Mental health deaths inquiry hears about ‘denial and defensiveness'
The default response of many NHS trusts is denial and defensiveness, an inquiry into the deaths of more than 2,000 mental health patients in Essex was told.
Deborah Coles, executive director of the charity Inquest, said that the falsification of safety records was 'well known within the Essex context'.
Ms Coles, giving evidence to the Lampard Inquiry on Monday, said that Inquest has a team of 16 people and carries out specialist casework on state-related deaths.
The Lampard Inquiry, chaired by Baroness Kate Lampard, is examining deaths at NHS-run inpatient units in Essex between 2000 and 2023.
It will include those who died within three months of discharge, and those who died as inpatients receiving NHS-funded care in the independent sector.
Ms Coles told the inquiry: ' One of the things that I think our work has identified thematically is that default response of many NHS trusts and private providers to kind of denial and defensiveness.
'And a lack of candour and of concern more about reputation management than being concerned about learning and seeking improvements.'
Nicholas Griffin KC, counsel to the inquiry, asked Ms Coles about 'poor record-keeping including falsification'.
Ms Coles said she believed the 'situation is well known within the Essex context, but with people just falsifying very significant safety records'.
Mr Griffin said Ms Coles makes reference in a statement to a 'high prevalence of falsified observation records'.
Ms Coles confirmed that she did make reference to this, and continued: 'I mean, if you think about the importance of observations to people who are particularly vulnerable, not least to self-harm and self-inflicted death, then observations are absolutely critical.
'To then see falsification does speak to a very worrying culture, I think.'
Earlier in Monday's hearing, at Arundel House in central London, Ms Coles addressed loved ones of those who have died.
She said she wanted to 'acknowledge the incredible strength, courage and determination of families who have been relentless in advocating for their loved ones in both life and in death and in having to fight for truth, justice and accountability'.
'We know the trauma of your bereavement but also the trauma in your dealings with the trust and the lack of candour and denial and false promises of learning and action and how retraumatising that has been,' she said.
'This inquiry I think is an absolute testament to your perseverance.
'When someone you love is taken into mental healthcare you expect them to be looked after and kept safe.
'The team at Inquest stand both in solidarity but in support for what you've achieved but also recognise the emotional and physical impact of what you've been and are still going through.
'You've ensured that a light is being shone behind the closed doors of these mental health settings and focusing a light on the candour of the trust and the truth must come out.'
Commemorative evidence from loved ones about those who died was given at a series of hearings last year, and this week is the third week of a three-week block of introductory hearings.
The introductory hearings will continue until Thursday, with the next block of hearings in July.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
19 minutes ago
- Times
The foods to eat to reduce inflammation — and those to avoid
Inflammation has been linked to the development of a host of life-threatening health conditions including heart disease, cancer, obesity, type 2 diabetes and dementia, and it plays a causal role in autoimmune diseases such as type 1 diabetes and inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). Reduce it, and the threat of these diseases has been shown to decline. But how many of us know what inflammation is, why too much is so damaging, or what we can do to protect ourselves from it? • Read more expert advice on healthy living, fitness and wellbeing 'Inflammation is a defence system,' says Dr James Kinross, a consultant surgeon and lecturer in colorectal surgery at Imperial College London. 'It is a process through which our body is able to detect harm and regenerate itself once it's sustained an injury.' Cut your finger or catch a cold, for example, and the damaged cells release chemicals that trigger a response to heal you. If all systems are in good order, the inflammation subsides once you are well. Inflammation becomes a risk, Kinross says, when that response isn't switched off again. It's designed to be acute, but not chronic or excessive. 'If it switches on for the wrong reasons or you lose that balance, it becomes problematic,' he says. 'The immune system will literally attack our body's cells and tissues.' One of its biggest triggers is our modern environment and lifestyle, says the gastroenterologist Shilpa Ravella, the author of A Silent Fire: The Story of Inflammation, Diet and Disease. 