Refugees in policy limbo
These refugees, mostly ethnic Karen minorities fleeing war and persecution in Myanmar, have lived in limbo for over 40 years. Many were born in the camps, their hopes for resettlement long dashed, with nowhere else to go.
The humanitarian crisis began with US President Donald Trump's executive order freezing all foreign aid for a 90-day review on Jan 20, immediately followed by a stop-work order for US-funded NGOs, including those serving nine refugee camps along the Thai-Myanmar border.
Now, the cuts have become permanent. Even with US assistance, food and medicine were barely enough. Without it, how long can people endure hunger, illness, and despair?
The Thai government must act before this desperate situation turns into a disaster. When the National Security Council meets this Thursday, it must go beyond temporary relief. A dignified and realistic solution is to allow them to work. With income, they can stand on their own feet, thus significantly reducing the burden on the government.
To be fair, the government acted swiftly by providing emergency health care. But food aid is drying up. Other donors offer only minimal support. Without proper food or income, families face starvation or breaking the law by slipping out of the camps to find work.
Let's be clear: these camps are no longer shelters. They are holding pens. People are locked in, barred from working or leaving. Thai is not even taught in the camps, making communication harder. Yet many are skilled and ready to contribute.
Thailand has done better before. The country has hosted refugees from Myanmar, Laos, Cambodia, Vietnam, even China and Nepal. When repatriation proved impossible, Thailand gave them "displaced person" status with legal IDs, the right to work, and the chance to live with dignity.
Reclassifying these refugees as migrant workers would be a mistake. That status limits them to manual labour, tight controls, and nearly no chance of changing jobs. The migrant worker label is neither fair nor productive. After all, refugees didn't migrate to find jobs, they were running away from a civil war. Their situation is different and deserves a different solution.
One proposed solution is to classify them as "displaced persons from Myanmar". This is possible under the Immigration Act, allowing legal stay and work rights in jobs not reserved for Thai nationals. This term enables security agencies to monitor and manage the process properly.
Many of these refugees are Karen, sharing cultural ties with Thai-Karen communities. Integration, especially in border areas, would not be difficult. Furthermore, only about 30,000 of these refugees are of working age. The labour market will have no problems absorbing the extra manpower.
Without intervention, the risks are clear: illegal work, trafficking, and an increase in crime. These problems can be prevented if the government acts now. No one is asking the government to feed 80,000 mouths forever. People want the chance to stand on their own two feet. Give them that chance before it's too late.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bangkok Post
2 hours ago
- Bangkok Post
Acting PM issues policy directives to better aid public
Interior Minister Phumtham Wechayachai on Thursday laid down urgent policy directives to provincial governors and senior officials, calling for faster and more effective responses to deliver government policies as well as better serve the people. Speaking at a high-level meeting at Impact Muang Thong Thani in Nonthaburi province, Mr Phumtham, who is also the acting prime minister, said the ministry's goal under his leadership is to turn government policies into actions that resolve long-standing problems and build sustainable happiness. Threats such as narcotics, call-centre gangs and illegal online gambling and promoting people's well-being fall under the ministry's responsibility, he said. Mr Phumtham said the growing abuse of illicit drugs is one of the most pressing issues and urged provincial governors to act as "commanders" in this ongoing battle and work closely with other security agencies in suppressing narcotics. "Governors must take charge and coordinate efforts with security units. Only concerted efforts can solve this problem," he said. Addressing the problem of household debt, he stressed the importance of saving and financial discipline, and proposed the establishment of a special mechanism to protect people from illegal lenders who charge excessive interest rates. He said the ministry plays a pivotal role in driving grassroots economic development and each province should identify its strengths and find ways to build on them. The minister also called for faster disbursement of funds, especially for emergency aid. He suggested that changes must be adopted if necessary. He pointed to his recent visit to a flood-affected community in Chiang Rai province where financial aid had to undergo several steps before reaching those in need. Meanwhile, the slow disbursement of financial support to those affected by the Thai-Cambodian border conflict also attracted attention when the provincial governors of Si Sa Ket, Surin and Ubon Ratchathani were summonsed by the House committee on administration to explain delays and inconsistencies in the distribution of emergency funds. Mr Phumtham also defended the recent ministerial order easing poker restrictions, saying it was not part of the effort to legalise gambling in general. He said the easing was to allow for poker to be played as a sport which would still be governed by an authorised association. He also called for the adoption of technologies to streamline work and place the public's interests first. "The ministry has the mechanisms and tools to work with all sectors. We can work and ensure that the government's policies are implemented to resolve the country's crises," he said.
