National Prosecuting Authority preparing to reinstate charges against Nulane accused
State capture: Ajay Gupta, Atul and Rajesh. (Adrian de Kock/Netwerk24)
The
'We are tirelessly working towards that,' said NPA spokesperson Mthunzi Mhaga
.
On Thursday, the NPA prevailed in the supreme court of appeal (SCA), which found that Judge
It said what transpired in the high court could only be summed up as a 'failure of justice'.
The SCA ruling came almost two years after Gusha
That decision meant that none of them had to take the stand to answer the case put forth by the state.
Gusha found that the prosecution had 'regrettably failed to pass even the barest of thresholds' in proving that the accused colluded to defraud the Free State government and ensure some R24 million was funnelled to a United Arab Emirates (UAE) Standard Chartered Bank account linked to the Gupta family.
Gupta associate Iqbal Sharma was arrested in 2021, nearly a decade after Free State officials deviated from public finance rules to awarded a contract worth R24.9 million for a feasibility study to his newly-founded Nulane Investments.
It pinpointed Paras, an Indian firm linked to the Guptas, as the preferred entity to a dairy project in Vrede in the Free State. This would later become the Estina dairy farm scam in which more than R280 million allegedly flowed to the Gupta family.
But Gusha, an acting judge, found that the prosecution was unable to prove that provincial officials broke the law when they gave the contract to Nulane.
It meant that the case collapsed at the first hurdle, because without proof that the money was stolen, the state could not sustain the charge of money-laundering in relation to the rapid-fire transfers that followed to companies in the Gupta stable.
The SCA agreed with the state that Gusha made a litany of errors in law and fact, resulting in a failure of justice. She had been obliged to consider the totality of evidence, and had failed to do so.
'The inference is inescapable — and the judgment itself shows — that the judge had closed her mind to the evidence adduced by the state.
'This is unfortunate, particularly in a case such as this, where it was prima facie established that scarce public funds were unlawfully extracted from the department and channelled to the UAE, by fraud and the misuse of power.'
Hence, the appellate court said, the acquittal of the accused was unfair to the prosecution.
The prosecution had relied on the doctrine of common purpose to prove that all accused were part of a conspiracy to defraud the government, as were Atul and Rajesh Gupta.
It had planned to add them to the list of accused if they were surrendered to South Africa.
The SCA said there was evidence that three Free State officials worked together to ensure Nulane was appointed and paid and, further, that fraud and money-laudering was committed with the cooperation of the rest of the accused, among them Ronica Ragavan, the director of the Gupta family's Islandsite Investment.
That was one of the companies in the family's business empire through which the state allegedly the money extracted from the Free State was laundered with 'bewildering rapidity'.
There was a real likelihood, the SCA said, that the accused would have incriminated each other, had they been put on the stand.
'The high court misapplied s174 of the CPA [Criminal Prosecution Act]: a court should not discharge an accused who might be incriminated by a co-accused. This was unfair to the state,' the court said.
'The trial in the high court can be summed up in a single sentence: This was a failure of justice.'
It added that regrettably this undermined public confidence in the criminal justice system.
The SCA ruling provided some comfort for the NPA a week after the Bloemfontein high court ruled that it did not have jurisdiction to try Ace Magashule's former assistant, Moroadi Cholota, for her role in the R225 million Free State asbestos scam case.
The court found that her extradition from the United States was unlawful as the NPA had failed to challenge an SCA ruling that only the minister of justice, and not the prosecuting authority, had the power to apply for extradition, in due time.
