Glasgow heritage groups slam approval of O2 ABC site plans
They've also called on the Scottish Government to reverse the approval, which will see the building of a nine-story mixed-use development.
The Glasgow School of Art has also called on Ministers to refuse the plans, stating that the approval "places their commitment to deliver the faithful reinstatement of the Mackintosh Building as a fully utilised purpose-designed art school at significant risk."
The development was presented to the planning committee at a meeting today, June 17, and a vote of eight to two approved the plans.
Stuart Robertson, director of the Charles Rennie Mackintosh Society, said, "I am really disappointed by the Planning Committee's decision to allow this proposal to go through.
"It is a very poor design, and I feel the developers have pushed boundaries, submitting revised plans that, while seemingly minor, collectively have created a situation where the planning department had little option but to approve this development.
Glasgow heritage groups slam approval of O2 ABC site plans (Image: Vita Group) "The Committee seemed to have reservations about the proposals, but were more concerned about leaving the area undeveloped.
"Glasgow City Council has missed a trick here. There was an opportunity to create something truly special on this site.
"The Scottish Government needs to step in and overturn this decision.
"Mackintosh and Glasgow deserves better."
READ MORE: Glasgow O2 ABC site plans approved for student accommodation
READ MORE: 'So depressing': Glasgow reacts to O2 ABC site plan
READ MORE: O2 ABC site owners clash with Glasgow School of Art
Niall Murphy, director of Glasgow City Heritage Trust, echoed Stuart's disappointment at the approval.
He said: "Given the acknowledged negative impact on Charles Rennie Mackintosh's Glasgow School of Art, Alexander 'Greek' Thomson's Grecian Chambers (now the CCA) and the Glasgow Central Conservation Area more broadly, I think this is a disappointing outcome for Glasgow's heritage.
"Nevertheless, we live in a democracy, and the councillors on the Planning Applications Committee decided that the regeneration of Sauchiehall Street was more important to Glasgow. I must respect their decision.
"Given the issues of national significance raised by Historic Environment Scotland, it will be interesting to see if Scottish Ministers call it in."
The approved proposal (Image: Vita Group)
Professor Penny Macbeth, director and principal of the Glasgow School of Art, also called on the government to reverse the approval.
She said: "The objection by Historic Environment Scotland does now require the approval by Glasgow City Council to be referred to Scottish Ministers.
"We hope that Ministers taking cognisance of the significant impact to the internationally important Mackintosh Building and its rebuilding, will exercise their powers purposefully, acknowledging that the setting, character and function of the Mackintosh Building is unacceptably compromised."
Stuart Robertson previously told us that the proposal was "so depressing" and was not swayed by anything said in today's meeting.
Stuart added: "As highlighted in my previous comments, this development is vastly over-scaled and does not meet development plan policy.
"This approval places the commitment to the rebuilding of the Mackintosh Building at significant risk and will set a dangerous precedent for our built heritage.
"Look at the M&S development. After securing planning permission, the developer puts it on the market. We could see the same happen here.
"The student housing sector needs to have a more robust public oversight.
"Rather than relying on speculative delivery and developer-led policy formation, it may be time to reassert a civic-led approach that places the needs of communities, students, and heritage on an equal footing."
The cast iron pieces will be displayed in the new building (Image: Newsquest/Gordon Terris) Niall found a silver lining in one of the conditions set: that part of the portico of the O2 ABC would be displayed to the public in the development.
He said: "On the positive side, I welcome the amended condition to see the incorporation of the Walter Macfarlane cast iron screen from the former ABC Cinema within the proposed development.
"It will be interesting to see how the screen will be respectfully installed given the constrained height within the new building; however, it is a significant artefact with regards to Glasgow's cast iron technologies and has strong social value too.
