logo
Appellate tribunal cuts Fema violation penalty slapped by ED on PwC from ₹230cr to ₹81cr

Appellate tribunal cuts Fema violation penalty slapped by ED on PwC from ₹230cr to ₹81cr

Time of India3 days ago
PwC
NEW DELHI: An appellate tribunal here has imposed a Rs 81 crore penalty on PwC, reducing it from the Rs 230 crore slapped by
Enforcement Directorate
(ED) on the audit firm in a case of violation of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (Fema).
PwC has been accused of receiving Rs 230 crore FDIs in violation of Fema rules as audit firms cannot receive foreign direct investment (FDI), according to ED. The case was initiated by ED on information that PwC had received FDI running in crores in the name of grant.
"The company is engaged in audit practice which does not permit receipt of the FDI," the ED had argued and which was upheld by the tribunal on Safema (Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators (Forfeiture of Property) Act, 1976).
The transactions were carried by PwC without the approval of the RBI, violating Fema rules, it had said.
The bench of the tribunal - headed by Justice Munishwar Nath Bhandari - in an order of July 9 accepted the investigation of ED but reduced substantially the penalty amount on the company, a former chairman and other officials.
In a show cause notice issued on Sept 11, 2019, ED had imposed a penalty of Rs 230 crore on PwC, Rs 23 lakh on former chairman Deepak Kapoor, Rs 11 lakh on Shyamal Mukherjee, the then chairman of PwC, as well as Rs 5 lakh on Ramesh Rajan, also a former chairman.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
15 most beautiful women in the world
Topgentlemen.com
Undo
"We find the penalty to be excessive and disproportionate to the allegations against the appellant (PwC). The appellant has received grants under licence and accordingly inward remittance, though it is in contravention of the (Fema) Act and Regulations made therein. Taking the overall view, we reduce the penalty from Rs 230 crore to Rs 80.50 crore on the appellant, PwC," the judgment said, and ordered for release of the bank guarantee furnished by the accused.
The judge further observed that the penalty of Rs 23 lakh on Kapoor was excessive and reduced it to Rs 5.75 lakh in place, finding it to be disproportionate to the contravention keeping in view the overall circumstances of the case.
"In the light of the findings recorded above, we cannot subscribe the arguments raised by the counsel for the appellants, rather, find a case for contravention of Sections 6(2), 6(3), 9(b), 10(5), 10(6) of Fema," the judge noted.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

LIC's Rs 15 lakh crore portfolio shakeup: Defence stocks in, retail darlings Suzlon, Vedanta out
LIC's Rs 15 lakh crore portfolio shakeup: Defence stocks in, retail darlings Suzlon, Vedanta out

Economic Times

time30 minutes ago

  • Economic Times

LIC's Rs 15 lakh crore portfolio shakeup: Defence stocks in, retail darlings Suzlon, Vedanta out

Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC), India's largest domestic institutional investor, controlling a staggering Rs 15.5 lakh crore equity portfolio, has pared stakes in 81 companies during the June quarter while strategically adding four PSU defence stocks. ADVERTISEMENT LIC has reduced positions in popular retail favorites, including Suzlon Energy, Reliance Power, and Vedanta - stocks that have been darlings of small investors despite their volatile performance. The insurance giant's current portfolio now spans 277 stocks, as shown by data collated from ACE Equity. LIC's most notable new additions reveal a clear defence sector bet, with the PSU insurer taking fresh stakes in Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders (3.27% holding worth Rs 3,857 crore), while increasing positions in established defence names. The insurer boosted its stake in Cochin Shipyard by 13 basis points to 3.05%, Bharat Electronics by 10 basis points to 1.99%, and Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) by 5 basis points to 2.77%. Defence stocks have been in focus for most of 2025 amid geopolitical tensions in various parts of the world, India's increased defence spending after Operation Sindoor, the government's indigenisation focus, and NATO's defence spending the last six months, the Nifty India Defence index is up 34% with PSU shipbuilder GRSE shares leading the rally with 71% returns. ADVERTISEMENT Also Read | Mutual funds cut Rs 1,700 crore exposure in 9 defence stocks. Too expensive to buy or smart exit? Beyond defence, LIC significantly ramped up exposure to technology and financial services. The insurer increased its Infosys stake by 43 basis points to 10.88% (now worth Rs 63,400 crore), while adding 48 basis points to HCL Technologies, bringing its holding to 5.31% valued at Rs 21,900 crore. ADVERTISEMENT In a bold move, LIC boosted its Jio Financial Services position by 55 basis points to 6.68%, signaling confidence in Mukesh Ambani's financial services venture. The insurer also increased Tata Motors' exposure by 74 basis points to 3.89%, betting on the automotive giant's electric vehicle transition. LIC's banking portfolio witnessed selective repositioning, with the insurer reducing heavyweight positions while backing select PSU banks. HDFC Bank saw a 30 basis point reduction to 5.45%, while ICICI Bank was trimmed by 42 basis points to 6.38%. ADVERTISEMENT However, Bank of Baroda benefited from a 61 basis point increase to 7.51%, while Canara Bank received a 13 basis point boost to 5.85%, indicating LIC's preference for PSU banking exposure. Also Read | The great Adani bet: Mutual funds & LIC are buying what GQG, FIIs are selling ADVERTISEMENT The most dramatic moves came in LIC's booking profits in some of the favorites of retail investors. Reliance Power, a multibagger stock beloved by small investors, saw its LIC holding reduced by 13 basis points to 2.43%. Vedanta faced a 21 basis point cut to 6.69%, while Suzlon Energy saw a 1 basis point MotoCorp witnessed the largest single reduction, with LIC slashing its stake by 531 basis points to 6.53%. Other reductions were Navin Fluroine, Divi's Labs, Marico, Apollo Hospitals, Eicher Motors, JSW Energy, Kotak Mahindra Bank, Bharti Airtel, and SBI. LIC's largest holding remains Reliance Industries (RIL) at Rs 1.3 lakh crore (6.93% stake), which saw a 19 basis point increase, reaffirming the insurer's faith in India's largest conglomerate. ITC retained its position as the second-largest holding at Rs 82,200 crore (15.8% stake) with a 28 basis point top 10 holdings account for over Rs 6 lakh crore of LIC's portfolio, with HDFC Bank (Rs 68,600 crore), State Bank of India (Rs 66,300 crore), and Larsen & Toubro (Rs 64,100 crore) completing the largest individual stock moves, LIC's portfolio reshuffle reveals clear sectoral preferences. The insurer added positions in renewable energy through IREDA (2.21% fresh stake), infrastructure via increased RVNL exposure (22 basis points to 6.06%), and consumer goods through Patanjali Foods (148 basis points increase to 9.14%).With equity markets at record highs, the insurer's selective approach suggests a more cautious stance on valuations while maintaining exposure to long-term India growth themes. (Data: Ritesh Presswala) (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel)

Celebi moves division bench of Delhi HC against revocation of security nod
Celebi moves division bench of Delhi HC against revocation of security nod

Hindustan Times

time30 minutes ago

  • Hindustan Times

Celebi moves division bench of Delhi HC against revocation of security nod

The CAG criticized the Bihar government for failing to submit utilization certificates for projects worth Rs 70,877 crore, as reported in the 2023-24 State Finances report. The absence of these certificates raises concerns about fund misappropriation. Additionally, pending bills and high liabilities indicate financial mismanagement, with the state only utilizing 79.92% of its budget.

Mom, partner get life till death for murdering kids in 2018
Mom, partner get life till death for murdering kids in 2018

New Indian Express

time30 minutes ago

  • New Indian Express

Mom, partner get life till death for murdering kids in 2018

CHENNAI: Seven years after a 33-year-old woman and her partner were arrested by the Kundrathur police for poisoning her two children to death, a special court in Kancheepuram, on Thursday, convicted and sentenced them to life imprisonment until death and slapped a fine of Rs 15,000 on each of them. The investigation carried out by the Kundrathur police found the children were killed by the woman, V Abhirami, as she felt they posed a stumbling block to her plan to live with her partner Meenakshisundaram, alias Sundaram, a vendor at a biriyani shop. The duo had hatched a conspiracy, and Abhirami poisoned the milk fed to the kids, causing their death. The complaint regarding the death of the children — Ajay and Karunika, aged six and four respectively — was filed by Abhirami's husband Vijay, a private bank employee and a resident of Kundrathur, in September 2018. The police said the woman had planned to elope with Sundaram after killing her children and husband, and that she had kept the poison-laced milk for Vijay as well. But, Vijay had a close shave as he didn't drink it, for he had work till late that night, the police said. Abirami and Sundaram were charged with conspiracy and murder and were arrested a few days after the case was registered. The Kundrathur police filed a charge sheet before the court after two months. As many as 25 witnesses were produced by the prosecution before the judge during the trial. The trial court found the prosecution, led by public prosecutor Sasirekha, had proved the charges beyond doubt, and convicted the duo.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store