Auditor-General report exposes depth of local government decay that sunk the ANC
A sharp critique of the ANC's municipal governance failures highlights how local service delivery crises contributed to the party's electoral decline in South Africa's 2024 general election.
Image: IOL Graphic
If anyone is still puzzled about why the ANC slipped to just 40% of the national vote at last year's national general elections for the first time in democratic South Africa, they have not been paying attention to the state of the country's municipalities.
The ANC did not lose votes because of a sudden surge in opposition support but because South Africans are gatvol
They are gatvol because the of broken street lights, the taps run dry, the potholes on the roads are a nightmare and the rubbish is not collected.
And this is where the ANC has failed dismally.
The Auditor-General's latest consolidated report on local government outcomes reads like a post-mortem of the ANC's electoral performance.
It exposes, in stark numbers, just how deep the crisis of service delivery runs at municipal level, where the ANC governs the majority of councils and metros.
In the 2023–24 financial year, 87% of municipalities failed to comply with procurement and contract management laws. In 63% of cases, these failures were severe enough to materially affect finances. Additionally, 77% of infrastructure projects inspected had serious deficiencies - meaning the roads, clinics, waterworks and housing projects ordinary people are promised are either not being built, or when they are, they are substandard and unfinished.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
It gets worse. Fifty-three percent of municipalities flouted laws around consequence management, which means that when officials mismanage funds, they are not fired, prosecuted or even formally disciplined. The result? Repeat offenders and serial incompetents, often politically connected, remain in office while communities suffer.
This is the height of bad governance.
The ANC's fatal miscalculation has been to believe that local government failures would not tarnish the party's national brand. But ask any voter in Joburg, Tshwane, Mangaung or the collapsing municipalities of the North West and Eastern Cape whether they make that distinction. They do not. When sewage runs down your street, you blame the government and in most towns, the ANC is the government.
The bread-and-butter issues of water, electricity, refuse collection and functioning infrastructure are the foundation of political credibility. The ANC's neglect of these basics, detailed year after year by the Auditor-General, has eroded public confidence to breaking point.
Since 2019, 446 material irregularities have been flagged at municipal level, including billions in lost or wasted funds. And while half have been resolved, it is too little, too late. The cumulative effect of that neglect is what finally showed up at the ballot box in 2024, where for the first time since 1994, the ANC fell below 50%, finishing with a bruising 40%.
The collapse of municipalities is not some side issue in national politics. It is where elections are won and lost. The ANC did not lose votes because South Africans suddenly were drawn to what opposition parties were offering, they voted out of frustration and many cases simply stayed at home - effectively denying the ANC their vote.
Because when water stops running, when clinics fall apart and when corruption flourishes unchecked at the local level, it affects people's lives more immediately than anything debated in Parliament.
The ANC's hollowing out of municipal governance - replacing skilled officials with politically connected but underqualified cadres - is at the heart of this crisis. It created a system where the consequences of failure were shrugged off until communities pushed back the only way they could - at the ballot box.
If the ANC is serious about rebuilding trust, they need to start with fixing municipalities, professionalising local government and finally holding those responsible for years of mismanagement accountable. Because no party can govern a country if it cannot manage a town.
South Africans voted against sewage in their streets, against empty promises, against councillors who disappear after elections, and against roads that turn to dust while tenders line the pockets of the politically connected.
The ANC dropped to 40% because it failed where it matters most - on the streets, in the suburbs and in the townships of this country.
And if it does not fix that, it will keep falling.