'We've altered, among many things, our diet, physical activity, stress levels, sleep, social connections, the quality of the air we breathe, and our exposure to toxins from our household and other products,' she says. We have never been exposed to so many factors that trigger inflammation in our bodies, and we know this owing to recent strides in molecular medicine. Danny Altmann, a professor of immunology at Imperial College London, says that doctors can now measure a range of biological markers, including cytokines, that increase with excessive inflammation and are signs of 'bad or unhealthy stuff going on'. Age, for example, increases our susceptibility to inflammation, Altmann says. 'If you do all those biomarker measurements, they grow further and further off-kilter as you grow older, and contribute to poor health.' In its early stages, persistent low-level inflammation can be silent and 'hidden, simmering quietly in the blood of ostensibly healthy people,' Ravella says. 'One thing to watch out for is belly fat, because it is a proxy for hidden 'visceral' fat that wraps around inner abdominal organs. And this type of fat is highly inflammatory, churning out inflammatory cytokines at all hours.' She stresses that the risk is more closely related to lifestyle choices than how you look. Improving diet, reducing stress and exercising more frequently can reduce chronic, hidden inflammation 'even without a change in the amount of belly fat one has'. Similarly, you can look fit and slim but harbour silent inflammation if you don't have good lifestyle habits. To make sense of this link, it helps to understand how the immune system works, says Kinross, who has written a book on the subject, Dark Matter: The New Science of the Microbiome. Your immune system has two parts. Your innate immune system deals with day-to-day challenges and threats: if your body meets a pathogen, it mounts an immediate response. When your body meets the same pathogen again, the second part of the immune system, the adaptive part, learns how to make antibodies to fight it and creates a more precise strike. • 14 foods you should eat every week (including chocolate) 'This is where the microbiome is so important,' Kinross says. 'You need bugs to educate and set up and teach that system friend from foe. You also need the right balance of microbes because they can speak to that immune system and say, 'Hey guys, you need to ramp up'. But they can also put the brake on.' So healthy gut bugs and a diverse microbiome make for a more efficient immune system. Kinross believes that the huge rise in conditions that share a common thread of inflammation can be attributed partly to failing to programme our immune systems effectively in early life. The overuse of antibiotics, a diet of nutrient-poor and ultra-processed foods and exposure to pollution all negatively affect the microbiome. Antonio Vidal-Puig, a professor of molecular nutrition and metabolism at the University of Cambridge, heads a team researching the mechanisms that link obesity with metabolic complications including insulin resistance, diabetes, fatty liver and heart disease. 'Obesity is also associated with neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer's, and also with cancer — such as colon, breast, prostate or gynaecological — as well as IBD and many other common diseases,' he says.'Inflammation is a key component in the story everywhere.' We already know that losing weight cuts obesity-related cancer risk, but a study presented at the European Congress of Obesity in May suggested that losing weight through taking GLP-1 medication (such as Ozempic or Mounjaro) resulted in a 41 per cent greater reduction in risk than if one were to lose the same weight through bariatric surgery. Obesity can cause chronic inflammation through metabolically abnormal fatty tissues releasing hormones and proteins that reduce anti-inflammatory immune cells across the body, as well as through imbalances in insulin and glucose, says Dr Matthew Harris, a Cancer Research UK clinical research fellow and lead author of PADRAIC, a project at the University of Manchester researching anti-obesity interventions to prevent adult cancers. However, it's likely that there are some direct effects of GLP-1 drugs on the immune system too, he adds. 'There are GLP-1 receptors all over the body — predominantly in the gut, brain and pancreas, but also on immune cells called T-cells that respond to inflammation. While it's likely that the anti-inflammatory effects of GLP-1 drugs are mostly due to a reduction in 'sick fat', it's speculated that there may also be some direct effects on the receptors.' A Mediterranean-style diet enhances health because it contains fruit, leafy greens and other vegetables, whole grains, legumes, nuts, spices and herbs, all of which have high anti-inflammatory potential, Ravella says. 'These foods contain a host of substances essential for regulating the immune system, like polyphenols, carotenoids and other phytochemicals, as well as unsaturated fats like omega-3s.' • The 13 carbs you should eat Our most anti-inflammatory nutrient? Fibre from plant sources. We should be eating 30g of fibre daily, but at least 90 per cent of UK adults are deficient in it. 