Social media firms have gone backwards in tackling online hate, says Kick It Out chairman
But that's, grimly, how it always is. Concerned that black players will be singled out for blame. Not with a legitimate critique of their performances, but with toxicity and racism.
And now Kick It Out is working with the Football Association to support Jess Carter after the England defender spoke out over the abuse she has been targeted with throughout the Women's European Championship.
The players want social media firms to do more, but Mr Bhandari, the Kick It Out chairman, is concerned by their limited approach to the scourge of online hate.
"The social media companies need to do far more," he told Sky News. "They've actually gone backwards over the last four or five years, not forwards. It's got worse on social media, not better.
"And they need to provide us with the tools to help keep us safe and to remove some of this toxicity from the platforms. They're just not doing enough.
"I would say that X is the worst. It has become no-holds-barred.
"And with Instagram, it is much more in the direct messaging, and I think there needs to be much more done there to protect people from those messages."
Meta, which owns Instagram, did not reply to a request for comment.
There was no response from an email sent to X's press email address.
1:17
LinkedIn indicated that X's UK managing director Jonathan Lewis's account had seen a request for comment, but there was no response.
On Friday, Mr Lewis and Premier League club Burnley were celebrating a new partnership in an announcement that made no mention of the abuse that many players across the world face on X.
The hope is that the Online Safety Act will lead to social media firms implementing the safety tools required of them.
Mr Bhandari said: "They have to be enforced by law enforcement against individual perpetrators, and also the regulatory parts need to be forced against the social media companies to force them to do the things that they need to do."
Grimly familiar situation
The FA reported the abuse suffered by Carter to police, and the hope is for speedy action because this is a grimly familiar situation.
After the men's Euros final in 2021, Marcus Rashford, Jadon Sancho and Bukayo Saka were racially abused after missing penalties in the shootout defeat to Italy.
While players have been taking a knee against racism in men's and women's games, the Lionesses feel that is no longer enough at these Euros.
They will stand instead before the semi-final with Italy because they say a new approach is needed to tackle racism.
Carter didn't just face racism around the quarter-final that England won on penalties after fighting back from 2-0 down against Sweden here in Zurich.
She has been subjected to abuse throughout the Euros.
"I'm really feeling for Jess and what's sad is that this is shocking, but not surprising," Mr Bhandari said.
"I watch every England game, at every tournament, with the fear that after the match, there's going to be abuse of a black player using the spurious basis of performance as an excuse to justify unjustifiable racism. All racism is unjustifiable.
"The fact that someone's had a good or bad game in your opinion does not justify that kind of racist abuse."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Guardian
14 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Zak Crawley and Ben Duckett put England in charge after Ben Stokes' five-for
England's openers reprised their Headingley heroics, which helped them draw first blood in last month's series opener, putting on 166 in 32 overs after India were all out for 358 at Emirates Old Trafford. Neither was able to get to three figures as Duckett fell six runs short and Crawley was out for 84, with England going to stumps after day two of the fourth Rothesay Test on 225 for two. That they only sit 133 behind and in a favourable position to move into an unassailable 3-1 series lead owes much to Stokes, who claimed five for 72 to restrict an India side who were able to call upon Rishabh Pant as he defied an injury to his right foot. A brilliant day for England! 