'I can't see Bumrah, Rahul, Gambhir agreeing with Shubman Gill': India captain faces fresh fire on bizarre decision
But while England celebrated a landmark-filled day, India found themselves gripped by a tactical mess, none more baffling than the non-utilisation of Washington Sundar.
After a brilliant four-fer in the Lord's Test, Sundar didn't bowl a single over across three sessions in Manchester, even as Ben Duckett, Zak Crawley, Ollie Pope, Root and Ben Stokes dictated terms with little resistance. India's bowling combination, already without a frontline spinner apart from Ravindra Jadeja, looked woefully incomplete. The decision not to use Sundar, who was picked over Kuldeep Yadav and has a track record of containing runs, raised eyebrows, particularly on a pitch that began to offer grip and variable bounce as the day progressed.
The matter snowballed into a key talking point post-stumps, when former India batter Sanjay Manjrekar posed hard questions on JioHotstar's broadcast.
'Can we assume that these decisions were taken solely by Shubman Gill? At this stage of his career, you'd expect him to get some inputs… or considering he has done so well as a batter, everybody has withdrawn, saying 'this guy is getting into the zone'," Manjrekar said.
"Because I can't see everyone agreeing to this kind of move. Bumrah, KL Rahul, or a Gambhir thinking Washi should not be bowled… come what may,' said Manjrekar further, mincing no words.
The selection of Sundar in itself had come under scrutiny after Gill's reluctance to introduce him to the attack, with former players surprised at the call to bring in an all-rounder without giving him a role in the match. While Gill has shown tactical clarity in patches, the inexperience of leading in high-pressure situations may finally be showing.
A challenging day for India ahead
Meanwhile, England continued to press forward. Root was finally stumped by Jadeja, but the damage had long been done. Stokes, who retired hurt on 66 with cramps, returned late in the day to remain unbeaten on 77 alongside Liam Dawson.
With two days left and India staring at a massive deficit, it will take a monumental turnaround and sharper decision-making on Gill's part to keep the series alive.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
26 minutes ago
- News18
Most Wickets For India In A Test Series Played Away From Home
Last Updated: Mohammed Siraj entered his name in the history books on August 4 by equalling the record of taking the most wickets for India in a Test series played in England. Mohammed Siraj entered his name in the history books on Monday (August 4) by equalling Jasprit Bumrah's record of taking the most wickets for India in a Test series played in England. Siraj played all five Tests for India in England and accounted for the dismissal of 23 batters. Siraj's tally of 23 wickets also helped him enter the top 10 list of Indian bowlers who have picked up the most wickets in a Test series played away from home. Here's a look: 1/12 Subhash Gupte dismissed 27 West Indies batters in five matches during India's tour of the West Indies in 1952-53. (Picture Credit: X) In 1967-68, Erapalli Prasanna played four Tests in New Zealand and dismissed 24 Kiwi batters. (Picture Credit: X/@ICC) In the 2003-04 Border-Gavaskar Trophy, Anil Kumble picked up 24 wickets in three Test matches in Australia. (Picture Credit: AFP) Kapil Dev played six Test matches in Pakistan in 1982-83 and accounted for the dismissal of 24 batters. (Picture Credit: X/@ICC) Jasprit Bumrah dismissed 23 English batters in five Test matches played during the 2021-22 series in England. (Picture Credit: AFP) In 2006, Anil Kumble played four Test matches in the West Indies and picked up 23 wickets for the Rahul Dravid-led side. (Picture Credit: AFP) Next Photogallery
Deccan Herald
4 hours ago
- Deccan Herald
Young India passes tough English test
Right after Mohammed Siraj picked up the final wicket of Gus Atkinson, the entire Indian team erupted in jubilation. First the pacer leapt in the air with his customary 'Siuu' celebration, then his teammates converged around him while a few members of the support staff beyond the boundary line rushed into the middle, all of them dancing in joy. A few moments later, the entire team proceeded for a victory lap around The Oval, which was packed to the rafters and roaring in delight after watching an epic 6-run win for the ages. The Indians didn't clinch the newly coined Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy, but the boisterous celebrations—like they'd won a World Cup—showed how much the 2-2 verdict meant for this transitional team under new captain Shubman Gill. Having achieved some incredible success—home and away—over the past decade, the Indian team was hit by the sudden retirements of Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma and R Ashwin. Transitions are an inevitable part of sport, but when three big superstars bid adieu around the same time, especially after lifting a team to rarefied heights, it's an extremely challenging affair. It's what new captain Shubman Gill and head coach Gautam Gambhir, who took charge from Rahul Dravid after the T20 World Cup a year ago, were tasked with — and to be fair, they've come out with flying colours. The biggest concern for the Indians before arriving here was on the batting front. Among the top order batters, only KL Rahul and Rishabh Pant had previous experience of playing a full series in England. Skipper Gill's form outside the subcontinent too was very average. Can