Fremantle Dockers CEO Simon Garlick wants father-son rule scrapped
As Brisbane prepares to launch into a bid for back-to-back premierships with superstar brothers Will and Levi Ashcroft, while leaders Collingwood boast Nick and Josh Daicos, Garlick declared the modern game couldn't keep limiting access to the best young talent.
The Ashcroft brothers, including Norm Smith medallist Will, were both likely No.1 picks who went to the Lions because of their father, Marcus, a 300-gamer for Brisbane who had first access to them.
Similarly, Nick Daicos was widely considered the best player in his draft but went at four due to Collingwood's bid, while Western Bulldogs 'unicorn' Sam Darcy, the son of club great Luke, has emerged as a potential $2m-a-season player and was another father-son product.
Even of one of the modern-day greats, dual Brownlow medallist Gary Ablett Jr, started his career and played in premierships with Geelong because of the link with his legendary father, Gary Ablett Sr.
Having been unable to get its hands on any of them, Garlick said the romantic notion of the rule was now outweighed by the need for equal access in the pursuit of premierships.
'The father-son is just pot luck,' he said.
'So from my perspective I just think when you've got players the like of the Ashcrofts, Sam Darcy – they're generational players – and we're all working towards trying to win flags by building great cultures, attracting and retaining talent, and doing things on an even playing field.
'It's one that I don't see as having a place in the contemporary game, albeit understanding it's lovely from a historical perspective and the culture of the game. I get that.
'But it just doesn't feel right to me.'
Garlick said the draft was the 'most critical equalisation measure in the game' and shouldn't be compromised anymore.
'I understand that we're going to have some concessions that are provided with it,' he told SEN.
'We want to encourage the game in the northern markets and we're supportive of that. We want to make sure we reach these people who might not necessarily play the game at a regular level.'
The AFL has given no indication that the father-son rule would be revisited.
The Dockers have one father-son player on their list, Jaren Carr, only the club's second father-son player after Brett Peake.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
an hour ago
- The Advertiser
Ex-AFL umpire admits to horse sale while assets frozen
A former AFL umpire who sold a racehorse he owned and gave his former partner $10,000 cash has admitted he breached a court-imposed freeze on his assets. Troy Pannell had previously pleaded guilty to four charges brought by his former company SeaRoad Shipping, relating to payments he had made while working there. Justice Andrew Watson had issued an order on Pannell to prevent him and his company Independent Container Surveyors & Assessors disposing of any goods unless he had assets worth more than $8.7 million. If he sold any of his holdings, those sales must not bring his worth under the amount. Pannell, who was self-represented, on Friday pleaded guilty to two charges of contempt after he handed $10,000 cash to his then partner and sold a racehorse which were in breach of his asset restrictions. The former AFL umpire had initially contested the horse sale charge, claiming in the Melbourne Supreme Court he was not the horse's owner so the sale was not a breach of the order. The plaintiff laid out his evidence, referring to the affidavits of two witnesses, including Matthew Scown, the general manager of Yarraman Park, a thoroughbred racehorse breeding company, and former partner Maree Wilke. Mr Scown said his company had entered into an agreement with Pannell for his horse Aimee's Jewel in 2022. "The stallion service agreement records Mr Pannell as 100 per cent owner of mare Aimee's Jewel," Mr Scown's affidavit read. The company's general manager detailed all the correspondence with Pannell, including preparations for the horse in the lead up to the sale and when the funds were dispersed. "Mr Pannell is recorded as the owner of the filly in all records held by Yarraman ...Yarraman sold the filly on 2 March in accordance with Mr Pannell's authority and direction," Mr Scown said. In Ms Wilke's affidavit, she said she had expressed shock over a transfer form for the horse which bared her signature which she did not sign. "This is the first time that I've seen that document ... I told him I didn't sign it. He told me he signed it on my behalf," she said. "In response to me saying I was worried about being charged under the freezing order, (Pannell) told me I couldn't be charged because I owned the filly." After hearing the plaintiff's evidence, Justice Watson asked Pannell if he wanted to reconsider his position or wished to proceed with cross-examining the witnesses. "I think I'll retract and change after hearing all that," Pannell answered. "You want to plead guilty to fifth charge of contempt now?" the judge asked. "Yes I will, your honour," the accused responded. The experienced umpire, who has presided over more than 200 AFL games, attracted attention after he awarded 17 free kicks to the Western Bulldogs in a 2016 match against the Adelaide Crows. Pannell will return to the court on Tuesday to learn of his penalty. A former AFL umpire who sold a racehorse he owned and gave his former partner $10,000 cash has admitted he breached a court-imposed freeze on his assets. Troy Pannell had previously pleaded guilty to