**Lee Rondganger is the deputy editor of IOL
IOL Opinion
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
The fatal failure of SA's political opposition
While the creation of our first national coalition government was supposed to be a major change in government, it has also led to major changes in the opposition benches. Despite the fact that the coalition has failed to improve the lives of most South Africans, parties that oppose it have failed to make much headway. South Africa's 2024 elections led to the biggest changes in the opposition benches. The Democratic Alliance (DA), which had become very effective in opposition, was suddenly in government (and taking many of its oppositional habits into the Union Buildings). advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads A party (MK) which had never been represented in Parliament before was suddenly the Official Opposition. And was led by someone who himself had never been an MP. The previous time John Hlophe had been mentioned in the National Assembly was the day he became the first judge to be impeached in the democratic era. The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), used to being able to make noise as the third-biggest party, found itself in a reduced role, even though its greater parliamentary experience has made it more effective than the uMkhonto Wesizwe (MK) party. And there are several smaller parties who have both tried to be oppositional to the coalition, and flirted with joining it. It is perhaps the greatest indictment of our opposition parties that despite the fact the coalition has delivered GDP growth of just 0.1%, they cannot craft an effective message. A major part of this has been the divided nature of the MK party. Considering President Jacob Zuma's history of a lust for personal power and for wrecking institutions, this was always going to be the case. The revolving door of people in the position of secretary-general has surely created massive instability. It was also entirely predictable that the trio of Zuma, Hlophe and Floyd Shivambu was going to be about as stable as the Trump-Musk relationship. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads Zuma also had very few people to choose from. The fact he had to appoint someone like Mzwanele Manyi to the position of Chief Whip and then demote him is proof of that. Probably only one other individual has said more and contributed less to our politics than he. Meanwhile, Hlophe has appeared to battle with the transition from being a judge, where your instructions are simply obeyed, to leading a parliamentary caucus, where people must be persuaded. He has also not been able to deliver a single speech in Parliament that has captured the public imagination. For the Leader of the Opposition, a constitutionally mandated position, this is a massive failure. Parliamentary speeches are a massive platform for the opposition and the leader of that party should be able to use it effectively. However, as has been said many times, MK's real problem is that there is no internal democracy and thus no durable legitimate structures. It is unlikely that this will change and thus unlikely that it will become a more effective opposition. The EFF has shown itself to be more effective than MK, partly because its members have more parliamentary experience and partly because its leader, Julius Malema, is prepared to be in Parliament and thus use its platform (unlike Zuma). advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads That said, it still appears as if the EFF has not yet got over the shock of being relegated to the position of fourth-largest political party. Certainly, Malema appears to be unable to grab the political agenda in a way he did, say, five years ago. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads Even though videos featuring him were shown during President Cyril Ramaphosa's Oval Office meeting with President Donald Trump, he was unable to really insert himself into that story. It may be that Malema's previous focus, on attacking first Zuma and then Ramaphosa so personally, has turned into a strategic weakness. Ramaphosa is not as powerful as he was and, while he may symbolise the coalition government, Malema has been unable to turn him into a hate figure. Crucially, Malema announced at the start of this Parliament that he would no longer disrupt proceedings as he had in the past. So far, he has not been able to come up with a new tactic, or a new line of attack that has really given him traction. One of the more intriguing dynamics of this period has been the role of some of the smaller parties that are not formally in the government coalition. ActionSA has found itself in a position where it can at times support the coalition or the ANC, and then oppose it. In the hours after ActionSA took the decision to vote with the ANC to support the fiscal framework of Budget 2.0, the party's Athol Trollip was incredibly honest when asked if ActionSA would now join the coalition. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads He summed up the situation for the party when he said: 'If the DA leaves the GNU [Government of National Unity], whether they get kicked out or they decide to leave, the opposition space is going to get crowded and we will have to take a strategic decision. Will we still make an impact in opposition, or must we look at perhaps going into government? But that depends on the GNU, whether they want us there or not. We will wait and see, but we will make a strategic decision where we can make the greatest impact.' advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads This revealed the options the party was dealing with in essence. But it also meant that when the ANC and the DA found each for Budget 3.0, ActionSA had to be content in the opposition benches, despite the fact voters would have known it considered joining the ANC. Build One South Africa, meanwhile, has appeared to struggle to gain traction with a consistent message. Its leader, Mmusi Maimane, has made regular media appearances and often provided principled opposition to government proposals. But it is hard to know if they have been able to really change government policy or win more votes. So far, it seems the coalition government has completely failed to make a difference to the lives of most people. Parties in opposition have failed too; they have not yet provided a credible alternative for voters. DM advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Helen Zille eyes Joburg mayorship after DA's top picks decline post
