The Irish Times view on Government spending: a warning to the Cabinet
The decision by the Minister for Public Expenditure, Jack Chambers,
to warn his Cabinet colleagues
that spending overruns must be avoided this year is notable. It remains to be seen, however, whether the spending Ministers will take it seriously. Last year the tacit understanding was there could be no spending clampdown ahead of the general election. It remains to be seen if the issue is taken more seriously this year.
We must presume that Chambers will have the support of Minister for Finance, Paschal Donohoe. But the key issue will be the attitude of Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Tánaiste Simon Harris. If they are not signed up to tighter spending control, then it simply will not happen.
Spending is again running well ahead of schedule this year and the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (Ifac) cautions that a €2 billion overrun could be in prospect. Nor is this new. The Central Bank calculates that spending – excluding once-offs – has grown by 37 per cent since the end of 2021, more than twice what would have occurred had the rule to keep annual spending growth to 5 per cent been adhered to.
This rule, introduced in 2021 , has been more honoured in the breach. True, there have been exceptional circumstances and some tax revenues has been put aside into two funds for the future. While this is welcome, the latest Ifac assessment points out that predictable overruns last year were not included in this year's spending calculations, meaning that they never looked realistic from day one. This is a poor basis for budgeting.
READ MORE
Ireland needs to avoid doubling down on its bets on corporate tax, particularly given the current uncertainties. It is vital , if tax revenues slow, to avoid having to make emergency spending cuts, particularly on key infrastructure spending. The additional State cash is also being injected into an economy already at full capacity.
Better control is needed - and a convincing budget framework replacing the 5 per cent rule. A new medium term budget plan is due – the question is whether anyone takes it seriously.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Average price of a second-hand home in Dublin pushes past €600,000 barrier
The average price of a second-hand home in Dublin has reached €600,047, according to a new report from estate agent DNG . Nationally, the average price of a home increased to €313,453. The average price of second-hand properties in Ireland, excluding Dublin, rose 4.7 per cent in the first half of the year. This compared to 3 per cent in the capital. In the past 12 months, Dublin has seen a marginally slower rate of house price inflation than the rest of the country, as measured by the DNG national price gauge. While Dublin saw an increase in the average second-hand home price of 8 per cent during the period, the average price across the other counties rose by 8.7 per cent. This is broadly in line with Residential Property Price Index figures released in the past week, which found that in the year to April 2025, property prices in Dublin rose by 6.2 per cent and prices outside Dublin were up by 8.6 per cent. READ MORE However, the second-quarter report on home prices found that listed home prices were, on average, 12.3 per cent higher in the second quarter of the year than in the same period in 2024. Apartments in Dublin experienced a 7 per cent increase in average price in the 12 months to June 2025. This rate, however, was significantly faster than the same period one year previously, during which apartment prices rose by 4.2 per cent. Outside of Dublin, house prices were at their highest in the mid-east of the country, with an average house price in June of €439,289. This is an increase of 6.7 per cent in the past year and 4.1 per cent in the first half of 2025. The southeast saw the average price of a house rise 8.6 per cent in annual terms and 5.1 per cent in the first six months of 2025, making it the third highest region at €357,660. The highest regional house-price growth was in the mid-west, which saw prices grow 10.4 per cent in the past year. However, with house prices there standing at €291,160, it remains below the national average. The region with the lowest average housing price is the border region, which rose slightly by 3.7 per cent to €242,426. DNG director of research, Paul Murgatroyd, said the housing market 'continues to be characterised by an excess of demand over supply', noting that housing prices 'continue to climb as a result'. He added: 'That said, however, there has been a welcome increase in the number of homes coming for sale in the Dublin second-hand market in recent months. While this has served to dampen the rate of price growth somewhat, demand has remained robust, particularly from first-time buyers keen to get on the property ladder.' [ What will €299,000 buy in counties Clare and Wexford? Opens in new window ] First-time buyers made up the majority of people purchasing second-hand properties through DNG, accounting for 54 per cent of buyers in the first six months of the year. An additional 19 per cent of home buyers were existing homeowners trading up in the market, with just 5 per cent buying in order to trade down. Keith Lowe, chief executive of DNG, noted there were '12 per cent more homes being advertised for sale' in Dublin in the first half of 2025 compared with the same period in 2024, which he said 'will be good news for those looking to buy'. However, he added it was 'not such positive news for tenants who are likely to see less rental stock available and higher rents'.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Electric car runs out of road
Sir, – I am currently sitting waiting in a queue at the Galway Plaza for one of only two high-speed chargers to come free on my journey on the M6 Galway motorway. I also stopped at an Athlone motorway service station and again all the chargers were occupied. Meanwhile, all the petrol and diesel cars are buzzing around and are filled in 2-3 minutes! The lack of a proper charging infrastructure makes any long distance journey very difficult, if not impossible, in Ireland. It is a national disgrace and flies in the face of the Government's environmental targets and commitments. READ MORE I would strongly urge any perspective buyers of new cars who regularly do long journeys to stay well clear of fully electric vehicles while our charging infrastructure is still so poor. – Yours, etc, BERNARD FARRELLY, Sixmilebridge, Co Clare.