"Therefore, it being back on public display once more is worth celebrating."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
33 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Scottish Government urged to introduce minimum income
The independent report, which was commissioned by the Scottish Government, was produced by an expert group featuring representatives from 16 leading charities and anti-poverty organisations while a separate strategy group has been chaired by Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville with members made up from MSPs in all five main parties in Holyrood. Recommending a three-stage approach to achieving this, the report outlines a series of devolved measures which can be taken by the next Scottish Government between 2026 and 2031 to strengthen the existing safety net. Read More: This includes action in the near term, a pilot project to test and learn from, as well as doubling the Scottish Child Payment to £55 per week by 2031 and an effective end to the 'punitive' sanctions, limits and freezes in the welfare system – moving instead to a system based on a guarantee of support. The group has recommended that in the next Scottish Parliament, a pilot scheme is established with an interim minimum income guarantee payment to be established by 2036, set at the relative poverty line. Based on 2024/25 prices, the level would be £11,500 for a single adult, with more for couples and parents, if they have no other sources of income. This may require direct investment of up to £5.9 billion per year if introduced tomorrow, but with economic growth and improvements in social security across the UK between now and 2036, this could be reduced significantly ahead of introduction, the report says. In addition, the harm caused to Scotland's economy by poverty is estimated to be at least £2.4bn per year. The first steps towards a minimum income guarantee, as proposed by the expert group, involve increasing the Scottish Child Payment, scrapping the two-child cap on benefits, and ending the five-week wait for first Universal Credit payments. This could cost £671 million per year by 2030/31, in today's prices, or just over £300 million of additional spending if the UK Government scraps the two-child limit and ends the five-week wait for Universal Credit. This could be funded through anticipated increases in Scotland's block grant, and if additional revenue is required beyond this, the expert group believes council tax should be reformed to create a more progressive local tax that can fairly close the gap between the money raised by council tax in Scotland and the equivalent higher levels of revenue in England. The second stage of the report's recommendations sets out proposals for a new cooperation commission between the UK and Scottish governments, with flexibilities or additional powers to deliver a minimum income guarantee in Scotland. Chair of the minimum income guarantee expert group, Russell Gunson from The Robertson Trust, said: 'If we've learned one thing in recent years it's that we can all need a helping hand from time to time. A minimum income guarantee could be transformative, putting in place a universal guarantee that's there for everyone in Scotland. Russell Gunson of the Robertson Trust (Image: Quantum Communications) 'Given the levels of poverty and inequality we see, we must act urgently. 'With technological change and an ageing population, we need to build security for all to make sure we can take the economic opportunities in front of Scotland. A minimum income guarantee could future-proof Scotland. 'With greater financial security, we can empower our people to live well, meet their potential and build a better future for themselves, for their families and for the country as a whole. 'The first steps we set out over the next five years are affordable in the current context, and doable within existing powers. We can't wait – and we don't need to wait – to begin to make the changes outlined in this report. 'We know poverty, inequality, and insecurity costs us dearly in financial terms and in lost potential. If things don't change, at scale, we will simply deliver the status quo, with the deepening poverty, stark inequalities and rising mistrust and disaffection that comes with that. 'Ultimately, ending poverty and inequality in our society requires investment. Trust in politics is low at the moment because the scale of action required to build security for everyone in society is underplayed. 'A minimum income guarantee is a big idea that will build that security.' Satwat Rehman, one of the members of the group and chief executive of One Parent Families Scotland, said a minimum income guarantee would be 'lifechanging for the families we support'. He said: 'Single parents – 90% of whom are women – are among the most economically vulnerable in our society, with 41% living in poverty. 'Too many single parents are trapped in low-paid, part-time, insecure work while navigating complex and inadequate support systems that fail to reflect the true cost of raising a family alone. 'A minimum income guarantee would provide a lifeline, ensuring no single-parent household falls below a dignified minimum income – whether in or out of work, studying or training – and ensure families and children thrive and not just survive.'
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
How could politics shape the Scotland of 2050?