'Fibre can manipulate all arms of the immune system,' Ravella says. Ultra-processed foods full of additives, foods that contain an excess of sugar and salt, plus refined carbs and unhealthy animal foods including processed meats can all activate the immune system, stressing cells in the body and triggering inflammation, she says. Alcohol, too, is inflammatory, says Dr Federica Amati, a medical scientist and nutrition lead at Imperial College London. Colourful fruit and veg and leafy greens 'Fruits and vegetables that are high in antioxidant polyphenols combat oxidative stress and lower inflammatory markers,' says Amati, who is also head nutritionist at the science and nutrition company Zoe and the author of Every Body Should Know This: The Science of Eating for a Lifetime of Health. Colourful fruits are particularly beneficial. Pomegranates, for example, contain specific polyphenols associated with reducing heart disease, she says. Beetroot is another deeply coloured antioxidant-rich plant that helps to reduce inflammation. And yellow-toned plants — papayas, oranges, mangos, apples, carrots and celery — contain the polyphenol apigenin, which has anti-inflammatory effects. Fruits and vegetables are also high in fibre, which helps to maintain a healthy gut microbiome, and can create short-chain fatty acids, which are good for maintaining the integrity of the gut lining. Cruciferous vegetables such as cauliflower, broccoli and Brussels sprouts, and leafy greens including spinach, Swiss chard and cavolo nero, are particularly beneficial. Legumes Black beans, chickpeas, lentils and edamame are high in fibre and polyphenols. 'Lentils contain plenty of fibre and plant protein, as well as micronutrients like iron. They are a nutritional powerhouse,' Amati says. MushroomsMushrooms provide fibre, plant protein and polyphenols that are special to fungi, Amati says. 'Increasing your intake of mushrooms is associated with lower inflammation and if you sunbathe them on your windowsill, they will also contain vitamin D, which is great for immune health.' Omega-3 fatty acids found in fishSalmon, sardines, anchovies, and mackerel are rich sources of omega-3 fatty acids, but so are flaxseeds, chia seeds and walnuts. Studies have found that they help cells to make more omega-3-derived metabolites which turn off the inflammatory response and work to improve the gut microbiome. 'They're known to have anti-inflammatory properties and are metabolised by the gut microbiome — our gut microbes love omega-3,' Amati says. 'They have properties that are important for reducing inflammation in the liver.' • The ultra-processed foods the top nutritionist says are healthy Wholegrains such as oats and speltSteel-cut oats, barley, quinoa, buckwheat and spelt contain a fibre called beta-glucan, which has anti-inflammatory properties, reduces cholesterol and helps with heart health. Nuts and seeds As well as the omega-3 in flaxseeds, chia seeds and walnuts, other seeds and nuts, such as almonds and pumpkin seeds, contain healthy poly and monounsaturated fats. 'They also provide polyphenols of their own that help to lower inflammation,' Amati says. Extra virgin olive oilThis is in a category of its own. 'It has a clear role in the Mediterranean diet, but as an ingredient itself, its particular polyphenols and fats have very strong anti-inflammatory effects that have been likened to the anti-inflammatory effects of ibuprofen,' Amati says. Herbs, spices and fermented foodTurmeric, ginger and garlic have potent anti-inflammatory effects thanks to the specific polyphenols found in them, such as curcumin in turmeric and allicin in garlic. Amati notes that a recent trial by scientists at Stanford University investigated how the gut microbiome and inflammatory modulation changed between a fibre-rich diet and a fermented food-rich diet. 'The high-fibre diet helped to improve immune system function, so it was better able to react appropriately to pathogens. The high fermented-food diet, containing yoghurt, kefir, sauerkraut and kimchi, helped to reduce systemic inflammation, specifically helping to modulate unnecessary inflammatory response.' Bacon and processed meatsThese are high in salt and saturated fat, both of which cause inflammatory responses in the body and are linked to an increased risk of bowel cancer. 'We think this is due to a combination of the saturated fat and the way they are processed, along with the additives like nitrates and salt,' Amati says. 'They are also not good for the gut microbiome, which makes it easier for the inflammation to go up.' Sweets and fizzy drinks Foods that are high in sugar will raise your blood sugar level rapidly, also increasing insulin levels, which promotes an inflammatory state in the body. 'Sugar is also absorbed quickly into the liver and the liver doesn't like that,' Amati says. Factory-made pastries and cakesThese tend to be high in saturated fats and refined carbohydrates, as well as sugar. 'Research has shown that people who have a higher intake of refined carbs have higher inflammatory markers,' Amati says. 'Refined carbs are stripped of fibre, antioxidants and micronutrients during processing, which removes the naturally anti-inflammatory compounds. When sugar reacts with proteins or fats in the body, it forms AGEs [advanced glycation end-products], which accumulate in tissues and trigger immune cells to release inflammatory cytokines.'
