
Pink smoke signals in Rome call for women priests
In a park on a hill overlooking the dome of St Peter's and the church's Vatican headquarters, campaigners released pink smoke from flares, and demanded that women be allowed to seek ordination.
"We are saying to the cardinals, you cannot keep ignoring 50 percent of the Catholic population, you cannot go into a locked room and discuss the future of the Church without half of the Church," said Miriam Duignan.
"Whoever they elect needs to be brave enough to properly tackle the question of women's inclusion, because so far it has not been, even by Pope Francis," said Duignan, of the Wijngaards Institute in Cambridge.
Duignan was briefly detained in 2011 after she attempted to enter the Vatican to deliver a petition in support of a priest backing the activists' cause.
Had the activists taken their Wednesday protest -- a nod to the black and white smoke used by the Holy See to announce voting results -- to the Vatican, they believe a similar fate would have awaited them.
"Whenever we go down to St Peter's Square, we are detained by the police ... and we are certainly not invited to go into the conclave," Duignan said
"The only women that those 133 men will see in the next few days will be nuns who are cleaning their rooms and serving them food and tidying up after them."
The cardinals meeting Wednesday behind closed doors in the Sistine Chapel will not hear any female opinions during deliberations expected to last days, with multiple rounds of voting.
The only women they will see before white smoke rises to announce their decision has been made will be the nuns who cook, clean and serve upon them in the Santa Marta guesthouse.
In the global church as a whole, women have begun to take some senior lay roles, a process that accelerated a little under Pope Francis's papacy.
But even those who have studied theology and church ministry are excluded from the priesthood, and only priests hold the most senior leadership roles.
"Yes, Pope Francis elevated and promoted a few women into roles of responsibility, but they are always lower in status and authority than a man," said Duignan.
"Even the youngest priest in the room is the boss of the oldest, more experienced woman."
'A sin and a scandal'
The campaigners say women took equal roles in worship in the early Church, before medieval reforms, and that, in Duignan's words, "the men who are going into the Sistine Chapel this afternoon know that, and they don't want everyone else to know that."
Kate McElwee, executive director of the Women's Ordination Conference campaign group, described this as an injustice and a "crisis" for the church.
"While the world may wait for white smoke or black smoke, we send up pink smoke as our hope that the Church may someday welcome women as equals," she said.
French activist Gabrielle Fidelin called it "a sin and a scandal that women are kept out of priesthood and the conclave."
According to Duignan, even after Francis's relatively reformist 12-year pontificate, only one of the 133 cardinal electors to be sequestered in conclave has taken a positive stance on women's ordination.
And she was reluctant to identify him by name, in case he found himself expelled from the gathering.
This despite the once taboo issue being given an airing in the Synod -- an assembly of clergy, clerics and laypeople -- which under Francis has included female members.
In October last year, a report was issued after Francis approved a working party to look into the idea of allowing women to become deacons -- a step before the priesthood.
It acknowledged that "the question of women's access to diaconal ministry remains open" but concluded that it was too soon to make a decision.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

LeMonde
44 minutes ago
- LeMonde
One year on, Macron remains entangled by fallout of rash snap elections
Ten months after the facts, the political earthquake was still a topic of conversation, even during the Paris Book Fair at the Grand Palais. In front of a bookstall, amid the hubbub, former culture minister Françoise Nyssen, accompanying President Emmanuel Macron on his visit, suddenly confided: "Thank you for the dissolution," she whispered to him, referring to his decision to dissolve the Asseblée Nationale and trigger snap parliamentary elections, the night his side was beaten in the European elections of June 9. "I was really proud of you. What's more, it was June 9, my birthday." Briefly taken aback, Macron replied: "I will be forgiven with time." "It wasn't a bad decision," approved a woman listening in. "No, because people have to be made to take their responsibilities," Macron said, glancing at the journalist's boom mic recording the conversation. "Otherwise, things fall apart from the inside. I've seen it happen before." Was Macron sincere? During his televised New Year's address on December 31, 2024, when France was entering 2025 without a budget after the first post-dissolution government, led by Michel Barnier, had been toppled, the president publicly admitted for the first time that the move had, "for now, brought more divisions to the Assemblée than solutions for the French people." He added: "Clarity and humility require us to recognize that, for the moment, the decision has produced more instability than calm, and for that, I take full responsibility."

