Man caught on video attacking pro-life activists handed slap-on-the-wrist sentence
Baltimore Circuit Judge Yvette M. Bryant rebuffed prosecutors' calls for a 10-year sentence against Patrick Brice, 28, after he was found guilty of two counts of second-degree assault and reckless endangerment in relation to the May 2023 incident, according to The Baltimore Banner.
Advertisement
'What about my rights and my well-being?' one of the victims in the attack, Mark Crosby — who was 73 years old at the time — reportedly shouted at Bryant on Thursday as she left the bench.
Brice said on May 26, 2023, he intended to debate Richard Schaefer – the other victim, who was 84 – about the concept of sin outside the Planned Parenthood facility, but then lost it after Schaefer made what he perceived to be a racial remark, The Baltimore Banner reported.
Surveillance video showed Brice shoving Schaefer into a flowerpot and then assaulting Crosby when he rushed to his aid.
'I just snapped one day,' Brice was quoted by The Baltimore Banner as saying in court Thursday before apologizing to both men.
Advertisement
As part of his sentence, Brice must complete anger management classes, undergo drug and alcohol screening, and remain in therapy, the website added.
It also said Crosby suffered permanent damage to his right eye as a result of the assault.
4 A 28-year-old man who was caught on video attacking two pro-life activists outside a Planned Parenthood clinic in Baltimore was sentenced this week to a year of home detention.
Youtube/WBAL-TV 11 Baltimore
'This was not a minor altercation between two parties with differing views on abortion. It was a vicious, targeted assault on two senior citizens whose only 'offense' was praying for expectant mothers and offering life-affirming alternatives to abortion,' Tom Brejcha, the President and Chief Counsel of the conservative law firm Thomas More Society, said in a statement.
Advertisement
'One of the victims was knocked unconscious. The other suffered broken facial bones and a lifelong eye impairment. This was an act of cowardice and cruelty, and sheer mayhem. This crime deserves far more serious consequences than a 'get out of jail free' card and a one-year home detention that amounts to nothing more than a slap on the wrist,' he added.
In May 2023, images posted on the Facebook page of Jay Walton, the president of the Baltimore County Right to Life chapter, purportedly showed Crosby wearing a shirt with the message 'Pro Life,' with swelling over his eye and blood covering his face following the attack.
4 Baltimore Circuit Judge Yvette M. Bryant rebuffed prosecutors' calls for a 10-year sentence against Patrick Brice, 28, after he was found guilty of two counts of second-degree assault and reckless endangerment in relation to the May 2023 incident, according to reports.
Youtube/WBAL-TV 11 Baltimore
'One of our volunteers, Mark Crosby, was brutally beaten on May 26, 2023, while he was praying in front of the Planned Parenthood in Baltimore City,' Walton wrote on a GoFundMe page at the time. 'Mark is currently in the hospital being treated for the serious injuries he sustained.'
Advertisement
'For years, Mark has prayed in front of the Planned Parenthood in Baltimore City to let the scared, young abortion-minded women know that they are loved, that their baby is loved,' Walton added.
In a redacted police report, a Baltimore police officer said one of the victims, later identified as Crosby, told investigators he was standing outside the Planned Parenthood clinic 'in support of Pro-life ideals when an unidentified [white male] attacked another member of the same beliefs as [him].'
4 Police released video that they said shows an assault of two men outside the Planned Parenthood offices in Baltimore.
Youtube/WBAL-TV 11 Baltimore
The individual 'stated that he immediately went to assist and was struck by the suspect and fell to the ground, where he was struck in the face,' the report said.
Police say the other victim, later identified as Schaefer, 'advised the suspect had approached volunteer members of the Planned Parenthood and spoke with them before directing his attention to him.
That victim said 'the suspect spoke with him in an aggressive manner, opposing [his] pro-life ideals and without warning tackled him into a large flowerpot,' the report added.
4 One of the victims of the violent assault at the Planned Parenthood.
Youtube/WBAL-TV 11 Baltimore
It also noted that several witnesses saw the assault unfold, with one telling investigators that the 'conversation between the suspect and [victim] was a debate over their ideas about pro-life and pro-choice viewpoints.'