The NPA is seeking to overturn this ruling as well.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
5 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
We need to rebuild the idea of the public
The struggle against white rule in South Africa was always grounded in a shared conviction — across organisations, ideologies and forms of struggle — that the country to come would not only end white supremacy, but would also be fundamentally just. The declarations of the Freedom Charter are seldom recalled today but this confidence is powerfully expressed in a still famous remark by Steve Biko: 'In time, we shall be in a position to bestow on South Africa the greatest possible gift — a more human face.' For many years after apartheid it was widely thought that, although we faced many serious problems, time was on the side of progress and justice. Jacob Zuma's cynical, violent, lying kleptocracy put an end to that and we have not been able to recover it. Impoverishment and inequality are worsening. More than 40% of people are without work — with over 60% of young people affected. It has been years since we last had any meaningful economic growth. Rural land reform has not been a success. The struggle for urban land is frequently met with criminalisation and violence. More than a fifth of our people do not have enough food. Almost 30% of children under five suffer from stunted growth. More than 11 000 children die of malnutrition each year. Public institutions — from schools to hospitals — and essential infrastructure like the rail network are in a dire state. Many municipalities have collapsed, and we endure one of the highest murder rates in the world. Extortion is endemic. People are desperate and in KwaZulu-Natal there is enthusiastic public support for the now regular executions by the police. While the capture of the state for private gain is no longer centrally directed, it continues — and in many cases worsens — through shifting, decentralised networks, some of which are well described as mafias. There is a systemic intersection of politics and criminality, and it is this, not ideology, that drives most political assassinations. Many of our laws and policies are an expression, even if modest, of an aspiration for a more just society. But while laws and policies matter, the decisive factor in whether we are able to move forward will be political will. If the right forms of political will are not developed, organised and mobilised — if democracy does not make significant progress in resolving our crisis — there is a significant risk that the crisis will further corrode or even explode democracy. As the legitimacy of the current order declines, there is, as is happening across much of the world, an active attempt to scapegoat migrants for the crisis. This process is accelerated by the now-endemic fake news on social media. This turn to a politics of cruelty cannot offer anything but the pleasures of public sadism as compensation for social suffering. It is also a politics of deflection that pulls attention away from the real issues we confront. Xenophobia builds a toxic sense of the nation as determined by exclusion rather than a positive aspiration. This is a problem wherever xenophobia is incited and exploited, but in South Africa — where the nation was forged in struggle against oppression — it means xenophobia is often entangled with some of the language and sentiment of the idea of national liberation, an idea with deep legitimacy. The same is often true of the now systemic and deeply embedded forms of predation on the state. Because they enable accumulation by previously oppressed and excluded people, they are often experienced and presented as a continuation of the national liberation struggle. This means that competing ideas of how we understand that struggle are themselves a key site of struggle. There is a reason Frantz Fanon — and many great thinkers in the movement of African emancipation, such as Amílcar Cabral and Ngugi wa Thiong'o among others — insisted on the need to confront predatory national elites as well as colonialism and imperialism. Fanon's observation that 'the sole motto of the bourgeoisie is 'Replace the foreigner'' and that this is taken up by 'the 'small people' of the nation' as xenophobia speaks directly to the limits of some forms of elite politics today. But along with these attempts to turn the idea of national liberation into what Fanon calls chauvinism, we also face an increasingly strident, and often white-led, demand to put an end to the idea of national liberation. This often includes a demand for the standard set of neoliberal measures — privatisation, austerity, commodification, undoing labour rights, doing away with racial redress and all the rest. The primary desire is to more fully subordinate society to the market. Building a viable political project against these contesting elites requires more than just developing a popular project. Gayton McKenzie, Zuma, Herman Mashaba and others are trying to build populist forms of often hard-right authoritarianism. Challenging the capture of the idea of national liberation by predatory elites and the attempts to consign national liberation — and all ideas of collective emancipation — to history by rival elites requires, among other things, a strong and inclusive commitment to the idea of the public and the public good. To recover a sense of shared future and rebuild trust in democratic life, we need to place the idea of the public at the centre of our political imagination. While bureaucratic and technical systems are important, the fundamental task is to build a moral and political vision of shared life, of dignity, solidarity and social rights. State services and institutions with a social function, such as health and education, can only be nurtured and defended if they are embedded in a shared sense of purpose. To recover a robust idea of the public — and thereby public services and institutions — we need to understand it as both virtue and entitlement. As entitlement, it means that everyone has the right to housing, clean water, good schools, healthcare, transport and public space. As virtue, the idea of the public demands a culture of stewardship, care and responsibility. We need to aspire to what the American activist and intellectual Ruth Wilson Gilmore calls 'life-affirming institutions', an infrastructure that prioritises care, enables flourishing and anchors people in the collective affirmation of dignity. Ultimately this requires a sense of politics as the creation of a shared world, a world where public services and institutions are not crumbling, corrupt or humiliating, but sources of shared belonging and dignity. Public money has to be understood as public wealth. Theft from public wealth has to be understood as theft from the people. Public institutions have to be understood as critical parts of the infrastructure of freedom. These kinds of ideals are never fully achieved, but in many societies political projects have been built that have enabled gains towards affirming an idea of the public and translating it into institutions that support its realisation. This includes countries in the Global South that have built impressive healthcare systems, public transport, education and more. In the early 2000s the Treatment Action Campaign made hugely important progress in building an idea of public healthcare, and then realising huge gains in the health system. Over the past 20 years Abahlali baseMjondolo, a very different kind of organisation, has made significant gains in challenging exclusionary forms of urbanism. None of the contenders for influence in the intra-elite battles over the future of our society has any meaningful interest in building a democratic and strong sense of the public. If we are to make progress towards this, we will require a lot more of the patient labour of organising and building progressive ideas and power from below. Richard Pithouse is distinguished research fellow at the Global Centre for Advanced Studies, an international research scholar at the University of Connecticut and professor at large at the University of the Western Cape.
