Blackouts, Blame Game, And The Future Grid
When millions of homes across Spain and Portugal were plunged into darkness on April 28, it took only hours for the political blame game to ignite. Pro-nuclear advocates and renewable energy critics seized the moment, framing the event as 'proof' that wind and solar are destabilizing our power grids. The reality, however, speaks to a far more nuanced challenge: how to build a system that's not just sustainable, but also secure and resilient in the face of growing volatility.
The Weaponization Of Renewable Energy
In the wake of the blackout, critics of Spain's energy policies, particularly those opposed to the country's nuclear phase-out, were quick to point fingers at renewables. But this was not the first time grid failure has been politically weaponized. After the 2021 Texas blackouts, state leaders and media commentators were also quick to blame renewables, in particular wind energy.
However, independent investigations later revealed that the primary cause was frozen natural gas infrastructure. All generation sources, including gas, coal, nuclear, wind, and solar, were affected by the extreme cold, highlighting the broader vulnerability of a grid unprepared for extreme climate.
Across Europe, concerns about the reliability of existing grid infrastructure in the face of a rapidly evolving energy landscape, have also gained traction. Germany, for instance, revisited its nuclear stance, floating the reactivation of plants and investment in small modular reactor research. Switzerland has also announced plans to lift its ban on new nuclear construction to pursue SMR projects.
Yet, while nuclear is back in the political spotlight, the underlying issue goes deeper: energy systems are under pressure, and existing planning, operational, and market structures are struggling to keep pace.
Texas suffered from an unexpected huge amount of snow. People without heat, without food, without ... More access to internet. It was a real life threatening situation. Dallas, 02.17. 2021.
What Really Happened On April 28?
According to ENTSO-E, at 12:33 p.m., a sudden outage at a substation in Granada caused a 2.2 GW generation loss, followed seconds later by further breakdowns in Badajoz and Sevilla. At the time, renewables supplied about 70% of Spain's electricity. While technically manageable and not unusual, this level of variable generation demands precise, real-time balancing.
The root cause of the April 28 blackout was a sequence of voltage oscillations that triggered widespread instability across the grid. Under normal conditions, such fluctuations can be absorbed by stabilizing mechanisms like synchronous generators, frequency reserves, or flexible imports via interconnectors. But in this case, the system had fewer synchronous generators online than planned, and several did not respond correctly to control signals.
Compounding the situation was insufficient voltage control and limited cross-border transmission capacity, leaving the grid more vulnerable. As the instabilities intensified, multiple generation units disconnected, some even prematurely, pushing the system into collapse.
Spain's limited interconnection capacity with the rest of Europe (just ~3% of its installed capacity, far below the EU's 2030 target of 15%) further reduced the system's resilience.
MADRID, SPAIN - APRIL 28: People shop for groceries using their phone as flashlight during a ... More widespread power outage that struck Spain and Portugal around midday on Monday, with the cause still unknown in Madrid, Spain on April 28, 2025. (Photo by Diego Radames/Anadolu via Getty Images)
Modern Grids Require Modern Tools
The lesson here is that we must modernize how we manage grids and markets. Unlike traditional power plants, which inherently provide inertia through their spinning mass, wind and solar installations lack this stabilizing force which is crucial in the event of sudden disturbances.
However, this does not mean renewables cannot support grid stability. On the contrary, they can - just through different means. With advanced inverter technologies providing 'grid-forming' capabilities, renewables can now be designed to emulate the stabilizing behavior of conventional plants. These innovations allow renewables to play an active role in maintaining frequency and voltage, especially when paired with other flexible assets.
One of the most promising solutions is grid-scale battery storage. Large battery systems can respond in milliseconds, absorbing excess electricity when there is too much supply or discharging it when demand rises, thus providing precisely the kind of fast, real-time support that modern grids increasingly require.