Advertisement
Crosby's attorney Terrell Roberts read a statement in court on behalf his client, saying that the incident demonstrated a 'gross disregard for the law and human decency.'
'We were in no position to defend ourselves,' Crosby wrote, according to The Baltimore Banner. 'To treat elderly folks with that kind of brutality is shocking.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
3 hours ago
- CNN
A heroic pit bull helps rescue his owners with the aid of a Pittsburgh man willing to follow
Animal stories Tech giantsFacebookTweetLink Follow Gary Thynes was taking his dog out to play in the park last week in Pittsburgh when he noticed a 'beautiful pit bull' walking alone with his leash dragging behind him. Concerned the dog might get hit by a passing car, Thynes tried to get close enough to catch him in hopes that he had a microchip, Thynes posted on Facebook. But the pit bull — a breed sometimes cast as made to fight and regulated as dangerous — stayed just out of arm's reach. He would bark and run a few steps ahead before turning back, the post said. That's when Thynes realized: 'This dog wanted me to follow him.' So, Thynes did just that. A young woman driving by stopped and tried to help Thynes catch the dog, the post said. 'I could get almost close enough to grab the leash and he would run a little farther,' Thynes said, describing how the dog began to lead him down a secluded path behind train tracks to a tent encampment. There he found an unresponsive man lying on a red couch, Thynes said in his Facebook post. 'I couldn't even tell if he was breathing or not. And then I turned around and noticed a pair of legs sticking out of a tent, and I tried to shake them, and it was a woman who would not respond to me,' Thynes told CNN Affiliate WTAE. He immediately called 911. Emergency personnel soon took both to the hospital, Thynes said in his post. An unresponsive man and woman were taken to the hospital on July 29, Pittsburgh Public Safety confirmed to CNN, praising the 'Good Samaritan' and its partners who helped at the scene. The woman as it turns out knew the two people and recognized the dog. She told Thynes she would check on the pair at the hospital the next day. When the ambulance was gone, Thynes turned his attention back to the dog. Soon, animal control arrived and said they would have to take the pit bull to a shelter far outside the city. But Thynes worried the owners wouldn't be able to get him back, he wrote on Facebook. So, he offered to take care of the dog while the owners received care. Thynes – who is '16 months sober from heroin addiction,' he told WTAE — understands how deep the bond can be between a person and their dog, especially during difficult times, he wrote in his post. 'It is an honor for me to take care of this guy until his humans are well enough to reunite with a dog that loves them very much.'
CNN
3 hours ago
- CNN
A heroic pit bull helps rescue his owners with the aid of a Pittsburgh man willing to follow
Animal stories Tech giantsFacebookTweetLink Follow Gary Thynes was taking his dog out to play in the park last week in Pittsburgh when he noticed a 'beautiful pit bull' walking alone with his leash dragging behind him. Concerned the dog might get hit by a passing car, Thynes tried to get close enough to catch him in hopes that he had a microchip, Thynes posted on Facebook. But the pit bull — a breed sometimes cast as made to fight and regulated as dangerous — stayed just out of arm's reach. He would bark and run a few steps ahead before turning back, the post said. That's when Thynes realized: 'This dog wanted me to follow him.' So, Thynes did just that. A young woman driving by stopped and tried to help Thynes catch the dog, the post said. 'I could get almost close enough to grab the leash and he would run a little farther,' Thynes said, describing how the dog began to lead him down a secluded path behind train tracks to a tent encampment. There he found an unresponsive man lying on a red couch, Thynes said in his Facebook post. 'I couldn't even tell if he was breathing or not. And then I turned around and noticed a pair of legs sticking out of a tent, and I tried to shake them, and it was a woman who would not respond to me,' Thynes told CNN Affiliate WTAE. He immediately called 911. Emergency personnel soon took both to the hospital, Thynes said in his post. An unresponsive man and woman were taken to the hospital on July 29, Pittsburgh Public Safety confirmed to CNN, praising the 'Good Samaritan' and its partners who helped at the scene. The woman as it turns out knew the two people and recognized the dog. She told Thynes she would check on the pair at the hospital the next day. When the ambulance was gone, Thynes turned his attention back to the dog. Soon, animal control arrived and said they would have to take the pit bull to a shelter far outside the city. But Thynes worried the owners wouldn't be able to get him back, he wrote on Facebook. So, he offered to take care of the dog while the owners received care. Thynes – who is '16 months sober from heroin addiction,' he told WTAE — understands how deep the bond can be between a person and their dog, especially during difficult times, he wrote in his post. 'It is an honor for me to take care of this guy until his humans are well enough to reunite with a dog that loves them very much.'