Scotland's politicians are all pretty focused on 2026 right now, with a Holyrood election less than a year should they be concentrating on longer-term objectives - and what Scotland could look like in 2050?A conference in Edinburgh invited leaders to think beyond the short-termism of the five-year electoral in an era where many voters feel politicians are all the same, perhaps we can learn more about their policies via their ultimate vision for the country. Scotland and the world are likely to be largely unrecognisable by back at the last 25 years and think about how the way we work, communicate, socialise and navigate our way through our lives has advances are a massive part of this. At the turn of the millennium you had to ask your mum to get off the landline phone so you could use the dial-up the WiFi hub connected to every other item in the house is probably the only thing plugged into that phone that change is not slowing down - it is accelerating exponentially. Algorithms already help decide what we watch on TV, who we date, and what content scrolls through our social media it so hard to imagine that in a few years' time they'll be driving our cars, diagnosing our illnesses and managing our financial markets?Politicians are always very keen to talk about new technology; nobody wants to be left Scottish government is going to set up its own AI agency to make sure innovations are shared across the public is Scotland well placed to forge into a new digital future?At Scotland 2050, Michael McLaughlin from legal firm Shoosmiths talked about a "massive skills gap" in recently represented a company looking to hire 70 developers for a big tech project; they ended up finding 85% of them argues that politicians and the private sector need to "get round the table and decide what we want to be good at in 25 years' time" - to prioritise four or five sectors and encourage and train people to work in Spowage from the Fraser of Allander Institute also urged leaders to focus on the economic strengths we already have - like financial services and world-class universities - rather than chasing fads. If there was one theme which came from the business leaders involved in the event, it was the need for consistency and policy certainty. Firms simply will not invest in jobs, infrastructure or training without that investment and growing the economy is a priority shared by all political parties. But it is striking how different their approaches are to achieving SNP has long had big government at its heart, proudly championing universal allowances, interventions in the lives of citizens and in the market and higher taxes to pay for contrast the Conservatives are more keen to slim down the size of the state while cutting taxes and "red tape".Meanwhile Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar popped up at the conference to argue for something in the middle - cutting taxes, but replacing that with income from economic growth which would maintain public intelligence is a key example of a buzzword field which politicians love to talk about, but which will need a concerted effort to use in a joined-up point about skills and focus is an important one, given finite resources - but the conference also heard that there are opportunities which could be Airey from German energy giant EnBW pointed out that Scotland produces more energy than it uses, but that the current state of the national grid makes it hard to transfer it down that infrastructure is a UK government priority, but Mr Airey suggested that Scotland could also look to house power-hungry AI data centres, which are best located in cold could put us at the heart of an industry set for exponential growth - and the excess heat from the servers could even be funnelled to nearby homes and businesses. Using Scotland's potential for renewable energy production as a cornerstone of the economy of 2050 was also highlighted by John Swinney, with the first minister suggesting it could lead to cheaper food production as well as products being made closer to offered a vision of "energy rich Scotland meaning energy rich Scots".Energy and climate more generally is certainly an area where the Scottish government has set ambitious goals - although it has also routinely fallen short of insist they are still on track to reach net zero carbon emissions by 2045 - five years ahead of the UK government goal of on from fossil fuels will represent a seismic change - the oil industry still provides tens of thousands of jobs and billions of pounds of economic activity; household energy prices are set based on the price of will have plenty of knock-on effects too, like the move to electric cars. The sale of new petrol and diesel vehicles is to be phased out by 2035, so by 2050 there will be next to none left on the is well-placed to tap into alternative forms of energy, with a wealth of renewable potential from wind and wave this is still an area where there are stark differences in the vision of the Swinney's SNP is not quite the same party that declared a climate emergency and brought the Greens into government, but it is still clear that it is prioritising renewable detail beyond that is difficult to pin down, because the government has still not published its long-promised energy also has a clear goal of phasing out oil and gas, but is pushing for a bigger move towards nuclear energy - something the SNP Conservatives meanwhile have gone in the opposite direction, pushing opposition to the difficult trade-offs involved in the transition to net zero. Something we can't ignore in all of this is that Scotland's population is going to look very different by 2050 the National Records of Scotland has projected forward to 2047, and thinks we are on track for modest population the average age of Scots is projected to increase, with the number of people over 75 set to grow by 341,300, up against falls in the numbers under 15 (down by 79,900) and aged 16 to 29 (down by 57,300).That puts increasing strain on the state, given current commitments to things like free personal care and the "triple lock" on are issues which are