What deal might emerge from Trump-Putin summit and could it hold?
European leaders and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy plan to speak with Trump on Wednesday amid fears that Washington, hitherto Ukraine's leading arms supplier, may seek to dictate unfavourable peace terms to Kyiv.
Trump said last Friday that there would be "some swapping of territories to the betterment of both".
This prompted consternation in Kyiv and European capitals that Russia could be rewarded for 11 years of efforts - the last three in full-blown war - to seize Ukrainian land. It occupies about 19% of Ukraine. Ukraine controls no Russian territory.
"It's a reasonable concern to think that Trump will be bamboozled by Putin and cut a terrible deal at Ukraine's expense," said Daniel Fried, a former senior U.S. diplomat now with the Atlantic Council think-tank.
But "better outcomes" for Ukraine were possible if Trump and his team "wake up to the fact that Putin is still playing them".
One could entail agreeing an "armistice line" instead of a transfer of territory, with only de facto - not legal - recognition of Russia's current gains.
Any sustainable peace deal would also have to tackle such issues as future security guarantees for Ukraine, its aspirations to join NATO, the restrictions demanded by Moscow on the size of its military, and the future of Western sanctions on Russia.
Trump has not commented on those issues since announcing the summit with Putin, though his administration has said Ukraine cannot join NATO.
Diplomats say there is an outside possibility that Trump might instead strike a unilateral deal with Putin, prioritising lucrative energy contracts and potential arms control accords. Trump himself has said he might conclude in Alaska that a Ukraine peace deal cannot be done.
The White House did not respond to a request for comment on the possibility of Trump clinching a unilateral deal with Putin.
Trump would face strong resistance from Zelenskiy and his European allies if any deal expected Ukraine to cede territory.
Zelenskiy says Ukraine's constitution prohibits such an outcome unless there is a referendum to change it.
Trump could try to coerce Kyiv to accept such a deal by threatening to stop arms supplies and intelligence sharing.
But analysts say there is more chance Ukraine might accept a freezing of battlelines and an unstable, legally non-binding partition.
One European official told Reuters that, even if Trump did renege on recent promises to resume arms supplies to Ukraine, he was likely to continue allowing Europe to buy U.S. weapons on Ukraine's behalf.
"The loss of U.S. intelligence capabilities would be the hardest element to replace. Europe can't even come close to providing that support," said the official, speaking on condition of anonymity.
There would be big political risks in the U.S. for Trump in abandoning Ukraine, said John Herbst, a former U.S. ambassador to Kyiv, now with the Atlantic Council.
This would portray him as "an accomplice in Putin's rape of Ukraine ... I don't think Trump wants to be seen that way, for sure", he said.
Despite his strong political position at home, Trump would also come under fire even from parts of the American right if he were to be seen as caving in to Russia.
"To reward Putin ... would be to send the exact opposite message that we must be sending to dictators, and would-be-dictators, across the globe," Brian Fitzpatrick, a Republican lawmaker and former FBI agent, said on X last week.
EU member states said on Tuesday that Ukraine must be free to decide its own future and that they were ready to contribute further to security guarantees for Kyiv.
Oana Lungescu, a former NATO spokesperson now with the RUSI think-tank, said European states must move much faster to arm Ukraine, and start EU accession talks in September.
Jana Kobzova, senior policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, said that "... if an unacceptable deal emerges from Alaska, European capitals will go into yet another diplomatic and charm offensive vis-a-vis Trump".
