Parent says teacher attacked autistic son like angry bouncer kicking someone out of club
The mother of an autistic child assaulted by preschool worker Tanya Shortt has told how the teacher twisted her young son's arm behind his back and called him disgusting.
The distraught mother described the assault as looking like something an angry bouncer kicking someone out of a nightclub would do - rather than a preschool teacher. She is now calling for CCTV to be installed in all facilities for vulnerable kids.
The Sunday World revealed last week how Shortt (36), from Esmondale, Kilcullen Road, Naas, Co Kildare, was given two two-month suspended sentences at Blanchardstown District Court last month after pleading guilty to assaulting two children at Play and Language Support (PALS) preschool for autistic children in Finglas, Dublin in January 2023.
Shortt was caught after other staff members reported her worrying behaviour around children and alerted bosses, who reviewed CCTV, suspended her and contacted gardai.
We spoke to families last week who were devastated after learning about Shortt's violent behaviour.
Our story last week
More details have now emerged as other parents came forward this week to tell their stories.
The mother of a six-year-old boy assaulted by Shortt said she was shocked when she sat in court just metres from the former teacher as CCTV of the incident was played.
'It was very difficult. I was shocked by what I had seen on the camera. I wasn't the better of it at all,' she said.
'His nose was running and she was telling him he was disgusting. She grabbed his hand behind his back and brought him over to the sink. It was like he was being taken out of a pub. The child started bursting out crying.
'All she had to do was say would you go over here; she didn't even need to put her hands on the child.'
Another mother, who was also present in court to see the video, said: 'She completely twisted his arm and held it in that twisted position behind his back.'
Our reporter Alan Sherry confronts Tanya Shortt
The boy's mother said after Shortt assaulted him he no longer wanted to go to school, would hit himself and became overly cautious of new people he would meet.
She said Shortt took his 'innocence, his trust and happy spirit.'
She also told how he would mimic what Shortt did to him and would call his siblings 'disgusting' and try to restrain them.
The mum said her ability to trust services available to her children has been greatly impacted since the assault.
Tanya Shortt
News in 90 Seconds - May 19th
'I have refused respite services that I desperately need because I no longer believe my children are safe in the care of those employed to mind them,' she said.
She said, unlike PALS, the respite service did not have CCTV so she wasn't taking any chances.
'I hope for a change in the law in the future so that CCTV can be mandatory in all special needs schools and any place where there are vulnerable or non-verbal people being cared for.'
She said without CCTV, Shortt may have never been brought to justice.
'CCTV is absolutely fantastic because it's black and white and there's no hearsay and she's bang to rights. But you need a human to raise concerns and a human to look at the CCTV and a human to make the calls to the guards and that's what they done,' she said.
'PALS did completely the right thing.'
Another mother was shown CCTV of her daughter being pulled by one arm from a play pool but was later told the DPP decided not to prosecute over that incident.
She sat in court during the recent case and watched all of the CCTV of the various incidents.
She described other incidents, including pinching of children, and said Shortt always appeared to hide what she was doing from other staff.
'She was bending down leaning over some of the kids, like as if she was trying to help them, I suppose, but as she was leaning down she'd be pinching their arms. Everything was really sneaky so other staff couldn't see.'
She said in the incident where Shortt grabbed her daughter by one arm that once other staff turned around she grabbed her by two arms.
'You could see in the videos she was waiting for the right opportunity. It was very sly and she knew she shouldn't have been doing it.
'There were other people in the room but obviously when they're busy with other kids and turned their back for a second, that seemed to be when she did things.'
She said the CCTV only covered a short amount of time and parents fear there could have been other incidents.
'It was like only like a day or two before Christmas and there was a Christmas break and then there was like a day after so we got very, very little footage.'
Both mothers praised how PALS handled the situation.
The mother of the six-year-old said: 'They were as stressed as we were. They were very attached to my children.
'They've always been very kind. They have always been very good from my experience with them. There is nothing I can really fault them with.
