logo
Will America's Unbalanced Trade Doom the Dollar?

Will America's Unbalanced Trade Doom the Dollar?

The Trump administration and Wall Street haven't exactly seen eye to eye, but they are starting to agree on one thing: America's trade deficits are a problem and the dollar might not stabilize until imports and exports realign.
But in reality, it is more likely that the currency's fate depends on the success of the 'Magnificent Seven' stocks.
In April, the trade deficit halved, official data showed Thursday. This was largely because companies had stocked up in March ahead of 'Liberation Day' tariffs, but the 19.9% drop in imports still exceeded economists' expectations. Declines in imports of cars, cellphones and other goods suggest tariffs are helping narrow the deficit.
With the WSJ Dollar Index down 7% this year, many investors who are concerned about the Republican Party's tax-and-spending bill see a connection between the trade and fiscal deficits, echoing comments by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent.
'America's net external asset position is the best metric to measure fiscal space, and this is on a rapidly deteriorating path,' Deutsche Bank economist George Saravelos recently wrote to clients.
Across wealthy countries, the cost of government borrowing tracks the balance of assets minus liabilities with the rest of the world, called the net international investment position. Switzerland, a net holder of foreign assets, has 10-year yields of 0.4%. The U.S., by contrast, is the biggest net external debtor among top nations, with a negative investment position equal to 88% of gross domestic product last year. It borrows at 4.5%.
Trade is central to the discussion: Accounting-wise, America borrows from foreigners whenever there is a gap between imports and exports. The negative external balance mainly reflects trade deficits accumulated since the 1990s.
In one regard, the link with the budget deficit is clear: If, on net, companies and consumers spend more abroad, demand is weaker at home and unemployment could rise, so the government has an incentive to fill the gap. Anticipating inflation, central banks in importer nations keep interest rates higher.
Yet the orthodox prediction is that a large buildup of external liabilities eventually leads foreigners to stop refinancing them, or the currency to readjust, and it hasn't panned out. It appeared to work in the U.S. in the 2000s when, as trade deficits widened, the dollar weakened and boosted the value of U.S. assets held abroad, improving the external balance.
Starting a decade ago, however, imbalances worsened again, with a dollar surge exacerbating them.
For President Trump's chief economic adviser, Stephen Miran, and economists such as Peking University's Michael Pettis, the explanation is the dollar's 'global reserve' role. They argue that it prompts exporter nations with excess savings, particularly China, to invest in U.S. assets, with the resulting capital inflows keeping the dollar overvalued and forcing either the federal government or Americans themselves to take on excessive debt—the latter having caused the 2008 financial crisis.
But this isn't quite right. When foreign companies sell more to the U.S. than they buy, they end up with dollars in cash, which is a U.S. liability. But this is just payment for purchases, it doesn't imply U.S. importers literally borrowing from overseas. Foreign exporters aren't refinancing ever-expanding debt: They are selling products and accumulating money in the bank, with little reason to stop—even if those dollars are eventually recycled into other investments.
Meanwhile, actual lending by foreign investors to Americans isn't recorded in net external balances because there is no net increase in liabilities: The U.S. issues debt but receives cash in return. This is why the link between external deficits and credit booms is actually hard to find.
Take Britain's vote to leave the European Union in 2016: The pound crashed instantly as investors priced in diminished growth expectations, yet trade and debt refinancing carried on uninterrupted despite a huge external deficit.
Indeed, changes in exchange rates and net international investment positions have shown no correlation over the past decade outside of the U.S. either, according to cross-country data from the International Monetary Fund.
As for the greenback's special role, it has coexisted with both weak and strong exchange rates since President Richard Nixon suspended gold convertibility in 1971. Dollar appreciation since 2014 has coincided with foreign Treasury holdings staying flat.
To be sure, there are cases in which foreign inflows push up the currency and worsen the external position. Conversely, the current weakening of the dollar could help narrow the deficit.
The point, though, is that exchange rates are driven by many factors. Forecasts of U.S. return-on-equity have strongly correlated with the dollar's value over the past decade, while also worsening the net international investment position: Foreigners have poured into U.S. stocks—counted as liabilities—that have surged thanks to the economy's strength and Silicon Valley's global edge, reflected in April's $25.8 billion services surplus. It is hard to argue that higher returns should lead a country's currency to depreciate.
What matters now is whether the artificial-intelligence boom and a resilient job market—despite hiring slowing mildly in May—can offset steep equity valuations, erratic tariff policies, and Section 899 of the new spending bill, which threatens to raise taxes on foreign investors.
The dollar's struggle to remain at historically elevated levels doesn't depend on rebalancing anything.
Write to Jon Sindreu at jon.sindreu@wsj.com