Zille told Daily Maverick that she would decide whether to apply to run for Johannesburg mayor by next week, as candidates who want to be considered have an application deadline of 15 June. DA federal chair Helen Zille is seriously considering a dramatic return to frontline politics as Johannesburg mayor. This comes after three high-profile candidates, most from business, turned down the party's approach to throw their hats into the ring to lead the party's Johannesburg campaign. The job was too hard-charging and the pay too low – mayors earn about R1.5-million a year. The local government election will happen in either late 2026 or early 2027. Zille told Daily Maverick that she would decide whether to apply by next week, as candidates who want to be considered have an application deadline of 15 June. 'My whole family is in Cape Town,' she said, adding that her greatest joy now is seeing her grandchildren regularly and that they had a weekly adventure date. 'My husband (retired sociologist Professor Johann Maree) has always been unbelievably supportive. He supports what I decide, but won't come (to Johannesburg).' She said Maree, now 82, was happily settled in their retirement village and that if she decided to run and were successful, they would remain in touch daily. Her sons Paul and Thomas live nearby. 'My family says it's my decision.' A close associate said Zille had been troubled by the state of Johannesburg since about 2019, when she realised that most traffic lights did not work. Since last year's election, she has spent much time in Gauteng planning the party's local government campaign here and had a front-row seat to what distresses the City of Gold and its six million people. Her sister lives in Emmarentia, an old near-northern suburb often with no water or electricity due to the city's regular outages. She said that should she run, she would live with her sister in her cottage. A mayoral candidate must be a resident of the city. Several DA councillors plan to contest the party primary. They must submit a formal application, undergo a screening test and prepare a presentation on their plan for the city. This presentation is made to a group of 15 party leaders, five each from the Johannesburg, provincial, and federal executives. They are also asked unscripted questions. Asked if a race would be moot should she decide to run, Zille said, ' Not at all.' She said formidable candidates were running. A senior official who spoke off the record said Johannesburg is 'so far gone' that the party felt it needed a high-velocity candidate, as the DA has a strong chance of winning the city. An ANC-led coalition holds a slim majority in the city with the EFF, Patriotic Alliance and Action SA. Johannesburg has been under soft intervention by the Presidency since March. Its collapse has become visceral with multiday power and water outages so regular they barely make the news. Thousands of traffic lights are out at any time and potholes are so large they have become dongas and memes. Zille previously told Daily Maverick that it would take about five years to turn the city around, but she says that was an undercount. 'It will take more than five years (now) to stop the rot and turn the tide.' She noted Johannesburg had an infrastructure backlog of R200-billion and an annual budget of R86-billion. She said the city's staff complement had grown by 86% since 2010. Asked what Zille had going for her for the task, the official said she had turned Cape Town around as urban blight slowly settled in around 2006, when she became that city's mayor. Recently, she headed the party's governance unit, which worked with councillors and representatives when they entered government. Mostly, he said, whether they liked her or not, Zille enjoyed trust in her ability to govern. This graphic shows the job description that the DA set for candidates. DM Slice of political life (part satire) The Zillenator – the coalition queen sets her sights on Joburg – here's what to expect By Marianne Thamm (Trigger warning: dead sheep and stunned mice) News that former Cape Town Metro executive mayor, Democratic Alliance leader and the party's current Fedex chair since 2019, Helen Zille, is about to 'throw her hat in the ring' to lead Joburg comes as no surprise. The Afrikaans Sunday platform, Rapport, let the Zille out of the bag at the weekend, breaking the news that the veteran politician had been 'approached to run'. It was Zille in the mid-2000s who held together a fragile and fractious six-party coalition of minor parties as executive mayor of Cape Town while her government faced a hostile ANC which, in opposition, unleashed death by legal challenge. With a background in provincial and national legislatures, Zille also came with made-in-Germany batteries that seemed to be self-charging, as she warded off each challenge, going on to win award after award. Soon she was Queen of the Western Cape, like it or not. Dragging and roasting Anyone who is hoping to run against Zille, in this, the next hill in the comrades marathon that has been her political career, must arm themselves with her tactics and novel approach to bouncing back. This includes the recent Showmax