'They could have said we're not going to pursue this we're a charity and rely on people's opinions and donations but instead they pursued it I think the school should be commended on it. They should be praised.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Former HR company boss Denyse O'Brien granted bail after being charged with 98 fraud offences
She set up Watch Your Back Ireland in 2019 The former owner of a human resources company has appeared in court charged with a total of 98 separate fraud offences. Denyse O'Brien (41) was remanded in custody with consent to bail when she appeared before Dublin District Court yesterday. She was charged with 18 counts of deception, 47 counts of using a false instrument and 33 counts of forgery following an investigation by the Garda National Economic Crime Bureau (GNECB). Three addresses were given for Ms O'Brien, in Tralee and Ballybunion in Co Kerry, and a hostel in Galway. She was arrested in Galway on Tuesday before her court appearance, at which evidence of arrest, charge and caution was given by GNECB detective David Comerford. Denyse O'Brien News in 90 Seconds - August 14th Gardaí objected to bail, but Ms O'Brien was granted it on condition that she provides a cash lodgment to the court of €400, along with other conditions. These include that she sign on three times a week at a garda station, be contactable by phone at all times, surrender her passport and keep away from witnesses. The case was adjourned to next Wednesday at Dublin District Court and is expected to be eventually sent forward to the Circuit Court, which has wider sentencing powers. Ms O'Brien set up HR company Watch Your Back Ireland in 2019, and many of the charges relate to her alleged activities with that firm. Some of the 98 charges she is facing include that under Section 26 of the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act 2001 she used a false email supposedly from an employee of the Workplace Relations Commission in August 2020 'with the intention of inducing another person to accept it as genuine'. She is also accused of using false emails purporting to be from a number of different organisations, including the Office of the Press Ombudsman on December 7, 2022; the Labour Court on two dates in August 2023; and the National Vetting Bureau of An Garda Síochana on August 21, 2022. She is further charged that on three occasions in December, 2022, she used a false email supposedly from an employee of the Courts Service, as well as twice in June 2022 and once in May of that year. Ms O'Brien also faces multiple charges under Section 26 of the Criminal Justice Act including that she dishonestly by deception induced a named woman to transfer €700 to her company, Watch Your Back Ireland, between March 1, 2020, and November 20, 2022. Other alleged deception charges relate to the transfer of sums to her from separate named individuals of amounts including €3,737, €1,600, €935, €720, €420, €310, €305 and €210. Among the other charges are that she used a false headed letter from a named firm of solicitors on two occasions in September, 2022, and another solicitors' firm in June 2022. It is also alleged that she used a false separation agreement on three occasions, in April, 2022; August, 2021; and June, 2023. Ms O'Brien is also charged with using a false document purporting to be from employers' group Ibec 'to induce another person to accept it as genuine and by reason of so accepting the said instrument to do some act, to the prejudice of that person or any other person'.
Sunday World
3 hours ago
- Sunday World
Jury fail to reach verdict in case of farmer charged with sexually assaulting girl (14)
The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was 72 at the time of the alleged assaults. A jury failed to reach a verdict after deliberating for three hours and two minutes in the trial of a 76-year-old Co Leitrim farmer accused of two counts of sexually assaulting a teenage girl in his home in 2021. The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was 72 at the time of the alleged assaults. He pleaded not guilty to two counts of sexually assaulting the teenage girl, aged 14 at the time, in both the kitchen and sitting room of his home in rural Co Leitrim on August 9th 2021. The trial began before Judge John Alymer at Carrick-on-Shannon Circuit Court with a jury of eight men and four women. Mr Edward Sweetman BL with Ms Niamh McGovern, State Solicitor, prosecuted, while Mr Colm Smyth SC, with Mr Eoin McGovern BL instructed by Mr Gerard McGovern, solicitor, appeared for the accused. Mr Sweetman outlined that the complainant was 14 at the time of the alleged assault and she was interviewed by specialist gardaí when she was fifteen. The trail took place at Carrick-on-Shannon courthouse News in 90 Seconds - August 14th The accused was a married man with children. The jury heard three days of evidence in the trial. Detective Garda Tom Tully of Carrick-on-Shannon Garda Station told the court he carried out a specialist interview with the alleged victim and a colleague of his, Gda Mary Tighe was present. The recorded interview took place on November 29 2021 and was played to the jury. She said the accused was 'being weird' and she said he winked at her. She said that around 1pm she was outside and the accused asked her to come up his house for tea. The complainant told gardaí she went in and sat down in the sitting room. The accused was leaning against the fire. She said he put his hand out and she could not remember what he said. She said she went to 'high five' his hand and said he pulled her up. He was hugging her and she could feel him grabbing her. She said she was trying to push him off. He was hugging and grabbing her and the accused asked if she was 'okay with this'. He said 'will you promise not to tell Mam.' She said his wife then rang at 1:26pm and she pretended to text her mother and told the accused her mother was texting and that she was up at their house. The girl said that when she was going out the door of the accused's house, he grabbed her again and said 'we'll finish this the next time'. She said the accused gave her and her brother a lift home as it was raining. She said she didn't want a lift and sat in the back seat. When asked by Dt Gda Tully about the hugging and grabbing, she said in the incident in the sitting room, he took her hand and pulled her up and pulled her in on top of him. She said she was like a statue and one of his hands was on her bum and another on her breast. She said he was not letting go. The complainant said she went home and phoned her friend. Her friend said to tell her mother and she said she wasn't going to. She said her friend made her tell her mother. She said her friend's mother typed a text message to the accused on the girl's phone which read, 'if you ever do what you did to me this morning I'll go to the guards'. In cross-examination, Mr Smyth asked the witness if she turned up the following morning (August 10) to babysit and she