Cracks in Indian community can be solved with unity
COMMENT | Why Indian Malaysians mourn wrong heroes
Prominority: There is no sincere interest group or strong ethical political party representing Indian Malaysians in the policymaking body.
The community is like a headless chicken.
Until Indian Malaysians organise themselves into a single voice and a cohesive society, policy designers will not be inclusive and will sideline them until the kingdom comes.
Indian Malaysians should organise themselves before finding fault with the ruling government.
Many pundits can list all the problems faced by Indians, but no one gives strategies for elevating the standard of living.
No satisfactory solutions in sight.
Falcon: Call it whatever you like, be it the Madani plan, the 13th Malaysia Plan or another plan.
The fact remains that nothing is going to change for Indian Malaysians from cradle to grave!
Be they life's challenges, systemic prejudices, racism or a place at the bottom of the social and economic barrel and food chain?
More so, when those claiming to represent Indian Malaysians only enrich themselves every which way!
What awaits is natural death, illness or, to some, death in a hail of bullets from assassins?
Former Klang MP Charles Santiago, please do not act naive or self-righteous. You should know, after all, you are a politician yourself!
A Little Bit Crazy: Alamak Charles! Don't depend on the government or anybody else to help the local Indian community.
We Chinese have learned the lesson hard, we help ourselves, we donate, and take our savings to help our community, culture and schools.
Start with small donations, here and there, build your schools, teach your youths, and advise your Indian gangster leaders not to ruin your own people.
Tell them to change their ways. Chinese politicians in small towns used to be gangsters; now, after 60 years, they are almost completely gone.
Don't depend on other races, especially Malay communities, to help you. They have their own problems and no time for you.
YellowFalcon7173: The problem with Indians in this country is that there is no unity amongst them.
The Tamil community here do not want to assimilate with the other Indian communities such as the Telugus, Sindhis, Bengalis and Malayalis. They even chant slogans to that effect.
Even in India, the different communities assimilate and consider themselves Indian first and only then their different communities.
In Malaysia, this division is even reflected in the political parties, which only want to propel Tamils (even then, based on caste).
If you cannot speak Tamil, you do not have a chance in political parties. So the other Indian communities shy away from politics.
Even then, if you see the majority of poor Indians, they are from the Tamil community.
This shows how the political parties have failed their community, whilst the other Indian communities have focused on business and education and established themselves.
Get rid of this ego, get rid of identifying yourselves based on your community and then see how it will propel the Indian community.
A good example is the Chinese. Even though there are Hokkiens, Hakka and so on.
When it comes to business, education and politics, they identify themselves as Chinese.
Spinnot: @YellowFalcon7173 yes, although the Chinese community here have many clan associations based on dialects, regional origins and even surnames, guild associations, state Chinese Chambers of Commerce, state Chinese Assembly Halls, they are all under a national umbrella body, Hua Zong (The Federation of Chinese Associations Malaysia), which is non-partisan.
RR: Each community leader must take care of their own community.
The Chinese are a good example.
Nonetheless, in a multiracial, multireligious nation, there must be a sincere commitment and political will of the government of the day to assimilate all races as Malaysians by giving equal and equitable opportunities to all and ensuring that no section of the people is left behind.
This should be the ideology and policy of a truly democratic government and country.
Chefoo: Which Indian leader genuinely cares for his community?
The Indian community have the highest number of political parties in Malaysia, and every one of these so-called leaders is fighting not to uplift the community but for their power and positions.
Don't blame the government, but blame yourself for being backwards and harping on the government for handouts.
The Chinese have shown how they can progress without much help from the government.
The above is a selection of comments posted by Malaysiakini subscribers. Only paying subscribers can post comments. In the past year, Malaysiakinians have posted over 100,000 comments. Join the Malaysiakini community and help set the news agenda. Subscribe now.