"European leaders are increasingly aware that the future of Ukraine's security is inseparable from that of the rest of Europe - and they can't let Putin alone decide its future shape and form."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
10 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
At least 25 killed by Israeli gunfire while seeking aid, say health officials
Israeli gunfire killed at least 25 people seeking aid on Wednesday, health officials and witnesses said, while Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Israel will 'allow' Palestinians to leave during an upcoming military offensive in Gaza. Mr Netanyahu wants to realise US President Donald Trump's vision of relocating much of Gaza's population of more than two million people through what the prime minister refers to as 'voluntary migration' – and what critics have warned could be ethnic cleansing. Advertisement 'Give them the opportunity to leave! First, from combat zones, and also from the Strip if they want,' Mr Netanyahu said in an interview aired on Tuesday with i24, an Israeli TV station, to discuss the planned offensive in some of the territory's most populated areas including Gaza City. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a press conference (Abir Sultan/Pool Photo via AP) 'We are not pushing them out but allowing them to leave.' Witnesses and staff at Nasser and Awda hospitals, which received the bodies, said people were killed on their way to aid distribution sites and while awaiting convoys entering the Gaza Strip. Israel did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Advertisement Efforts to revive ceasefire talks have resumed after apparently breaking down last month. Hamas and Egyptian officials were set to meet on Wednesday to discuss efforts to stop the war, according to Hamas official Taher al-Nounou. Israel has no plans to send its negotiating team to talks in Cairo, the prime minister's office said. Israel has said it will widen its military offensive against Hamas to the areas of Gaza that it does not yet control, where most of the territory's residents have sought refuge. Advertisement Those plans have sparked international condemnation and criticism within Israel, and could be intended to raise pressure on Hamas to reach a ceasefire. Israeli soldiers use binoculars to look at damaged buildings in the Gaza Strip, from southern Israel (Ariel Schalit/AP) The militants still hold 50 hostages taken in the October 7 2023 attack that sparked the war. Israel believes around 20 of them are alive. Mr Netanyahu was asked by i24 News if the window had closed on a partial ceasefire deal and he responded that he wanted all of the hostages back, alive and dead. Advertisement Egyptian foreign minister Badr Abdelatty told reporters that Cairo is still trying to advance an earlier proposal for an initial 60-day ceasefire, the release of some hostages and an influx of humanitarian aid before further talks on a lasting truce. Hamas has long called for a comprehensive deal but says it will only release the remaining hostages in return for the release of Palestinians imprisoned by Israel, a lasting ceasefire and an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. The militant group has refused to lay down its arms as Israel has demanded. Israel and South Sudan are in talks about relocating Palestinians to the war-torn East African nation, The Associated Press (AP) reported on Tuesday. Advertisement The office of Israel's deputy foreign minister Sharren Haskel said on Wednesday that she was arriving in South Sudan for a series of meetings in the first visit by a senior government official to the country, but she did not plan to broach the subject of moving Palestinians. Damaged humanitarian aid for Palestinians in Gaza scattered on the ground next to the border with the Gaza Strip near the Kissufim crossing in southern Israel (Ariel Schalit/AP) In a statement on Wednesday, South Sudan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs called reports that it was engaging in discussions with Israel about resettling Palestinians baseless. The AP previously reported that US and Israel have reached out to officials of three East African governments to discuss using their territories as potential destinations for moving Palestinians uprooted from Gaza. Among those killed while seeking aid on Wednesday were 14 Palestinians in the Teina area approximately 3km away from a food distribution site run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), according to staff at Nasser hospital. Hashim Shamalah, who was trying to reach the sites, said Israeli troops fired towards them as people tried to get through. Many were shot and fell while fleeing, he said. Five other Palestinians were killed by Israeli gunfire while trying to reach another GHF distribution site in the Netzarim corridor area, according to Awda hospital and witnesses. The US and Israel support the GHF, an American contractor, as an alternative to the United Nations, which they say allows Hamas to siphon off aid. The UN, which has delivered aid throughout Gaza for decades when conditions allow, denies the allegations. Trucks carrying humanitarian aid for Palestinians in Gaza move along the border with the Gaza Strip in southern Israel (Ariel Schalit/AP) The GHF said there were no incidents at or near its sites on Wednesday. There are aid convoys from other groups that travel within 100 metres (328ft) of GHF sites and draw large crowds attempting to loot them. An overwhelming majority of violent incidents over the past few weeks have been related to those other aid convoys, the organisation said, noting it has provided more than one million meals to aid seekers. At least six other people were killed by Israeli fire waiting for aid trucks close to the Morag corridor, which separates parts of southern Gaza, Nasser hospital said. The UN and food security experts have warned starvation and malnutrition in Gaza are at the highest levels since the war began. UN spokesman Stephane Dujarric on Tuesday reported the warning from the World Food Programme and said the Gaza Health Ministry told UN staff in Gaza that five people died over the previous 24 hours from malnutrition and starvation. Gaza's Health Ministry says 106 children have died of malnutrition-related causes during the war and 129 adults have died since late June when the ministry started to count deaths among this age group. The UN and its humanitarian partners are doing everything possible to bring aid into Gaza, Mr Dujarric said, but still face significant delays and impediments from Israeli authorities who prevent the delivery of food and other essentials at the scale needed. A Palestinian boy after collecting water from a distribution point in Gaza City (Jehad Alshrafi/AP) Hamas-led militants abducted 251 people and killed around 1,200 people, mostly civilians, in the 2023 attack. Most of the hostages have been released in ceasefires or other deals. Israel's air and ground offensive has since displaced most of Gaza's population, destroyed vast areas and pushed the territory towards famine. The offensive has killed more than 61,700 Palestinians, according to the Gaza Health Ministry, which does not say how many were fighters or civilians but says around half were women and children. The ministry is part of the Hamas-run government and staffed by medical professionals. The UN and independent experts consider it the most reliable source on war casualties. Israel disputes its figures but has not provided its own.