The UK grid incident in 2019 offers a powerful example of this, especially as the supply from synchronous generation declines: After a lightning strike triggered a cascading series of failures that removed nearly 1.4 GW of generation from the grid in seconds, frequency dropped below the safe operating limit of 49 Hz, forcing operators to begin low-frequency demand disconnection (LFDD) to avoid a larger collapse. Crucially, battery storage operators responded almost instantaneously, discharging 475 MW to support grid frequency. Thanks in part to these batteries, grid frequency was restored to safe levels within just four minutes.
Across Europe, momentum is building. The European market for autonomous battery storage solutions (by application) is forecast to grow at a compound annual growth rate of 11.24% between 2024 and 2031. The deployed battery storage systems will be able to provide grid-forming services, helping to stabilize the grid in the same way as conventional fossil-fueled powerplants once did. In fact, numerous battery systems deployed have these capabilities, however they are not being used. Without clear pricing or incentives for such grid services, this valuable resource remains untapped.
After experiencing several major blackouts, the U.S.A has also come to recognize the necessity of investing in grid flexibility over the years. Despite looming cuts to clean energy tax credits introduced under the Inflation Reduction Act, battery storage capacity is expected to grow 70% in 2025 alone, with 18.2 GW of utility-scale storage slated for installation.
Image of a battery energy storage system consisting of several lithium battery modules placed side ... More by side. This system is used to store renewable energy and then use it when needed. 3d rendering.
The Missing Link: Energy Markets Design
Beyond modernizing infrastructure and ramping up storage capacity, the design of electricity markets will also play a critical role in determining our energy security. As renewables grow, electricity pricing is being reshaped, and supply planning must be reorganized.
Today's market frameworks, across both Europe and the U.S, were built around dispatchable generation from coal, gas, nuclear or hydro power. These assets can be turned on or off to follow demand, and they bid into markets based on their fuel and operating costs.
Renewables, however, behave differently, with their power output depending on the weather, while having an effective marginal cost of production of zero once installed. This causes significant shifts in market dynamics.
One consequence is growing price volatility. For example, excess wind and solar power purchase agreements that are strictly based on energy produced can push wholesale market prices down to zero or even into negative territory, meaning producers must actually pay to feed electricity into the grid. On the other hand, when solar and wind production dip, especially during morning and evening demand peaks, prices can spike dramatically.
Such volatility creates uncertainty for investors and challenges the profitability of energy producers. That makes it all the more important to develop real-time balancing mechanisms and price signals that reflect the true value of stability and responsiveness in a renewable-heavy grid. On the demand side, transparent pricing like hourly electricity contracts, is changing how customers use power - encouraging them to shift consumption based on price signals.
Moreover, the ability to quickly balance supply and demand as renewable output fluctuates needs to be valued in today's markets. In many cases, services like fast frequency response, grid-forming capabilities, and storage are treated as ancillary rather than core components of system planning. This leaves key flexibility providers, including batteries, demand response, and distributed energy resources, at a disadvantage when competing for market revenues.
Grid operators and policymakers need to recognize that market structures need to evolve:
Electronic trading board at Louisville Gas & Electric (LG&E) where traders buy cheap electric power ... More on spot market. (Photo by Michael L. Abramson/Getty Images)
The Path Forward
The energy transition is accelerating. The question is no longer whether grids can handle high shares of renewables, rather how to adapt infrastructure, markets, and regulations to this new reality.
Crucially, modernizing grids to integrate flexibility and decentralization isn't just a technical necessity; it's also more economical in the long run than trying to retrofit outdated systems. With the right investments and a fact-based public discourse, we can build a resilient, affordable, and clean power system fit for the future.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
10-08-2025
- Wall Street Journal
What Spiked Crime in the Pacific Northwest?
