MPs should stop obsessing over foreign issues and try fixing the problems here
Pity the poor lambs. Labour MPs Abtisam Mohamed and Yuan Yang set out from Luton Airport to Israel's Ben Gurion, only to be detained by officials on arrival, and then deported. Hopefully they at least managed to get the local experience with a frothy café hafuch and a nice flaky rugelach at Terminal 3's Ilan's Coffee House during their short trip.
Their plan was to visit some West Bank charity projects, or, as Israel officials put it, 'to document Israeli security forces and spread hateful rhetoric against Israel'.
Both MPs had previously called for a boycott of Israel and the state thus concluded that it was their duty to deny entry to people who intended to cause it harm.
Mohamed and Yang were frightfully cross about this and back home rallied colleagues for a photo call in Westminster Hall on Monday.
How dare Israel stymie their weekend jaunt, was the message. 'There is no direct route into the West Bank. We have to go through Israel,' said Ms Mohamed. 'This act was not just a diplomatic affront. This wasn't about security. It was about control and censorship.'
In fact it was a salient reminder that these members of Parliament were elected to serve their constituents. The House of Commons was not in recess until April 8 of this week and one might assume that MPs had more appropriate things to do for their voters than gathering for photo calls about Israeli diplomacy or attempting entry to the occupied West Bank.
Mohamed was elected to represent Sheffield Central in July 2024. Yuan Yang is MP for Earley and Woodley, in Berkshire.
Sheffield's challenges are numerous. There is in-work poverty, the city has some of the lowest levels of pay in the UK, it's a de-industrialised metropolis with higher-than-average unemployment, there's a housing shortage, it's a city with high levels of pollution, high levels of crime and drug-taking and high levels of chronic ill-health.
Earley and Woodley also has its fair share of problems. Although generally more prosperous than central Sheffield, GP and dental appointments are hard to come by, one in five children are recorded as living in poverty and many school children are malnourished. As Yuan Yang said herself during the 2024 General Election campaign: 'We [need to] make sure that every child gets a proper breakfast before they start school.'
Quite how visiting the Palestinian territories helps these issues is anyone's guess. But it's sure as hell more fun than spending a Saturday shaking hands with the arts and crafts stallholders of Nether Edge or looking at potholes around Wokingham.
Grandstanding on international issues and joining an overseas parliamentary delegation is rather more wholesome. And it's an irresistible habit. Indeed just as rats as big as cats began to mooch about the streets of Birmingham, as mounds of rubbish piled up due to a bin strike after hundreds of Unite members walked out in a row with the Labour-run council, Liam Byrne, MP for Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North, flew to Tokyo.
He joined a House of Commons business committee jaunt, meeting opposite numbers in the Japanese parliament and then – as he was already out there – reportedly extended his stay for a holiday.
Thus while rodents nibbled their way through the rotting leftovers of Indian takeaways, Mr Byrne could avail himself of a tasting menu of omakase nigirizushi.
Similarly, at the end of March, Tahir Ali, MP for Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley, joined 20 parliamentarians in writing a letter to the prime minister of Pakistan urging him to build an airport in Mirpur. Granted they just wrote, signed and dispatched a letter and didn't fly to Islamabad (bunch of amateurs: all that 30-degree heat and sunshine, chicken karahi and chana chaat) but it left thousands of their constituents scratching their heads.
Sadly the reality is that unless you're in the Cabinet, and especially if you're in Opposition, being an MP is dull; all those tedious problems, moaning constituents who think you're the Citizen's Advice Bureau and the horror show that is the weekend surgery where you must listen to people whinging about their mouldy flats.
