Welsh rugby decline gathers pace after loss to Japan
So the depressing decline of Welsh rugby keeps gathering pace.As the Wales rugby team leave Kitakyushu for a second time in six years, the heady days of 2019 seem a lifetime ago.When Warren Gatland's squad departed their training base in the Japanese city back then to concentrate on the World Cup, they were second in the official rankings having been top just a month earlier.Wales were the recently crowned Six Nations Grand Slam champions and would go on to reach the World Cup semi-finals in Japan before a narrow defeat to eventual winners South Africa.Contrastingly, Matt Sherratt's side have departed Kitakyushu to travel to Kobe for the second Test, reflecting on how they relinquished a match-winning position and lost 24-19 to Eddie Jones' Japan in the first match of the series. It meant a record 18th consecutive Test defeat, continuing a losing streak that stretches back 21 months. That is a record for a tier one nation, while Japan also recorded a first victory against tier one opposition for six years. Furthermore, Wales are now in their lowest-ever position of 14th in the world rankings having dropped below Japan and Samoa. Let this latest new low sink in.
Finding new ways to lose
Wales have now followed up their record 68-14 Six Nations defeat against England in March in Cardiff with only a second loss to Japan.The previous failure came 12 years ago when Jones was also in charge of Japan but this victory for such an inexperienced Brave Blossoms side was more impressive, and in contrast, more humbling for Wales.The 2013 defeat for Wales came when they fielded a second-choice side with 15 players away with the British and Irish Lions.Twelve years on, Wales were closer to a full-strength available squad, with only flanker Jac Morgan and scrum-half Tomos Williams initially picked for the Lions in Australia and a few players rested or injured.After Williams' injury during that tour, Morgan is the only representative left in Andy Farrell's squad to further underline how far Welsh rugby has fallen.Not many nations would head on a summer tour without a permanent head coach but this is what Wales and the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) have chosen.With former head coach Warren Gatland having left the role in February and his successor yet to be appointed, Wales have a fresh coaching staff at the helm for just this trip.Sherratt has again taken on the interim head coach role before returning to his Cardiff day job next season.He is backed up by Gethin Jenkins, Danny Wilson and Leigh Halfpenny, while Adam Jones and Rhys Thomas have continued their Six Nations roles.While a new coaching team has been put together, the same result emerged on the weekend.
Players devastated by results sequence
What can Wales do in less than a week?The malfunctioning lineout and manner in which Japan gained the upper hand in the scrum, after early Wales dominance, will need to be rectified and questions will be asked on whether replacements could have been introduced sooner.Sherratt might well reflect on his selection and ponder whether there needs to be changes for next weekend in Kobe. There might be a chance for fly-half Dan Edwards instead of Sam Costelow. Why scrum-half Rhodri Williams was an unused replacement for Kieran Hardy in the intense heat appears baffling.Could the Wales caretaker rethink his midfield selection of Johnny Williams alongside Ben Thomas, given the pair are both specialist inside centres?There has been no consistency in selection throughout the season as Wales are almost hoping they stumble on a winning formula.For example, Thomas and Williams were the eighth different centre combination in nine games over the 2024-25 campaign.While the effort and desire is evident, currently the quality or belief is not.This Wales side have forgotten how to win. In fact, many of the players have never experienced success for their country on the senior stage.This lack of confidence was glaringly obvious in Kitakyushu as Wales allowed their hosts to recover from a 12-point deficit to inflict further misery on the beleaguered tourists.The depressing aftermath of these defeats has also become familiar. It continues to be uncomfortable viewing as proud young Welshmen once more experience another loss while representing their country.Captain Lake looked a broken man afterwards, while seeing inexperienced internationals Tom Rogers and Blair Murray just staring into the abyss after the final whistle was hard to watch.But this is what the Wales class of 2025 has been reduced to.
