A quiet Tiananmen Square anniversary shows China's ability to suppress history
By KEN MORITSUGU and KANIS LEUNG
For most Chinese, the 36th anniversary of a bloody crackdown that ended pro-democracy protests in China passed like any other weekday. And that's just how the ruling Communist Party wants it.
Security was tight Wednesday around Beijing's Tiananmen Square, where weeks of student-led protests shook the party in 1989. Under then-leader Deng Xiaoping, the military was sent in to end the protest on the night of June 3-4. Using live ammunition, soldiers forced their way through crowds that tried to block them from reaching the square. Hundreds and possibly thousands of people were killed, including dozens of soldiers.
The party has tried, with some success, to erase what it calls the 'political turmoil' of 1989 from the collective memory. It bans any public commemoration or mention of the June 4 crackdown, scrubbing references from the internet.
In recent years, that ban has been extended to Hong Kong, where a once-massive annual candlelight vigil is no longer permitted. Police said they brought 10 people on suspicion of breaching public peace to a police station for investigation. Three were still detained late Wednesday, while the rest were allowed to leave. Police also arrested a woman for failing to show her identity document and a man for obstructing police officers from performing their duties.
It is only in Taiwan, a self-governing island that is claimed by China but runs its own affairs, that large June 4 gatherings can still take place.
Tiananmen Square is a vast space in the center of Beijing with monumental, communist-era buildings along two sides and the mausoleum of Mao Zedong, who founded the communist era in 1949, on the south end.
University students occupied this symbolically important site in the spring of 1989. Their calls for freedoms divided the party leadership. The decision to send in troops marked a decisive turning point in the evolution of modern China, keeping the party firmly in control as it loosened economic restrictions.
Chinese officials have said the country's rapid economic development since then proves the decisions made at the time were correct.
'On the political turmoil that happened in the late 1980s, the Chinese government has already reached a clear conclusion," Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian said Wednesday. He added that China would continue along its current path of what it calls 'socialism with Chinese characteristics."
Tiananmen Mothers, a group formed by relatives of the victims, made an annual online appeal to the government. Signed by 108 members, it called for an independent investigation into what happened on June 4, 1989, including a list of all who died. The group also demanded compensation for the families and a legal case against those responsible for the deaths.
The British and German Embassies in Beijing posted videos commemorating the anniversary on Weibo, a Chinese social media platform, but they were later taken down, presumably by censors. The Canadian and German Embassies displayed images of a single lit candle on large screens facing the main street.
In Hong Kong, a carnival showcasing Chinese food and products was held in Victoria Park, where tens of thousands of people used to gather for a candlelight vigil to mark the anniversary.
Hong Kong authorities first shut down the vigil during the COVID-19 pandemic and arrested the organizers in 2021. The moves were part of a broader crackdown on dissent following monthslong anti-government protests in 2019 that turned violent and paralyzed parts of the city.
A former district council member, Chan Kim-kam, said customs officers questioned her at her shop on the eve of June 4 after she advertised small white candles for sale in an Instagram post titled 'June, we don't forget.'
'You know, Hong Kongers have become silent lambs after 2019,' said King Ng, who was at the park on Wednesday.
Police were out in force to try to prevent any protest, and took several people away from the park on Wednesday. They included a young woman wearing a school uniform and holding flowers, a man who lowered his head in apparent prayer, and a man wearing a white T-shirt reading 'Vindication for June 4. It's getting closer and closer." Police also questioned a woman who lit up a mosquito lamp, but eventually let her go.
Rows of electronic candles lit up the windows of the U.S. consulate, and the British consulate projected 'VIIV' — Roman numerals in reference to June 4 — on one of its walls.
The British and Canadian consulates earlier posted social media messages about remembering June 4. Hong Kong was a British colony until 1997. The U.S. consulate posted a message from U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio on its website.
'The CCP actively tries to censor the facts,' Rubio said, referring to China's Communist Party. "But the world will never forget.'
Taiwan's President Lai Ching-te used the anniversary to position the island he leads on the frontline of defending democracy against authoritarianism. In a Facebook post, he drew a distinction between Taiwan's multiparty democracy and China's one-party rule.