The Herald Scotland
25 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Women's Prize for Fiction ‘greatest honour' as an intersex woman, says winner
The book, which explores repressed desire and the unresolved aftermath of the Holocaust in post-Second World War Netherlands, was described as an 'astonishing debut' by the head of the judges. The ceremony, held in central London on Thursday, saw the non-fiction prize awarded to physician Dr Rachel Clarke for The Story Of A Heart, which explores the human experience behind organ donation. In her winner's speech, after thanking the judges, van der Wouden said: 'I was a girl until I turned 13, and then, as I hit puberty, all that was supposed to happen did not quite happen. 'And if it did happen, it happened too much, and all at once my girlhood became an uncertain fact. 'I won't thrill you too much with the specifics, but the long and the short of it is that, hormonally, I'm intersex. 'This little fact defined my life throughout my teens, until I advocated for the health care that I needed. 'The surgery and the hormones that I needed, which not all intersex people need. Not all intersex people feel at odds with their gender presentation. 'I mention the fact that I did, because in the few precious moments here on stage, I am receiving, truly, the greatest honour of my life as a woman, presenting to you as a woman, and accepting this Women's Prize. Aria Aber, Miranda July, Nussaibah Younis, Elizabeth Strout, Sanam Mahloudji and Yael van der Wouden at the ceremony (Ian West Media Assignments/PA) 'And that is because of every single trans person who's fought for health care, who changed the system, the law, societal standards, themselves. I stand on their shoulders.' The NHS website says intersex, or differences in sex development (DSD), is a group of rare conditions involving genes, hormones and reproductive organs that mean a person's sex development is different to most. In contrast, people who are transgender identify as a gender separate to the sex they were born in and sometimes go through gender-affirming surgery. Van der Wouden's novel follows Isabel, a young woman whose life in solitude is upended when her brother's girlfriend Eva comes to live in their family house in what turns into a summer of obsession, suspicion and desire. The chairwoman of the judges for the fiction prize, writer Kit de Waal, said: 'This astonishing debut is a classic in the making, a story to be loved and appreciated for generations to come. Books like this don't come along every day.' Van der Wouden will receive £30,000 and a limited-edition bronze statuette known as the Bessie, which was created and donated by artist Grizel Niven. Rachel Clarke won the non-fiction prize (Ian West Media Assignments/PA) The judging panel for the Women's Prize for Fiction included novelist and journalist Diana Evans, author and journalist Bryony Gordon, writer and magazine editor Deborah Joseph, and musician and composer Amelia Warner. Clarke said she has 'literally been a feminist since I was too young to know what that word even meant', as she collected her award. The physician's book recounts two family stories, documenting how medical staff take care of nine-year-old Kiera in her final hours after a car accident, while offering a new life to nine-year-old Max who is suffering from heart failure from a viral infection. Clarke, who is behind the books Breathtaking and Your Life In My Hands: A Junior Doctor's Story, will receive £30,000 and a limited-edition piece of art known as the Charlotte, both gifted by the Charlotte Aitken Trust. The judging panel for the non-fiction prize included writer and broadcaster Dr Leah Broad, whose work focuses on women's cultural history, and novelist and critic Elizabeth Buchan. Previous winners of the fiction prize include Tayari Jones for An American Marriage and Madeline Miller for The Song Of Achilles, while the first non-fiction prize was awarded last year to Naomi Klein for Doppelganger: A Trip Into The Mirror World. The awards were announced by the Women's Prize Trust, a UK charity that aims to 'create equitable opportunities for women in the world of books and beyond'.
