East Lothian flat owner loses appeal over 'professional' holiday lets
A Dunbar flat owner who claimed the majority of her guests were 'professional' and letting her property was good for the local economy has lost her appeal to carry on renting.
Leanne Montgomery appealed to Scottish Ministers after East Lothian Council refused to grant a change of use for her second floor flat on the High Street to a short term let.
She told them use of the holiday flat 'helped the economy', however the Scottish Government Reporter ruled its local impact was irrelevant.
And they said the flat owner had provided no evidence that it was mainly used by professionals, as had been claimed.
Dismissing the appeal, they said: " In assessing the appeal I am only able to consider whether or not the use as a short term holiday let represents a material change from the legitimate established use of the property as a flat.
"Any assessment which considers the merits of the use would need to take place through an application for planning permission."
East Lothian Council refused the application for a certificate of lawfulness, which would mean planning permission was not needed, to operate the holiday flat, because they said a shared stairwell with other residents in the block meant it was a material change of use.
And the Reporter agreed with their position saying the frequent arrival and departure of guests in the flat would impact on residents who used the same hallway.
They also dismissed claims that the majority of guests at the flat were 'professionals' who were there to work in the town.
They said: "The appellant contends that most visitors are professionals who visit the area to work a nine to five job for a the very short period of time they are in the area.
"I have been provided with no specific reasoning as to why the property would appeal to professionals in particular and I have been provided with no evidence to substantiate this claim.."
The Reporter ruled the impact of guests at the short term let was a material change of use and the council had been correct to reject the application for the certificate.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
13 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Mikaku: ‘End of an era' as Tokyo-inspired Glasgow restaurant to shut due to National Insurance rise
A 'much-loved' Scottish restaurant that brought a colourful and innovative experience of Japan is set to close in September. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... A Japanese bar and restaurant in Glasgow will close its doors for the final time next month, citing the 'strangling' National Insurance rise as a key reason. Mikaku, known for its immersive 'slice of Tokyo' experience, colourful interiors and innovative menu, will shut on Sunday, September 14. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Queen Street restaurant has been a staple of Glasgow's hospitality landscape since it opened in 2018. Over the years, it has built a loyal customer base and welcomed thousands of guests through its doors. The decision to close Mikaku comes as the team behind the venue shifts focus to their next chapter – the launch of Clydeside Containers, a new riverside street food and drink destination opening on Glasgow's waterfront. Restaurant director Nathan Sparling said: 'Closing Mikaku was not an easy decision. It has been a truly special place for both our team and our guests, and we are incredibly proud of what Mikaku has achieved. 'From celebrating Ramen Week with £1 bowls, to launching one of Glasgow's most innovative cocktail menus, to introducing a real Robata Grill to the city for the first time – Mikaku has been about bringing something bold, different and authentic to Queen Street, seven days a week. The memories created here, and the community that has grown around it, will always be a huge source of pride. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "But like so many venues in Glasgow and across the UK, we've faced the well-documented challenges in hospitality – from rising costs and staffing pressures, to shifts in consumer behaviour. Mikaku 'The recent rise in National Insurance contributions has added even more pressure, strangling independent operators like us at a time when the sector is still recovering. These wider challenges have been a significant factor in the decision to close, allowing us to refocus our efforts and resources on the exciting opportunity ahead at Clydeside Containers.' Mikaku will adjust its opening hours for the final weeks of service. From Wednesday, August 20, the restaurant will open Wednesday to Sunday, before moving to a Thursday to Sunday schedule from August 28 until the final day of service on September 14.
Edinburgh Live
13 minutes ago
- Edinburgh Live
East Lothian Council set to seek partners to help rebuild Brunton Theatre
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Cash-strapped East Lothian Council is set to seek potential partners to fund the redevelopment of the Brunton Theatre with the offer of using part of it as a commercial venture to recoup the costs. A new report on the future of the theatre building says the council does not have the cash to rebuild it on its own and needs to find an 'alternative funding model'. And it asks elected members to approve the launch of a Prior Information Notice (PIN) to potential contractors to give them an idea of market reaction. It says the PIN would set out the council's proposals for the redevelopment of the site to include theatre and performance space, adding the 'remaining part of the site can be redeveloped commercially to offset the cost of providing a theatre and performance space, subject to obtaining necessary consents.' The local authority has been consulting on the future of the Brunton Hall, in Musselburgh, since formally closing its doors last October. The theatre was initially shut over two years ago after the discovery of reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RAAC) in the building but some offices remained in use and the debate over its future continued for several months. At the time of its closure, it was estimated the cost of refurbishment and RAAC remediation was £42.912 million with the cost to demolish and build a new facility estimated to be £50.742 million. A new report to councillors next week reveals there is overwhelming support for retaining an arts venue in Musselburgh with 98.2% of people who responded to an online consultation backing it and an estimated 5,500 people signing a petition to save it. It also reveals Historic Environment Scotland have launched a consultation on whether the building should be listed as a building of special architectural or historic interest. It adds: 'There is strong public support for the continued provision of the arts in Musselburgh. However, repairing the existing Brunton Hall is financially unviable. 'A replacement is necessary, but the council's capital plan is fully committed to statutory obligations and growth-related pressures. Delivering a new facility will require an alternative funding model, potentially involving commercial finance, government support, grant funding, or a combination thereof.' PINs are issued via Public Contracts Scotland and are public notices used to signal to the wider market that the buyer has a specific upcoming commercial need that will require support from one or more suppliers. The report urges councillors to support issuing the PIN and setting up a project team to oversee the work going forward. It says: 'Given the scale of this project, it will be necessary to set up a project development team. The project team will consist of professional officers from a range of council services and will be chaired by the Head of Infrastructure. It will oversee further development of the replacement theatre and will provide governance to the project. It will report to the council's management team on a regular basis. It will also keep members informed on a regular basis.' The report will be discussed at a full meeting of the council next week.
South Wales Argus
33 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Waitrose apologises as product recalled due to 'health risk'
The supermarket chain has recalled its Waitrose & Partners Creamy Pesto Chicken Pasta from shelves in its Scottish and Welsh stores. The pasta poses a 'possible health risk' to some customers as it contains mustard which is not mentioned on the label. The affected pasta has a use by date of August 27, 2025 and comes in packs of 375g. A spokesman for the Food Standards Agency (FSA) said: 'Waitrose is recalling the above product from customers and has been advised to contact the relevant allergy support organisations, which will tell their members about the recall. 'The company has also issued a point-of-sale notice to its customers. 'These notices explain to customers why the product is being recalled and tell them what to do if they have bought the product. 'If you have bought the above product and have an allergy to mustard, do not eat it. Instead return it to your local Waitrose & Partners branch for a refund. 'You can contact Waitrose Customer Care on 0800 188 884, Option 4.' A Waitrose spokesman added: 'We apologise that it has been necessary to recall this product and for the inconvenience caused.' Recommended Reading: What is a product recall? If there is a problem with a food product that means it should not be sold, then it might be 'withdrawn' (taken off the shelves) or 'recalled' (when customers are asked to return the product). The FSA issues Product Withdrawal Information Notices and Product Recall Information Notices to let consumers and local authorities know about problems associated with food. In some cases, a 'Food Alert for Action' is issued. This provides local authorities with details of specific actions to be taken on behalf of consumers.