Faletau class lives on but lack of leaders exposed
There were some familiar standout players. Number eight Taulupe Faletau is Wales' oldest and most experienced performer on this tour at the ripe old age of 34. He also remains the best player, with his class continually shining through.While wing Josh Adams was also prominent, Faletau continues to be Wales' leading light as he created two of the three tries for the tourists.Faletau trudged off slowly during the second half, as he, like many players, appeared to be struggling with the extreme heat, but Sherratt said the veteran forward's withdrawal was a tactical replacement.Wales will hope he is fit next weekend because they are an inferior side without him.It was after the Cardiff forward departed on 56 minutes, when the visitors were leading 19-7, that Japan's final-quarter flourish occurred.Faletau is not the most animated character but he leads expertly by example and his absence in the latter stages was noticeable.It was evident that, while Wales wilted in the extreme conditions late on, there is also a lack of experienced international leaders in the current set-up as the tourists could not stop Japan's second-half momentum. Faletau is the final remaining playing member of Wales' golden generation on the international stage and there are few figures coming through to fill the void.
Welsh Rugby Union failures
The players and coaches will be scrutinised following another dire defeat, with some brutal comments on social media already on display.However, the powerbrokers need to take responsibility, with Welsh rugby in freefall on and off the field. WRU chief executive Abi Tierney has officially been in charge since January 2024, with all 18 international defeats coming on her watch.She does not pick the team, nor is to blame for why the supply chain of top-class players has dried up in recent years, but should expect questions on why it has taken five months, and counting, to appoint a new head coach.Tierney, who is in Japan alongside WRU president Terry Cobner, inherited a mess but the demise has intensified during her tenure.The chief executive and chair Richard Collier-Keywood is responsible for leading the game in Wales which is in disarray across the board.There has yet been no evidence of strong leadership from the current regime to fix the sinking ship.New director of rugby Dave Reddin has been tasked with appointing Gatland's successor in time for the autumn internationals, while Tierney and Collier-Keywood have other matters on their agenda.The domestic game is in flux with a major debate going on about the future of professional clubs in Wales and suggestions the number of teams could be reduced from four to three, or even two.The WRU has so far remained publicly tight-lipped on its plans for the Welsh game's future, which has created more uncertainty among players, coaches and supporters.So despite what happens next weekend in Kobe, as Wales aim for a first Test victory in what will be 644 days, it will not be the end of Welsh rugby's turmoil.A win might provide some short-term respite and a glimmer of hope, with Sherratt saying the squad must channel the hurt from Kitakyushu to fuel their bid to level the series.But a solitary success will not chase away all the clouds hovering over rugby in Wales. That is the sad reality.A stormy summer is brewing before next season - with major change required to avoid more depressing days like Wales' latest visit to Kitakyushu.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Owen Farrell in contention to make Lions match-day squad for first Test against Australia after shock call-up
Owen Farrell hadn't recovered from the impact of a long-haul trek to Australia in time to be part of the Lions squad to face the Brumbies here, but his chance will come on Saturday – and perhaps seven days later. It appears that an opportunity could present itself for the former England captain to emerge as a late 'bolter' – albeit an experienced one – for a place in the match-day squad for the first Test against Australia in Brisbane on July 19. He is expected to feature against a potentially dangerous Australia-New Zealand Invitational XV in Adelaide at the weekend, in the last selection audition before the series opener. A bench role against the Wallabies can't be discounted, given the way Fin Smith struggled to direct the tourists effectively in the shaky 21-10 win over the Waratahs in Sydney. Marcus Smith will wear the 22 shirt on Wednesday in the clash with the Brumbies, but he is seen as a utility option who can cover full-back, and Ireland wing Mack Hansen is also among the replacements for the next tour match. The presence of two back-three options among the support cast is highly unlikely to be repeated in the Tests, as it doesn't maximise back-line permutations. There is no obvious, specialist fall-back plan to cover inside centre here, which Owen Farrell can do. Already, there is a growing expectation that the veteran will be considered ahead of the younger playmaker who he operated alongside in the England back line, in the latter part of Eddie Jones's tenure. Farrell jnr arrived Down Under last Friday night, after being hurriedly summoned as a replacement for his Saracens team-mate