'Is it really justified?' Contractor linked to aid group details chaos in Gaza
A contractor involved with a US-Israeli-backed aid group in Gaza has spoken out about what he claims is a chaotic operation marked by 'bad practices'.
The contractor worked with the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) and documented his time on the ground over a number of weeks.
Speaking to ITV News on condition of anonymity, he alleges a culture of 'just winging it' and said he was left 'traumatised' by some of what he witnessed.
The GHF was established in February 2025 and took over food distribution operations in Gaza in late May, prompting outcry from UN agencies and other private groups.
More than 1,000 people have died while trying to get food in recent weeks. Of those, over 670 people have been killed in the vicinity of the group's sites, according to the latest UN figures, often attributed to Israeli fire – including gunshots and tear gas – while the GHF has also been criticised for crowd control incidents, including stampedes.
The contractor, who has worked at all four of the GHF's distribution sites, had conflicting emotions.
'If it wasn't for the amount of meals that we've given out, a lot more people would have died from starvation than the hundreds of people that might have died as a result of them being killed on the way or back from one of these sites, so obviously it is the lesser of two evils,' he said.
'But I'm thinking, is it really justified? Is there actually such a thing as the lesser of two evils? Logically, yes, because if you've got a choice in terms of 10,000 people dying or 1,000 people dying, I'd obviously take 1,000.
'But who's really allowed to make that decision? Who has given somebody the authority?'
The contractor explained the aid delivery trucks are driven in a convoy guarded by the IDF, and when they reach distribution points, the IDF is there, alongside armed guards working for the GHF, to protect the sites while the aid is being unloaded. / Credit: Associated Press
But according to him, the overrunning of aid sites has become commonplace, creating dangerous situations for everyone on the ground.
'I saw in one instance during an evacuation, Israeli soldiers running and shouting at two people that were dressed in regular clothing.
'I saw a couple of IDF soldiers going prone and then about two seconds afterwards, I saw both of the heads of the Palestinians snap back and then drop and that was during one of the very frequent evacuations because of [the site] being overrun.'
In a video shared with ITV News, an IDF tank on the perimeter of a GHF site can be seen firing, while retaliatory shots appear to come back towards where the aid is being delivered.
In another video, the contractor claimed that unidentified Palestinians entered a road which was outside of the 'safe zone' and gunfire subsequently rings out.
At one point, a man at the site can be heard laughing and saying: 'Here comes the tanks…run the f***ers over.'
The GHF, he claimed, needs 'restructuring because there's a lot of bad practice.'
'There's a whole culture of just winging it,' he added. Palestinians carry humanitarian aid packages near the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution center. / Credit: Associated Press
In a statement to ITV News, the GHF rejected the claims made by the contractor, adding: 'It is an active war zone in Gaza. It's also one of the most complex operating environments in the world. The legacy models of aid delivery have failed to adequately meet the overwhelming needs of the population.
'That's why GHF exists and why we are committed to constant innovation to meet President Trump's call for new, effective ways to get aid into Gaza while the UN's trucks get looted and overrun and their aid is not making it into the strip.'
Today, a spokesperson for the GHF told reporters it was 'routinely pressing' the IDF to 'facilitate the safe movement of civilians accessing aid at all points.
'They have made some improvements to their procedures, but we will continue to press them.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
an hour ago
- Powys County Times
JD Vance greeted by Palestine protesters as he begins holiday in Scotland
US vice president JD Vance has arrived in Scotland as he continues his family holiday to the UK. Donald Trump's second-in-command landed at Prestwick Airport on Wednesday evening before travelling with a large motorcade to the luxury Carnell Estate near Kilmarnock in East Ayrshire. He was greeted at the resort by dozens of pro-Palestine protesters, who accused him of supporting a 'genocide' by Israel in Gaza. The demonstrated were kettled by police as they bashed pots and pans, waved Palestine flags and shouted pro-Palestine chants. Police had initially told the protesters they would need to move and that officers would do so if they refused to leave to a different space nearby. Airspace restrictions are in place around the estate until Sunday. Mr Vance will reportedly spend five days in Scotland – the same amount of time his boss did during his trip to the country last month. President Trump split his stay between his golf courses in South Ayrshire and Aberdeenshire, during which time he met the First Minister and Prime Minister. A spokesperson for Police Scotland said: 'This visit requires a significant police operation and we have appropriate resources in place using local, national and specialist officers from across Police Scotland.' Mr Vance had been holidaying in the Cotswolds, but travelled to the Foreign Secretary's Chevening House retreat in Kent on Friday – and he joined David Lammy for a spot of carp fishing at the countryside estate. Earlier on Wednesday, Mr Vance described the UK-US relationship as 'a beautiful alliance' during a speech at RAF Fairford in Gloucestershire.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Zelensky urges Trump and Putin to include Ukraine in peace negotiations
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has insisted that Ukraine must be included in any peace deal discussions between Russian President Vladimir Putin and US President Donald Trump. The upcoming summit between Mr Putin and Mr Trump is scheduled for Friday in Alaska. Mr Zelensky said that it is impossible to talk about Ukraine without Ukraine, expressing hope that the US president understands this. Mr Trump had previously suggested the meeting could involve swapping of territories for the 'betterment' of both countries. Watch the video in full above.
STV News
an hour ago
- STV News
JD Vance greeted by Palestine protesters as he begins holiday in Scotland
US vice president JD Vance has arrived in Scotland as he continues his family holiday to the UK. Donald Trump's second-in-command landed at Prestwick Airport on Wednesday evening before travelling with a large motorcade to the luxury Carnell Estate near Kilmarnock in East Ayrshire. He was greeted at the resort by dozens of pro-Palestine protesters, who accused him of supporting a 'genocide' by Israel in Gaza. PA Media Police officers surrounded protesters (Craig Meighan/PA). PA Media The demonstraters were kettled by police as they bashed pots and pans, waved Palestine flags and shouted pro-Palestine chants. Police had initially told the protesters they would need to move and that officers would do so if they refused to leave to a different space nearby. Airspace restrictions are in place around the estate until Sunday. PA Media Dozens of pro-Palestine protesters turned up at the resort (Craig Meighan/PA). PA Media Vance will reportedly spend five days in Scotland – the same amount of time his boss did during his trip to the country last month. President Trump split his stay between his golf courses in South Ayrshire and Aberdeenshire, during which time he met the First Minister and Prime Minister. A spokesperson for Police Scotland said: 'This visit requires a significant police operation and we have appropriate resources in place using local, national and specialist officers from across Police Scotland.' PA Media US vice president JD Vance disembarked from an official US plane at Prestwick Airport earlier in the evening (Jane Barlow/PA). PA Media Vance had been holidaying in the Cotswolds, but travelled to the Foreign Secretary's Chevening House retreat in Kent on Friday – and he joined David Lammy for a spot of carp fishing at the countryside estate. Earlier on Wednesday, Mr Vance described the UK-US relationship as 'a beautiful alliance' during a speech at RAF Fairford in Gloucestershire. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
