Nigel Owens says Springboks should have been penalised for illegal scrum tactic
Image: Anne-Christine Poujoulat/AFP
The Springboks broke the law with their scrum tactic in the second Test against Italy and should have been penalised, said former referee Nigel Owens.
Rassie Erasmus and the Springboks created a stir with a number of contentious tactics in the second Test against the Italians in Gqeberha, which they won 45-0.
Right off the bat, the Boks manufactured a scrum off the kick-off when André Esterhuizen went ahead of kicker Manie Libbok, resulting in a scrum being awarded for having a player in front of the kicker.
Later in the match, the Boks came up with another tactic that saw Ruan Nortjé being lifted to secure a ball in the middle of the park.
Get your news on the go, click
here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
According to Owens, a penalty should have been given to Italy, while the lifting incident is open for interpretation.
'The key word is 'deliberate'. Normally, in this kind of situation, if a player is in front of the kick-off, it's deemed to be offside and a scrum is awarded. What we saw in this instance is that it looks deliberate. It's a ploy, an action to get a scrum.
'In this instance, if I was refereeing this game, that would have been a pretty straightforward, clear penalty because it's not the normal action of being slightly in front,' said the Welshman when talking to England great Ugo Monye on Whistle Watch on YouTube.
On Nortjé being lifted in the middle of the field, again, Owens felt it was a grey issue that was open for interpretation.
'A player being lifted in the air to catch the ball from a kick-off is perfectly legal. We see it every game and nothing's wrong with it at all. Within the laws, this is not an illegal action.
'Is it against the sportsmanship of the game or is it an unfair advantage? If a guy is in the air, the defenders cannot do anything to compete for that ball. You can't touch the player or bind around those who are supporting him. The opposition pretty much have to wait for him to come down, then they can do something.
'It's a very clever ploy. Some like it, some think it's not right, but it all comes down to whether you think it's fair.'
Owens went on to discuss Jasper Wiese's red card, which was shown to him after a supposed headbutt on an opponent.
While many commentators in South Africa have felt it was a headbutt and the red card was a harsh sanction, Owens felt it was appropriate given the coming together of heads. Wiese has since been suspended for four matches following a World Rugby disciplinary hearing and will be available for selection again on September 13 when the Boks play the All Blacks in Wellington.
IOL Sport
Get your news on the go, click
here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
England hero Kelly overcomes 'dark moments' on way to Euro glory
England penalty hero Chloe Kelly said Sunday she had been unable to hold back the tears after finishing a roller-coaster... England's Chloe Kelly celebrates after scoring the winning penalty in the shootout against Spain on Sunday. Picture: Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP England penalty hero Chloe Kelly said Sunday she had been unable to hold back the tears after finishing a roller-coaster year in her career by scoring the spot-kick that allowed the Lionesses to beat Spain in the Women's Euro 2025 final. ALSO READ: Sub sinks Morocco as Nigeria are crowned African football queens The 27-year-old's penalty sealed a 3-1 shoot-out victory for England against Spain after the match in Basel had finished 1-1 at the end of extra time. England's Kelly's key impact She had earlier come off the bench late in the first half in place of the injured Lauren James with England trailing 1-0, and crossed for Alessia Russo to head in her team's equaliser. 'I just came on the pitch and wanted to make something happen,' said Kelly, who has made a habit of being a super-sub during the tournament. The Arsenal player came on as a substitute against Sweden and helped England recover from 2-0 down in a quarter-final they eventually won on penalties — Kelly scored in that shoot-out too. Then she scored the winner late in extra time in the semi-final against Italy, following in to net after her penalty had been saved. 'I know Alessia's strengths and I just tried to put the ball on her head, and then taking the penalty,' Kelly said. 'I actually missed three penalties in training yesterday but I think it's the belief in this squad, all 23 players and the people that you don't see behind the scenes, the staff members, to get us through this tournament. 'I am proud to be part of an amazing group of girls.' It is a familiar feeling for Kelly, who scored the extra-time winner when England beat Germany 2-1 in the Euro 2022 final in front of over 87,000 fans at Wembley. In between she was unable to change the game from the bench in the 2023 World Cup final, which England lost 1-0 to Spain in Sydney. 