Telegraph
10 minutes ago
- Telegraph
If modern Britain is so great, why didn't Lammy bring Vance to Tottenham?
It's intriguing that out of all the places in Europe he could have chosen to spend his August holiday, Vance chose Britain. Like a 19th-century gunboat sailing into the port of some troublesome satrapy, there's almost the sense that the US vice-president was here to concentrate some minds within the Labour Government, and to remind them that they are being watched by the imperial metropole. If Labour is so convinced that all is well with the modern Britain they're building, why not show the vice-president themselves, and force him to concede the error of his ignorant prejudice in front of the cameras? That would shut cranks and the Russia shills up. Rather than have him cloistered away among the provisional wing of the lanyard classes in the Cotswolds, perhaps have him enjoy a traditional English seaside break at Bournemouth? Obviously, the Government would have to find him a private house to stay in, seeing as the resort's main landmark hotels have been used to house illegal immigrants. Watching rival gangs of London 'roadmen' fight it out on the promenade would surely be a more exciting spectator sport than 'Dance for Vance'. Or, rather than drag the veep all the way down from the Cotswolds to Chevening in Kent, the Foreign Secretary could have met him in the middle, in the traditional seat of one of the Home Counties; Bedford perhaps? There, he could have seen the fruits of Labour's far-sighted decision to decriminalise vagrancy, and joined some of the city's new arrivals from around the world in wandering aimlessly about its shopping precinct. Despite their political differences, by all accounts David Lammy has built genuine personal rapport with JD Vance. So when he visited London, why didn't he take his guest to visit his own constituency in Tottenham? Or maybe, the vice-president could have come away reassured by Britain's unity after a visit to Birmingham or Tower Hamlets, and an encounter with one of several exciting new political parties that have proliferated to challenge Labour among some of its ethno-sectarian client groups. Given all of these possibilities, it seems disappointing that JD Vance has only been allowed to see the handful of places that still resemble the stuffy, boring old Britain of American tourists' imagination. All in all, it was a missed opportunity for the defenders of contemporary, multicultural Britain to confound their paranoid naysayers. The parlous state of Starmer's Britain is becoming a favourite subject of Americans in Vance's political milieu. As far as they are concerned, we are a country collapsing into criminal disorder, drowning in migration, and chafing under a government whose response to it all is a sneering assault on free expression and the imposition of vindictive two-tier justice. The term 'anarcho-tyranny' is one they increasingly use to describe a system under which basic law and order is allowed to degrade, but in which the authorities will come down like a ton of bricks on anybody who even thinks about doing anything about it themselves. Mr Vance's visit has coincided with a concerted attempt, not only by the Government, but also by defenders of the previous government, to insist that Britain's structural problems are being massively overblown by Right-wing cranks on both sides of the Atlantic. Official statistics show that crime is actually coming down, and that GDP has generally been rising; and of course, non-immigrants still heavily outnumber immigrants as perpetrators of crime. Just don't look too carefully at any of the base-rate figures underneath those numbers, or ask why an increasing number of goods in supermarkets have to have special anti-theft protection. Labour MPs have even been accusing those with misgivings of working for the Russians.
