Cookstove Carbon Credits: Recipe For Cooking The Climate Books
A new report, 'Recipe for Greenwashing', commissioned by Korean NGO Plan 1.5 and co-authored by Carbon Market Watch and Director of the Berkeley Carbon Trading Project Barbara Haya, has revealed that the climate credentials of the Korean Emissions Trading Scheme (K-ETS) risk being significantly undermined by its inclusion of international carbon credits.
The report analyses a sample of 21 clean cookstove projects that have supplied South Korean companies with carbon credits for use under the K-ETS, finding that on average they are likely generating 18.3 times more credits than they should.
The analysis finds that the 9.7 million credits (representing 9.7 million tonnes of emissions reductions) likely have a climate impact of only approximately half a million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (531,979 tCO2e), the equivalent of 18 times more credits than are justified.
Cookstove projects constitute the majority of international credits used by companies complying with the K-ETS. Companies under the K-ETS are entitled to match their emission reduction obligations with the purchase of international credits, as long as they exceed no more than 5% of the company's compliance obligation.
Break the mould
The analysis highlights that reliance on international credits undermines the effectiveness and credibility of the K-ETS. It mirrors the now-abandoned practice in the European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS), where such credits led to an inflation in supply, price crashes, and delayed domestic decarbonisation.
While the EU has banned international credits from its ETS since 2021, the Korean government appears to be taking the opposite approach. Alarmingly, the government is considering raising the limit from 5% of a company's emissions threshold to 10% in the fourth period of the K-ETS (2026-2030). Doubling the share of an already problematic decision will likely have detrimental consequences for the environmental integrity of the policy.
The South Korean government also plans to use international credits to reach its United Nations climate target for 2030 by including 37.5 million international credits into its nationally determined contributions.
The projects analysed in the report use methodologies AMS-I.E and AMS-II.G to generate carbon credits. Generally, the number of credits a carbon credit project issues under these two methodologies is determined by a number of factors, including actual stove usage, drop-outs, fuel consumption patterns, and many more.
Research, as well as a decision by the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM) in March, has determined that both methodologies lead to over-crediting because these methodologies rely on outdated assumptions that allow a high, and inflated, volume of credits to be generated. Both methodologies were rejected from attaining the ICVCM's Core Carbon Principles label.
The wrong path
The report calls on the South Korean government to ban international credits from use under the K-ETS, strengthen caps and focus on domestic emissions reductions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
6 days ago
- Scoop
Save Our Sheep Billboards Hit Wellington
Wednesday, 4 June 2025, 1:43 pm Press Release: Federated Farmers Federated Farmers have taken the fight for the future of New Zealand sheep farming to the streets of Wellington, with bold digital billboards visible directly from Ministers' Beehive offices. The message to politicians is clear and concise: sheep are not the problem - stop planting productive farmland in pine trees for carbon credits. Save our sheep billboard (Photo/Supplied) "We wanted this campaign to be bold and directly in politicians' faces. That's the only way we're going to get their attention," Federated Farmers meat & wool chair Toby Williams says. "Sheep farming is in crisis. We need the Government to urgently wake up to the impact poor policy is having on our farming families and rural communities. "Each year we're losing tens of thousands of hectares of productive farmland. "Where sheep and lambs once grazed there's now nothing but pine trees as far as the eye can see." Between 2017 and 2024, more than 260,000 hectares of productive sheep farming land were plastered in pine trees - never to return to pasture. In just one generation New Zealand has lost over two-thirds of our national flock, reducing from over 70 million sheep in 1982 to fewer than 25 million sheep today. "Our national flock is declining by almost a million sheep every year and the number one driver is carbon forestry," Williams says. "Farms are being converted to forestry because Government policy is screwing the scrum and making it more profitable to plant pine trees than to farm sheep. "The Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) is effectively subsidising pine trees to offset fossil fuel emissions, and that's pushing farming families off the land and destroying rural communities." New Zealand is the only country in the world that allows 100% carbon offsetting through forestry, with other countries recognising the risk and putting restrictions in place. Federated Farmers is now calling on the Government to urgently review the ETS and fix the rules to either limit or stop the offsetting of fossil fuel emissions with forestry. You can sign the petition at © Scoop Media
Techday NZ
30-05-2025
- Techday NZ
APJ region accelerates AI adoption as Dell rolls out new innovations
Artificial intelligence is moving at an incredibly fast speed in the Asia Pacific and Japan (APJ) region, according to senior Dell Technologies executives who spoke at a media roundtable during the Dell Tech World conference in Las Vegas. As AI use cases proliferate and investment ramps up, the region is fast emerging as a global leader, both in adoption and ambition. "Asia Pacific is leading the way in generative AI spending, with 38% of AI investment in the region now focused on Gen AI, compared to just 33% in the rest of the world," said Peter Marrs, President of Asia Pacific, Japan and Greater China at Dell. "Even North America sits at 29%," he added, highlighting the region's rapid pace. Dell is positioning itself at the heart of this growth through its AI Factory and a growing ecosystem of technology partners, universities and governments. "There's not an industry that's untouched by AI, but financial services, healthcare, energy, retail and manufacturing really stand out. We're at the forefront of helping customers across these sectors," he added. Transforming business through AI factories The Dell AI Factory, a framework designed to help organisations scale AI, has quickly gained traction. "It's been a year since we announced it, and we've moved from having tens or hundreds of customers globally to thousands," said Chris Kelly, Senior Vice President of Data Center Solutions APJC at Dell. "Not only are more customers deploying it, but they're achieving real, tangible