Why Canadians might want to beware what they have wished for with Mark Carney
When Mark Carney 's name is mentioned to Mark Francois, chairman of the ultra Brexiteer European Research Group, a smile creeps across his face.
The newly elected Canadian prime minister has won an extraordinary victory in Canada for the Liberal Party, overturning a previous two digit lead for the Conservative Party.
But Brexiteers consider his interventio n in the 2016 EU referendum to be almost as decisive in their favour, even though he spoke against the Leave campaign.
Mr Francois noted: 'Ultimately, I would say it was almost as helpful as Barack Obama's. The British people simply refused to be bullied by 'Project Fear', of which Mark Carney was clearly a part.'
While the remark may be seen as a joke, it underlines a mixed legacy for the former governor of the Bank of England.
Bank of England Governor
Mr Carney was brought in as governor in 2013 by the then chancellor George Osborne having previously occupied the same role in the Bank of Canada.
He continued with it until 2020 taking the UK through austerity, the Scottish and EU referendums, and then the immediate aftermath following the vote to leave in 2016.
At the time, Mr Osborne described his new recruit as "the outstanding central banker of his generation" and expressed his confidence that he was the man to help the UK restore its economic and fiscal credibility in the wake of the banking collapse of 2008.
Announcing the appointment to MPs, Mr Osborne said: "He is quite simply the best, most experienced and most qualified person in the world to be the next governor of the Bank of England and to help Britain's families and businesses through these difficult economic times."
Osborne has never regretted the decision and recently said of Carney that he would 'want him to go in to bat for Canada' if he was Canadian.
Austerity
As governor Carney was instrumental in helping George Osborne push through his economic policies on squeezing public spending, trying to bring down structural debt and restore the public finances.
The Bank's cutting of interest rates under his watch to what became historically low levels but also the printing of billions of pounds to underpin the economy were essential for Osborne's strategy.
However, it meant that under Mr Carney's watch the UK was storing up problems for the future.
The ongoing austerity saw wages especially in the public sector lag behind their previous levels, and involved cuts in public services.
Trade union leaders like the former TUC president Matt Wrack have pointed to those restrictions on wages being behind the wave of strikes from council workers, doctors, nurses and teachers all demanding restoration of pay levels.
The Labour government now is blaming the years of austerity for the lack of economic growth and productivity.
Project Fear
While arguments can be made both for and against on the Osborne/ Carney economic legacy, the real controversy comes over his decision to step into UK domestic politics.
The term 'Project Fear' was coined to great effect by the late Alex Salmond in the 2014 Scottish independence referendum to underline the establishment coordinated attempts to get a no vote.
The anger Project Fear caused in Scotland saw the SNP and separatists at one point go ahead in the polls and only narrowly losing in the final vote.
But then in 2016 the EU referendum, also overseen by Mr Osborne, saw the same tactics being used.
This time Project Fear, which involved a clumsy intervention by the then US president Barack Obama, helped Mr Francois, Boris Johnson, Nigel Farage and others in winning the referendum.
Mr Carney's own contribution was to warn of a massive recession and economic meltdown if Brexit was voted for. People did not believe him but in the long term he may be proven right.
Arguably, as an official not a politician then, Mr Carney should have stayed well clear of the debate on political issues and just done his job. the skills he has used in recent weeks in Canada were not the ones he needed to deploy in the UK.
The Brexit negotiation years
Mr Carney did not get as much credit as he deserved for creating financial stability as the political chaos unfurled after the EU referendum.
But to achieve this he had to slash interest rates to just 0.25 per cent and carry out more quantative easing (printing money).
He left just before the Covid pandemic in 2020 with the UK's finances still reeling from the effects of the Brexit vote.
When he departed for a life in the private sector on company boards and then into Canadian politics, Mr Carney left a country more divided politically and economically than before he arrived.
While he cannot be blamed for all of what happened there is little doubt he contributed to those divisions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
13 minutes ago
- BBC News
Israeli military recovers two hostages' bodies in southern Gaza
Israeli forces have recovered the bodies of two Israeli Americans taken back to Gaza as hostages during the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on 7 October 2023, the Israeli military Weinstein Haggai, 70, who was also a Canadian citizen, and her husband Gadi Haggai, 72, were murdered by gunmen from the Mujahideen Brigades group when they attacked Kibbutz Nir Oz, a statement bodies were recovered from the southern Khan Younis area of Gaza and brought back to Israel for forensic are now 56 hostages still being held by Hamas in Gaza, at least 20 of whom are believed to be alive.