Far better a trip to a war zone or posturing on irrelevant infrastructure. Except that, sorry Mmes Mohamed and Yang, that's the job, that's the honour, to do the dirge, to clean up the mess on your own doorsteps. And if that's not sexy enough for you, quit your roles so we can have some nice fruity by-elections and get MPs elected who want to do the actual job.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
an hour ago
- Powys County Times
Powys County Council's budget black hole value queried
HOW big a funding gap Powys County Council is expected to fill with cuts and savings over the next four to fove years varies by over £20 million – a councllor has pointed out. Calls were made to clarify the figures that the council is using to explain their predicted financial black hole during a joint meeting of all of the council's scrutiny committee's on Wednesday, June 11. At the meeting, councillors looked at the council's draft Corporate and Equalities Strategic Plan which has been updated from the version that was agreed earlier this year. The plan sets out the council's well-being objectives, and what action they need to take to deliver them up the next local election in 2027. All the departmental strategies, action and business plans are linked by a 'golden thread' into this document which encompasses them all. This plan is supposed to keep track of how the council is performing against the three objectives of the Liberal Democrat/Labour cabinet's Stronger Fairer, Greener agenda. Cllr Gareth E Jones (Powys Independents) highlighted the problem and said: 'If you go to the leader and deputy leader's introduction (to the document) there's a statement there that the funding gap is £60 million but on the MTFS (Medium Term Financial Strategy) the funding gap on those assumptions is shown as £39.1 million. 'I think they two figures need to be the same for consistency.' Director of corporate services and section 151 officer, Jane Thomas replied: 'We can and will amend that to the latest figure, it should reflect what was approved in council back in February. 'We will see the gap change quite often now as we go through the years and we develop our five year plans.' Making sure that the figure changes forms one of the recommendations made by councillors at the meeting – which will be added to the report when it goes before cabinet at a later date. Another recommendation by councillors is that members of the Liberal Democrat/Labour cabinet should attend the joint scrutiny meeting to explain and if needed defend the council's performance. Cllr Jones said: 'It was very disappointing about the number of cabinet members that were present today, we should have a recommendation at future meetings that they have more presence. 'This is the council's performance document ,officers develop the plan but cabinet member sign it off.' Learning and skills committee chairman who chaired the joint-scrutiny meeting, Cllr Gwynfor Thomas (Conservative) said: 'I'm happy to do that as they (cabinet members) are the line holders and are responsible for the different measures and things.'
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Glasgow demonstration takes place to 'remember Gaza's lost men'
The Gaza Genocide Emergency Committee (GGEC) organised the national demo to coincide with Father's Day on June 15. Ahead of today's event, they said: "This coming Father's Day, we gather in red to honour all the men slaughtered in Gaza, to demand decisive sanctions against Israel, forcing it to halt the extermination, and to assert the internationally-recognised right of all Palestinians to resist their genocidal elimination." (Image: Gordon Terris, Newsquest) Those taking part were asked to wear red. The demo began at Glasgow Green at the McLennan Arch at 12.30pm today (June 14) before a march into the city centre started at 1pm. Rabbi Elhanan Beck and Rabbi Haim Sofer joined the march and were pictured at the front of the crowd. (Image: Gordon Terris, Newsquest) The two men were greeted by members of the GGEC arriving at Glasgow Central Station on Friday, June 13. A post shared by the Committee on Instagram read: "Both men are anti-Zionist Orthodox Jews who fervently oppose genocidal Israel and stand in unshakeable solidarity with the Palestinian people." They also spoke at the demo in Glasgow Green alongside Adam Al Khateb and Hussein Ezzedine Rabbi Beck was pictured holding a sign which read: "Judaism condemns the state of 'Israel' and its atrocities." Other signs by those taking part had statements such as "stop Gaza genocide", "it's not a war, it's a genocide", and "stop bombing Iran". (Image: Gordon Terris, Newsquest) (Image: Gordon Terris, Newsquest) (Image: Gordon Terris, Newsquest) (Image: Gordon Terris, Newsquest)
NBC News
2 hours ago
- NBC News
Spanish-language misinformation on Los Angeles protests pushes a familiar theme