this young crop deliver in a country where sound technique is of utmost importance? Yes, they did — with Gill leading from the front with a jaw-dropping 754 runs that included a career-best 269. Rahul scored 532 runs with two centuries and an equal number of half-centuries, his opening partner Yashasvi Jaiswal hit 411, starting and ending the series with a ton each, while vice-captain Pant was in elements, amassing 479 runs with two centuries and three fifties and earning a lot of praise for batting with a fractured foot. On the batting front, the find of the series was Washington Sundar. The Tamil Nadu off-spinning all-rounder scored a career-defining 101 not out to help India pull off a remarkable draw against all odds in the fourth Test in Manchester that ensured the series was still alive in the fifth. He was backed to the hilt by captain Gill, whose decision to play him instead of attacking spinner Kuldeep Yadav was pilloried by many critics — but Sundar repaid all that faith with performances on the field. No praise can be too high for Ravindra Jadeja, who yet again proved why he's the Most Valuable Player in the team still. One of the remnants of the old guard, the 36-year-old all-rounder brought his A-game in exceptional fashion, amassing 516 runs with one century and five half-centuries, playing several game-changing knocks. On the bowling front too, the southpaw didn't disappoint, bagging seven wickets. With regards to Gill's captaincy, the 25-year-old marshalled his resources incredibly well. He faced numerous challenges, especially in terms of fielding a settled bowling unit because of Jasprit Bumrah's 3-match availability 'clause', but he did a job with whatever he had. He made some bold calls in backing Sundar instead of Kuldeep because of the former's superior batting abilities and stood firm by his decision despite a lot of outside noise. There have been times when he has looked clueless and turned defensive when England batters were on the assault, but like he said, there are lessons to be learnt and he's willing to incorporate them in future assignments. On the bowling front, this tour has been Mohammed Siraj's. The Hyderabadi bowled with a lion's heart, sending down 185.3 overs with barely a dip in intensity. The spotlight was on Bumrah but Siraj deservedly stole the limelight with a mesmerising performance at The Oval. Prasidh Krishna and Akash Deep fared decently as understudies but it's the back-ups where India have a problem with. During Kohli's reign they had a wealth of resources on the fast bowling front — but suddenly the barrel appears a little dry. It's something that needs serious addressing if India are to continue dominating.
Indian Express
7 hours ago
- Indian Express
Shubman Gill to compete with Ben Stokes, Wiaan Mulder for ICC Player of the Month
India captain Shubman Gill was on Wednesday named among the three nominees for ICC's Player of the Month award for July along with South Africa's Wiaan Mulder and England skipper Ben Stokes. Gill led India remarkably in the recently-concluded Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy against England as his young side emerged with a hard-fought 2-2 draw, a series in which the 25-year-old rewrote batting records. Gill scored 754 runs in the series against England with four centuries, including a double ton at 75.40 to break legendary Sunil Gavaskar's record (732) for the highest run tally for an Indian captain in a five-Test series. Gill's returns are now also the second-best behind Sir Donald Bradman (810 runs) in the all-time list for captains. 'Shubman Gill had a sensational month, amassing 567 runs at an impeccable average of 94.50 in three Tests during India's gripping series in England,' the ICC wrote on its website. 'He played a starring role in India's record-breaking win at Edgbaston, where he scored a monumental 269 in the first innings followed by 161 in the second. His combined 430 runs across the two innings is the second highest tally, next only to Graham Gooch's 456,' it added. The ICC said Gill carried the baton from 'all-time great' Virat Kohli at No.4. 'His consistency at No. 4, carrying on the baton from all-time great Virat Kohli, provided stability and flair in equal measure, and combined with his extraordinary captaincy in his debut series,' it said. In his maiden outing as South Africa captain, Mulder struck a mammoth 367 not out against Zimbabwe but declared his team's innings when he could have broken legendary Brian Lara's record for highest individual total of 400 not out against England in 2004. The ICC said, 'He scored 531 runs across the two matches at an astonishing average of 265.50, including a composed 147 in the second innings of the first Test.' 'However, his standout act came in the second Test at Bulawayo, where he smashed an unbeaten 367 in his maiden outing as South Africa's Test skipper — the highest individual score in South African Test history.' 'Mulder also chipped in with the ball, claiming seven wickets at just 15.28 apiece, including a four-wicket haul in the first Test,' it added. The ICC lauded Stokes for his all-round show against India saying, 'He scored 251 runs at an average of 50.20 and took 12 wickets at 26.33, delivering in high-pressure situations with both bat and ball.' 'His leadership proved crucial in maintaining England's intensity and belief in a closely contested series. With ball in hand, he bowled long spells, often breaking key partnerships and turning the tide in England's favour,' it added. With PTI inputs