'Authoritarian governments often choose to remain silent and forget about history, while democratic societies choose to preserve the truth and refuse to forget those who have contributed to the ideals of human rights and the dreams they embrace,' Lai wrote.
Taiwan transitioned from authoritarianism to democracy in a process that began in the late 1980s. It relies on support principally from the U.S., along with other democratic partners, to deter China from an invasion.
Several hundred people gathered Wednesday evening for a candlelight vigil in downtown Taipei's Freedom Square. In the center stood a scaled-down model of the 'Pillar of Shame," a sculpture commemorating the protests that once stood on the campus of the University of Hong Kong.
Hong Kong authorities have placed bounties on some activists who have moved abroad. Other democracy advocates in the semi-autonomous Chinese city remain in jail or intimidated into silence.
Wu Lang-huang, a Taiwanese professor who was present when troops arrived on the square in 1989, said he will continue to document what happened and collect related artifacts.
'It's not just about remembering what happened then but also for the lessons it tells us about modern Hong Kong and Taiwan,' Wu said.
One of the vigil's organizers, who went by the name Mimi for fear of repercussions, said some may question why people born years after the 1989 protests still care.
'It's about memory, which is itself a form of resistance,' she said.
The year in which British colonial rule ended in Hong Kong has been corrected in this story to 1997.
© Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Asahi Shimbun
2 hours ago
- Asahi Shimbun
U.S. declines to label China a currency manipulator, but blasts its transparency policies
WASHINGTON--The U.S. declined to label China a currency manipulator in a new Treasury report released Thursday but accuses Beijing of standing out among America's major trading partners for lacking transparency in its exchange rate policies. Treasury's semi-annual report to Congress — called Macroeconomic and Foreign Exchange Policies of Major Trading Partners of the United States— comes as the Trump administration seeks to strike a trade deal with China, averting a trade war that has been brewing between the two nations. A Treasury official told reporters previewing the report that the U.S. could in the future find evidence that China is manipulating its currency and will make a determination in the fall whether China has been manipulating the renminbi, also known as RMB. During President Donald Trump 's first term, the Treasury, which was then led by Secretary Steve Mnuchin, labeled China a currency manipulator in 2019 — before then the U.S. had not put China on the currency blacklist since 1994. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said the administration 'has put our trading partners on notice that macroeconomic policies that incentivize an unbalanced trading relationship with the United States will no longer be accepted.' 'Moving forward, Treasury will use all available tools at its disposal to implement strong countermeasures against unfair currency practices,' he said. The decision not to sanction China for currency manipulation comes after Trump said Thursday that his first call with China's Xi Jinping since returning to office was 'very positive,' announcing that the two countries will hold trade talks in hopes of breaking an impasse over tariffs and global supplies of rare earth minerals. 'Our respective teams will be meeting shortly at a location to be determined,' Trump wrote on his social media platform after the call, which he said lasted an hour and a half. Trump has lowered his 145% tariffs on Chinese goods to 30% for 90 days to allow for talks. China also reduced its taxes on U.S. goods from 125% to 10%. The back and forth has caused sharp swings in global markets and threatens to hamper trade between the two countries.