ROI." According to Danny Elmarji, Vice President of Presales APJC at Dell, the AI Factory has resonated because it provides a practical pathway for organisations to adopt AI at scale. "CIOs are trying to understand how to tackle AI inside their business. Unlike past technology shifts, this is fundamentally a business-driven initiative," he explained. Elmarji pointed to significant momentum in financial services, where generative AI is being used to recommend customer actions, automate fraud detection and transform digital banking experiences. In manufacturing, AI is powering digital twin capabilities and revolutionising fault detection, while in healthcare, early detection tools and enhanced electronic medical records are improving patient outcomes. AI is also driving change in retail, with computer vision enabling smarter inventory management, and in education, where Dell is working with universities to personalise learning and foster innovation. "We're building connections between the IT world, research and industry," Kelly noted. "It's about moving beyond pilot projects and making AI meaningful for everyday users." From modular data centres to sovereign AI The roundtable also showcased a unique customer partnership with South Korean AI education platform Elice. CEO Jae Won Kim described how Elice faced soaring costs when trying to provide deep learning environments for students and businesses. "We had to reduce GPU cloud fees by more than 90%," he said. The solution was a portable modular data centre powered by Dell servers, now used for everything from AI digital textbooks for five million students to sovereign AI workloads that comply with government requirements. "There's very limited data centre capacity in Korea for high-density AI workloads," Kim explained. "The modular data centre lets us host hundreds of GPUs, with liquid cooling for the latest chips. It's not just about education anymore – we're talking about a hybrid solution that could be deployed in Japan, Australia or anywhere data centre construction lags demand." Marrs praised the partnership, saying, "You really thought big, and you went and made it happen." Kim's advice for others: "AI is not going away. It's better to start early. If you're worried about investment, modular is the best way to start small and start fast." Innovation and ecosystem challenges Dell's announcements at the conference included a raft of new infrastructure solutions designed to cut energy costs, boost data centre efficiency and accelerate AI deployments of any size. The company's latest cooling technology can reduce energy costs by up to 60%, while new servers with AMD and NVIDIA chips promise up to 35 times greater AI inferencing performance than previous generations. Yet, challenges remain. "The biggest hurdles are people and ecosystem," Marrs acknowledged. "We need to educate the next generation of AI talent and work with governments to create the right regulatory and compliance frameworks." Kelly added, "Access to data centre space, power and cooling is going to be crucial. Requirements are moving so fast that what seemed high density a year ago now looks standard." To address these gaps, Dell is nurturing partnerships with universities, local ISVs and industry bodies, running hundreds of AI innovation days and investing in hands-on labs. "We're enabling partners to experiment in safe environments and bring AI to life," said Elmarji. Dell executives are optimistic but realistic about the scale of change. "We're delivering AI at scale in the largest and most complex use cases, but also helping small startups get started," Kelly said. "You don't have to spend a fortune – start small and grow. If you don't act now, you're falling behind." For Kim, the journey with Dell is just beginning. "It was a huge investment for us, basically a startup. We poured all our money into GPUs. But I think it will be a good journey," he said.
Otago Daily Times
27-05-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Hoggard: Can't ‘smash through' change
Associate Minister for Agriculture and for the Environment Andrew Hoggard at the Croydon Lodge on Monday, speaking on beef and lamb issues related to his portfolios. PHOTO: ELLA SCOTT-FLEMING Act New Zealand MP Andrew Hoggard visited Gore this week to speak on issues facing local producers, including the conversion of farms to forests, but said changes to the surrounding law were not something the government could rush. Mr Hoggard, the Minister of Biosecurity and Food Safety and Associate Minister of Agriculture, said while the rapid conversion of arable land to forestry might be a pressing concern for the farmers in the audience, it was not something the government could just "smash through". "It's probably good that, in some respect, it isn't that easy, because you don't want governments to be able to smash stuff through," he said. "It's good to have some checks and balances on them." The forum was hosted by Beef + Lamb NZ at the Croydon Lodge on Monday, where Beef + Lamb senior staff gave a outline of their key policy areas, the minister touched on what related to his portfolios and the audience were then invited to raise their concerns. The policy areas touched on by the executives and MP were global warming, forestry, biosecurity, gene technology, the Resource Management Act and fresh water. Mr Hoggard, a former Federated Farmers president, said Act would support the trend of turning farms to forestry if it was about the price of timber but it was not. The change was driven by the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) price, however, which had created a "false market", he said. Due to the rise in forestry for ETS money, once the world discovered technology that rendered carbon farming obsolete, we could be left with a country covered in pines, he said. "We're going to be left with a country that's covered in pine trees, a massive fire risk, with nothing productive happening. "These companies will basically just walk away." On global warming, he said if the world "walked back" its level of ambition, New Zealand would have already met that standard. Despite this, he saw no need for New Zealand to reduce its farming. "There is zero sense of the most carbon-efficient farming nation in the world to reduce its farming. If anything ... we don't need to be farming less, we need to be farming better." In regard to gene technology, he said the key thing for him was co-existence, allowing space for those who wanted to be organic and GMO-free as well as those who wanted to use the latest innovation. He said that legislative process was in the hands of a select committee. "The last thing I want is someone from either side telling me how I have to farm," he said. Changes to fresh water legislation was going to be messy, he said, as the government aimed to work with local government, with a variety of different needs and plans already in place. "We are trying to build the plane as we're flying it in some cases," he said.