🏴 We trail by just 1️⃣3️⃣3️⃣ runs with 8️⃣ wickets in hand. Roll on tomorrow 💪 — England Cricket (@englandcricket) July 24, 2025 Less than 24 hours after retiring hurt on 37 and being taken off the field on a golf buggy, Pant resumed his innings although substitute fielder Dhruv Jurel is taking on wicketkeeper duties for the rest of the Test. Amid reports of a broken metatarsal – India have not publicly confirmed the severity of his injury – Pant limped every time he moved forward before being bowled for 54 by Jofra Archer, who claimed three for 73. Archer struck in his first over with the second new ball after squaring up Ravindra Jadeja and drawing the edge but Shardul Thakur and Washington Sundar took India from an overnight 264 for four past 300. Stokes ended the union when Thakur was excellently caught at gully by a leaping Duckett for 41, leading to Pant's slow march to the crease, receiving a standing ovation from the crowd for soldiering on. He wore a blow to the gloves from his third ball and runners being outlawed in Tests meant he had to hobble through for singles. His movement was severely restricted but the danger remained as Archer's slower ball after lunch was launched over deep midwicket en route to Pant reaching a courageous fifty. But then, he was running out of partners as Stokes bounced out Sundar for 27 and nicked off debutant Anshul Kamboj three balls later for his first Test five-for since a career-best six for 22 against the West Indies nearly eight years ago. With Jasprit Bumrah for company, Pant refused a run after smashing Archer only to be cleaned up next ball in a carbon copy of his second-innings dismissal at Lord's, with his off-stump sent flying. After Archer finished proceedings as India lost their final four wickets for 21, Duckett had his heart in his mouth when he gloved his first ball down the leg-side, just out of reach of the diving Jurel. Duckett then flung his bat over his shoulder close to his stumps but he ended Kamboj's eventful first over in an India jersey with back-to-back clips for four and did not look back. A close call for Ben Duckett 😅 Have you ever seen this before? 👀 — England Cricket (@englandcricket) July 24, 2025 Even Bumrah struggled for containment after being dispatched twice to the boundary in an over, with all of India's seamers coming in for punishment for drifting into Duckett's pads far too often. Crawley took 14 balls to get off nought at a ground where he made 189 in the 2023 Ashes and was initially happy to swim in Duckett's slipstream but he gradually started to assert himself with several fantastic cover drives. While Duckett was first and quickest to fifty, Crawley overtook his partner and hammered Jadeja for a meaty straight six after the slow left-armer was brought on to offer a semblance of control. But Jadeja got the breakthrough having been required to bowl an extra ball after overstepping moments earlier when Crawley hung out his bat and nicked low to KL Rahul, who clung on inches above the turf. Nevertheless, Crawley had been at the centre of the timewasting row that erupted last week at Lord's and was once again under pressure after four successive scores under 25 so this knock was some riposte. Having looked short of ideas, India celebrated with a huddle after ending the Crawley-Duckett onslaught – their second best of the last few weeks having made 188 together in Leeds. Duckett made a match-winning 149 on that occasion but he could not ton up here after a wild slash to a Kamboj long hop took the edge through to Jurel to end a fine 100-ball innings. There were no further alarms as Ollie Pope ended the day unbeaten on 20 and Joe Root on 11 not out.
Glasgow Times
14 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Zak Crawley and Ben Duckett put England in charge after Ben Stokes' five-for