special, Calamitous Caucus of Clowns – The Roast of Helen Zille, during which everyone on stage appeared to be straightjacketed by a script which sucked all spontaneity out of the room. But worth a watch, anyhow. Earlier in the year, Zille made an appearance as Zille Von Teez in full drag on the Tollie en Manila Show, also on Showmax. Zille might and could very well just stay in drag and go out and campaign… she's that good, say those in the know. Zille on the campaign trail, even in her sixties and now at 74, knows exactly what works for which constituency, including which soundtrack to play while choreographing her own dance moves. Zille can probably do a Zulu warrior kick while posting on social media and reach higher than PJ Powers. The three previous occasions that Zille offered to 'throw her hat in the ring', she won. First to lead the Cape Metro (2006-2009) as executive mayor, then the DA itself (2007-2015) while simultaneously being elected as premier of the Western Cape (2009-2019). This is an indication of Zille's unwaning political stamina and clout, whatever your views of her ways und means. They're eating the sheep In 2016, Zille published her autobiography, Not Without A Fight (say it out loud in your head in her voice), weighing in at a hefty 700 or so pages. There she documents her impressive, life-long activism in townships in and around Cape Town, where she has survived being shot at, shouted at, being arrested… the usual. Seen it all. At about this time, Zille writes: 'I should stress that my constituency work involved much more than regular visits to police stations and courts (and dodging the occasional bullet)'. She recalls that 'I was also called on to provide ambulance services from time to time, sometimes in the dead of night. At times, I transported some interesting passengers… 'Every time we had a branch launch, we would buy a live sheep, which I would fetch in my car. 'The animal would sit meekly in the back, looking out of the window as if it was enjoying the view. It gave me an insight into the English idiom that compares a calm, unwitting walk into disaster with 'a lamb being led to the slaughter'.' Zille says that during the drive, she would bond with each sheep and 'felt deeply guilty every time I dropped it off at the party venue'. Say what? You didn't stay for the tjoppies? The mouse and other tails For some time now, I have been wandering on and off stages across the country, in restaurants, bars and festivals with a piece of 'performance journalism' titled, Round of Applause – South Africa Still Standing. I have turned into a bit of roving, three-dimensional, human newspaper, a town crier of sorts, celebrating SA's victory over State Capture and the role of the media, judiciary, whistle-blowers and others while catching up with the latest news. Zille has, since 2023, when I first followed this calling, grown into a fulcrum around which some of the funniest moments of the show revolve. One of the other centrepieces (and this is a retelling audiences have demanded not be shelved, as of yet) is an incident with a mouse that I witnessed with my own Putin-blue eyes while Zille was touring Julius Malema's hood, Seshego, in Limpopo in 2011. I will not let the mouse out of the bellbottom here (so to speak), but let's just say the incident is indicative of the stamina and discipline of Helen Zille when she is on a mission. The Government of National Unity was pulled together during a 10-minute comfort break, requested by Floyd Shivambu (still then dressed in red) while new MPs were being sworn in after the 2024 elections, enabling Zille and the ANC (and others) to sign a Memorandum of Agreement that had been left hanging. And voila, we have our Republiek van Alle Kante with Baie Kante in Die Parliament. Since the rugby incident, I take it no translation is required. Of the future political horizon in Joburg, where Zille has set her sights, all we can say is beware of the politician in drag who comes bearing sheep. DM
The South African
7 hours ago
- The South African
Luxury travel buddy: Who is Paul Mashatile's wife?
Paul Mashatile has been condemned by parliament for spending millions on luxury travel alongside his wife, Humile. The deputy president and the Second Lady – who have a 24-year age gap – wed in 2023 after both their partners died in 2020. Over the past few days, Deputy President Paul Mashatile has been grilled over his five-star luxury travel he made with his wife Humile on unofficial trips, at the expense of the taxpayer. In a recent parliament sitting, it was revealed that Paul spent over R2 million on a six-night stay in London last year. Earlier this year, he travelled to Japan, where he splurged almost R1 million on a four-night stay with his wife. Since being sworn in last July, Paul has spent almost R8 million on four international trips. Paul Mashatile's younger, attractive wife is no stranger to the spotlight. Humile was first married to former ANC Western Cape secretary Songezo Mjongile, who died in 2020 after a battle with colon cancer. At the time, Paul was the treasurer of the ANC. Paul's first wife, Manzi Ellen Mashatile, died in July 2020 after contracting COVID-19. Paul has four children with his late wife, while Humile has two from her marriage to Songezo. The couple's nuptials occurred just days after Paul was sworn in as SA's new deputy president. Paul Mashatile and his wife Humile Mjongile. Images via X: @pmashatile/ RODGER BOSCH, AFP According to her Instagram account, the second lady is a philanthropist who recently launched her own charity, the Humile Mashatile Foundation. Her areas of interest are autism, HIV/ Aids treatment in young children, and holistic healing. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 . Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp , Facebook , X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