Daily Mail
10 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Rising Republican hopeful pushes for Trump's endorsement despite private GOP concerns she'll NEVER be the next Glenn Youngkin
Virginia 's Republican Lieutenant Governor Winsome Sears is scrambling to secure Donald Trump 's backing in her high-stakes gubernatorial race - but the commander-in-chief has yet to throw his weight behind her campaign. The president told a gaggle of reporters earlier this month that 'the candidate is running against is not very good', adding that 'she's got a tough race' and he 'would' endorse. Sears told the Daily Mail exclusively at a Monday campaign event that she wants 'every endorsement that comes.' 'We all want to win. And his, of course, will help,' Sears added when asked if Trump should weigh in on her race. That's a stark contrast from 2022, when Sears said that voters 'want a different leader.' It's the first time Sears has directly stated that she desires Trump's immediate backing. She previously brushed off questions about her past critical remarks on Trump, saying she doesn't dwell on the past. As Lt. Gov., Sears was victorious in 2021, alongside current Governor Glenn Youngkin and Attorney General Jason Miyares. However, Gov. Youngkin is term-limited, and Miyares is running for his current job for a second time. The trio delivered the first Republican clean sweep of statewide offices in Virginia in over a decade. Three years later, despite Trump and JD Vance holding several events in Virginia during the 2024 cycle in the hopes of a new 'red wave' - it never came. A Republican has not won Virginia's coveted presidential electoral votes in over 20 years. And now Sears is undoubtedly running an uphill battle, despite her framing of the governor race as within the 'margin of error.' Per the Virginia Public Access project, Sears has raised over $11 million, compared to Democrat Abigail Spanberger's $27 million. Sears told the Daily Mail that she broke records with her impressive fundraising haul at the start of the year. 'You can check... in the first quarter of my campaign, I raised more money than any Republican ever has historically,' she stated. The president told a gaggle of reporters earlier this month that 'the candidate is running against is not very good', adding that 'she's got a tough race' and he 'would' endorse Her claim about being a top GOP fundraiser in the first quarter after announcing her candidacy is mostly true. Incumbent Governor Glenn Youngkin had over $7 million at the end of his first quarter financial report in 2021, but $5 million of that was self-funded. That's compared to Sears's $3 million raised at the start of her current campaign. The degree to which outside groups are willing to invest in Virginia is also telling. The Republican Governors Association (RGA) has spent $500,000 on behalf of Sears, compared to the $2 million that the Republican Attorneys General Association has pledged to Miyares. RGA Rapid Response Director Kollin Crompton told the Daily Mail that the group is firmly behind Sears. 'Winsome Earle-Sears is the only candidate in this race who will keep Virginia on the right track forged by Gov. Glenn Youngkin. Under their leadership, parents' rights have been protected, Virginia's economy is growing, and communities are safe.' Krompton also added that 'under Abigail Spanberger, the clock will be turned back on all these accomplishments – just like they were while she was in Congress.' But numerous longtime Republican players in Virginia privately told the Daily Mail that they have serious doubts about Sears's ability to emerge victorious in November. One operative told the Daily Mail under the condition of anonymity that 'this is 100% Glenn Youngkin's fault for clearing the field by endorsing her right after the 2024 election.' The operative also noted that there were real conversations about potential primary challengers to Sears, which the governor worked to keep at bay. Two representatives for Trump's political operation did not respond to the Daily Mail's requests for comment in time for publication. The wide-ranging forum touched on issues including preserving women's spaces in locker rooms and on sports teams At her Monday campaign event in Fauquier County, Virginia, an hour and a half outside of Washington, D.C., Sears held a roundtable of female leaders, which included participants from business, non-profit, and political sectors. The wide-ranging forum touched on issues including preserving women's spaces in locker rooms and on sports teams and ensuring that women who are victims of crimes have the proper legal recourse to deal with their assailants. There was also a discussion about anti-semitism on college campuses, which Sears believes Spanbeger has not adequately condemned.