England's openers reprised their Headingley heroics, which helped them draw first blood in last month's series opener, putting on 166 in 32 overs after India were all out for 358 at Emirates Old Trafford. Neither was able to get to three figures as Duckett fell six runs short and Crawley was out for 84, with England going to stumps after day two of the fourth Rothesay Test on 225 for two. That they only sit 133 behind and in a favourable position to move into an unassailable 3-1 series lead owes much to Stokes, who claimed five for 72 to restrict an India side who were able to call upon Rishabh Pant as he defied an injury to his right foot. A brilliant day for England! 🏴 We trail by just 1️⃣3️⃣3️⃣ runs with 8️⃣ wickets in hand. Roll on tomorrow 💪 — England Cricket (@englandcricket) July 24, 2025 Less than 24 hours after retiring hurt on 37 and being taken off the field on a golf buggy, Pant resumed his innings although substitute fielder Dhruv Jurel is taking on wicketkeeper duties for the rest of the Test. Amid reports of a broken metatarsal – India have not publicly confirmed the severity of his injury – Pant limped every time he moved forward before being bowled for 54 by Jofra Archer, who claimed three for 73. Archer struck in his first over with the second new ball after squaring up Ravindra Jadeja and drawing the edge but Shardul Thakur and Washington Sundar took India from an overnight 264 for four past 300. Stokes ended the union when Thakur was excellently caught at gully by a leaping Duckett for 41, leading to Pant's slow march to the crease, receiving a standing ovation from the crowd for soldiering on. He wore a blow to the gloves from his third ball and runners being outlawed in Tests meant he had to hobble through for singles. His movement was severely restricted but the danger remained as Archer's slower ball after lunch was launched over deep midwicket en route to Pant reaching a courageous fifty. Stokes claimed five wickets to restrict India (Martin Rickett/PA) But then, he was running out of partners as Stokes bounced out Sundar for 27 and nicked off debutant Anshul Kamboj three balls later for his first Test five-for since a career-best six for 22 against the West Indies nearly eight years ago. With Jasprit Bumrah for company, Pant refused a run after smashing Archer only to be cleaned up next ball in a carbon copy of his second-innings dismissal at Lord's, with his off-stump sent flying. After Archer finished proceedings as India lost their final four wickets for 21, Duckett had his heart in his mouth when he gloved his first ball down the leg-side, just out of reach of the diving Jurel. Duckett then flung his bat over his shoulder close to his stumps but he ended Kamboj's eventful first over in an India jersey with back-to-back clips for four and did not look back. A close call for Ben Duckett 😅 Have you ever seen this before? 👀 — England Cricket (@englandcricket) July 24, 2025 Even Bumrah struggled for containment after being dispatched twice to the boundary in an over, with all of India's seamers coming in for punishment for drifting into Duckett's pads far too often. Crawley took 14 balls to get off nought at a ground where he made 189 in the 2023 Ashes and was initially happy to swim in Duckett's slipstream but he gradually started to assert himself with several fantastic cover drives. While Duckett was first and quickest to fifty, Crawley overtook his partner and hammered Jadeja for a meaty straight six after the slow left-armer was brought on to offer a semblance of control. But Jadeja got the breakthrough having been required to bowl an extra ball after overstepping moments earlier when Crawley hung out his bat and nicked low to KL Rahul, who clung on inches above the turf. Pant was bowled by Archer after batting with a foot injury (Martin Rickett/PA) Nevertheless, Crawley had been at the centre of the timewasting row that erupted last week at Lord's and was once again under pressure after four successive scores under 25 so this knock was some riposte. Having looked short of ideas, India celebrated with a huddle after ending the Crawley-Duckett onslaught – their second best of the last few weeks having made 188 together in Leeds. Duckett made a match-winning 149 on that occasion but he could not ton up here after a wild slash to a Kamboj long hop took the edge through to Jurel to end a fine 100-ball innings. There were no further alarms as Ollie Pope ended the day unbeaten on 20 and Joe Root on 11 not out.