South Wales Guardian
33 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Women's Prize for Fiction ‘greatest honour' as an intersex woman, says winner
Dutch author Yael van der Wouden won the accolade for her debut novel, The Safekeep, and used her winner's speech to champion the trans community, who have 'changed the system' and 'fought for health care'. The book, which explores repressed desire and the unresolved aftermath of the Holocaust in post-Second World War Netherlands, was described as an 'astonishing debut' by the head of the judges. The ceremony, held in central London on Thursday, saw the non-fiction prize awarded to physician Dr Rachel Clarke for The Story Of A Heart, which explores the human experience behind organ donation. In her winner's speech, after thanking the judges, van der Wouden said: 'I was a girl until I turned 13, and then, as I hit puberty, all that was supposed to happen did not quite happen. 'And if it did happen, it happened too much, and all at once my girlhood became an uncertain fact. 'I won't thrill you too much with the specifics, but the long and the short of it is that, hormonally, I'm intersex. 'This little fact defined my life throughout my teens, until I advocated for the health care that I needed. 'The surgery and the hormones that I needed, which not all intersex people need. Not all intersex people feel at odds with their gender presentation. 'I mention the fact that I did, because in the few precious moments here on stage, I am receiving, truly, the greatest honour of my life as a woman, presenting to you as a woman, and accepting this Women's Prize. 'And that is because of every single trans person who's fought for health care, who changed the system, the law, societal standards, themselves. I stand on their shoulders.' The NHS website says intersex, or differences in sex development (DSD), is a group of rare conditions involving genes, hormones and reproductive organs that mean a person's sex development is different to most. In contrast, people who are transgender identify as a gender separate to the sex they were born in and sometimes go through gender-affirming surgery. Van der Wouden's novel follows Isabel, a young woman whose life in solitude is upended when her brother's girlfriend Eva comes to live in their family house in what turns into a summer of obsession, suspicion and desire. The chairwoman of the judges for the fiction prize, writer Kit de Waal, said: 'This astonishing debut is a classic in the making, a story to be loved and appreciated for generations to come. Books like this don't come along every day.' Van der Wouden will receive £30,000 and a limited-edition bronze statuette known as the Bessie, which was created and donated by artist Grizel Niven. The judging panel for the Women's Prize for Fiction included novelist and journalist Diana Evans, author and journalist Bryony Gordon, writer and magazine editor Deborah Joseph, and musician and composer Amelia Warner. Clarke said she has 'literally been a feminist since I was too young to know what that word even meant', as she collected her award. The physician's book recounts two family stories, documenting how medical staff take care of nine-year-old Kiera in her final hours after a car accident, while offering a new life to nine-year-old Max who is suffering from heart failure from a viral infection. Clarke, who is behind the books Breathtaking and Your Life In My Hands: A Junior Doctor's Story, will receive £30,000 and a limited-edition piece of art known as the Charlotte, both gifted by the Charlotte Aitken Trust. The judging panel for the non-fiction prize included writer and broadcaster Dr Leah Broad, whose work focuses on women's cultural history, and novelist and critic Elizabeth Buchan. Previous winners of the fiction prize include Tayari Jones for An American Marriage and Madeline Miller for The Song Of Achilles, while the first non-fiction prize was awarded last year to Naomi Klein for Doppelganger: A Trip Into The Mirror World. The awards were announced by the Women's Prize Trust, a UK charity that aims to 'create equitable opportunities for women in the world of books and beyond'.
