Dylan Scannell hit Cobh chef with a sword over debt, murder trial told
A 30-year-old Cobh man got out of a car shortly before nine o'clock at night at a shopping centre car park to meet a man who owed him money and he struck him with a sword, it was alleged on Tuesday at the opening of a murder trial in Cork.
Dylan Scannell of O'Rahilly Street, Cobh, County Cork, replied to the charge of murdering Ian Baitson, in Eurospar car park, Newtown Road, Cobh, on March 19, 2024: 'Not guilty to murder, guilty of manslaughter.'
His trial before Ms Justice Eileen Creedon and a jury of six men and six women is expected to go on until June 6 at the Central Criminal Court sitting in Cork. The date on the charge refers to March 19, 2024, where it is alleged that the deceased was fatally injured four days earlier.
Prosecution senior counsel Donal O'Sullivan gave the jury an outline of the evidence anticipated in the case but stressed to them that this was not itself evidence.
First, Mr O'Sullivan said that for a person to be guilty of murder they must intend to kill or to cause serious injury so that in this case the prosecution must prove that Dylan Scannell intended to kill Ian Baitson or to cause him serious injury.
'The accused man in front of you pleaded guilty to manslaughter but not murder. He accepts he caused the death but he did not have the requisite mental element of intention.
'The events which give rise to this are on March 15, 2024, just over a year ago, at a shopping centre/petrol station in an area of Cobh called Newtown. It is called Eurospar. It is alleged Dylan Scannell attacked and struck Ian Baitson with a sword causing his death. That is in essence what is alleged.
'The two men knew each other. It appears there was a debt owed by Ian Baitson to Dylan Scannell, being paid off bit by bit over a period of time.
'In the immediate aftermath a mobile phone was recovered at the scene with messages from a WhatsApp conversation between Dylan Scannell and Ian Baitson. You will see the messages. There are voice notes as well. In the run-up to the events of March 15 the messages from Dylan Scannell are coming in a more threatening way.
'There is going to be a CCTV montage… At about 8.50pm Ian Baitson left his mother's home which is very close. He went to the car park at the back of the complex, where there is one of these washing machine facilities…
The court was told today that it appears Ian Baitson (pictured) owed a debt to Dylan Scannell. File picture
"A car pulled up. A person got out and struck him with a sword. The person who was struck was Ian Baitson. The person who carried out the attack left immediately in the car.
'He was removed to hospital and passed away four days later.
'The Skoda Octavia was tracked by other cameras going to the car park. (Afterwards) it is tracked to various places. It returns to O'Rahilly Street but does not stop there. It goes to Connolly Street right next to the harbour.
'Subsequently, gardaí carried out a search in the Mall, Cobh, a shingle-type beach, and a sword was found (with a DNA match to Ian Baitson).
'The (rental) Skoda Octavia was returned a day or so early. A car mat was seized and blood which was that of the deceased was found.'
Read More
Jury sworn in as Cobh man denies murder but admits manslaughter of young chef
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Son is sentenced to life in prison for murdering his ill mother in her home
The brother of a man who murdered their ailing 58-year-old mother has told the Central Criminal Court that 'someone who should have protected' her had instead taken her life in the 'most cruel, violent and sadistic way possible'. In a victim impact statement on Tuesday, Angela Canavan's son Keith Canavan said his brother Nigel did not just take their mother's life, but had also tried to take her dignity in the way he had killed her 'using the one method she feared the most'. Keith also said his brother had 'portrayed her in the courtroom not as the woman she truly was, but as someone he could scapegoat to protect himself'. He said his mother always had a fear of anyone touching her neck and 'to think that this was the way she died in the one way she had a deep fear of' was 'unthinkable' and 'beyond comprehension' to him. READ MORE Keith said Nigel had denied their mother 'even the smallest grace, both in her final moments and in how he spoke about her after'. In his statement, Keith also said that anyone who would have known Nigel would have known how much he loved their mother, but his actions had not shown love. Mr Justice Kerida Naidoo said Ms Canavan was a well-loved and accomplished person and he said it 'must be beyond any mother's darkest imaginings that they would die at the hand of the child they gave birth to'. Angela Canavan previously had a 'glittering career' as a psychotherapist. Photograph: On Tuesday Nigel Canavan (39) was sentenced to life imprisonment after he was convicted last month of murdering his mother. Desmond Dockery SC, defending, said the defendant's brother Keith had made a passing reference in his victim impact statement that despite the violence inflicted by Nigel on their mother, anyone who knew Nigel would have known how much he loved his mother. On May 16th, a jury convicted Nigel of murder, rejecting his claim he was provoked and defending himself from an attack by his mother, whom he strangled and smothered to death in her own home. Nigel claimed that stab wounds to each of Ms Canavan's thighs, one of which tracked to 13.5cm in depth, were self-inflicted by his mother, who the trial heard had a 'glittering career' as a psychotherapist before succumbing to alcoholism. Nigel also claimed he had acted in self-defence when his mother, who had a brain injury from a fall four years before her death, attacked him by swinging her open hands at him and trying to kick him. Taking the stand during his trial, Nigel further accused his mother of deliberately provoking him by calling him the 'worst son in the world' and saying during a heated argument how she wished she had never had him. The jury also rejected a suggestion by Nigel's defence that his mother's alleged insults so provoked him that he could be found guilty of manslaughter rather than murder. A pathologist found that, besides being strangled and smothered, Ms Canavan had suffered a laceration to the top of her head, bruises to her face, body, arms and legs and three broken ribs. Some injuries indicated she tried to defend herself from an attack, and bruises to her chest suggested she had been manhandled before her death, the court heard. Nigel, with an address at Erris Gardens, Crossmolina, Co Mayo, had pleaded not guilty to his mother's murder at her home in St John's Terrace, Sligo, on May 1st, 2023.