The Journal
5 hours ago
- The Journal
Taoiseach fails to commit to 6am closing time for nightclubs but promises licensing law reform
TAOISEACH MICHEÁL MARTIN has failed to confirm if the government will sign off on 6am closing time for nightclubs. The Programme for Government commits to enacting legislation to update Ireland's licensing laws and promoting the development of a 'modern and diverse night-time economy in harmony with increased town centre living'. However, at the launch of the Dublin City Taskforce roadmap plan to revamp and revitalise the capital, the Taoiseach would not comment on what time he expects nightclubs and pubs will be allowed close at. The previous government committed to allowing nightclubs to open until 6am and pubs to open until 12.30am, stating that the law would be in place before Christmas 2023, but complications with updating the laws significantly delayed the process . Last year, former Taoiseach Leo Varadkar, who was an advocate for the law change, cast doubt over whether reforms to late licensing laws would be introduced in the short term. Further hurdles for the legislation became apparent within the Fine Gael party, when pressure was placed on the new party leader Simon Harris to scrap the idea. Advertisement Senior sources told The Journal earlier this year that despite the bill being drafted and ready to go in the Department of Justice, there is no urgency to progressing the legislation. Asked today about changes to Ireland's licensing laws, the Taoiseach said the nature of nightlife in Ireland is changing, stating 'we do legislatively have to accommodate that change'. Taoiseach says it is complex 'It is very complex. When you begin the process of changing licensing laws. It's not simple. I know that from previous experience in government, but it is something we want to do,' he said. Martin said he wants to ensure people can enjoy a night out properly, without people scrambling around trying to get home. 'So in short, it will be progressed. The minister will come back to us with more detail,' he said. When asked if he the previous promise of a 6am close for nightclubs is on the cards, Martin would said he would not get into specifics. 'Certainly the nighttime economy is an important part and we will work with all the stakeholders,' said Martin, who promise the the legislation will be brought forward. Harris said: 'I think the concerns a number of us had in the last government is we need to tease our way through this.' Any change to Ireland's licensing law must be done in an 'integrated manner', he said. Related Reads Laws allowing nightclubs to stay open later put on the long finger by government Andrea Horan: Dancing 'til dawn is a valid human pursuit - let's stop being afraid of the night 'Delighted' ... 'badly needed' - Positive early reaction to late-night club opening change A city that opens later has to have transport later and has to have police on the streets at that time, said the Tánaiste. The 'whole picture in the round' must be considered, he said, stating that it is not solely about the opening hour of a nightclub. 'It's actually about how do people get home safely after they have left the nightclub, what time do the buses run to, what's the taxi service like? What's the police presence like? So when I know Jim O'Callaghan will weigh all this up,' he said. Give Us The Night, a volunteer group of professionals campaigning for changes in Irish nightlife, has said that allowing later opening times will bring new opportunities for performers. It has previously said Ireland's 89 nightclubs should be permitted to serve until 5am, with dancing allowed up to 6am, stating that would not even be in line with the European average, but would be an improvement. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