A surge of false or misleading posts, photographs and videos about the Los Angeles protests have been circulating on social media, with many of those shared among Latinos — mostly in Spanish — tying the protesters to socialist or communist governments. One post on X with over 600,000 views claims that in the U.S., immigration protest groups have links to 'the Venezuelan mafia,' the Communist Party of Cuba, and the Morena Party, the left-wing ruling party of Mexico. But the post doesn't specify any groups and doesn't give evidence of this. The narrative echoes similar falsehoods that circulated during the 2020 George Floyd protests and the 2024 pro-Palestinian student protests on university campuses. Parts of Los Angeles and other cities across the country have seen protests against immigration raids as President Donald Trump's administration enforces a hard-line immigration policy. Dramatic scenes where cars, including Waymo taxis, were set on fire and protesters confronted law enforcement by throwing objects at them have filled social media feeds. While some far-left groups have encouraged and even glorified violence in the protests, the onslaught of posts, mostly in Spanish, appears to be an attempt to link protests against immigrant raids to leftist Latin American governments, and the posts show support for President Donald Trump and his policies. 'Though there is always inaccurate information swirling around, there has certainly been a spike since the Los Angeles protests took off,' said Evelyn Pérez-Verdía, president of We Are Más, which focuses on social impact consulting. 'In the past we would find false or inaccurate information more hidden in platforms like Telegram, WhatsApp. Now it's more in the open and more easily found on social media and online publications.' The falsehoods revive prior conspiracies that the protests are a planned provocation from leftist governments and not a spontaneous response to the immigration raids. On his platform, Truth Social, Trump has baselessly claimed protesters are 'Paid Insurrectionists!' Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass and California Gov. Gavin Newsom have been targets of some of the misinformation that seeks to link them to communism. A fake picture of Bass with Cuba's late leader Fidel Castro, with his arm around her has circulated on social media. The original picture showed Castro with the late activist and former South African President Nelson Mandela. Bass does have some connections to Cuba; she traveled to the country with the Venceremos Brigade in the 1970s to do volunteer construction work and later went there as a member of Congress. She received criticism in 2020 for calling Castro's death ' a great loss, ' but the fake picture is a step further to link her directly with Fidel Castro. 'What we're seeing in Spanish is different from what we're seeing in English,' said Pérez-Verdía. In Spanish, she added, the false information is mainly focused on elected officials, like Newsom and Bass. 'They talk about the extreme left, communism — actors, whether domestic or foreign, are changing the messaging based on the community they are targeting,' said Pérez-Verdía. In some cases, false information has made its way to the federal government. Some conservative and pro-Russian social media accounts have circulated a video of Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum from before the protests, claiming she encouraged them, according to Newsguard, a fact-checking website. The move was 'portrayed as foreign interference in domestic U.S. politics,' Newsguard reported. During an oval office briefing Tuesday, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem accused Sheinbaum of encouraging 'violent protests.' Sheinbaum responded on X, saying it's 'absolutely false' and included a video of herself from the day before saying she does not agree with violent actions as a form of protest. She also accused the opposition party of falsely saying she incited the protests. In some cases, videos and photos that include a hammer and sickle, are taken out of context to make it seem the protests are a communist movement. One post with tens of thousands of views claims that the protests are 'URBAN COMMUNIST TERRORISM.' One Spanish-language post from an account with over 1 million followers glorifies violence against 'progressive anti-ICE protestors.' Situations like these create fertile ground for disinformation to spread. Fake accounts in Spanish are more prevalent than they are in English, according to Darren Linvill, a professor at Clemson University and co-director of its Media Forensic Hub. Social media platforms are more likely to identify and shut down accounts in English than in other languages. Linvill said that another reason accounts in Spanish are more common than in English is that the use of marketing companies utilizing fake accounts — on behalf of political organizations or politicians — has spiked in the last few years. The spread of false information 'is absolutely having an effect on driving partisanship, conspiratorial thinking, distrust for expertise and the lack of a sort of shared reality,' said Linvill. 'A shared reality is important for us to build compromise and govern nations together. And I think it is absolutely having an effect on that.' 'The degree to which motivated actors [bad actors], are responsible, versus the fundamental nature of social media to create a giant game of telephone that virtually generates the spread of false information, it's hard to say,' Linvill said.