replied she had. She said the families were quite close. He put it to her that the accused was on a telephone call to his vet at 1:19pm that day in his farmyard. He said that there was a very tight short timeline for the accused to get to the house where the alleged assault was taking place, with his wife calling him at 1:26pm. Mr Smyth said that the man telephoned her father three times and that he was very upset and worried after receiving the text message. He rang three times and her father called him back the following day and the phonecall was recorded by her father. The accused denied anything happened 'in any shape or form'. Mr Smyth said that his client's recollection of their conversation in the house was that she enquired about a young man she was going out with at the time. The complainant said she didn't remember that conversation. When asked the alleged victim said she was 'frozen'. She said she would have walked past him but she couldn't move. He asked her about the text message that was sent to the accused at half two that day (August 9) asking her if she thought it was fairly threatening and she replied no. He said it did not seem to be coming from someone who was frozen and terrified and witness replied that it was after the alleged assault. He put it to her that the accused did not assault her in the timeline set out as he didn't have the time. 'Yes, he did, he did do it,' replied the alleged victim. The mother of the alleged victim gave evidence to the jury. She said she was on her lunchbreak from work and she met her daughter in their kitchen. She was visibly shaking and said she was not sure if she should tell her or not, but her friend said if she didn't, she would tell her. Her mother asked her what was wrong. She replied that she was after being groped by the accused. She said she was in shock and tried to ask her what happened. She said her daughter said the accused put his arms around her and tried to hold on and that he touched her. She said her daughter told her she was getting up to give the accused a high five and he pulled her towards her in a grope and held tight. One hand of his was one her bum and one was on her breast, she said. Her daughter said it lasted a minute or two and then the accused's phone rang and it was his wife. She said her daughter pretended to message her. When asked by Mr Sweetman what her reaction was, she replied that she 'nearly dropped'. She said she thought 'this is not happening to me'. She said she could remember her daughter shaking and said not to tell her father. The witness said she texted her husband to call her. The woman went back to work and dropped her daughter to her friend's house. When asked if they had any contact with the accused, she replied that her husband had a couple of missed calls and rang back the next day. The conversation with her husband and the accused was recorded and she was there. The accused said he got a serious text message and what were they going to do about it. He said absolutely nothing had happened. A short time after the phonecall, they met the accused as planned. The mother said that the accused had sexually assaulted her daughter. She said that none of them wanted to be there and everyone was very upset. She said the accused said to her to look into his eyes and said he never touched her. The woman said she replied she (daughter) is only 14 years of age and they had nothing to do but go to the gardaí. She said they didn't want to but they felt they had no choice. She said everyone was very upset including the accused. They then went to the garda station and the gardaí took their statements. When asked by Mr Sweetman how her daughter was after the alleged incident, she replied that she was very shaken up, very embarrassed and very traumatised. Mr Smyth said that after the meeting the accused went to complain to gardaí about the text message at 7pm that evening. Mr Sweetman in his closing speech to the jury said there was a conflict between whose idea it was to go up to the house for tea. He said the accused said it was the complainant's idea to have tea. Mr Sweetman said that something 'jars' in the reality of the human experience of a child inviting herself to tea. He said the complainant doesn't drink tea and said there was a 'conflict' in the evidence. He said that one question the jury had to consider was whether there was time for this to happen. He said the timeline was 'central'. He said the complainant said it happened in one or two minutes. He told the jury the other evidence they should give particular regard to is that the complainant almost immediately tells her mother, who said she was visibly upset. Mr Sweetman told the jury that nothing could remove the compelling account given by the complainant. He said they have to decide whether to accept the accused's account of what happened or if they are convinced by the complainant's beyond reasonable doubt. He asked them to convict on both allegations. Mr Smyth told the jury that their task was a very difficult one in that there were two people involved, the complainant who was on the brink of early life and the accused, a semi-retired farmer. He said he was a man that raised his family and had been married a long time. He had no previous convictions and had led a blameless life. He said a sexual assault case is very difficult as it is one word against another. He said the accused man was very worried and very concerned after receiving the text message and asked the jury if those are the actions of a man who committed a serious offence. He told the jury they had to decide whether it was a case that was proven beyond reasonable doubt. After deliberating for three hours and two minutes, the jury foreman told Judge Aylmer that they were deadlocked and could not reach an agreement on each count. Judge Aylmer thanked the jury and excused them from jury service for five years. The Director of Public Prosecutions will now decide if there is to be a re-trial in the matter..
Sunday World
20 hours ago
- Sunday World
Motorcyclist left in critical condition after serious crash in Co Down
The man has been taken to hospital for treatment after the two-vehicle crash. A motorcyclist is in critical condition following a serious two-vehicle crash in Co Down. Police and the Northern Ireland Ambulance Service responded to a report of a collision on Church Street in Newtownards involving a car and a motorcycle at around 10.25pm last night. 'The male motorcyclist was taken to hospital for treatment for injuries, and is described as being in a critical condition at this time,' Sergeant Pye said. Church Street in Newtownards. News in 90 Seconds - August 13th 'Enquiries are ongoing, and police would appeal to anyone who has any mobile phone or dash cam footage, or any information which may assist, to get in touch via 101, quoting reference number 1914 of 12/08/25.' Church Street was closed earlier today and police were advising road users to avoid the area. The road has now reopened to traffic.