Daily Mail
14 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
England produce their best day of the summer to pull ahead in fourth Test against India as they push for series victory
The sun came out in Manchester on Thursday - and it began to shine on England's chances of pulling clear in this relentless tussle of a series. India have pushed them all the way this summer, and may yet do so again over the next three days. But as Zak Crawley and Ben Duckett responded to the tourists' 358 with a punitive opening stand of 166 at more than five an over, it was hard to avoid the sense that something had finally shifted, that a crack had opened at last. England are desperate to avoid heading to The Oval next week all square at 2-2, and girded their loins to produce their best all-round day of the series. Inspired first by Ben Stokes 's latest heroics with the ball, they were later boosted by an opening pair who exploited some dreadful Indian bowling. In the final session alone, England scored 148, and if a little gloss was removed by the demise of Crawley, caught at slip by KL Rahul off Ravindra Jadeja for 84, and of Duckett, edging a cut off the debutant Anshul Kamboj for an even more agonising 94, then they will tell themselves that another day's batting should put this game beyond their opponents. On a pitch that remains true, it ought not to be beyond them. The conditions, for sure, favoured England. The ball did all sorts in the morning under grey skies, when the average swing of 1.6 degrees was higher than it has been at any point during the summer. Then, soon after Crawley and Duckett began the reply, the clouds began to part, as if the ECB were now controlling the weather. And yet that could only partially explain why England outplayed India, who began by serving up an array of freebies on Duckett's pads - 'rubbish', their former coach Ravi Shastri called it up in the commentary box, speaking on behalf of a nation. It didn't help that Shubman Gill handed the new ball to the nervy Kamboj ahead of Mohammed Siraj, India's leading wicket-taker in the series. Sensing his chance, Duckett took 12 off Kamboj's first over, and helped himself to the first 26 runs of the innings. Crawley, meanwhile, embarked on his best Test knock since destroying Australia here two years ago, a vindication - the management will argue - of his continued selection ahead of the return Ashes this winter. 'I always want more from myself, and I certainly have for the last year or so,' he said. 'I owe it to myself to have a few good more performances. It makes days like today worth it.' For his part, Duckett rediscovered the touch that had yielded his fourth-innings masterpiece in the series opener at Headingley, only to scratch an old wound by falling short with three figures his for the taking. Another wicket or two before stumps might have redressed the ledger, but Ollie Pope survived some jumpy moments, and with Joe Root ushered England to 225 for two, a deficit of 133. With Bumrah enduring a rare off day, India looked mainly toothless. Shardul Thakur went at seven an over, Siraj at nearly six, and Kamboj at just under five. Even Jadeja's normally precise left-arm darts were milked at 4.62. It was no recipe for any kind of control. There were just five maidens out of 46, and four came from Bumrah. The first half of the day had belonged to England, too, as Stokes continued to harry India in what has turned into the bowling summer of his life. The initial breakthrough was supplied in the second over by Jofra Archer, whose expertise against left-handers earned him the wicket of Jadeja, well caught by Harry Brook low to his right at second slip to end a sequence of four half-centuries. TOP SPIN AT THE TEST Ben Stokes became only the fourth player in Test history to achieve the double of 10 hundreds and five five-fors, after Garry Sobers, Ian Botham and Jacques Kallis. He now has 229 Test wickets, drawing level with England fast bowler Darren Gough, having surpassed the 15 Stokes picked up in his first Test series, in the 2013-14 Ashes. Ben Duckett has now fallen between 71 and 98 on 10 occasions – and remains marooned on six Test hundreds. Thakur and Washington Sundar steadied India's ship, but now Stokes imposed himself on the game, as he had on Wednesday with the wickets of Gill and Sai Sudharsan. His nominal role as England's 'fourth seamer' increasingly feels like a breach of the Trade Descriptions Act. Thakur, on 41, edged him into the gully, where he was superbly caught by a flying Duckett, before Stokes persuaded Sundar to top-edge to fine leg - just as he had Sudharsan. When Kamboj was caught behind three balls later for a duck, Stokes had his first Test five-for since 2017, and more wickets (16) than in any series in his career. If he has ever bowled better, no one could immediately pinpoint when. Meanwhile, Rishabh Pant - perhaps the only player on either side to outrank Stokes in the box office - had hobbled back to the middle to resume his innings on 37, making light of a suspected broken foot and roared on by another vocal Indian contingent. The question of whether this was an act of bravery or bravado disappeared as he pulled Archer for six, then - feet in cement - timed Stokes through the covers to bring up his fifth score of 50-plus in the series. Archer ended his fun moments later, reproducing the gem that had knocked back his off stump at Lord's, and might have been too good for Pant this time even if he had been mobile. And when Root persuaded Stokes to review a faint glove down the leg side from Bumrah off Archer, India had lost their last five for 44. They are not out of this game, but all this has made their life much harder.
