
Appellate tribunal cuts Fema violation penalty slapped by ED on PwC from ₹230cr to ₹81cr
NEW DELHI: An appellate tribunal here has imposed a Rs 81 crore penalty on PwC, reducing it from the Rs 230 crore slapped by
Enforcement Directorate
(ED) on the audit firm in a case of violation of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (Fema).
PwC has been accused of receiving Rs 230 crore FDIs in violation of Fema rules as audit firms cannot receive foreign direct investment (FDI), according to ED. The case was initiated by ED on information that PwC had received FDI running in crores in the name of grant.
"The company is engaged in audit practice which does not permit receipt of the FDI," the ED had argued and which was upheld by the tribunal on Safema (Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators (Forfeiture of Property) Act, 1976).
The transactions were carried by PwC without the approval of the RBI, violating Fema rules, it had said.
The bench of the tribunal - headed by Justice Munishwar Nath Bhandari - in an order of July 9 accepted the investigation of ED but reduced substantially the penalty amount on the company, a former chairman and other officials.
In a show cause notice issued on Sept 11, 2019, ED had imposed a penalty of Rs 230 crore on PwC, Rs 23 lakh on former chairman Deepak Kapoor, Rs 11 lakh on Shyamal Mukherjee, the then chairman of PwC, as well as Rs 5 lakh on Ramesh Rajan, also a former chairman.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
15 most beautiful women in the world
Topgentlemen.com
Undo
"We find the penalty to be excessive and disproportionate to the allegations against the appellant (PwC). The appellant has received grants under licence and accordingly inward remittance, though it is in contravention of the (Fema) Act and Regulations made therein. Taking the overall view, we reduce the penalty from Rs 230 crore to Rs 80.50 crore on the appellant, PwC," the judgment said, and ordered for release of the bank guarantee furnished by the accused.
The judge further observed that the penalty of Rs 23 lakh on Kapoor was excessive and reduced it to Rs 5.75 lakh in place, finding it to be disproportionate to the contravention keeping in view the overall circumstances of the case.
"In the light of the findings recorded above, we cannot subscribe the arguments raised by the counsel for the appellants, rather, find a case for contravention of Sections 6(2), 6(3), 9(b), 10(5), 10(6) of Fema," the judge noted.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Deccan Herald
6 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
Discovery Global Management exits SpiceJet, sells 2.2 pc stake for Rs 119 cr
The transaction was executed at an average price of Rs 38.14 apiece, taking the total deal value to Rs 118.82 crore.


Hindustan Times
6 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Home buyers 'fraud': ED secures custody of 2 Ramprastha Group directors
Gurugram, The Directorate of Enforcement on Wednesday secured two-day custody of Sandeep Yadav and Arvind Walia, promoters of Haryana-based realty company Ramprastha Group, in connection with a money laundering probe linked to an alleged ₹1,100 crore fraud with homebuyers. Home buyers 'fraud': ED secures custody of 2 Ramprastha Group directors The two were arrested on Monday after the Gurugram zonal office of the federal probe agency raided three premises in Delhi and Gurugram, including those of the directors, early morning on that day. Yadav and Walia are directors and majority shareholders in Ramprastha Promoters and Developers Pvt Ltd . They were taken into custody under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act . The federal probe agency produced the two in the court of an additional session judge, following which the ED secured their custody. The agency conducted a survey against the group in September 2024. It is alleged that the RPDPL collected about ₹1,100 crore from more than 2,000 homebuyers for various housing schemes like Project Edge, Project Skyz, Project Rise and Ramprastha City in various sectors of Gurugram during 2008-11. The possession of the flats or plots is yet to be given, even after 15-20 years, the sources said. Earlier this month, the agency attached colonies and plots spread across more than 1,900 acres and worth over ₹681.54 crore of the group in Gurugram as part of this investigation. The money laundering case stems from multiple FIRs filed by the Economic Offences Wing of the Delhi and Haryana Police based on complaints of numerous homebuyers against RPDPL and its promoters, like Yadav, Walia and Balwant Chaudhary for their "failure" to deliver promised flats and plots within the promised timeframes, the ED had said in a statement. The company and its promoters "diverted" the funds sources from buyers of these projects to its group companies as advances for the purchase of land parcels, instead of using them for completion of promised homes, it had said. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.


Time of India
19 minutes ago
- Time of India
Three men damage 15 vehicles with stones & sticks in Dhankawdi
1 2 Pune: Three men damaged 18 vehicles — 15 autorickshaws, two cars and a school van — with stones and sticks between 12.35am and 1am on Wednesday at Dhankawdi, and threatened residents with dire consequences if anyone intervened in their act of vandalism, claiming themselves to be local "Bhais" (strongmen). Sumit Rangnekar (42), a resident of the area, lodged a complaint with the Sahakarnagar police later in the morning. The trio damaged the windshield of his car. Deputy commissioner of police (Zone II) Milind Mohite told TOI, "The reason behind the vandalism is not known yet. Our team is studying the CCTV footage of the area, which shows the three men riding on a motorcycle and damaging the vehicles parked on a road. They have been riding triple-seat." You Can Also Check: Pune AQI | Weather in Pune | Bank Holidays in Pune | Public Holidays in Pune Inspector Surekha Chavan of the Sahakarnagar police said, "The three men damaged the vehicles parked on the public road. A majority of the affected people are autorickshaw drivers, who stay nearby." An autorickshaw driver (48) said, "I had parked my autorickshaw on the road around 10.30pm on Tuesday. After parking my autorickshaw, I went home. I received a call from one of my friends around 1am, stating that someone damaged the windshield of my autorickshaw." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villa Prices in Dubai Might Be Lower Than You Think! Villa for sale in Dubai | Search Ads Learn More Undo He said, "Now, to repair the windshield, I will have to spend around Rs2,000. I also will miss two days' income, which is around Rs600 to Rs700 per day." DCP Mohite said, "We suspect that the case of vehicle vandalism is connected to another case of house ransacking in the area. A man celebrated his birthday with his second wife and two sons, and three sons of his earlier wife came to his house and ransacked it. The three men were seen leaving the same area on their motorcycle where the ransacked house is located. We are yet to arrive at any conclusion, though." Late on Sunday night, a gang of eight men damaged a grocery store and then damaged an autorickshaw. On Saturday evening, three people damaged eight vehicles in Kondhwa over an old rivalry.