These comments are compiled to reflect the views of Malaysiakini subscribers on matters of public interest. Malaysiakini does not intend to represent these views as fact.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Interview: Former Italian senator sees robust potential for stronger Italy-China ties
ROME, July 3 (Xinhua) -- Former Italian Senator Manuel Vescovi emphasized the potential for enhanced Italy-China cooperation in economic and cultural fields, describing such collaboration as "a gateway to tremendous opportunities." In a recent interview with Xinhua, Vescovi, who served on Italy's Senate Foreign Affairs Committee from 2018 to 2022, urged Italian enterprises to engage with China's dynamic market proactively. "China's market is enormous and still expanding," he said, noting that China has remained Italy's largest Asian trade partner, with bilateral trade reaching 72.54 billion U.S. dollars in 2024. Highlighting particular areas of opportunity such as renewable energy, automotive manufacturing, and agri-food exports, Vescovi said Italy's renowned expertise aligns well with China's market demands. Marking the 55th anniversary of China-Italy diplomatic relations in 2025, he underscored the historic cultural exchanges spanning over two millennia. "We should leverage these historical bonds to propel our partnership to new heights," he said. Recent high-level visits, including those by Italian President Sergio Mattarella and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni to China, have led to a new three-year cooperation agreement through 2027, focusing on green technology, advanced manufacturing, and cultural exchanges. Vescovi firmly believes in the value of grassroots diplomacy. "It's important to start from the local level rather than relying solely on high-level summits," he said. As an example, he recently led a delegation from Grosseto, Tuscany, to Nanping in China's Fujian Province, initiating a sister-city partnership. During the visit, the two cities signed an agreement and hosted forums on trade, tourism, and education exchanges. By June 2025, Italy and China had established 90 sister-city pairings, which Vescovi sees as essential platforms for tangible and consistent cooperation. During his visit, Vescovi was particularly impressed by China's technological achievements, citing an advanced automobile factory capable of producing a car every 76 seconds as "an incredible engineering achievement." He also toured factories producing eco-friendly bamboo products, highlighting a Fujian-based company keen on opening a branch in Italy, a direct outcome of the sister-city relationship. "Local partnerships foster concrete results through business matchmaking," he noted, emphasizing the need for sustained and consistent engagement. Looking forward, Vescovi is optimistic about the future of Italy-China relations. He envisions scenarios where Italian cities like Grosseto become popular destinations for Chinese tourists, and Chinese tech startups collaborate with Italian artisans. "China has so much to offer, and so do we," he remarked, emphasizing mutual learning opportunities. Specifically, he suggested that Italy could benefit from China's successful territorial marketing and sustainable practices, while China could leverage Italy's expertise in design, high-end manufacturing, and agri-food. Stressing the importance of ongoing cultural exchanges alongside economic collaboration, Vescovi called for regular delegations, student exchanges, and joint cultural initiatives. "Only by being culturally and economically open can we genuinely thrive together," he said, reflecting the enduring legacy of Marco Polo's historic journey, which continues to inspire the strengthening of contemporary Italy-China ties.