Bangkok Post
3 hours ago
- Bangkok Post
Pheu Thai MP secures deputy speaker's post
Pheu Thai MP Chaiya Promma has been selected as first deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives, replacing the governing party's Pichet Chuamuangphan, who was thrown out of parliament by the Constitutional Court on Aug 1 for misusing state funds. Mr Chaiya, an MP for Nong Bua Lam Phu and former deputy agriculture minister, was nominated on Thursday by Sorawong Thienthong, a Pheu Thai MP for Sa Kaeo, without any opponent. Addressing the meeting, Mr Chaiya pledged to use his knowledge and political experience to enhance the work of the legislative branch and ensure it would be an institution people could continue to count on. Before the vote took place, the chamber was thrown into chaos when Koravee Prisananantakul, a Bhumjaithai MP for Ang Thong, proposed an urgent motion to discuss assistance measures for people displaced by the Thai-Cambodian border clashes. Watcharapol Khaokham, a Pheu Thai MP for Udon Thani, responded that the vote for the deputy speaker would not take long, especially if the opposition did not nominate anyone. This prompted Mr Koravee to propose a quorum check. Deputy House Speaker Chalard Khamchuang, who presided over the meeting, agreed to a roll call. The check confirmed that 248 MPs out of 492 were present, or two more than the minimum requirement. The opposition MPs did not join the quorum check.
Bangkok Post
4 hours ago
- Bangkok Post
Thailand and Cambodia sign 13-point ceasefire agreement
Thailand and Cambodia have reached a landmark agreement on a 13-point ceasefire plan aimed at de-escalating tensions along their shared border and fostering peace between the two nations. The agreement was formalised on Thursday afternoon during a special ministerial session of the General Border Committee (GBC) in Kuala Lumpur, which followed three days of intensive official-level negotiations. Leading the Thai delegation was Deputy Defence Minister Gen Nattaphon Narkphanit, in his capacity as acting defence minister because the top position remains vacant. He was joined by his Cambodian counterpart, Gen Tea Seiha. Also present were international observers from China, the United States and Malaysia in its capacity as the chair of Asean this year. The Malaysian Chief of Defence Forces acted as a facilitator for the talks, symbolising a neutral stance between the two nations. After more than an hour of discussion, Thailand and Cambodia unanimously endorsed the 13-point ceasefire protocol. The new framework builds upon a prior 7-point agreement discussed at the regional military command level, and was developed collaboratively by Thai agencies and the Cambodian GBC Secretariat. It includes key provisions such as: A complete and unconditional ceasefire Protective measures for civilians A freeze on troop reinforcements and movements Facilitation of the return of displaced individuals The establishment of a bilateral rapid coordination team, with four representatives from each side, to ensure continuous communication and immediate conflict resolution Commitments to refrain from provocations, violations of agreements, or territorial intrusions. The full English text of the agreement can be found here. Both sides expressed hope that the accord would lead to lasting peace and stability along the border, fostering harmonious coexistence between the peoples of the two nations. Gen Natthaphon and Gen Tea Seiha formally signed the document, reflecting the consensus reached over three days of discussions. Thailand also reaffirmed its support for bilateral mechanisms as a means of resolving disputes effectively and peacefully. Gen Natthaphon earlier in the day paid a courtesy call on Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim in Putrajaya after his arrival in Kuala Lumpur. The Thai side expressed appreciation for Malaysia's role as the Asean chair and its ongoing support in promoting regional peace — particularly through its facilitation of the GBC discussions. During the meeting, Thailand reiterated its firm stance on resolving border conflicts through peaceful means, upholding international law, and maintaining mutual respect for national sovereignty, said government spokesman Jirayu Houngsub. Also participating in the GBC meeting with their Cambodian counterparts were Gen Songwit Noonpakdee, Chief of Defence Forces; Gen Thongchai Rodyoiy, Army Chief of Staff; Adm Phairoj Fueangchan, Navy Chief of Staff; and ACM Watcharapol Muangnoi, Air Force Chief of Staff. They were joined by officials from the ministries of Foreign Affairs and Interior, along with representatives from key national security agencies. (Story continues below) Asean observers The defence officials agreed to allow observers from Asean to inspect disputed border areas and help ensure that hostilities do not resume following a violent five-day conflict that ended in a ceasefire on July 28. The worst fighting in over a decade included exchanges of artillery fire and jet fighter bombing runs that claimed at least 43 lives — military and civilian — and displaced more than 300,000 people on both sides of the border. Fighting continued despite diplomatic interventions from China and Malaysia, both calling for restraint. The leaders of Cambodia and Thailand only came to the negotiating table when US President Donald Trump told them that tariff negotiations would not continue unless there was peace. 'There will be an observation team of Asean military attaches based in Thailand and Cambodia, led by Malaysia,' Gen Nattaphon told reporters at a press conference after the meeting, adding that foreign inspectors based in either country would not cross the border. 'Thailand and Cambodia are neighbours with a shared border that can move away from each other … a resolution will allow our people to return to peaceful lives,' he said. Thailand and Cambodia said in a joint statement that they would hold more talks in two weeks and then again in a month.
