
Karen Read: Expert From Trial Explains'Hos Long To Die In Cold' And Deleted Calls
The Karen Read trial, with its swirling allegations of murder, conspiracy and law enforcement cover-up became a national spectacle not just for its courtroom drama, but for the pivotal role that digital evidence played in shaping the narrative.
As a digital forensics expert myself, I found the case to be a textbook example of both the power and the pitfalls of technical evidence in the justice system. My recent conversation with Jessica Hyde, who testified as a digital forensics expert in the trial for the prosecution, underscored how critical our discipline has become; and how easily it can be misunderstood.
The Search: 'Hos Long To Die In Cold'
The trial's most debated digital artifact was a Google search from Jen McCabe's iPhone: 'hos long to die in cold.' The defense's expert in the first trial claimed this search occurred at 2:47 a.m., before the victim was found, implying prior knowledge. Hyde's testimony clarified that the timestamp reflected when the browser tab was opened, not when the search was performed. This misinterpretation arose from an over-reliance on automated forensic tools. "If the tools themselves did the job for us, we wouldn't need us as experts. We have to provide that nuanced meaning, because it is such technical work. You just can't rely on the results of the forensics tools,' Hyde said, echoing a principle I stress in the Continuing Legal Education classes I teach to attorneys.
Call Logs: User Deleted or Automated?
Another flashpoint was the accusation that McCabe deleted call logs to cover her tracks. Hyde's examination and testing revealed that the model and iOS version of McCabe's iPhone retained a maximum of 200 calls per type, automatically overwriting the oldest entries as new ones come in. This is standard device behavior, not evidence of user deletion. I have encountered this exact misconceptions in my own work, and particularly in commercial vehicle and trucking accident cases. As Hyde expressed in our interview, it is essential to test and validate before drawing conclusions.
Neutrality Above All: The True Role of the Expert
Hyde emphasized a point I adamantly agree with: digital forensic experts are not advocates for either side. Our mandate is to remain independent, to interpret data impartially, and to present findings—exculpatory or inculpatory—based solely on the evidence. 'Our entire job is to be neutral,' she explains. 'When we're hired, we're hired as an independent expert. They don't tell me what to find. They tell me my scope, and then I tell them my findings.' This independence is non-negotiable, and as I know from my own casework, it's often misunderstood by the public and even by some legal professionals.
Digital Forensics: Lessons For The Legal System
The Karen Read trial exposed the stakes of digital forensics in modern litigation. Hyde's experience mirrors my own, and highlights the urgent need for more education. Both for legal professionals and for experts themselves. As Hyde noted, 'the field is only getting more complex, with new data sources and evolving technology raising the bar for both technical skill and clear communication.' If an expert cannot explain technical findings in plain language to judges and juries, they can become a liability rather than an asset, independent of their findings.
Ultimately, the Read case is a cautionary tale: digital evidence is only as reliable as the expertise behind its interpretation. In a world where digital footprints are central to so many investigations, the integrity and clarity of our work as digital forensics experts has never mattered more.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Here's what we know about the deadly shooting in Midtown Manhattan
Suspected gunman Shane Tamura is accused of opening fire in a Midtown Manhattan office building in New York City on Monday evening and killing four people, including a New York police officer, before turning the gun on himself. 'I want to extend my profound sympathies to all of the victims and their families, and to the brave NYPD cops who today lost a brother,' NYPD commissioner Jessica Tisch said a press conference on Monday evening. 'There are still many questions that we have to answer and we will answer them. For now, our city is in mourning of the innocent lives lost. May their memories be a blessing.' Here are the key details we know so far about the mass shooting. What happened? At 6:28 p.m., police began getting calls from the skyscraper at 345 Park Avenue, home to the offices of the NFL and Blackstone, about an active shooter. Security cameras captured Tamura, 27, double-park a black BMW on the street outside the office tower and enter the building holding what was later determined to be an M4 assault rifle, Tisch said. The 27-year-old, who had a Las Vegas, Nevada, address, proceeded to 'immediately open fire' on the ground floor of the building, Tisch said at the press conference, striking NYPD officer Didarul Islam, 36, who later died of his injuries. Police said Tamura continued firing, shooting at a security guard taking cover behind a desk, and another man. The gunman is then accused of taking an elevator to the building's 33rd floor, which houses the offices of Rudin Management. Inside the office, police say Tamura continued firing, striking and killing another person, and then shooting himself in the chest. Tamura is believed to have acted alone and there is no longer a threat to the public, according to police. Who are the victims and the injured? Tamura is accused of shooting dead at least four people, one of whom was the NYPD officer Islam. The three others shot and killed are yet to be formally identified. Islam served in the NYPD's 47th Precinct in the Bronx, and had been with the force for three-and-a-half years, officials said. The Bangladeshi immigrant was a father of two young boys, and his wife is pregnant with the couple's third child. The NYPD said on X late Monday, 'Police Officer Didarul Islam represented the very best of our department. He was protecting New Yorkers from danger when his life was tragically cut short today. We join in prayer during this time of incomprehensible pain. We will forever honor his legacy.' 'He loved this city and everyone we spoke with stated he was a person of faith and a person that believed in God and believed in living out the life of a godly person,' New York City Mayor Eric Adams said at the press conference on Friday. 