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Cork man accused of attempted murder in arson attack pleads guilty to other related charges
A facing the prospect of trial by judge and jury for attempted murder arising out of an arson attack on a house in Cork city on Christmas Day 2023 confessed to other related charges today. Shane Casey, aged 32, of Shanowen, Rathcormac, Co Cork, was arraigned on three charges at the Central Criminal Court today and pleaded guilty to all three of them. He did not plead guilty to another charge on the indictment — namely the attempted murder of Billy Murphy, a man in his 60s, owner of the house at Dyke Parade, Cork, where the arson was carried out. However, defence senior counsel Ray Boland conceded that the plea of guilty to certain charges was entered on the basis that the full facts of the case would be given at the sentencing hearing. Mr Boland asked for free legal aid to be extended to include the preparation of a psychiatric report on Shane Casey. Ms Justice Eileen Creedon acceded to that application. The case was adjourned until October 6 when it is anticipated a date will be set for sentencing. Detective Garda Brian Barron originally charged Casey with the attempted murder of Mr Murphy, but there was no plea to that charge. There was a plea of guilty to a charge of assault causing harm to Mr Murphy, production of an article, namely a blade, in the course of the assault, and finally causing criminal damage to the house and neighbouring properties with intent to endanger life. Evidence It was previously alleged when the case first came before the courts that the accused set fire to the house on Dyke Parade, Cork, just after 6pm on December 25, 2023, when four people were present in the house and that the accused man stood outside swinging a blade when the first person ran from the burning building, telling him, 'You are going to die here tonight.' Referring to CCTV and other evidence, Det Garda Barron said: 'At 6.05pm, he exits and stands looking in the open front door at the fire taking hold. At 6.06pm, it is alleged that he closes the front door and attempts to barricade the front door from the outside, using a piece of timber to jam to the side and then under the door. 'It is alleged he takes a blade from his pocket and holds it out in front of him and waits outside. At 6.08pm, the front door bursts open and [one of the men] attempts to escape the now blazing house. "It was alleged he said (to one injured party), 'My name is Shane Casey and you remember me from two days ago — you are going to die here tonight.'' It was further alleged that one woman had to be rescued from the roof and that it took six units of the fire service more than six hours to bring the fire under control and make the building safe. The fire caused thousands of euro in damage, the detective said. Jane Hyland prosecution senior counsel said that victim impact statements would be prepared in advance of sentencing. This case had been listed for trial by judge and jury at the Central Criminal Court on June 18 but it will now be removed from that list.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘As a father, he betrayed her': Man jailed for engaging in sex act with vulnerable adult daughter
A man who 'betrayed' his adult daughter, who has an intellectual disability, by engaging in a sexual act with her, has been jailed for eight years. The 69-year-old man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, pleaded guilty to two counts of engaging in a sexual act with a protected person in Leinster on February 7th, 2023. The woman has a moderate intellectual disability and now lives in a residential care setting, the court heard. Passing sentence on Tuesday in the Central Criminal Court , Mr Justice Paul McDermott said this is a very serious offence with a maximum sentence of life in prison. READ MORE 'As a father, he betrayed her,' he said. 'These offences were committed by her father – he could do whatever he liked.' Mr Justice McDermott sentenced the defendant to nine years in prison but suspended the final year for a period of two years. He also placed the man under the supervision of the Probation Service for five years and directed him to undertake any courses it deems appropriate. The judge said the man is to have no contact with his daughter without her consent and only then under very strict supervision. He backdated the sentence to when the defendant went into custody. At a previous hearing, an investigating garda told the court the injured party is in her mid-30s and has moderate intellectual disability. The court heard the woman was given a course on sexuality, during which she disclosed that she had never shared a bed with a man before, except for her father, who had not worn a condom. Specialist interviewers from An Garda Síochána spoke to the victim and she was moved into residential care after the abuse was disclosed. The investigating garda agreed with Seoirse Ó Dúnlaing SC, defending, that a trial date was fixed for March this year, but a guilty plea had been entered, saving the woman from having to give evidence in front of a jury. The garda also accepted that the man had no previous convictions and that his wife had passed away a number of years ago, meaning he became his daughter's main carer. A social worker gave evidence that the woman has good independent skills and is a kind and caring person who masks her emotions. She told Mr Vincent Heneghan, SC, prosecuting, that the injured party had not availed of any counselling and the abuse continues to affect her daily life.