inextricably knitted into questions about our future economy and workforce - and which politicians are notoriously shy of grappling with, given older people reliably turn up to with Holyrood's social security bill set to be £2bn higher than the block grant coming from Westminster by 2030, questions about how sustainable this is are Freeman was the social security secretary who set up Scotland's devolved welfare agency, and even she says that governments - including the one she served in - "dodge the decision" about what the care system should look like and how it should be paid said governments of all stripes need to have "proper conversations" with voters about big issues - including things like the triple lock, which she said was "well worth a debate".Ms Freeman also noted that the danger of short-term political promises is that increasingly, "people just don't believe them". Anything is possible That feels particularly true for younger conference reflected that many young people are finding it harder to make their way in the world than their parents' generation - from the job market to the housing emergency, to the constant scrutiny of social Barnes, from the John Smith Centre, warned that some young people have so little optimism for the future that they are losing faith in democratic politics group recently ran a poll asking young people whether they would prefer dictatorship to democracy, and 27% of respondents chose an extreme example, but it rings true after a decade where the defining political force in almost every corner of the world has been is inherently linked to an era of exponential change - it is unsettling, and it leaves people grasping for they feel the government of the day isn't delivering stability or certainty, it isn't surprising that dissatisfaction with institutions is growing - or that some are willing to throw votes behind those who promise to listen to them, and to shake things Swinney has certainly detected this mood; he talked about "listening to the public and addressing the strain they feel on the cost of living".Over the longer term his answer, unsurprisingly enough, is we didn't learn anything new about the parties' positions during this conference - Swinney didn't offer any new insight on how the SNP might force the matter if its calls for a referendum continue to be blanked, for when we think again about how much things have changed over the last few decades - devolution, Brexit, five prime ministers in five years - and how much our unpredictable world is likely to change again by 2050, it's fair to conclude that just about anything is possible.
Edinburgh Reporter
4 hours ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Essential Documents to Prepare During Major Life Changes
Major life events such as marriage, divorce, buying property, or welcoming a child almost always require specific legal documents. Each transition requires paperwork that protects your interests and helps processes move forward without unexpected problems. Reports from the Scottish Legal Aid Board highlight a steady demand for legal support in family matters, with civil legal assistance remaining an important area. Legal paperwork plays a central role during major life changes, especially in family law matters. Correct and organised documentation supports important decisions, prevents disputes, and provides structure when circumstances shift. Solicitors with experience in family law can guide individuals through detailed forms and requirements, helping avoid the types of delays and disputes regularly reported by the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service. Professional guidance can make a marked difference when navigating complex documentation requirements during major life transitions. Key Legal Documents for Marriage and Civil Partnerships When preparing for marriage or civil partnership in Scotland, several types of paperwork should be tackled early. Planning often focuses on the event itself, but safeguarding both parties requires attention to the correct supporting documents. Registrars across Scotland require specific forms submitted within set timeframes. Initial documentation includes marriage or civil partnership notice forms. These must be submitted to the local registrar with original birth certificates and proof of address. Those with previous marriages must submit divorce decrees or dissolution certificates. Missing papers could delay or prevent registration of the marriage. Full-service family law offices can help ensure forms are properly completed, reducing administrative hassle and potential delays. Steps to Protect Your Interests: Prenuptial and Postnuptial Agreements Prenuptial agreements have become more common in Scotland, particularly when one or both parties have large assets, children from previous relationships, or own a business. These agreements specify how assets, debts, and property would be divided if the marriage or partnership ends. For a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement, both parties should seek independent legal advice. Mistakes often occur when couples use informal agreements or templates found online that do not comply with Scottish legal requirements. Both parties must disclose their assets fully to avoid agreements being set aside later. Updating Wills and Beneficiaries After Marriage or Partnership Marriage or civil partnership in Scotland automatically revokes previous wills. The exception is when a will states it was drafted with that specific marriage in mind. Without updating your will, assets may not pass to intended beneficiaries, potentially causing family disagreements over an estate. Beneficiary nominations on pensions, life assurance, and investment accounts must also be reviewed, as these do not automatically update because of a marriage. Request the latest policy documentation from each provider and submit updated nomination forms if necessary. Documentation Needs During Separation and Divorce During separation or divorce, accurate paperwork is necessary for safeguarding future interests. Every case must start with a detailed financial