Charles Fain Lehman flouts the basic rule that correlation isn't causation by linking short-lived drug decriminalization in Oregon and Washington to rising violent crime ('This Is the Pacific Northwest on Drugs,' op-ed, Aug. 7). But there's no plausible reason that people who use drugs nonviolently would suddenly turn violent simply because they're no longer jailed for possession. Even the study Mr. Lehman cites doesn't blame drug use itself. Its authors suggest other causes: weakening social cohesion, failure to jail chronic offenders and broader 'de-policing.' None point to drug use as the driver. Portugal's drug decriminalization in 2001 didn't cause an increase in crime; nor did the Czech Republic's nine years later. Mr. Lehman also blames the rise in overdoses on decriminalization. Yet a recent study from Brown University and RTI International researchers finds no link between Oregon's Measure 110 and the state's rise in overdose deaths. The authors accounted for fentanyl's arrival, which moved east to west and hit the Pacific Northwest around 2019-20, causing the same overdose spike seen elsewhere. Once fentanyl was factored in, the association between decriminalization and overdose deaths disappeared. The real driver was the shifting drug supply.
Yahoo
09-08-2025
- Yahoo
Retiring and relocating? Take a holistic approach
NEW YORK (AP) — Debra Taylor has had a busy year or so: She's going through a divorce while in the process of retiring — and she's moving to Portugal from Southern California with one of her daughters. After deciding her next home would be outside the U.S., she narrowed down her choices based on tax burdens (Spain was out with its wealth taxes), climate (no Costa Rica, too hot) and ease of travel within Europe, one of her favorite parts of the world. She then toured Portugal with a relocation company, Expatsi, and found her new home, Aveiro. It's a striking city on the country's west coast with lovely canals that earned it the nickname the Venice of Portugal. It's all logistics from there. Taylor signed a year lease on an apartment (a requirement for moving forward), hired the company Viv Europe to navigate bureaucracies and paperwork, signed up for the necessary FBI background check and has an appointment in late September to move ahead with visas. Her youngest child gave her the idea to leave the country. 'After our current president was elected, my 18-year-old transgender daughter came to me and said, 'I want to get out of this country ASAP,'' Taylor recalled. 'That was just fine with me.' Her oldest daughter, who's 20, will stay in the U.S. to complete college. 'None of this means I have to live there forever,' Taylor said. 'I'll use this as my jumping-off point to do more deeper dives, explore the rest of the region. I want to buy a place, but I'm not going to do that until I'm living there and spend more time in different communities.' According to aging and relocation experts, Taylor has made the right decisions. Relocating for retirement The number of people who relocate upon retirement fluctuates, based on such factors as politics, home affordability and cost-of-living rates. While older adults are less likely to move than younger populations, more than 3 million people age 65 and older relocated within the U.S. in the five years before the coronavirus pandemic, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. As for moving abroad, U.S. politics is now the No. 1 reason cited by people who use Expatsi, the company's co-founder Jen Barnett said. 'The one downside is that a lot of countries retirees are interested in don't want retirees, and that is to say wealthy, English-speaking countries, because they want laborers,' Barnett said. While most U.S. retirees stay put in existing homes and locales, those who want to age in place face mounting challenges, said AARP Vice President Rodney Harrell, who focuses on housing and livable communities. Challenges include rising rents or mortgages, costs for home modifications, and a lack of community support services like adequate health care, reliable utilities and safe environments. 'One of the biggest challenges that we have is making sure that we take the future us into account, and not just look at our needs today," Harrell said. 'Are we driving today? Is our income where it is? Is our spouse and myself healthy right now? How able are we to walk around and use steps, etc.? Things can change.' All of the above is crucial as the U.S. heads into a gray bubble. 'We're going to have more people over 65 than under 18 by 2034. For the first time in U.S. history, we have more older adults than children,' Harrell said. It's not just about weather or grandkids Do you want mountains, an ocean, to be closer to grandkids? Would you like a university town or city, a particular religious institution? Harrell suggests setting clear priorities when planning a relocation. And they should go well beyond those specifications. Taking housing costs into consideration is generally universal, he said, but he urged a more subtle consideration. 