Breaking down why Howard-O'Reilly deal is a good trade for Oilers and Lightning
In a world of NHL trades that often masquerade as salary dumps or with retained salary, this Ike Howard for Sam O'Reilly deal is refreshing stuff — two high-end forward prospects, one a college player, one a junior, one a fast winger with dynamic offensive chops, one a right-shot centre who plays a pro-type game.
Article content
Howard's ready now, O'Reilly is, say, two years away.
Article content
Article content
For now, let's pump the brakes some on where Howard fits.
Article content
Article content
Howard, a Hobey Baker winner as the best college hockey player like Cale Makar was, like the late Johnny Gaudreau, by all accounts has top-6 NHL skill, but with a very crowded forward group, on paper at least here, it would be realistic to just hope this Michigan State left-winger is a top-9 forward for the Edmonton Oilers.
Article content
For now.
Article content
Those pre-season forecasts from some that have a 21-year-old who has never played a single minute of pro hockey, pencilled in to play left wing with the best player in the world Connor McDavid, while Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, closing in on 1,000 NHL games with the Oilers, drops down from McDavid's line to be a third-line centre? Seems a bit of a reach.
Article content
Truth is, Howard, who didn't want to sign with Tampa after being drafted in the first round in 2022, only has to be in the top 9 to start, and if not, with Nugent-Hopkins and Andrew Mangiapane as the first and second line left wingers, then the 21-year-old belongs in Bakersfield.
Article content
Article content
Where does Howard fit?
Article content
Article content
With McDavid or Leon Draisaitl likely not playing any more than three or four exhibition games, there is not much time for the team to find if Howard meshes with either of them but he should play with both, a lot, when they dress for those games so we see. So, we find out, but if not, then he can hopefully be a third-line left winger to start, maybe with Trent Frederic as the third line centre with Matthew Savoie on right wing.
Article content
We still see Nugent-Hopkins and Zach Hyman, coming off his dislocated wrist, playing with McDavid. It's who plays with Draisaitl. Maybe Mangiapane moves to the right side, and Howard gets a look on left wing there. But you can also bet that Czech forward David Tomasek, 29, who won the Swedish Hockey League scoring title, will be in the mix somewhere. He will get a shot with Leon or, at worst on the third line.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Vancouver Sun
8 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
PWHL Vancouver: Coach Brian Idalski's history includes Hammer time
PWHL Vancouver coach Brian Idalski can obviously talk pro women's hockey. He can also talk Dave (The Hammer) Schultz. Idalski, 54, added to what has to be one of the more unique resumes in the sport a few weeks back when he was named bench boss of the Vancouver expansion team that starts play based out of the Pacific Coliseum in the fall. Idalski was coach of Team China at the Beijing 2022 Olympics. He guided a Chinese team in a Russian pro women's league for three seasons. He was bench boss of the University of North Dakota squad that helped produce American Olympians like twin sisters Jocelyne and Monique Lamoureux but folded in 2017 due to funding constraints at the school. Before that, the Warren, Mich., native was a steady, stay-at-home defenceman who saw action in minor pro for five seasons. That included suiting up in 1996-97 for the Madison Monsters, a team in the Colonial Hockey League that was coached by Schultz, a winger for the Philadelphia Flyers in their Broad Street Bullies days. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. There have been four seasons in NHL history where a player has amassed 400 minutes or more in penalties. Schultz owns two of those, including a league record 472 minutes in 1974-75. Schultz was at the helm for Idalski's second year in Madison. Mark Johnson was the coach for the first campaign, and as a player he was a stylish, savvy centre who starred with the 1980 U.S. Olympic team and then went on see duty in 11 seasons in the NHL. For comparison's sake, Johnson totalled a mere 269 minutes in the sin bin in his career. 'The Hammer? I enjoyed playing for him, but it was funny because that was such a different era,' said Idalski, who was heading up minor hockey camps at the North Shore Winter Club this past weekend. 'Mark had brought in some Europeans and we were playing on an Olympic-sized sheet, so we were all over the place. Dave had a hard time with that. He was used to the Broad Street Bullies in the 1970s, up and down the wing, get it in deep and go. 