Ongoing inspections reveal undocumented workers
Image: Department of Employment and Labour
A year after the George building collapse, which claimed the lives of 34 people and left 28 injured, the Department of Employment and Labour continues oversight on construction sites in towns such as Knysna, which saw multiple undocumented foreign nationals taken into custody and the sites closed temporarily.
In a statement, the department confirmed that during a multidisciplinary and unannounced inspection held on June 3, they visited the construction and hospitality sector in Knysna, where several undocumented workers were found.
'At one construction site, gross contravention to labour legislation was discovered, which led to the temporary closure of the site,' said the department.
'Multiple undocumented foreign nationals were taken into police custody on site, all thanks to the swift work of the joint venture between the department's Inspection and Enforcement Services (IES) unit, the local Knysna police office, as well as Home Affairs' Border Management Authority.
'The blitz inspection forms part of the department's service delivery campaign in Knysna. #Yazini #Delservices #workersrights.'
Teboho Thejane, chief communications officer, said as it was a multidisciplinary blitz, they could not comment formally on undocumented persons, when asked how many persons were detained.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
'As labour migration Act is outside our scope we do not effect arrests, but we look at, Basic Conditions of Employment Act,(BCEA), National Minimum Wage Act, (NWM), Labour Relations Act, ( LRA), Employment Equity Act, (EEA ) and, Occupational Health and Safety Act, (OHSA) just to mention a few," he said.
'Inspection and Enforcement Services (IES) nationally does have proactive and reaction inspection in different sectors, inclusive of contraction. Construction is one of the sectors under our radar. Because such blitz inspections include other role players as they are multiciliary when they are arranged and finalised we will inform accordingly.'
In January, the Department of Employment and Labour carried out a similar blitz in Camps Bay where 10 illegal immigrants were found working at restaurants, and their employers held accountable, with one arrested.
The Department of Home Affairs's David Hlabane did not respond to queries.
Just last week, the Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure, Dean Macpherson, received the final report from the Council for the Built Environment (CBE), through its body Engineering Council of South Africa (ECSA), surrounding the tragic George building collapse.
He said the department will carefully study the report to develop a pathway forward to ensure such a collapse never happens again.
Earlier, the George Municipality also confirmed that the final report involving the independent structural investigation of the site, which was commissioned and undertaken by the Engineering Design Services (EDS), has been handed over to the police.
Human Settlements Minister, Thembi Simelane, said via a report that the municipality was at fault for approving the apartment block's plan when it was already in the process of construction.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
9 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Crucial Air Traffic and Navigation Services faces payroll and skills crisis
Payroll issues, staff discontent and a potential exodus of skilled air traffic controllers are colliding at the state-owned Air Traffic and Navigation Services, raising fears of operational instability in South Africa's skies. The state-owned Air Traffic and Navigation Services (ATNS), responsible for controlling every aircraft in South Africa's skies, is facing a convergence of crises. Already under regulatory scrutiny over grounded flights, leadership instability and concerns about passenger safety, ATNS is now grappling with payroll chaos that has left air traffic controllers and other critical personnel short-paid, overpaid or unable to access payslips. A whistleblower told Daily Maverick that these issues, far from being isolated glitches, form part of a broader pattern of operational lapses, internal inequities and governance failures that threaten safety and service continuity. 'This is the second payroll issue in less than a year and the third incident this year regarding unpaid overtime claims and training allowances,' an ATNS employee told Daily Maverick, underscoring that the distraction of missing pay is not merely an HR hiccup but a potential hazard in a safety-critical environment. Stalled on the runway In July, many ATNS employees logged into their bank accounts to discover their salaries had been underpaid by thousands of rands. Others were overpaid, while some could not even access their payslips. For a workforce where operational vigilance is paramount, the impact of such disruptions isn't merely a speed bump but a safety risk. Linden Birns, aviation expert and publisher of the industry newsletter Plane Talking, underscored the risk to Daily Maverick: 'You don't want people who have got such a responsible job to be distracted by something like that.' The psychological burden is not academic — air traffic controllers and ATNS staff manage split-second decisions involving hundreds of lives, and the erosion of their financial security risks undermining the very focus that makes aviation safe. At the centre of the payroll dispute is the payroll software in use by ATNS. According to Solidarity's sector co-ordinator for aviation, Barend Smit, who confirmed the salary issues, the system's shortcomings have been long evident. Smit told Daily Maverick the system was 'unreliable, outdated… Many clients have become frustrated with [its shortcomings] and moved on.' He said that in correspondence with ATNS, the union had cited contraventions of sections 32(3) and 33 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act. Solidarity has formally demanded the termination of ATNS's agreement with Oracle in favour of a more reliable system. In its written response to Daily Maverick, the ATNS disputed any systemic failure, stating: 'A temporary technical glitch occurred and corrective processes were implemented.' Pay disparity and policy challenges Beyond the immediate payroll dispute, internal wage and policy disparities are fuelling further resentment. In the 2025 salary adjustment round, air traffic controllers allegedly received a 9.3% increase, technicians 6.3% and administrative staff 5.3%. Air traffic controllers also benefited from retention packages in the 2024/25 financial year, while other categories did not. Employees allege this has compounded morale problems, especially when coupled with differing remote work arrangements. 