Minnesota's bill to ban transgender athletes fails
Debate on a bill to ban transgender athletes from Minnesota school sports started late Monday afternoon, and has now failed after not getting 68 votes to pass the bill.
GOP authors believe allowing it opens girls up to losing their spot on a team or even dangerous physical interactions, and it's just unfair.
DFL opponents say it's an unnecessary and cruel distraction that ignores established law and demonizes the small population of transgender people.
ST. PAUL, Minn. (FOX 9) - The Minnesota House spent Monday in the longest debate of the year over a GOP bill to block transgender athletes in girls' sports, which failed Monday evening.
What they're saying
The bill to ban transgender athletes from girls' sports in Minnesota failed in the Minnesota House. The House voted 67-66 in favor of the bill, but a 68-vote majority is needed to pass a bill in the House.
Speaker Emerita Melissa Hortman released the following statement:
"People of all ages deserve to be loved, accepted, and valued for who they are. At its core, this bill is about how we treat children, and it would allow children to be bullied by adults and other children for not meeting a particular definition of femininity. While Republicans push cruel, divisive bills like this, they ignore the real challenges Minnesotans are facing — like the rising costs of childcare, health care, and housing. Instead of solving problems, they're fueling division."
Author of the bill, Rep. Peggy Scott (R-Andover) released the following statement:
"There are fairness issues and there are safety issues involving girls' sports teams. When it comes to boys' and girls' athletics, how you identify shouldn't matter; how you were born should."
The celebrity case
It's a hot-button issue across the country and the vote drew a celebrity spokesperson to support the bill.
Riley Gaines took center stage in the debate before the debate.
A crowd at the Capitol heard from the former Kentucky swimmer who rose to fame after she tied for fifth place with transgender swimmer Lia Thomas.
A crowd also heard support for trans athletes from another 2022 college swimmer from here in Minnesota.
"I believe in preserving female sports teams," said Rep. Dawn Gillman, (R-Meeker).
For at least ten years, transgender kids in Minnesota have been allowed to participate in sports based on their gender identity.
Republicans want that to end, and they brought Gaines to the Capitol for a rally to boost their bill.
"Minnesotans and Americans alike reject this absurdity," said the former swimmer. "We embrace the America First agenda, and we reject this absurdity."
Challenging gender
The bill debated Monday on the House floor would have banned transgender girls from school sports.
If challenged, a female athlete would have to prove their gender. The House bill no longer describes how that would happen, leaving it up to the schools, but it originally matched a corresponding Senate bill requiring a doctor's note after an examination of the athlete's anatomy, hormone levels and chromosomes.
Authors told FOX 9 they're not aware of any transgender athletes competing now in Minnesota.
But they believe allowing it opens girls up to losing their spot on a team or even dangerous physical interactions, and it's just unfair.
Allowing access
Not all female athletes see it the same way.
"Athletics offers so many benefits, from physical to mental health," said Kara Cowell, another former NCAA championship swimmer. "To educational success and self-confidence. Trans women and girls deserve the same access to these benefits."
Transgender advocates point out that not even 10 of the 520,000 college athletes last year were transgender and none of them was a superstar.
They point to research showing hormone therapy seems to remove any physical advantages.
And they accuse Republicans of creating a distraction by making a boogeyman out of transgender athletes.
"This bill is not about protecting fairness in sports or upholding integrity," said transgender teacher and coach Maggie Dayvis. "Instead, it is a calculated effort to sow division, to amplify fear, and to distract from the larger issue of defunding education."
A similar Senate will was also rejected by the DFL majority on Monday.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


USA Today
28 minutes ago
- USA Today
I'm glad Trump is gutting the EPA. My family's tire-burning business is on fire!