'He was a great human being. I really enjoyed playing for him as a person. But there are a fair number of stories coming out of that year that I still chuckle about.' Idalski comes to PWHL Vancouver after spending the past three seasons guiding the St. Cloud State University Huskies. The St. Cloud, Minn., program had a 16-point jump in the overall standings in his first season in 2022-23, leading Idalski to win U.S. College Hockey Online (USCHO) coach of the year honours. Part of the appeal with the new job is the roster that general manager Cara Gardner Morey has assembled. The forward crew includes national team stalwart Sarah Nurse along with homegrown talents Hannah Miller and Jenn Gardiner . The defence features reigning PWHL defender of the year finalists Claire Thompson and Sophie Jaques, and the netminding has two former starters in the loop in Kristen Campbell and Emerance Maschmeyer. The team looks like it will contend instantly and, as Idalski says, 'The fact that I get the keys to something that has the opportunity to be special right away is really something — normally, you have to cut your teeth, pay your dues for a few years.' Running an NCAA team has become a complicated proposition of late as well, with more frequent player movement due to looser transfer regulations and enticements like Name Image Likeness (NIL) sponsorship deals ruling the day. 'This is a best-on-best league, and how you show up, how you prepare, gives you have a chance to win and that's on you,' Idalski said. 'There's a lot of things in college … it didn't matter how much time I put or how hard I worked.' All told, Idalski has coached 18 seasons in the NCAA, including 10 at North Dakota. They were a prominent program then, particularly when they had the Lamoureux sisters. The pair represented the U.S. at three Olympics, including Vancouver 2010. In 2017, North Dakota shut down the team as well as the men's and women's swimming squads in a bid to slice $1.3 million from the athletic budget. 'I wouldn't wish that on anybody, especially with what we had built and what was around the corner for us,' Idalski said. 'But, out of that, I can turn around and say that it was one of the best things that happened to me. I got to go to the Olympics, I got to coach overseas and live in China and Russia. Who gets to do those things? 'I probably would have stayed in North Dakota another 10 or 15 years. I may have ended my career there. But it forced me to grow. Dealing with that made me a better person.' After North Dakota, Idalski went to the KRS Vanke Rays and guided the team from Shenzhen, China to two titles in three years in the Russian Zhenskaya Hockey League. That led to him being named bench boss of the Chinese team for Beijing 2022. China went 2-2-0 there. Highlights from that stretch for him — a kid who grew up in a Detroit suburb — included having breakfast with former Red Wings winger Slava Kozlov when their teams wound up staying at the same hotel, and watching former Red Wings centre Pavel Datsyuk play in a 5,000-seat arena. 'I loved it. I thought it was just an awesome experience,' Idalski said. The PWHL has yet to announce its schedule for its upcoming third season, which now features eight teams with the additions of Vancouver and Seattle. Teams played 30-game seasons last year, beginning on Nov. 30. Check the PWHL Vancouver website for more information . @SteveEwen SEwen@
Edmonton Journal
9 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
Oilers notebook: Keith Acton fondly recalls 'resilient' Mark Kirton who died after fight with ALS
Former Edmonton Oilers Stanley Cup winner and associate coach Keith Acton fondly remembers his friend and ex-NHL forward Mark Kirton, who fought the bravest of fights with ALS before dying Sunday in Ontario. Article content 'It's so sad…he really dedicated himself in every way to generate resources to fight this for others, you know, coming down the pipe, making people aware (ALS),' said Acton, who played three years of OHL junior hockey in Peterborough with Kirton, who was diagnosed with the awful disease in 2018 and died at 67. Article content Article content 'He gave a message on video for (former NHL goalie and TV broadcaster) Greg Millen's funeral (April). Mark was always thinking of others. He was a good player, a good person and so resilient,' said Acton, who was successfully treated for testicular cancer when a Maple Leafs' assistant coach to Pat Quinn. Article content Article content No disrespect to Kirton's 266 NHL game career after being a second-round Toronto draft pick in 1978—it's not easy making the best league in the world—but he got more