The Sun
9 hours ago
- The Sun
US aircraft carrier makes Philippines port call
MANILA: The nuclear-powered US carrier George Washington arrived off the Philippine capital Thursday for a port visit, as the two allies increase defence cooperation aimed at contesting China's sweeping claims in the South China Sea. The Nimitz-class vessel's port call came the same day that China's first domestically produced aircraft carrier, the Shandong, sailed into Hong Kong. Beijing claims almost the entirety of the South China Sea, through which more than 60 percent of global maritime trade passes, despite an international ruling its assertion has no merit. 'The US Navy along with our allies and partners are committed to a free and open Indo-Pacific,' the ship's spokesman, Lieutenant-Commander Mark Langford, told AFP by email, without offering further details about the visit. 'These operations demonstrate the commitment to stability in the region, a commitment we uphold throughout the year and regardless of current events,' Langford said, calling the Philippines a 'long-standing and critical ally'. Manila and Washington have deepened their cooperation since President Ferdinand Marcos took office in 2022 and began pushing back on Beijing's South China Sea claims. Bound by a 1951 mutual defence treaty, the two allies conduct frequent maritime exercises in the South China Sea. The Philippine and US coast guards in May conducted their first-ever joint military drills in the archipelago nation's coastal waters. The Shandong, which sailed off the northern Philippines in April, arrived in Hong Kong on Thursday after concluding combat drills in the western Pacific alongside fellow Chinese aircraft carrier the Liaoning. The US Department of Defense said in a December report that China numerically has the largest navy in the world, with a battle force of more than 370 ships and submarines. – AFP
New Straits Times
10 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Trump's tariff deadline to have only 3 outcomes
A few days before United States President Donald Trump reimposes steep tariffs on dozens of economies, including the European Union and Japan, many are still scrambling to reach a deal that would protect them from the worst. The tariffs taking effect on July 9 are part of a package Trump imposed in April citing a lack of "reciprocity " in trading ties. He slapped a 10 per cent levy on most partners, with higher customised rates to kick in later in countries the US has major trade deficits with. But these were halted until this month to allow room for negotiations. Analysts expect countries will encounter one of three outcomes: they could reach a framework for an agreement; receive an extended pause on higher tariffs; or see levies surge. "There will be a group of deals that we will land before July 9," said Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent last Friday on CNBC. Policymakers have not named countries in this group, although Bessent maintains that Washington has been focused on striking deals with about 18 key partners. "Vietnam, India and Taiwan remain promising candidates for a deal," said Asia Society Policy Institute vice-president Wendy Cutler. Without a deal, Vietnam's "reciprocal tariff" rises from the baseline of 10 per cent to 46 per cent, India's to 26 per cent and Taiwan's to 32 per cent. Josh Lipsky, international economics chair at the Atlantic Council, cited Indian negotiators' extension of their US trip recently in noting that it "seems like a frontrunner ". "Japan was in that category, but things have set back a little," said Lipsky, referring to Trump's criticism on Monday over what the president called Japan's reluctance to accept US rice exports. The deals, however, would unlikely be full-fledged trade pacts, said analysts, citing complexities in negotiating such agreements. Since April, Washington has only announced a pact with Britain and a deal to temporarily lower tit-for-tat duties with China. Bessent has also said countries "negotiating in good faith" can have their tariffs remain at the 10 per cent baseline. But extensions of the pause on higher rates would depend on Trump, he added. "With a new government, (South) Korea looks well positioned to secure an extension," said Cutler of ASPI. Lipsky expects many countries to fall into this bucket, receiving an extended halt on higher tariffs that could last until Labour Day, which falls on Sept 1. Bessent earlier said Washington could wrap up its agenda for trade deals by Labour Day, a signal that more agreements could be concluded but with talks likely to extend past July. For countries that the US finds "recalcitrant", however, tariffs could spring back to the higher levels Trump previously announced, Bessent has warned. These range from 11 per cent to 50 per cent. Cutler warned that "Japan's refusal to open its rice market, coupled with the US resistance to lowering automotive tariffs, may lead to the reimposition of Japan's 24 per cent reciprocal tariff ". Trump himself said on Tuesday a trade deal was unlikely with Japan and the country could pay a tariff of "30 per cent, 35 per cent, or whatever the number is that we determine". Lipsky believes that the EU is at risk of having tariffs snap back to steeper levels, too —to the 20 per cent unveiled in April or the 50 per cent Trump more recently threatened. An area of tension could be Europe's approach to digital regulation. Trump recently said he would terminate trade talks with Canada — which is not impacted by the July 9 deadline — in retaliation for the country's digital services tax, which Ottawa eventually said it would rescind. This week, EU trade chief Maros Sefcovic is in Washington in a push to seal a trade deal, with the EU commission having received early drafts of proposals that officials are working on.