Asahi Shimbun
2 hours ago
- Asahi Shimbun
Hong Kong activist Joshua Wong charged under Beijing-imposed security law for second time
HONG KONG--Prominent Hong Kong activist Joshua Wong on Friday was charged with conspiracy to collude with foreign forces to endanger national security under a Beijing-imposed law that critics say has crushed Hong Kong's once-thriving pro-democracy movement. The prosecution was the second time Wong has been charged under the sweeping national security law. He was already convicted in a separate subversion case linked to an unofficial primary election and is serving a sentence of four years and eight months. The prosecution accused Wong, 28, of conspiring with fellow activist Nathan Law and others to ask foreign countries, institutions, organizations and individuals outside of China to impose sanctions or blockades, or engage in other hostile actions, against Hong Kong and China. They also said he disrupted the formulation and implementation of laws and policies by the Chinese and Hong Kong governments, and that the act was likely to have serious consequences. The alleged offense occurred between July 2020 and November 2020. The prosecution didn't elaborate on the accusations in court. The charge carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. After hearing the charge in court, Wong, who wore a blue shirt and was visibly thinner, said he 'understood' the charge. The case was adjourned to August. National security police arrested Wong in Stanley, an area in southern Hong Kong, over the national security charge and also on suspicion of 'dealing with property known or believed to represent proceeds of indictable offense,' police said in a statement. Wong rose to fame in Hong Kong in 2012 as a high school student leading protests against the introduction of national education in the city's schools. Two years later, he became world famous as a leader of the Occupy Movement. In 2016, Wong co-founded a political party named 'Demosisto' with fellow young activists Law and Agnes Chow. In the 2019 pro-democracy movement, Wong helped seek overseas support for the protests. His activism led Beijing to label him an advocate of Hong Kong's independence who 'begged for interference' by foreign forces. Demosisto disbanded when Beijing imposed the security law in 2020. The Chinese and Hong Kong governments said the law brought back stability to the city.
Asahi Shimbun
2 hours ago
- Asahi Shimbun
INTERVIEW/ David Shear: China's buildup poses threat to U.S. alliances in the Indo-Pacific
China's dream to establish a Sinocentric order in East Asia and the Indo-Pacific poses a grave security threat to the United States and its allies, according to a former U.S. assistant secretary of defense and expert on Asian affairs. 'The Chinese want to diminish America's alliances with East Asian countries in the short to medium term and--I'm sure--eliminate them in the long term,' David Shear told The Asahi Shimbun in a recent interview. He said the Chinese military buildup gives China an increased ability to drive wedges, or attempt to drive divisions, between the United States and its allies. Shear said China has been deploying its naval forces throughout the region partly to ensure the security of sea lanes through the Indian Ocean. According to Shear, the Chinese believe in the philosophy espoused by Alfred Thayer Mahan (1840-1914), an influential exponent of sea power. The U.S. naval officer and historian argued that naval strength is essential to protect commercial shipping fleets, which transport domestic products to overseas markets. 'The flag follows trade,' Shear said. 'The Chinese are Mahanians. They know that merchant marine and naval deployments go together.' The former U.S. diplomat also said the United States needs to beef up its shipbuilding industry with its allies to match China's quick pace of launching new, large warships. Excerpts from the interview follow: * * * Question: While China continues to be building large warships, the United States has failed to produce a sufficient number of ships. What can the United States do? Shear: We should be particularly concerned about U.S. naval shipbuilding capacity. President Donald Trump touched on this important issue in his State of the Union address. We're not producing ships fast enough. We don't have the facilities necessary to produce the number of ships we want over the next couple of years. My understanding is that we need to build 2.3 submarines per year to maintain the levels we need, particularly in the western Pacific. But we're building something like 1.5 submarines a year. We need the facilities and the skilled labor. At the end of April, John Phelan, secretary of the Navy, visited Japan to discuss defense industry cooperation, including bilateral efforts to maintain U.S. warships, with Defense Minister Gen Nakatani. Carlos Del Toro, secretary of the Navy in the Biden administration, visited Japan at least three times and had a productive discussion with the Japanese side on shipbuilding. South Korean shipbuilder Hanwha Ocean agreed to invest in a Philadelphia shipyard last year, and the Hyundai group also decided to work with a U.S. shipbuilding company in April. The United States needs to get together with our allies, particularly Japan, Australia and hopefully Britain, to address these issues. Q: How do you assess China's military activities in recent years? A: The growth of Chinese military strength and Chinese naval strength provides a revisionist Chinese Communist regime with the increased options and extra tools it wants to assert its expansive and excessive