interest for his ALS battle and raising money to draw awareness to the insidious disease. He founded ALS Action Canada with PALS (Patients with ALS), a patient-led alternative to find a cure in 2020. Article content Article content Article content Five years is usually the high bar with people with ALS and Kirton lived seven. In December, 2023, after Kirton spearheaded the effort, the seven Canadian teams got together to help raise funds and reached $1 million. Article content Article content 'He was a dedicated hockey player who loved the game but his dedication to this (ALS) was a whole other level,' said Acton, who won a Cup ring here in 1988, and later was on Dallas Eakins' staff, along with owning a Boston Pizza franchise for about 20 years in Stouffville, Ont. and currently on city council there. Article content Kirton and Acton played three years together in Peterborough, the first season for Roger Neilson, who later would coach the Leafs and Canucks. Acton would go on to play 1,023 NHL games, and Kirton had stops with Toronto, Detroit and Vancouver, becoming an NHL role player, lessons learned from Neilson. Article content 'Mark was strong for his size and he did the basics…he was a Roger (Neilson) kind of player, disciplined and dedicated the defensive side of the game. Good on face-offs, a good penalty-killer and he could score. He wasn't flash and dash but he was a very serviceable player. I'm sure Roger was instrumental in Mark being drafted to the Leafs because, and deservedly so, Roger held Mark in high regard,' said Acton.
National Post
9 hours ago
- National Post
Oilers notebook: Keith Acton fondly recalls 'resilient' Mark Kirton who died after fight with ALS
Former Edmonton Oilers Stanley Cup winner and associate coach Keith Acton fondly remembers his friend and ex-NHL forward Mark Kirton, who fought the bravest of fights with ALS before dying Sunday in Ontario. Article content 'It's so sad…he really dedicated himself in every way to generate resources to fight this for others, you know, coming down the pipe, making people aware (ALS),' said Acton, who played three years of OHL junior hockey in Peterborough with Kirton, who was diagnosed with the awful disease in 2018 and died at 67. Article content 'He gave a message on video for (former NHL goalie and TV broadcaster) Greg Millen's funeral (April). Mark was always thinking of others. He was a good player, a good person and so resilient,' said Acton, who was successfully treated for testicular cancer when a Maple Leafs' assistant coach to Pat Quinn. Article content Toronto Maple Leafs' Hall of Famer Borje Salming, Calgary Flames ' assistant GM Chris Snow and Ottawa Senators assistant coach Bob Jones have also succumbed in the last three years to ALS or Lou Gehrig's Disease, the nerve system disease which affects nerve cells in the brain and spinal cord, causing a loss of muscle control and eventually a loss of mobility and the ability to eat and speak, paralysis and respiratory failure. Article content No disrespect to Kirton's 266 NHL game career after being a second-round Toronto draft pick in 1978—it's not easy making the best league in the world—but he got more interest for his ALS battle and raising money to draw awareness to the insidious disease. He founded ALS Action Canada with PALS (Patients with ALS), a patient-led alternative to find a cure in 2020. Article content Article content Five years is usually the high bar with people with ALS and Kirton lived seven. In December, 2023, after Kirton spearheaded the effort, the seven Canadian teams got together to help raise funds and reached $1 million. Article content Article content 'He was a dedicated hockey player who loved the game but his dedication to this (ALS) was a whole other level,' said Acton, who won a Cup ring here in 1988, and later was on Dallas Eakins' staff, along with owning a Boston Pizza franchise for about 20 years in Stouffville, Ont. and currently on city council there. Article content Kirton and Acton played three years together in Peterborough, the first season for Roger Neilson, who later would coach the Leafs and Canucks. Acton would go on to play 1,023 NHL games, and Kirton had stops with Toronto, Detroit and Vancouver, becoming an NHL role player, lessons learned from Neilson. Article content 'Mark was strong for his size and he did the basics…he was a Roger (Neilson) kind of player, disciplined and dedicated the defensive side of the game. Good on face-offs, a good penalty-killer and he could score. He wasn't flash and dash but he was a very serviceable player. I'm sure Roger was instrumental in Mark being drafted to the Leafs because, and deservedly so, Roger held Mark in high regard,' said Acton.