'He embodies what this city is all about. He is a true blue hero not only in the uniform he wore, but in his spirit and energy of loving this city.' Another man was seriously wounded in the shooting, and four others were treated for 'minor' injuries, Tisch said. Who is the gunman? Police believe Tamura, a 27-year-old Las Vegas man, acted alone in the shooting. 'He has a documented mental health history,' Tisch said Monday. 'His motives are still under investigation. We are working to understand why he targeted this particular location.' The gunman had a firearms permit for the state of Nevada, officials said. Tamura appears to have driven across the country through Colorado, Nebraska, and Iowa in the days before the shooting, police said. His car was then spotted in Columbia, New Jersey, just after 4 p.m. the evening of the shooting. Tamura appeared to be wearing dark sunglasses and a dark-colored jacket and carrying a large rifle as he approached the office tower, according to security video images. Officials told CNN Tamura has no significant criminal background and had an expired private investigator license in Nevada. The FBI said Friday during the press conference that its systems did not contain additional prior information about the 27-year-old. In high school, Tamura was reportedly a standout competitive football player. What happens next in the investigation? The NYPD is leading the investigation into the shooting. Federal agencies including the FBI and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives are assisting on the case. Police say they found a rifle case, rounds of ammunition, a revolver, and medication bearing Tamura's name inside the BMW left outside the office building before the shooting. After the search and evacuation of 345 Park Avenue, police said they were conducting a secondary sweep of the building. Officers are still working to determine a motive. What have witnesses said? A witness to the shooting, Jessica Chen, told ABC News she was on the second floor with about 150 people when they heard 'multiple shots go off in quick succession from the first floor.' She ran into a conference room with others, and they barricaded the door. 'A lot of us were young, a lot of us went through training in elementary school of what to do in an active shooter situation. We were all, unfortunately, prepared,' Chen said. Chen said they were in constant communication with police during the shooting. While sheltering inside the conference room, Chen texted her parents that she loved them. 'We were honestly really, really scared,' Chen said. 'All of us were frozen. All of us were shocked.'
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Gunman kills four, including police officer, in New York skyscraper
STORY: :: July 28, 2025 :: Emergency crews rush to Manhattan after reports of an active shooter :: New York ::Officials said later that the gunman killed four people before shooting himself One of the four victims slain in the gun violence was a 36-year-old New York Police Department officer who immigrated to the U.S. from Bangladesh. Authorities offered few details about the three other victims killed by the suspect - two men and a woman. A third male was gravely wounded by the gunfire and was "fighting for his life" in a nearby hospital, the mayor said. New York Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said the gunman, identified as Shane Tamura, 27-year-old Las Vegas resident with a history of mental illness, had driven cross-country to New York in recent days.
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
What to know about the shooting at a New York City office tower that killed 4
NEW YORK (AP) — A man with a rifle killed an off-duty New York City police officer and three other people before taking his own life at a Manhattan office tower on Monday, according to officials. Law enforcement officials were working to unravel what took place and why this location may have been targeted in a city that had recently announced it was on pace to have its fewest people hurt by gunfire than any year in recent decades. Here are some things to know: What happened? A man exited a double parked BMW with an M4 rifle and then walked toward the building on Monday evening, according to surveillance video. He quickly opened fire on the NYPD officer as he entered the building before shooting a woman who tried to take cover, police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said at a news conference on Monday night. He then started 'spraying' the lobby with gunfire. The man went to the elevator bank and shot a security guard who was taking cover behind a security desk and also another man in the lobby, Tisch said. The man took the elevator to the 33rd floor to a real estate management company and one person was shot and killed on that floor. The man then walked down a hallway and shot himself, she said. What do we know about the gunman? Police identified Shane Tamura of Las Vegas as the gunman, although his motive and reasoning for targeting the building was not immediately clear. Tamura had a 'documented mental health history,' Tisch said. His vehicle had traveled across the U.S. through Colorado on July 26 and then Nebraska and Iowa on July 27. It arrived in Columbia, New Jersey, as recently as Monday afternoon, before making it to New York City, she said. Officers found a rifle case, a revolver, magazines and ammunition in his car, Tisch said. No one answered the door at the address listed for Tamura in Las Vegas. Who were the victims? Didarul Islam, 36, had served as a police officer in New York City for 3 1/2 years. He was an immigrant from Bangladesh. Islam was married and had two young boys, Tisch said. His wife is pregnant with their third child. The names of the other victims, along with a man who was seriously wounded and remains in critical condition, have not yet been released. Where did the shooting happen? The shooting took place at 345 Park Avenue, a commercial office building in a busy area of midtown that is just a short walk north from Grand Central Terminal and about a block east of St. Patrick's Cathedral. The building's tenants include the NFL and Rudin Management, as well as finance companies KPMG and Blackstone. It also includes the consulate general of Ireland. The Associated Press