LeMonde
3 hours ago
- LeMonde
Le Monde Group's 2024 accounts mark a landmark year
In 2024, the year marking Le Monde 's 80 th anniversary, Le Monde Group experienced a landmark period in many respects. First, with new records for the number of subscribers to our editorial offerings, which propelled our paid circulation to unprecedented levels. To put these results in the broader context of our evolution since our founding in December 1944, we presented the curve of our paid circulation in France and internationally at our most recent supervisory board meeting, certified monthly by independent bodies. This annual average, now including our digital subscribers, has reached over 530,000 copies per day – well above the previous peak of 440,000 in 1978, during the legislative elections preceding the election of former French president François Mitterrand. In the long term, three essential factors form the basis of our readers' trust and loyalty. The independence of our journalism – committed to values but not partisan – toward all forms of power, starting with those held by political leaders; the particular focus devoted to covering major events, both international and French; and the determination to break our own stories through investigation and reporting. The increasing attention paid over the years to our readers – their lives, interests and habits – has not only led us to continually expand our editorial offering but also to embrace digital platforms early on. These platforms now drive our success, enabling us to reach far beyond our borders to engage with more diverse and younger audiences. All three of these factors were fully at play in 2024, enabling us to respond to an intense, often violent and always uncertain news cycle, while continuing to innovate and broaden the scope of our editorial coverage. Our visibility has attracted its share of criticism, but more importantly, it challenges the defeatist narrative that has long surrounded the print press. Far from being doomed to decline, print media can thrive when it strives to strengthen its newsroom and defend free journalism. Individual and collective honors This success was reflected in 2024 by several major awards from our profession. Le Monde was especially honored to see two of its journalists win the Albert Londres Prize: Lorraine de Foucher, for her reporting and investigations on the Mazan rape case, on migrant women who are victims of rape, on victims of the pornography industry, on young girls exploited for sex in the southern French city of Perpignan and on teenage hitmen; and Martin Untersinger, for his book Espionner, mentir, détruire ("To Spy, To Lie, To Destroy"). These two awards recognize not only the talent of our journalists and their ability to explore new facets of reality, but also the transformation of Le Monde 's newsroom, whose staff has nearly doubled in less than 15 years. There were also collective awards. Le Monde 's circulation performance was recognized with two stars awarded by the ACPM (Alliance pour les Chiffres de la Presse et des Médias, the independent body certifying French press circulation). The first reflects the largest increase in paid circulation in 2024 in the daily press sector; the second, especially meaningful to us, rewards sustained success – that is, a growth in sales, with an increase of 141,444 copies per day since 2020. Another Groupe Le Monde publication, the weekly Courrier International, led by Claire Carrard and François-Xavier Devaux, also received two ACPM awards: one star for the highest growth in paid circulation among magazines, and another for sustained success between 2020 and 2024. Thanks to steady growth in paid circulation, the Courrier International now ranks as the top French magazine for its portfolio of digital subscribers. The second spot in this ranking is now held by another of the group's weeklies, Télérama, which in 2024 continued to revamp its editorial approach and significantly invest in coverage of streaming platforms, especially through its website and app. This strong digital transition, under the leadership of Valérie Hurier and Fleur Lavedan, positions Télérama for a future that reflects the loyalty shown by its subscribers for decades. Finally, La Vie, the group's third weekly, made a mark in summer 2024 with the publication of an investigation revealing accusations of sexual assault against Abbé Pierre. A drive for diversification In recent years, our group has gradually diversified its activities by creating or co-organizing events to reach new audiences, such as our student fairs or the "Nos Futurs" ("Our Futures") event in Rennes, which features debates and workshops on major societal issues like climate and artificial intelligence. The year 2024 also saw the launch of the Le Goût de M festival, which in March brought together more than 5,000 people with the