'Support staff are forced to work in the office full-day Monday to Friday, while the rest of the head office and some admin staff work remotely,' the whistleblower told Daily Maverick. For Smit, these disparities have operational implications. 'If a controller or technician isn't paid on time, you create a chain reaction — they may not be able to cover transport costs, they arrive stressed, and that stress carries into the control room. In this job, distraction can be dangerous.' In response to questions from Daily Maverick, ATNS clarified that employee remuneration structures and service level agreements with third parties — such as their payroll contractor — were not disclosed to external parties. Leadership in turbulence The payroll instability comes against a backdrop of leadership challenges and infrastructure lapses. Earlier this year, Transport Minister Barbara Creecy suspended ATNS CEO Nozipho Mdawe over the organisation's failure to maintain instrument flight procedures at key airports — procedures that dictate the circumstances under which flights can operate. Birns recalled one striking example at Kimberley airport just last week: 'No flights could go in or out … because there are no currently valid instrument flight procedures for Kimberley, either arrival or departure.' This followed an earlier systems failure at Johannesburg, where the primary air traffic control system was corrupted and the backup had not been maintained, creating operational gaps in one of the busiest airspaces in the country. The looming exodus ATNS is also contending with a looming skills crisis. Globally, trained air traffic controllers are in short supply, and South Africa has seen its share of departures. 'There's been quite an exodus of people going over to other parts of the world … there's a global shortage of controllers,' said Birns. The opening of new international airports in other countries will intensify this competition, given the global skills shortage, and Smit warned that the impact could be direct, highlighting that a new airport will soon open in the Middle East. 'That will need at least about 150 traffic controllers,' said Smit. 'I think there's only one place that those airports are going to look for them, and that's in South Africa.' The combined effect of payroll instability, wage disparities and morale issues risks accelerating staff departures at precisely the moment when replacements are hardest to find. Why ATNS matters The stakes extend beyond ATNS's internal performance. Birns emphasised that the aviation sector had 'massive catalytic power in terms of cascading job creation' and that the government's failure to grasp the interdependence of air transport and economic growth was costly. 'Infrastructure failures hold the growth of the economy to ransom,' he said. An ATNS that is distracted, understaffed or hobbled by systemic faults risks constraining trade, tourism and investment far beyond the runway. The Department of Transport did not respond to direct questions from Daily Maverick, but referred all queries to ATNS, which stated that it 'fosters a culture of open, honest and fair two-way communication with employees' and applies 'internal policies based on operational requirements, safety imperatives, and service continuity'. It said hybrid work arrangements are supported 'where feasible' and that operational requirements dictated site presence for some staff categories. It did not respond to direct questions about salary disputes. In response to the mounting challenges at ATNS, Creecy mandated a comprehensive turnaround strategy, and on 30 January she approved recommendations from her Committee of Aviation Experts — established in December 2024 — to immediately enhance staffing, critical systems and governance within the organisation. The plan focuses on accelerating the recruitment of air traffic controllers and technical personnel over a period of up to three years, while also upgrading communication, navigation and surveillance infrastructure, including air traffic flow management; restoring and maintaining vital instrument flight procedures; and streamlining governance by instituting single-point accountability for implementation. In an update in March, Creecy outlined measures to stabilise and rebuild ATNS since December 2024, including fast-tracking the recruitment of air traffic controllers, upgrading critical navigation and surveillance systems, reinstating suspended flight procedures and strengthening safety oversight. She said these interventions were 'beginning to show progress', while noting that ATNS's CEO remained on precautionary suspension pending an independent investigation. DM
IOL News
24-07-2025
- IOL News
What the Eastern Cape High Court ruling means for foreign employee terminations
