quit to Be an Entrepreneur Again
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
Musk threatens to sue Apple for not listing X or Grok among its top recommended apps
Billionaire SpaceX, Tesla and X owner Elon Musk says he plans to sue Apple for not featuring X and its Grok artificial intelligence chatbot app in its top recommended apps in its App Store. Musk posted the comments on X late Monday, saying, "Hey @Apple App Store, why do you refuse to put either X or Grok in your 'Must Have' section when X is the #1 news app in the world and Grok is #5 among all apps? Are you playing politics? What gives? Inquiring minds want to know." Grok is owned by Musk's artificial intelligence startup xAI. Musk went on to say that "Apple is behaving in a manner that makes it impossible for any AI company besides OpenAI to reach #1 in the App Store, which is an unequivocal antitrust violation. xAI will take immediate legal action." He gave no further details. There was no immediate comment from Apple, which has faced various allegations of antitrust violations in recent years. A federal judge recently found that Apple violated a court injunction in an antitrust case filed by Fortnite maker Epic Games. Regulators of the 27-nation European Union fined Apple 500 million euros in April for breaking competition rules by preventing app makers from pointing users to cheaper options outside its App Store. Last year, the EU fined the U.S. tech giant nearly $2 billion for unfairly favoring its own music streaming service by forbidding rivals like Spotify from telling users how they could pay for cheaper subscriptions outside of iPhone apps. As of early Tuesday, the top app in Apple's App Store was TikTok, followed by Tinder, Duolingo, YouTube and Bumble. Open AI's ChatGPT was ranked seventh.