NBC News
an hour ago
- NBC News
Māori lawmakers suspended over protest haka performed in New Zealand Parliament
Three Māori lawmakers in New Zealand received record suspensions of up to three weeks on Thursday, local media reported, over a protest haka they performed in Parliament last year against a contentious bill. The lawmakers drew global attention in November when they performed the haka, a ceremonial chanting dance of defiance that is a cherished cultural symbol of New Zealand. They were protesting legislation that would have reinterpreted the country's 184-year-old founding document, a treaty that was signed between colonial British rulers and Indigenous Māori. A parliamentary committee found the three lawmakers in contempt of parliament last month and recommended that they be suspended for up to three weeks 'for acting in a manner that could have the effect of intimidating a member of the House.' Debbie Ngarewa-Packer and Rawiri Waititi, co-leaders of Te Pāti Māori, the Māori party, which holds six of Parliament's 123 seats, were suspended for three weeks each. Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke, who at 22 is New Zealand's youngest legislator, was suspended for one week on the recommendation of the committee, which said in its report that she had demonstrated 'some level of contrition' in her written statement. It is rare for New Zealand lawmakers to receive such suspensions, which are unpaid, and the longest anyone had previously been suspended was three days. The opposition Labour Party as well as the Green Party criticized the suspensions as disproportionate, with the Labour Party proposing censure instead. The three lawmakers performed the protest haka in November during the reading of a bill that would have redefined the Treaty of Waitangi. Signed in 1840 between the British Crown and Māori chiefs, the treaty established British governance and structures to protect Māori rights and continues to influence policy today. The legislation was brought by the small libertarian party ACT New Zealand, which said the treaty had been misinterpreted to give Māori people special treatment. Critics of the bill, which was defeated in April, said it would undo decades of progress for Māori, who make up about 20% of New Zealand's 5 million people and fare worse than the rest of the population in health, education and the criminal justice system. One of the Māori lawmakers, Maipi-Clarke, led the haka by tearing up a copy of the bill, joined by other Māori members and some visitors in the public gallery. Video of the protest went viral and gathered hundreds of millions of views across social media. Some lawmakers objected to the way their Māori colleagues advanced toward them across the floor. 'This was a very serious incident, the likes of which I have never seen before in my 23 years in the debating chamber,' said Judith Collins of the center-right National Party, chair of the parliamentary committee that issued the report. She added that the lawmakers had performed the haka without permission and that the disruption had suspended legislative proceedings for 30 minutes. The three Māori lawmakers declined to appear before the committee during its investigation, citing disrespect for their cultural traditions. Their party said the way it was being conducted was 'grossly unjust' and that 'this was not about process, this became personal.' The committee said the lawmakers were being sanctioned not for performing the haka, but for 'the time at and manner in which it was performed.' It said the severity of the sanctions was intended to 'leave members in no doubt that the behavior discussed is not acceptable.' The vote had originally been scheduled for last month but was postponed so that the three Māori lawmakers could participate in debate over the federal budget. Performing haka in Parliament is not uncommon, and is typically seen when Māori members celebrate the passage of a particular bill. The dance is known abroad for being performed at matches by New Zealand's rugby teams, and variations of it are also performed at funerals and formal welcomes. 'It would have been clearly understood by everyone in the parliament that this was a peaceful act of protest done in a way that aligns with Māori tradition,' said Julian Rawiri Kusabs, a Māori historian and researcher at the University of Melbourne in Australia. Kusabs said the suspension was a setback in decades of reconciliation efforts between the New Zealand government and Māori communities, whose members have had to navigate 'a highly complex and frequently painful relationship' even to achieve representation in Parliament. The suspension, he said, reinforces the longstanding perception that 'Māori culture is not equally respected within New Zealand's formal institutions of governance.'
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Struggling Wizz Air's annual profit down over 61%, misses expectation
June 5 (Reuters) - Budget carrier Wizz Air (WIZZ.L), opens new tab on Thursday reported an annual operating profit that fell short of analysts' expectations, as capacity constraints due to grounded planes and stubbornly high costs continued to weigh on performance. Wizz Air reported an operating profit of 167.5 million euros ($191.05 million) for the financial year, down 61.7% from a year ago and missing the 246 million euros projected by analysts polled by LSEG. European airlines have warned of longstanding delivery delays and uncertainty around maintaining post-COVID demand as the world faces economic turmoil tied to U.S. President Donald Trump's tariff threats. However, the sector has largely benefited from lower fuel prices. Wizz Air in particular has been bogged down by Pratt and Whitney engine repair challenges, limiting its ability to grow capacity. It has issued two profit warnings in the last year. On Thursday, the company said it would not provide guidance for 2026 at this stage of the year, citing limited visibility across its trading seasons. ($1 = 0.8767 euros)