'What are the neighbors like? Is it an active community, if that's what you want. Do people keep to themselves more? That social connection is really important, too,' Harrell said. The AARP's livability index scores neighborhoods and communities across the U.S. for the services and amenities that impact older people. It's easily searchable by address, city, state or ZIP code. 'Think about all of the things that you might want collectively, and know that there's no perfect place,' Harrell said. 'Once you have those things in mind, you'll get to the best possible outcome. Every place has trade-offs." If being close to children and grandchildren is high on the list, set clear expectations about how involved you want to be in such things as child care, said retirement transition planner Elizabeth Zelinka Parsons. Also, chat with adult children before making a move to determine how settled they are themselves. Casey Bowers and her husband, Dave Bowers, recently relocated to Ericeira, northwest of Lisbon on Portugal's beachy Silver Coast. They love it, but it's not all ocean and sun. 'We have three adult children and their partners, and one grandbaby with another on the way,' Casey said. 'We're very close to our children. Learning the grocery store, getting new cellphones, those are just procedural things, but being away from family — that's the hardest part.' Sarah Friedell O'Connell, a retirement coach in Boston, looks at relocation this way: 'You're going to get a lot of hours back when you stop your full-time job. What are you going to do with that time?" Take a good look at your lifestyle As a wealth manager, Chad Harmer has helped dozens of retirees relocate, from Ontario, Canada, to Arizona's High Desert, from the Boston suburbs to the Carolinas. And he's dealt with some 'boomerang' moves back home after grandchildren arrived. 'Start with a 'lifestyle audit,' not a tax table," he said. 'I ask clients to write a perfect Thursday five years from now. Where are they walking? Who are they meeting for coffee? How long is the drive to the grandkids? That exercise surfaces climate preferences, social networks, volunteer hobbies and healthcare priorities long before we argue over property tax millage rates.' He also recommended budgeting for hidden inflators — such as higher insurance premiums in disaster-prone areas and frequent flights to see family — and considering less obvious weather complications, like pollen levels. Parsons, who wrote 'Encore: A High Achiever's Guide to Thriving in Retirement,' is a staunch supporter of taking a short-term rental before deciding on a permanent move. 'It's tempting to retire where you vacation, but that may not be the greatest idea,' she said. Harmer's rule of thumb: When 80 % of your desired daily routine is achievable in a new location for at least 80 % of the year, you're in the right ZIP code. 'Anything less and you're probably chasing an Instagram fantasy rather than a retirement reality,' he said. Leanne Italie, The Associated Press Sign in to access your portfolio
Associated Press
09-08-2025
- Associated Press
Retiring and relocating? Take a holistic approach
NEW YORK (AP) — Debra Taylor has had a busy year or so: She's going through a divorce while in the process of retiring — and she's moving to Portugal from Southern California with one of her daughters. After deciding her next home would be outside the U.S., she narrowed down her choices based on tax burdens (Spain was out with its wealth taxes), climate (no Costa Rica, too hot) and ease of travel within Europe, one of her favorite parts of the world. She then toured Portugal with a relocation company, Expatsi, and found her new home, Aveiro. It's a striking city on the country's west coast with lovely canals that earned it the nickname the Venice of Portugal. It's all logistics from there. Taylor signed a year lease on an apartment (a requirement for moving forward), hired the company Viv Europe to navigate bureaucracies and paperwork, signed up for the necessary FBI background check and has an appointment in late September to move ahead with visas. Her youngest child gave her the idea to leave the country. 'After our current president was elected, my 18-year-old transgender daughter came to me and said, 'I want to get out of this country ASAP,'' Taylor recalled. 'That was just fine with me.' Her oldest daughter, who's 20, will stay in the U.S. to complete college. 'None of this means I have to live there forever,' Taylor said. 