statement, which involves collecting recent bank statements, wage slips, mortgage documents, and property valuations. Incomplete financial disclosures often cause delays in contested divorce matters. For those with children, preparing documents showing current childcare arrangements and proposed schedules is important. Professionals recommend using a written parenting plan that addresses who the children will live with, handover routines, and decision-making authority. Its essential when going through something like this, to use a solicitor with full service family law offices, to remove as much of the stress as possible. Step-by-Step Preparation for Divorce and Separation Documents Prepare a complete list of all assets and debts, using independent valuations when needed. Next, gather documentation for pensions, including the most recent statements for each scheme. For jointly owned properties, request current title deeds and understand the legal options for dividing or transferring equity. Draft a minute of agreement if terms can be settled amicably, spelling out the division of property, assets, and any ongoing maintenance payments. This formal document, when registered, makes the agreement binding in the Scottish courts. Correcting Common Errors in Separation Paperwork One recurring problem in Scottish separations involves incomplete financial disclosures. This often leads to delayed proceedings or agreements being challenged later. Solicitors recommend double-checking all figures, using professional valuations where possible, and requesting full pension sharing statements. Another issue is failing to update property records after division or sale. Every change must be formally registered with the Land Register of Scotland using up-to-date transfer forms. Incorrect or missing forms cause many rejected submissions each year. Legal Paperwork for New Parents and Guardians New parents in Scotland must register their child's birth within 21 days, establishing legal parenthood and assigning parental responsibilities. Late registration can disrupt access to child benefits and delay school enrolment for families. Parents need to contact their local registration office to book an appointment. Both parents' names can appear on the birth certificate when they attend the appointment together with proof of identity and the child's NHS birth card. If unmarried, they must complete Form 27 at the registration office. Beyond birth registration, parents should prepare wills that appoint guardians for children. This determines who would care for children if both parents died before the children reach adulthood. Without named guardians, courts decide, which can lead to disputes. Documenting Parental Rights for Non-Biological and Separated Parents Specific paperwork ensures all responsible adults have legal rights. Adoption orders, parental responsibility agreements for step-parents, or surrogacy parental orders are required for those who are not biological parents. Failing to formalise these arrangements restricts adults' ability to make medical and educational decisions. When parents do not live together, creating formal child maintenance agreements is also important. Written agreements detailing financial support help set clear expectations and reduce the likelihood of future disputes about payments. End-of-Life Documentation Everyone Should Consider Preparing for what happens if someone cannot make decisions for themselves or after they pass away should be part of everyone's planning. Many adults have not created a valid will, risking default outcomes that may not align with their wishes. Key End-of-Life Documents for Scottish Residents Power of Attorney (PoA) arrangements play an important role at any adult age. The two main types are continuing PoA, which covers property and finances, and welfare PoA, which specifies health and personal welfare decisions. Setting up both ensures trusted individuals can step in if someone becomes incapacitated. Advance Medical Directives allow a person to detail their wishes regarding future medical care if they later become unable to communicate decisions. Although not legally binding in Scotland, they provide clear instruction to doctors and family members about personal preferences for treatments. Wills, Inheritance Tax, and Asset Distribution Wills are at the heart of end-of-life planning. Without a current will, assets will be distributed according to the default rules of intestacy, which may not match individual family situations. Drafting or updating a will enables people to decide who receives property, money, or personal items. Inheritance tax planning documents can help reduce future tax bills for beneficiaries. This may include keeping detailed records of gifts, establishing trusts, or seeking advice on insurance. Regular consultation with legal advisers ensures strategies remain compliant and effective. Essential Document Preparation Timeline Preparing these documents at the right time is important. Marriage documents should be addressed before the wedding or shortly after. Registering a child's birth and updating wills within three months helps prevent benefits disruption and ensures compliance with local regulations. Separation paperwork should begin once the decision to separate is made. End-of-life documents are best created while in good health, typically starting in the 30s or 40s with regular reviews every few years. This helps keep them current with changing circumstances and wishes. Document Storage Best Practices Proper storage of legal documents ensures they are available when needed. National Records of Scotland recommend keeping originals in a fireproof, waterproof container or a safe deposit box. Digital copies stored securely online serve as practical backups. Information about document locations should be shared with trusted family members or a solicitor. Families who provide clear document instructions encounter fewer delays during probate or family law proceedings. Regular reviews and updates of all legal documents are important, especially after major life changes. Like this: Like Related