The glorious news that the Trump administration is basically disavowing the very idea of climate change (HOAX!) rattled all the eco-losers out there. Every morning I wake up, open the doors to my family tire-burning and tainted-meat-sales business and thank God for President Donald J. Trump. We have learned that the Environmental Protection Agency is going to do away with its woke and anti-tire-fire-business belief that greenhouse gas emissions are a danger to human health. According to USA TODAY – which I don't read – EPA head Lee Zeldin said getting rid of the 'endangerment finding' of 2009 will 'save Americans money and unravel two decades of regulation aimed at reducing carbon dioxide, methane and other greenhouse gases from cars, power plants, oil production and other sources.' It's about freakin' time. I've been in the outdoor tire-burning business for more than two decades, and I know firsthand my burn pit's emissions don't present any health risks. My remaining half-lung is healthier than ever (only weak soy boys need two lungs) thanks to the strength it built up through years of asthma. Trump knows EPA has no business protecting the environment And don't get me started on climate change. The higher the temperatures, the easier it is to stand next to a pile of burning radial tires for hours a day without noticing a temperature difference. Heck, we're even saving money on matches and kerosene because the summers are so hot the tires just spontaneously combust. Opinion: Trump's mental decline is on vivid display as he rages about Epstein, windmills The glorious news that the Trump administration is basically disavowing the very idea of climate change (HOAX!) rattled all the eco-losers out there, including Scott Saleska, professor of ecology and evolutionary biology at the University of Arizona, who told The Associated Press: 'To repeal the endangerment finding now would be like a driver who is speeding towards a cliff taking his foot off the brake and instead pressing the accelerator.' Damn right, Prof. Scaredy Cat. Everyone knows you hit the accelerator when approaching a cliff. You don't want to hit the kick-ass canyon-jumping ramp going slow. That's a little thing called 'fun' – maybe look it up in one of those books you claim contain 'facts.' Deregulating food safety is a win for tainted-meat sellers and customers Anyway, thanks to President Trump, the tire-burning arm of my family's business is about to boom, just like our tainted-meat sales spiked earlier this year after MY president issued an executive order doing away with the Department of Agriculture's National Advisory Committee on Meat and Poultry Inspection and the National Advisory Committee on Microbiological Criteria for Foods. Previously: Musk, RFK Jr. drive off FDA inspectors, preserving my right to eat tainted meat | Opinion We here at the Huppke Flaming Tire and Cheap Meat Emporium say the more deregulation, the better – especially when it comes to food. Since that executive order, our unrefrigerated, fresh-from-Interstate-57, week-old cuts of venison and 'mystery protein' have been selling like unregulated lead-based hotcakes. Government can't stop me from selling tire fire-smoked jerky We used to have to hide the fact that we smoke our delicious precooked meats over the artisanal tire fires, but not anymore. And the money we're saving on fly control … it's a real boon to businesses like mine that believe meat in any condition is suitable for human consumption as long as you tell the customers to cook it a good long time so they don't get the trots. Opinion: Trump is unpopular, polls show, and he's building an America most Americans hate With the extra money we're making, we'll now be able to hire another tire fire tender, since the last one died of a rare combination of heat exhaustion and mystery-jerky poisoning. God bless you, President Trump! And thank you for not caring about the cancer cluster in the town downwind of our business. Only a lib would think there's some kind of connection! Follow USA TODAY columnist Rex Huppke on Bluesky at @ and on Facebook at You can read diverse opinions from our USA TODAY columnists and other writers on the Opinion front page, on X, formerly Twitter, @usatodayopinion and in our Opinion newsletter.