'Tough times don't last' Just a few months ago it seemed Kelly might not even make Sarina Wiegman's squad for the tournament in Switzerland, given her situation at club level. In January she asked to leave Manchester City, where she had been used sparingly in the first months of the season. Kelly wrote on social media that people at City had been trying to 'assassinate my character' and said her mental wellbeing had been affected. She then joined Arsenal on loan until the end of the campaign, and went on to play for them as they beat Barcelona in the Champions League final in May. 'There were a lot of tears at full-time especially when I saw my family because those are the people who got me through those dark moments,' Kelly said on Sunday. 'I am so grateful to be out of it but if that is a story to tell someone who maybe experiences something the same, then tough times don't last,' she added. 'Just around the corner was a Champions League final — I won that, and now a Euros final I have won that, so thank you to everyone who wrote me off. I am grateful.' Kelly recently signed permanently for Arsenal, where she also played earlier in her career, and will return to North London as a European champion at club and international level. 'Every player has their own story, and I think every story is incredible on its own, but her story is unbelievable,' said England coach Sarina Wiegman. 'I am so happy for her too. She has been fighting to come back to her highest level. ALSO READ: No complaints from Ellis in Banyana defeat 'She loved this moment, she just really wanted to take the penalty — to be able to score that penalty under that pressure is very impressive too.'
The South African
3 hours ago
- The South African
England to 'copy' Springboks' 7-1 bomb squad
The concept of the 'bomb squad' first came into the rugby conversation when the Springboks utilised a 6-2 forwards-to-backs split on the bench during the 2019 World Cup, while this was elevated even further in recent times when Rassie Erasmus occasionally opted for a 7-1 substitutes set up. Although there have been some critics of this tactic – mainly from overseas pundits – there have been a number of other clubs and countries who have begun to experiment with a bench that is also packed with forwards, coupled with versatile backs. Now, according to The Telegraph , England are planning to also try out a 7-1 split as coach Steve Borthwick apparently wants to be able to include as many back-rowers as possible in his match-day squad considering this is an area where they have plenty of depth. In aiming for maximum flexibility, it's also reported that Borthwick is training props to deputise at hooker, while also prioritising some players who have the ability to cover more than one position. It all sounds a bit familiar, doesn't it? As part of recent World Rugby workshops looking at law changes, it was stated that the governing body was looking at the role of the replacements. In what will come as a huge relief to the Springboks and their fans, World Rugby's chief executive, Alan Gilpin, told The Guardian that there are no medical grounds to outlaw this bench configuration. 'We looked at it from a science, medicine perspective. Was there a distinctive view that a bunch of fresh players coming on with 20‑30 minutes to go is going to create a more injurious position, and the science said that's not the case. 'So there was no reason from that perspective to look at how we might do replacements differently. Ultimately, there are a lot of different ways to win a rugby match.' Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 0211. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
The South African
14 hours ago
- The South African
'Third floor': Ox Nche celebrates his 30th birthday in style
Springbok Ox Nche celebrated his 30th birthday in style in his hometown of Bloemfontein this weekend. The popular player is known for his love of cake and for being one of rugby's best loosehead props in the world. Over the weekend, Ox Nche posted pictures of his 30th birthday celebration, which took place in Bloemfontein. The back-and-white party was attended by family and friends, and naturally included a big, beautiful cake!. He captioned the clip: 'The 3rd floor…Thank God for the wonderful life. Thank you for all the birthday wishes. Thank you to all the friends and family in my life. I love you guys'. While Ox Nche celebrated his 30th birthday, he has made 40 test match appearances for the Springboks. The Bok veteran is enjoying mingling with the squad's newbies, whom he has taken under his wing. He said of his mentorship: 'It makes you want to better yourself. You know the standards that have been set. It just makes you want to take them and try to elevate them to the next level.' He added: 'When we give each other advice, we are actually pulling each other up. We don't doubt the information we're giving each other'. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 . Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp , Facebook , X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