territorial claims throughout the region, including over the Senkaku Islands in the East China Sea as well as in the South China Sea. For the past couple of years, we've seen the Chinese leadership use military options vis-a-vis Taiwan, drastically increasing their operations and efforts to intimidate it. The Chinese military buildup gives China an increased ability to drive wedges, or attempt to drive wedges, between the United States and its allies. We've seen intensified Chinese military activity and Coast Guard activity in the vicinity of the Senkakus and Taiwan as well as in the South China Sea. I note that the Chinese have double the number of Coast Guard cutters over 1,000 tons that Japan has. Q: What is China's objective? A: Chinese President Xi Jinping has said that he wants the 'great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation' by 2049 (the centenary of the founding of China). He wants to establish a community of common destiny, which basically means a Sinocentric order in East Asia and the Indo-Pacific. To do that, the Chinese want to diminish America's alliances with East Asian countries in the short to medium term and--I'm sure--eliminate them in the long term. This represents a threat to the security of the United States as well as of our allies like Japan. Q: Does China intend to deploy its Navy globally? A: In the short to medium term, the Chinese intention is to increase deterrence with the first and second island chains and maximize their ability to prevent the United States from intervening in a Taiwan Strait crisis. But it's clear that the Chinese have much more expansive ambitions for their Navy over the longer term, and you can see this in their posture and deployments throughout the region. They are concerned about the security of sea lanes through the Indian Ocean, from the Strait of Malacca to the Persian Gulf. China has increased deployments of warships and submarines to the Indian Ocean and built dual-use port facilities throughout the region, such as in Djibouti in Africa and Ream, Cambodia. The Chinese appear to have interests in other port facilities in Pakistan, Myanmar and even Equatorial Guinea in Africa. The flag follows trade. The Chinese are Mahanians. They know that merchant marine and naval deployments go together. Q: Can China coexist with the United States in the Pacific? A: I think the Chinese want to come to us and say, 'You take your side of the Pacific, and we'll take ours, and all the world will be at peace.' I just don't think that that is an acceptable arrangement for the United States, and I hope it's not an acceptable arrangement for the Trump administration as well. Q: Trump is trying to link national security with tariff negotiations. What is your view? A: I agree with the Trump administration that our allies need to step up more strongly to provide for their defense and contribute to the alliance. That has always been my aim as an American diplomat working with the Japanese side. But linking economic and security issues as closely as the Trump administration has is detrimental. It would be very dangerous for us to suggest that our defense commitment would diminish with the extent of the trade deficit. The Trump administration is also trying to get close to our allies geopolitically while beating them up geoeconomically. I don't think that's a good idea. Q: Is it impossible for Japan to prevent China's high-handed behavior without increasing its defense spending? A: Both the United States and Japan need to increase their defense budgets and strengthen their military capabilities to continue deterring China. But deterrence isn't the only piece to a successful approach to China. Both of us need to be engaging China diplomatically at the same time. It just doesn't pay to stop communicating with our Chinese counterparts. We need a diplomatic as well as an economic component to our strategy. It's not just a matter of military confrontation to be able to communicate with the Chinese. I would welcome increased dialogue between Japan and China, just as I welcome increased Japanese defense spending. Q: Does it mean that a combination of dialogue and deterrence is necessary? A: It's important that our approach to China not deteriorate into a mere military confrontation. That is the road to war, and to avoid taking that road, we need to have healthy diplomatic exchanges with the Chinese. In fact, our actual strategy toward China has been a combination of engagement and hedging and deterrence for decades. The question is which component of that approach you place emphasis on. We're now in a hedging and deterrence phase, but we can't abandon the engagement side. It's the only way to maintain some kind of stable situation in the western Pacific. Q: Southeast Asian countries are concerned that Trump is not interested in this region. What can change his stance? A: The best way to get President Trump to participate in the East Asia Summit and the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit is to get moving on trade talks as quickly as possible. (This article is based on an interview by Atsushi Okudera, a senior staff writer.) * * * David Shear was a U.S. diplomat in charge of Japan, China and other Asian countries. A former U.S. ambassador to Vietnam, he also worked in Tokyo, Sapporo and Beijing. Shear served as assistant secretary of defense for Asian and Pacific security affairs between 2014 and 2016 under the second Obama administration. He is currently a senior adviser at the Edwin O. Reischauer Center for East Asian Studies of the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies.