The Herald
7 hours ago
- The Herald
Death toll in Eastern Cape floods rises to 86
The death toll in the Eastern Cape floods has risen to 86 with more than 1,000 people displaced. Police minister Senzo Mchunu confirmed the number after he and national police commissioner Gen Fannie Masemola met police officials from the Mthatha area on Saturday. Mchunu commended police for their ongoing efforts as search and rescue efforts and mop-up operations continue in the flood-ravaged province which suffered billions of rand damage to infrastructure. 'Please continue to assist where you are called on as this makes it appear to people that government is lending a hand in their hour of need. Let's ignore the comments that the district municipality opened the sluice gates leading to the disaster.' OR Tambo district municipal officials denied allegations the municipality recklessly opened the sluice gates of the Mthatha Dam, causing flooding and deaths along the Mthatha River. The claims, circulating on social media, suggested the municipality's actions worsened the damage caused by heavy rainfall. However, the municipality has dismissed these claims as mischievous and dangerous misinformation. OR Tambo mayor Mesuli Ngqondwana said: 'In times such as these, misinformation fuels panic, confuses communities and undermines the real work being done to protect and support our people.' Ngqondwana described the allegations as an improbable theory, highlighting the widespread devastation in the district. 'The municipality is working to reinforce water delivery trucks to support affected communities, with a need for more trucks to meet the demand.' This comes after President Cyril Ramaphosa, national ministers and provincial government officials led by Eastern Cape premier Oscar Mabuyane visited affected areas, including the worst-hit village in Mthatha, Dicolyn, on Friday. H e addressed about 100 displaced residents at the Sinolwazi Senior Secondary School. 'We are not used to losing so many people at one time, that is why I came to see for myself what happened,' Ramaphosa said. He said he had received an extensive briefing from Mabuyane, and praised the response from the three spheres of government in helping the victims and searching for those who were still missing. 'That to me demonstrates the capability of our government in responding to disasters like this. 'As the premier says, it could have been much worse than this. 'Obviously, we are disturbed that so many people passed away but it could have been much worse. He said a day of mourning is being considered to remember those who lost their lives in the catastrophic event It's unclear how many people are still missing. TimesLIVE
The Herald
7 hours ago
- The Herald
Ramaphosa expresses heartbreak during Mthatha visit but satisfaction with disaster response
Ramaphosa also reacted with shock to the story of a young woman, Ongezwa Ntlabathi, who lost her three young boys and her mother in the tragedy. Her mother and eldest son's bodies have not yet been recovered. The young mother is based in Polokwane and had to rush back home after hearing the devastating news. 'So many of you are in a similar situation. We feel your pain. 'It is deeply saddening to lose your child or your parent. 'We are not used to losing so many people at one time, that is why I came to see for myself what happened,' Ramaphosa said. He said he had received an extensive briefing from premier Oscar Mabuyane and praised the response from the three spheres of government in helping the victims and searching for those who were still missing. 'That to me demonstrates the capability of our government in responding to disasters like this. 'As the premier says, it could have been much worse than this. 'Obviously, we are disturbed that so many people passed away but it could have been much worse. 'The response teams acted quickly and I've also heard good reports about how the [state] mortuary forensic team has acted quickly to do autopsies to ensure [victims'] loved ones are able to receive their remains.' Daily Dispatch