four charges brought by his former company SeaRoad Shipping, relating to payments he had made while working there. Justice Andrew Watson had issued an order on Pannell to prevent him and his company Independent Container Surveyors & Assessors disposing of any goods unless he had assets worth more than $8.7 million. If he sold any of his holdings, those sales must not bring his worth under the amount. Pannell, who was self-represented, on Friday pleaded guilty to two charges of contempt after he handed $10,000 cash to his then partner and sold a racehorse which were in breach of his asset restrictions. The former AFL umpire had initially contested the horse sale charge, claiming in the Melbourne Supreme Court he was not the horse's owner so the sale was not a breach of the order. The plaintiff laid out his evidence, referring to the affidavits of two witnesses, including Matthew Scown, the general manager of Yarraman Park, a thoroughbred racehorse breeding company, and former partner Maree Wilke. Mr Scown said his company had entered into an agreement with Pannell for his horse Aimee's Jewel in 2022. "The stallion service agreement records Mr Pannell as 100 per cent owner of mare Aimee's Jewel," Mr Scown's affidavit read. The company's general manager detailed all the correspondence with Pannell, including preparations for the horse in the lead up to the sale and when the funds were dispersed. "Mr Pannell is recorded as the owner of the filly in all records held by Yarraman ...Yarraman sold the filly on 2 March in accordance with Mr Pannell's authority and direction," Mr Scown said. In Ms Wilke's affidavit, she said she had expressed shock over a transfer form for the horse which bared her signature which she did not sign. "This is the first time that I've seen that document ... I told him I didn't sign it. He told me he signed it on my behalf," she said. "In response to me saying I was worried about being charged under the freezing order, (Pannell) told me I couldn't be charged because I owned the filly." After hearing the plaintiff's evidence, Justice Watson asked Pannell if he wanted to reconsider his position or wished to proceed with cross-examining the witnesses. "I think I'll retract and change after hearing all that," Pannell answered. "You want to plead guilty to fifth charge of contempt now?" the judge asked. "Yes I will, your honour," the accused responded. The experienced umpire, who has presided over more than 200 AFL games, attracted attention after he awarded 17 free kicks to the Western Bulldogs in a 2016 match against the Adelaide Crows. Pannell will return to the court on Tuesday to learn of his penalty. A former AFL umpire who sold a racehorse he owned and gave his former partner $10,000 cash has admitted he breached a court-imposed freeze on his assets. Troy Pannell had previously pleaded guilty to four charges brought by his former company SeaRoad Shipping, relating to payments he had made while working there. Justice Andrew Watson had issued an order on Pannell to prevent him and his company Independent Container Surveyors & Assessors disposing of any goods unless he had assets worth more than $8.7 million. If he sold any of his holdings, those sales must not bring his worth under the amount. Pannell, who was self-represented, on Friday pleaded guilty to two charges of contempt after he handed $10,000 cash to his then partner and sold a racehorse which were in breach of his asset restrictions. The former AFL umpire had initially contested the horse sale charge, claiming in the Melbourne Supreme Court he was not the horse's owner so the sale was not a breach of the order. The plaintiff laid out his evidence, referring to the affidavits of two witnesses, including Matthew Scown, the general manager of Yarraman Park, a thoroughbred racehorse breeding company, and former partner Maree Wilke. Mr Scown said his company had entered into an agreement with Pannell for his horse Aimee's Jewel in 2022. "The stallion service agreement records Mr Pannell as 100 per cent owner of mare Aimee's Jewel," Mr Scown's affidavit read. The company's general manager detailed all the correspondence with Pannell, including preparations for the horse in the lead up to the sale and when the funds were dispersed. "Mr Pannell is recorded as the owner of the filly in all records held by Yarraman ...Yarraman sold the filly on 2 March in accordance with Mr Pannell's authority and direction," Mr Scown said. In Ms Wilke's affidavit, she said she had expressed shock over a transfer form for the horse which bared her signature which she did not sign. "This is the first time that I've seen that document ... I told him I didn't sign it. He told me he signed it on my behalf," she said. "In response to me saying I was worried about being charged under the freezing order, (Pannell) told me I couldn't be charged because I owned the filly." After hearing the plaintiff's evidence, Justice Watson asked Pannell if he wanted to reconsider his position or wished to proceed with cross-examining the witnesses. "I think I'll retract and change after hearing all that," Pannell answered. "You want to plead guilty to fifth charge of contempt now?" the judge asked. "Yes I will, your honour," the accused responded. The experienced umpire, who has presided over more than 200 AFL games, attracted attention after he awarded 17 free kicks to the Western Bulldogs in a 2016 match against the Adelaide Crows. Pannell will return to the court on Tuesday to learn of his penalty.