NBC News
29 minutes ago
- NBC News
Natural disaster victims would get six months of mortgage relief under Senate bill
LOS ANGELES — Natural disaster survivors would be eligible for six months of mortgage relief under a bill introduced Thursday by two senators whose states have been ravaged by wildfires and floods. The Mortgage Relief for Disaster Survivors Act would apply to homeowners with federally backed loans in areas declared disasters since Jan. 1 without accumulating interest or penalties during the six-month period. Borrowers could apply for additional six-month extensions. 'Earlier this year, we watched as families in Los Angeles were devastated by wildfires, and to date, many homeowners are still struggling to rebuild from this disaster,' said Sen. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., who is co-sponsoring the bill. 'As natural disasters become more frequent due to climate change, it is critical that we pave a path to stability for homeowners in times of crisis,' he added. Parts of Schiff's former congressional district in Southern California were devoured in January when the Eaton Fire tore through Altadena, destroying nearly 6,000 homes and killing at least 19 people. His co-sponsor is Sen. Michael Bennet, D-Colo., whose state was ravaged by the 2021 Marshall Fire, which damaged or destroyed some 1,200 homes in Boulder County. 'Coloradans know all too well how difficult it is to pick up the pieces and move forward after catastrophic wildfires,' Bennet said. 'When mounting financial and emotional costs of recovery weigh on families, they should be able to take time to put their lives back together and rebuild their homes.' House members who represent Altadena, Pacific Palisades and Malibu in California introduced a companion bill this year that would provide 180 days of mortgage relief without penalties or late fees. The pause would apply only to federally backed loans. Nonfederal lenders are not required to offer payment reprieves to homeowners in disaster zones. But after the Palisades and Eaton fires, more than 400 lenders agreed to a 90-day pause without reporting the missed payments to credit agencies. Eaton Fire survivor Freddy Sayegh said he took advantage of the program after heavy smoke damage prevented him from returning to his Altadena home. He has since moved his family seven times and incurred thousands of dollars of unforeseen costs for food, clothing and other immediate needs. Some of the costs were covered by insurance, but much of the money came out of his pocket while he awaits compensation. He dipped into his savings when the 90 days were over and paid his delinquent mortgage in a lump sum, fearing he would incur fees or be forced to refinance. 'It actually placed a lot of pressure to come up with three months all at once,' he said. 'There's a lot of people who don't have three months of savings.' In Texas, where cataclysmic flooding that began July 2 caused an estimated $240 million in damage, officials announced a 90-day foreclosure moratorium that prohibits mortgage companies from initiating or completing foreclosures in Kerr County, the area hardest hit by the disaster. According to the Mortgage Bankers Association, delinquencies nearly doubled nationally in March compared with the same time last year, up 21% from 12%. In California, wildfire-related delinquencies peaked in March at 4,100 and fell to 2,240 in June, according to the data tracking company ICE Mortgage Technology. The trend follows a pattern seen after other natural disasters, in which delinquencies spike in the months immediately following catastrophes and gradually level out over the next 18 to 24 months, said Andy Walden, head of mortgage and housing market research at Intercontinental Exchange, the parent company of ICE Mortgage Technology. 'It takes time for many homeowners to untangle finances while dealing with the emotional and logistical aftermath of losing their homes,' he said. 'From navigating insurance claims to working with FEMA, borrowers often need time to stabilize. Foreclosure moratoriums introduced after major disasters often give families the breathing room they need to recover.' Former Altadena resident Keni 'Arts' Davis stared down at a 10-year mortgage when his home of nearly four decades was destroyed. He has moved six times since then, finally landing close to the neighborhood he loved so much. Much of his recovery journey included negotiating with his insurance company to pay off his mortgage, rather than borrowing or seeking an extension. 'It might have meant financial ruin,' he said. He intends to rebuild by cobbling together the money through savings and microloans that are sometimes just $500. He said that the mortgage relief bills sound good on paper but that their timing leaves something to be desired. 'My grandmother would have said it's a day late and a dollar short,' he said. 'We're all just depending on any help we can get to make it one day to the next.'


CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
US support for Israel's actions in Gaza drops, as Democratic opposition grows and MAGA movement splits
Americans' support for Israel's military actions in Gaza is dropping rapidly, prompting pro-Israel Democrats and some of President Donald Trump's long-time allies to warn that the country could permanently damage its standing in the United States. A Gallup poll released this week found that just 32% of US adults support Israel's military actions in Gaza — a record low since the war was launched in response to Hamas' October 7, 2023, terror attack. The poll also found the strongest partisan split yet: Support among those who identify themselves as Republicans remained strong, at 71%. But just 8% of Democrats and 25% of independents say they back Israel's military actions. In perhaps the most ominous long-term sign for backers of Israel, the poll found just 9% support for its actions among those age 18-34 of all political parties. The shift in public opinion has crucial implications for both parties: Some key members of Trump's MAGA movement are vocally questioning whether the United States should keep supporting Israel, while plummeting backing for the country among Democrats will likely impact the party's primaries in key races in 2026 and 2028. The collapse in American support for Israel is part of a global trend. The United Kingdom said this week it would recognize a Palestinian state before the United Nations General Assembly unless Israel takes major steps to end the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. The announcement followed France's decision to do so. United Nations agencies are warning that 'time is running out to mount a full-scale humanitarian response' in the besieged Gaza Strip. Data show that more than one in three people (39%) are now going days at a time without eating, the UN's World Food Programme said in a statement Wednesday, adding that over 500,000 people — almost a quarter of Gaza's population — 'are enduring famine-like conditions.' Rep. Brad Sherman, a California Democrat who co-chairs the bipartisan Congressional Israel Allies Caucus, told CNN that Israel is losing the battle for worldwide public opinion. He said Israel's military faces serious challenges in Gaza, where Hamas is willing to incur massive civilian casualties 'to undermine Israel's position in the world,' but said its objectives 'have to be balanced against each other.' 'Israel has to determine, what are its military objectives, and what casualties is it willing to incur to realize that national security includes your image around the world,' Sherman said. 'You can't get everything you want, and your worldwide image is important.' Within the GOP, fissures over Israel's actions came into public view after Trump on Monday disputed Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's weekend assertion that there is 'no starvation in Gaza.' 'That's real starvation stuff,' Trump said. 'I see it, and you can't fake that. So, we're going to be even more involved.' Georgia Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, a prominent figure in Trump's 'Make America Great Again' movement, appeared to become the first Republican in Congress to describe the crisis in Gaza as a 'genocide' with a Monday night social media post. 'It's the most truthful and easiest thing to say that Oct 7th in Israel was horrific and all hostages must be returned, but so is the genocide, humanitarian crisis, and starvation happening in Gaza,' Greene said. Her comment came in a longer post criticizing Florida GOP Rep. Randy Fine, a staunch supporter of Israel. Fine told CNN that 'those who claim that Israel is engaged in genocide are either antisemites or idiots or both.' 'If Israel had wanted to commit a genocide in Gaza, they had the ability to do it. And it would have been done 18 months ago, and it would have been over in two days,' he said. 'Israel has the capability to kill everyone in Gaza, but they haven't. … Hundreds and hundreds of Israeli soldiers have died in order to minimize the deaths of Gaza Arabs.' He argued that Israel should stop putting its own soldiers at risk 'to minimize the deaths of the enemy.' Fine added: 'Israel needs to stop worrying about what the rest of the world thinks and take care of business. Political opinion does not win wars.' While many Republicans still agree with Fine, Steve Bannon, the former Trump chief strategist, said Tuesday on his podcast that there is 'very little support for Israel' within Trump's MAGA movement among those under age 30. 'And now, even people who support Israel are sitting there going, what in the hell's going on here?' Bannon said. Inside the Democratic Party, the issue of support for Israel proved to be a difficult one in 2024 for President Joe Biden and then his replacement atop the ballot, Vice President Kamala Harris, particularly in the battleground state of Michigan. That state, with its large Arab-American population, will host a competitive Senate contest in 2026. And Democrats who hope to run for president in 2028 will surely be pushed on their Israel policies in primaries across the country. Progressive Pennsylvania Rep. Summer Lee, who was one of six members of Congress to support a recent Greene amendment to strip $500 million in funding for Israel's missile defense systems from a defense appropriations bill, said in a statement that, 'The United States has a responsibility to demand a permanent ceasefire, stop funding and supplying the bombs being dropped, and call for unconditional humanitarian aid to enter Gaza immediately. It is good policy, good politics, and the right thing to do.' More establishment figures in liberal media have also sharpened their criticism of Israel in recent days — offering a preview of what could become a significant long-term shift in the party. The former aides to President Barack Obama who host the 'Pod Save America' podcast argued this week that Democratic candidates should stop supporting military aid for Israel. 'There has to be a total mindset change in the Democratic Party,' co-host Tommy Vietor, a former Obama National Security Council staffer, said. 'When the war ends, we are not going back to the pre-October 7 status quo. It's not where the party is. It's not where the world is.' Eric Fingerhut, the president and chief executive officer of the Jewish Federations of North America and a former Ohio Democratic congressman, said the Gallup findings numbers reflect 'overwhelmingly negative media coverage of the war.' 'There's no question that we are in a very partisan moment in America, and that that is an overlay on how people react to the situation in Israel and in the war in Gaza,' Fingerhut said. CNN's Nadeen Ebrahim and Ibrahim Dahman contributed to this report.