USA Today
7 hours ago
- USA Today
Trump never actually cared about making IVF affordable. He just wanted your vote.
President Donald Trump continues to make it clear that actually helping women isn't a priority with this administration. Turns out the 'father of IVF' isn't going to live up to the promise he made on the reelection campaign trail. Who could have seen that coming? After campaigning on the promise that the government would pay for in vitro fertilization or require insurers to cover it, The Washington Post reports that President Donald Trump has no actual plan to make the procedure more affordable. There are no talks of federal subsidies or Affordable Care Act coverage, and administration officials say that there is no plan to get insurance companies on board. When asked about this by The Post, the White House issued a statement saying, "The Administration is committed like none before it to using its authorities to deliver on this pledge" to make IVF more accessible in the United States. Of course, there's a difference between saying you're committed to doing something and actually doing it. I'm not shocked that Trump made a promise he has failed to keep – after all, this is the same man who said he was going to make the cost of living go down and stop the wars in Gaza and Ukraine. Unfortunately, this is just another instance of his administration failing to prioritize reproductive rights. Let's look at what Trump said about IVF during the campaign On the campaign trail, Trump was all-in on IVF, making the claim in August 2024 that the government or insurance companies would pay for the treatment. 'We want to produce babies in this country, right?' Trump said at the time. In February, the president signed an executive order giving domestic policy advisers 90 days to brainstorm ways to lower the cost of IVF and other fertilization treatments. The deadline came and went without any public progress, and the administration recently declined to comment on it. Opinion: Planned Parenthood isn't the only loser in Supreme Court case. Women lose, too. IVF is an incredibly cost-prohibitive procedure that accounts for about 2% of births annually. The nonprofit organization KFF reports that the cost of a single round of IVF can range between $9,000 and $14,000. In the executive order, Trump claimed the costs could get up to $25,000. It's no surprise that an administration determined to pinch pennies is backing away from a plan that would cost them a lot of money, nor is it surprising that Trump would come to realize that forcing the insurance industry to do anything would hurt his chances at future donations. More than anything, it's unsurprising that Trump would go back on a promise that, while controversial in right-wing circles, would benefit families who want to have children. IVF isn't the only reproductive rights challenge we face The fight for IVF is closely linked to the fight for reproductive freedom and abortion access. It comes down to whether women can make decisions about their bodies and their ability to start a family, regardless of the beliefs of others. Opinion: Who would want to have babies under a Trump administration? Not me. In February 2024, the Alabama Supreme Court ruled that frozen embryos were considered human beings, leading IVF clinics in the state to pause services out of fear. The legislature quickly introduced a bill that protected patients from potential legal issues, but it didn't address embryonic personhood. The entire situation revealed how complex the legal landscape could become after the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization decision overturning Roe v. Wade, to the point that it could even harm people who are actively trying to conceive. Not financially supporting IVF comes at a time when women have lost the right to choose when and how they are going to start a family: The government is making it clear that women are subject to the whims of politicians, rather than being able to make decisions about their own bodies. Trump officials never actually cared about making IVF affordable, just like they don't actually care about improving the conditions for people who want to start families but can't afford to. It was all so that Trump could get reelected. Follow USA TODAY columnist Sara Pequeño on X, formerly Twitter: @sara__pequeno