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Buy LRCX Stock At $90?
Buy LRCX Stock At $90?

Forbes

time15 minutes ago

  • Forbes

Buy LRCX Stock At $90?

CANADA - 2025/02/10: In this photo illustration, the Lam Research Corporation logo is seen displayed ... More on a smartphone screen. (Photo Illustration by Thomas Fuller/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images) Lam Research (NASDAQ:LRCX) stock has experienced a notable increase this year, rising by 22% and significantly outperforming the S&P 500's modest gain of 2%. This remarkable performance can be attributed primarily to the company's solid quarterly results, fueled by strong foundry revenues and improving margins. Given this recent surge, the crucial question for investors is whether LRCX is still a compelling purchase. We believe it is. Despite its current price hovering around $90, we see little reason for worry regarding LRCX stock, particularly in light of its reasonable valuation. Our conclusion stems from a thorough analysis of Lam Research's operational performance in recent years, along with its current and historical financial health. We have assessed the company based on several core metrics: Growth, Profitability, Financial Stability, and Downturn Resilience. Our results show that Lam Research demonstrates exceptionally strong operating performance and financial stability, positioning it as an attractive investment option. However, for those investors who prefer lower volatility compared to individual stocks, the Trefis High Quality portfolio offers an alternative — it has outperformed the S&P 500 and delivered returns exceeding 91% since its inception. Separately, see – What's Better – Circle Stock Or Bitcoin? When considering what you pay per dollar of sales or profit, LRCX stock appears slightly overvalued in relation to the wider market. Lam Research's Revenues have demonstrated significant growth over the past few years. Lam Research's profit margins are significantly higher than those of most companies in the Trefis coverage universe. Lam Research's balance sheet appears very robust. LRCX stock has underperformed compared to the benchmark S&P 500 index during some recent downturns. Concerned about how a market crash could affect LRCX stock? Our dashboard How Low Can Lam Research Stock Go In A Market Crash? provides an in-depth analysis of how the stock has fared during and after previous market crashes. In conclusion, Lam Research's performance across the discussed metrics is summarized as follows: Overall, Lam Research has demonstrated excellent performance across the critical metrics we evaluated. We believe this strong operational and financial health is not entirely reflected in the current moderate valuation of the stock, making LRCX an appealing investment. This further reinforces our belief that Lam Research is a solid investment choice. Although LRCX stock appears promising, investing in a single stock can entail risks. Conversely, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio, comprising 30 stocks, has consistently outperformed the S&P 500 over the past 4-year period. Why is that the case? As a group, HQ Portfolio stocks yielded better returns with lower risk in comparison to the benchmark index; providing a smoother ride, as shown in HQ Portfolio performance metrics.

BlackRock, Goldman Scale Up Tax Trades in $3 Trillion SMA Boom
BlackRock, Goldman Scale Up Tax Trades in $3 Trillion SMA Boom

Bloomberg

time18 minutes ago

  • Bloomberg

BlackRock, Goldman Scale Up Tax Trades in $3 Trillion SMA Boom

This year's stock market turbulence has punished ordinary investors. But for the wealthy, it's opened up fresh opportunities to convert equity swings into tax breaks — fueling a growing Wall Street business that turns volatility into a financial advantage. BlackRock Inc., Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and Morgan Stanley are among firms scaling up a strategy known as tax-loss harvesting, typically offered through customized portfolios called separately managed accounts. When markets drop, managers sell stocks trading below their purchase price to realize losses. Those losses offset gains elsewhere in a portfolio, reducing clients' tax liabilities while maintaining overall portfolio exposure.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store