team from M Le magazine du Monde. Our magazine will celebrate its 15 th anniversary in 2026 and will mark the occasion with another edition of this festival. This drive to diversify our editorial production will also be illustrated in a few months by the publication of a book, then a graphic novel and finally a documentary in 2026 – all based on the series of articles by Philippe Broussard, deputy editor-in-chief of Le Monde, dedicated to the "unknown photographer of the Occupation," published in summer 2024. This series was a tremendous success with our readers and now justifies, as we intend to do more often, presenting it in other formats to new audiences. Faced with an advertising market paralyzed since the announcement of the dissolution of the Assemblée Nationale (lower house of France's parliament) in June 2024, the group's advertising division, M Publicité, managed to limit its decline to 3% by drawing on 7% growth in digital revenue and a 27% increase in special projects linked to the Olympic Games and our events. This advertising business, strictly governed by a charter that clearly distinguishes between advertising formats and editorial content, generates 20% of the group's revenue and is a structural component of our business model, offering our readers and subscribers carefully selected advertising in both print and online. Despite the market share captured by digital players, this revenue remains essential for our sustainability. Another highlight of the year came in March 2024, when Le Monde announced the signing of the first agreement between a French media outlet and OpenAI, the publisher of ChatGPT. A year on, Le Monde remains the only French media group to have signed such a deal and is among about 15 global groups with which OpenAI has entered into a multi-year partnership. The agreement governs OpenAI's use of our content while strictly protecting the rights of publishers and copyright holders. In line with the charter we adopted in 2023 governing our use of AI, it guarantees fair visibility for our content on a platform widely used by younger generations, gives us direct access to a technology that is revolutionizing media habits and establishes fair compensation for training OpenAI's model and using our content in responses provided to users. On this last point, we ensured that this revenue stream would be treated as neighboring rights, thus entitling journalists to a share as provided by law. In 2024, we reached an agreement with trade unions setting the redistribution rate at 25% – a proportion now adopted by several other media groups, far exceeding what others had tried to impose. Most recently, another agreement with the company Perplexity, signed in mid-May, completed our initiatives in the field of artificial intelligence, in the same spirit and under the same conditions. This collective momentum, the steady growth of our digital audience and these new AI partnerships all contributed to the group's revenue growth and to our 2024 results. Le Monde Group's accounts, approved by the supervisory board on May 13, showed revenue of €309.5 million for 2024, EBITDA (operating cash flow) of €26.2 million and net income before tax of €10.6 million. Recapitalized in 2010 thanks to the joint investment of Pierre Bergé, Xavier Niel and Matthieu Pigasse, Le Monde Group has recorded a profitable operating result every year since 2015 and, since 2016, has consistently posted a positive net result. This profitability is the foundation of our independence. It has enabled sustained and ongoing investment in our newsrooms and in innovation. Furthermore, in 2024, the group's profit contributions from Le Monde (€7.5 million) and our magazine division (€8.4 million) converged, with comparable profitability thresholds and a more balanced distribution between the group's two pillars. It is up to us, collectively, to continue along this path to strengthen the quality, independence and innovation standards of a rigorous editorial offering worthy of the trust you place in us.


France 24
4 hours ago
- France 24
UN Ocean Conference in Nice : Stark warnings on ocean conservation
05:05 09/06/2025 French Open : Two-in-a-row for Alcaraz after thrilling final France 09/06/2025 French politics : Assessing Macron's difficult year after snap vote France 09/06/2025 Where does French president Emmanuel Macron stand a year after snap vote ? France 09/06/2025 Exploring France's cutting-edge ocean research ahead of the UN conference Environment 09/06/2025 Ocean warriors: The race to save seahorses, seagrass and flat oysters Environment 09/06/2025 UN Ocean conference opens in France today : What are the next steps ? Environment 09/06/2025 Saving the ocean: 'We have to be optimistic because it's our only planet' France 09/06/2025 Don't let deep sea become 'wild west', Guterres tells world leaders in Nice Environment