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Who Freo fans should barrack for in EVERY remaining game
With Fremantle in a massive fight for the finals, The West Australian has gone through every game and settled on which team Dockers fans should get behind in the match-ups that matter. Plus, what happens if it all goes their way … SATURDAY Hawthorn v Port Adelaide Sydney v North Melbourne SUNDAY Geelong v St Kilda Collingwood v Fremantle Adelaide v Gold Coast A Hawthorn loss to Port Adelaide in Tasmania will keep the Dockers level on points with the Hawks, even better it will give the Dockers' four points of separation if they can knock off top-of-the-ladder Collingwood. With an Adelaide loss and their own win, the Dockers could jump up as high as third. James Sicily of the Hawks. Credit: Paul Kane / Getty Images THURSDAY Hawthorn v Carlton FRIDAY Essendon v Western Bulldogs GWS v Sydney SATURDAY Gold Coast v Brisbane Fremantle v West Coast North Melbourne v Geelong Adelaide v Port Adelaide SUNDAY Richmond v Collingwood If the Hawks keep losing, a spot in the eight is really there for the taking, while a Dogs loss would give the Dockers more insurance on their finals spot. The Giants are also a rival for the eight. The western derby could be a chance for Fremantle to boost their percentage, while a Showdown upset could keep them in the mix for the spots right up the top. Marcus Bontempelli. Credit: Michael Willson / AFL Photos THURSDAY Western Bulldogs v GWS FRIDAY Adelaide v Hawthorn SATURDAY Gold Coast v Richmond Collingwood v Brisbane SUNDAY Geelong v Port Adelaide Fremantle v Carlton If results go Fremantle's way, they could start to shake some teams by this stage, including Greater Western Sydney, Gold Coast, Adelaide and Hawthorn, while Collingwood and Brisbane will be within reach. Lachie Whitfield. Credit: Michael Willson / AFL Photos THURSDAY Hawthorn v Collingwood FRIDAY Geelong v Essendon SATURDAY Brisbane v Sydney Carlton v Gold Coast Port Adelaide v Fremantle SUNDAY GWS v North Melbourne Melbourne v Western Bulldogs West Coast v Adelaide As tough as it is to support West Coast, an Eagles win would force Adelaide well back into the pack. The Crows would fall three wins behind the Dockers and the Cats would go three wins back, while the Suns would slide too. Tyler Brockman of the Eagles celebrates a goal. Credit: Sarah Reed / AFL Photos FRIDAY Fremantle v Brisbane SATURDAY Gold Coast v GWS Hawthorn v Melbourne Adelaide v Collingwood The Dockers wouldn't mind a dent in the confidence of Hawthorn given they're a good chance to meet in September. They'd want the Suns to continue to slide and the Magpies to keep slipping up. Darcy Moore of the Magpies looks dejected. Credit: Chris Hyde / Getty Images North Melbourne v Adelaide Western Bulldogs v Fremantle Collingwood v Melbourne In this dream scenario, a final-round win would leave the Dockers on top of the ladder. In reality, this game is likely to be crucial to their finals hopes. One more loss for Adelaide and Collingwood would do them some favours too. In all likelihood, they would at this stage still be barracking for Hawthorn to be knocked off by Brisbane and an upset by St Kilda over the Giants. Max Heath of the Saints celebrates kicking his first AFL goal in his debut match. Credit: Kelly Defina/AFL Photos / via Getty Images
Perth Now
3 hours ago
- Perth Now
Ex-AFL umpire admits to horse sale while assets frozen
A former AFL umpire who sold a racehorse he owned and gave his former partner $10,000 cash has admitted he breached a court-imposed freeze on his assets. Troy Pannell had previously pleaded guilty to four charges brought by his former company SeaRoad Shipping, relating to payments he had made while working there. Justice Andrew Watson had issued an order on Pannell to prevent him and his company Independent Container Surveyors & Assessors disposing of any goods unless he had assets worth more than $8.7 million. If he sold any of his holdings, those sales must not bring his worth under the amount. Pannell, who was self-represented, on Friday pleaded guilty to two charges of contempt after he handed $10,000 cash to his then partner and sold a racehorse which were in breach of his asset restrictions. The former AFL umpire had initially contested the horse sale charge, claiming in the Melbourne Supreme Court he was not the horse's owner so the sale was not a breach of the order. The plaintiff laid out his evidence, referring to the affidavits of two witnesses, including Matthew Scown, the general manager of Yarraman Park, a thoroughbred racehorse breeding company, and former partner Maree Wilke. Mr Scown said his company had entered into an agreement with Pannell for his horse Aimee's Jewel in 2022. "The stallion service agreement records Mr Pannell as 100 per cent owner of mare Aimee's Jewel," Mr Scown's affidavit read. The company's general manager detailed all the correspondence with Pannell, including preparations for the horse in the lead up to the sale and when the funds were dispersed. "Mr Pannell is recorded as the owner of the filly in all records held by Yarraman ...Yarraman sold the filly on 2 March in accordance with Mr Pannell's authority and direction," Mr Scown said. In Ms Wilke's affidavit, she said she had expressed shock over a transfer form for the horse which bared her signature which she did not sign. "This is the first time that I've seen that document ... I told him I didn't sign it. He told me he signed it on my behalf," she said. "In response to me saying I was worried about being charged under the freezing order, (Pannell) told me I couldn't be charged because I owned the filly." After hearing the plaintiff's evidence, Justice Watson asked Pannell if he wanted to reconsider his position or wished to proceed with cross-examining the witnesses. "I think I'll retract and change after hearing all that," Pannell answered. "You want to plead guilty to fifth charge of contempt now?" the judge asked. "Yes I will, your honour," the accused responded. The experienced umpire, who has presided over more than 200 AFL games, attracted attention after he awarded 17 free kicks to the Western Bulldogs in a 2016 match against the Adelaide Crows. Pannell will return to the court on Tuesday to learn of his penalty.