A law firm looks at the law following a judgment saying employers are not entitled to fire foreign nationals on the spot if they are working without a valid visa. Image: File A foreign national employee must be provided with proper notice of their termination in line with the Basic Conditions of Employment Act (BCA). Failure to provide such notice may result in the termination being unlawful. This is the warning of employment law experts at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr (CDH), following a recent Eastern Cape High Court judgment. This was after an application by a research assistant and Zimbabwean national, Samuel Nyakudya. He was granted a temporary residence permit allowing him to reside in South Africa and seek employment in the category of general work as provided for under the Immigration Act. His employer, the OR Tambo District Municipality, however, terminated his employment contract due to allegations of its unlawfulness and irregularity. Commenting on the case, CDH said that this area of termination has just become a lot clearer for employers after the recent ruling, stating that employing a foreign national without a work visa does not automatically grant an employer the right to summarily terminate the employment contract. 'This indicates a key warning for employers highlighting their responsibility to act lawfully and in accordance with the BCA,' CDH said. The experts explained that a foreign national employee must be provided with proper notice of their termination in line with the BCA. 'Failure to provide such notice may result in the termination being unlawful. The dismissal may also be found to be unfair in the CCMA (Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration).' Nyakudya was employed on successive fixed-term contracts, but following the expiration of his last contract, the municipality allowed him to continue working without a new fixed-term contract. Throughout his employment, Nyakudya was not consistently in possession of a work visa. In November 2023, the municipality notified him that his contract had expired on March 31, 2022, and that he had failed to provide a copy of his South African identity document, despite being requested to do so. Consequently, the municipality claimed it had no choice but to terminate his employment immediately, citing the unlawful nature of his contract due to the expiration of his work visa. While Nyakudya could have contested the fairness of his dismissal before the CCMA, he opted to challenge the termination in the High Court. The court ultimately ruled that Nyakudya's employment contract termination was unlawful.. CDH said the Immigration Act outlines an employer's responsibilities regarding the employment of foreign nationals, specifically in Section 38, which prohibits the employment of illegal foreigners or those whose status does not authorise them to work. It said the court also referenced Section 49(3) of the Immigration Act, which states that employing an illegal foreigner or a foreigner in violation of the Act constitutes a criminal offence. The court confirmed that such employment is punishable by fines or imprisonment upon conviction. Regarding the summary termination of Nyakudya's contract, the court considered Section 37(1) of the BCEA, which stipulates the notice period required for termination based on the duration of employment. The court highlighted that the purpose of providing notice is to allow employees to prepare for a smooth transition. 'Nyakudya's lack of a work visa or South African identity document was a critical factor in the case. The court determined that employing a foreign national without a work visa is prohibited, and thus, the municipality's immediate termination of Nyakudya's contract was unlawful. 'This case serves as a significant reminder that employing a foreign national without a work visa does not automatically grant an employer the right to terminate the employment contract summarily,' CDH warned.
IOL News
27-06-2025
- IOL News
Why sentencing was postponed for Chinese nationals convicted of human trafficking in SA
The trial against seven Chinese nationals charged with human trafficking and child labour is expected to resume on July 4. Image: File The Department of Employment and Labour has confirmed that sentencing proceedings in the high-profile trial of seven Chinese nationals convicted of human trafficking and child labour have been postponed to next week. The matter was due to proceed at the Gauteng South Division Court in Johannesburg on Wednesday, June 26, 2025. However, the Court was informed that pre-sentencing reports had not yet been officially submitted. According to the Department, Advocate Valencia Dube informed the Court that all the accused were allocated probation officers to prepare pre-sentencing reports. While all the accused were visited by social services, their reports were not yet ready for submission. The convicted individuals, Kevin Tsao Shu-Uei, Chen Hui, Qin Li, Jiaqing Zhou, Ma Biao, Dai Junying, and Zhang Zhilian, were found guilty on February 25, 2025, of 160 counts. These included human trafficking, aiding and benefiting from trafficking, keeping persons in bondage, and a wide range of labour law violations. The convictions followed a joint operation in November 2019 at Beautiful City Pty Ltd, a textile factory based in Village Deep, Johannesburg. The operation was conducted by the Department's Inspection and Enforcement Services branch, the SAPS/Hawks, and the Department of Home Affairs, following a tip-off. The raid uncovered illegal immigrants, some of them minors, who were working in locked factory conditions. 'The seven were found guilty of violating South Africa's labour laws by not registering with the Compensation Fund and declaring their operations; failure to keep records of their earnings; failure to submit their return on earnings; failure to pay and declare assessments; failure to maintain a safe workplace; failure to report incidents; failure to register and declare with the Unemployment Insurance Fund Commissioner; failure to inform the Commissioner on Unemployment Insurance changes.' Departmental spokesperson Teboho Thejane said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading 'In addition, they were found guilty of human trafficking, aiding/facilitating human trafficking, bondage, benefiting from victims of human trafficking, and assisting illegal immigrants to remain in South Africa.' A new legal twist emerged during proceedings when defence Counsel J. Kruger, who had represented the accused since 2019, announced that his mandate had been terminated. 'Defence Counsel J. Kruger regretted to tell the Court that his mandate has been terminated,' Thejane said. The accused are now expected to be represented by Goodgall Attorneys. Six of the seven convicted individuals remain in custody. Only accused number six, Dai Junying, has been released on medical grounds. The case is provisionally scheduled to return to court on July 4, 2025, for submission and review of the pre-sentencing reports. IOL News