'I'll use this as my jumping-off point to do more deeper dives, explore the rest of the region. I want to buy a place, but I'm not going to do that until I'm living there and spend more time in different communities.' According to aging and relocation experts, Taylor has made the right decisions. Relocating for retirement The number of people who relocate upon retirement fluctuates, based on such factors as politics, home affordability and cost-of-living rates. While older adults are less likely to move than younger populations, more than 3 million people age 65 and older relocated within the U.S. in the five years before the coronavirus pandemic, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. As for moving abroad, U.S. politics is now the No. 1 reason cited by people who use Expatsi, the company's co-founder Jen Barnett said. 'The one downside is that a lot of countries retirees are interested in don't want retirees, and that is to say wealthy, English-speaking countries, because they want laborers,' Barnett said. While most U.S. retirees stay put in existing homes and locales, those who want to age in place face mounting challenges, said AARP Vice President Rodney Harrell, who focuses on housing and livable communities. Challenges include rising rents or mortgages, costs for home modifications, and a lack of community support services like adequate health care, reliable utilities and safe environments. 'One of the biggest challenges that we have is making sure that we take the future us into account, and not just look at our needs today,' Harrell said. 'Are we driving today? Is our income where it is? Is our spouse and myself healthy right now? How able are we to walk around and use steps, etc.? Things can change.' All of the above is crucial as the U.S. heads into a gray bubble. 'We're going to have more people over 65 than under 18 by 2034. For the first time in U.S. history, we have more older adults than children,' Harrell said. It's not just about weather or grandkids Do you want mountains, an ocean, to be closer to grandkids? Would you like a university town or city, a particular religious institution? Harrell suggests setting clear priorities when planning a relocation. And they should go well beyond those specifications. Taking housing costs into consideration is generally universal, he said, but he urged a more subtle consideration. 'What are the neighbors like? Is it an active community, if that's what you want. Do people keep to themselves more? That social connection is really important, too,' Harrell said. The AARP's livability index scores neighborhoods and communities across the U.S. for the services and amenities that impact older people. It's easily searchable by address, city, state or ZIP code. 'Think about all of the things that you might want collectively, and know that there's no perfect place,' Harrell said. 'Once you have those things in mind, you'll get to the best possible outcome. Every place has trade-offs.' If being close to children and grandchildren is high on the list, set clear expectations about how involved you want to be in such things as child care, said retirement transition planner Elizabeth Zelinka Parsons. Also, chat with adult children before making a move to determine how settled they are themselves. Casey Bowers and her husband, Dave Bowers, recently relocated to Ericeira, northwest of Lisbon on Portugal's beachy Silver Coast. They love it, but it's not all ocean and sun. 'We have three adult children and their partners, and one grandbaby with another on the way,' Casey said. 'We're very close to our children. Learning the grocery store, getting new cellphones, those are just procedural things, but being away from family — that's the hardest part.' Sarah Friedell O'Connell, a retirement coach in Boston, looks at relocation this way: 'You're going to get a lot of hours back when you stop your full-time job. What are you going to do with that time?' Take a good look at your lifestyle As a wealth manager, Chad Harmer has helped dozens of retirees relocate, from Ontario, Canada, to Arizona's High Desert, from the Boston suburbs to the Carolinas. And he's dealt with some 'boomerang' moves back home after grandchildren arrived. 'Start with a 'lifestyle audit,' not a tax table,' he said. 'I ask clients to write a perfect Thursday five years from now. Where are they walking? Who are they meeting for coffee? How long is the drive to the grandkids? That exercise surfaces climate preferences, social networks, volunteer hobbies and healthcare priorities long before we argue over property tax millage rates.' He also recommended budgeting for hidden inflators — such as higher insurance premiums in disaster-prone areas and frequent flights to see family — and considering less obvious weather complications, like pollen levels. Parsons, who wrote 'Encore: A High Achiever's Guide to Thriving in Retirement,' is a staunch supporter of taking a short-term rental before deciding on a permanent move. 'It's tempting to retire where you vacation, but that may not be the greatest idea,' she said. Harmer's rule of thumb: When 80 % of your desired daily routine is achievable in a new location for at least 80 % of the year, you're in the right ZIP code. 'Anything less and you're probably chasing an Instagram fantasy rather than a retirement reality,' he said.