Elliot Daly. The late-comer's father and Lions head coach Andy Farrell made it plain that his son had every chance to push for Test selection. He was booed when he appeared on the big screen during the game against the Waratahs, but it was more panto routine than real vitriol. As the British and Irish side toiled in vain for fluency and attacking purpose, it was a fine time to be a returning veteran No 10. Both Smiths had trouble trying to run the show as the Test centurion watched on from the stand. His integration will be fast-tracked. Asked if Owen had come through his return-to-play protocols – after a concussion – and jet-lag, Andy Farrell said: 'I wouldn't say jet-lag just yet. I think he was up all night. But the rest is fine.' Pressed on whether the four-tour Lion was in contention for Saturday's game, the reply was: 'Yes.' The sense that a selection path is rapidly opening up was heightened by the lack of clarity over the contingency on Wednesday, in the event of Bundee Aki – who is at 12 – going off injured. 'We have got players who have trained there and understand the different roles,' said Andy Farrell. 'There are all sorts of permutations we have prepared for.' The fall-back plan wasn't readily apparent. There are still plenty of permutations in several areas, with the head coach insisting he is remaining 'open-minded' about series selection, despite the Irish-heavy line-up for the Brumbies game being interpreted as a Test XV in all but name. 'A closed book is not good for anyone,' said Farrell snr. Among those hoping to ram home their case to start against the Wallabies is England flanker Tom Curry – back at openside and acclaimed as a 'machine' by the man in charge. He will form a back-row alliance with Leicester's Ollie Chessum, the Leicester flanker redeployed at blindside and identified as a prime Test contender by Andy Farrell. 'He's been very impressive,' he said. 'He's got a chance.'
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
Lions Test XV takes shape — but Tom Curry and Ollie Chessum need big games
The reception staff at the British & Irish Lions hotel welcomed the team to Canberra by wearing replica jerseys over their regular uniforms, a nice gesture undermined a little by the fact they were fakes. The real thing is a deeper, blood red. And in a meeting room off the lobby, Andy Farrell was eyeing the most-prized Lions jersey of all. Farrell's Test selection is starting to take shape. The Lions head coach, as forecast since the opening game in Perth, named his strongest line-up of the tour to play ACT Brumbies on Wednesday night. Farrell's challenge to each man was to seize this opportunity and nail down their jersey for the first Test against Australia on July 19. 'I will tell you what I said to the team: 'It is up to people to put their best foot forward for a Test spot from now on in,' ' he said. Farrell's thinking has to remain flexible, with one further tour game scheduled before the Test series, but his selection strategy appears to have narrowed to the extent that there are no more than four positions still to be confirmed from a potential starting XV to face the Wallabies. Blair Kinghorn gets his chance to start at full back after Hugo Keenan's error-strewn performance against the Waratahs. Tadhg Furlong has had an injury-disrupted season but needs to only come through this game positively to secure the tight-head prop berth, with Will Stuart and Finlay Bealham competing to be his understudy. The flanker roles will be influenced by the Lions' preferred back-row balance. Farrell has an embarrassment of riches, although Tom Curry is a favourite. 'He is a machine,' Farrell said. 'His work rate, the stuff he does off the ball makes teams tick. He is so fit and so determined to have an impact on the game, especially as far as physicality is concerned. I think he has started the tour really well.' The question is not whether Curry plays, but where? The Lions have had a good look at fielding two open-sides, twice pairing up Curry with Jac Morgan, and they would have given that plan a twist against the Waratahs had Henry Pollock been fit to start in the No6 jersey. Against the Brumbies, Curry will switch to open side, with Josh van der Flier ready to state his own case from the bench. Ollie Chessum, another abrasive English forward with an incredible engine, comes in at blind-side flanker, with Jack Conan at No8. That is probably the most physical trio the Lions could pick. It will be the first time that Curry and Chessum have played together in the same back row, which is a surprise only because they would appear to offer the perfect balance. Chessum is a bopper on the blind side; a genuine lineout option who has soft hands but a hard edge to his game. Slated as the next captain of Leicester Tigers and England, he offers some important strategic calm amid the chaos. 'He's got a Test chance, yes, 100 per cent,' Farrell said. 'He's been very impressive. He's a big man. He's obviously a fantastic lineout option, but he moves really well. He's a rugby player throughout, as in good with the ball in hand, he understands the game, the holistic game. It'll be interesting to see how he goes at six.' The Lions have been too lateral in attack on this tour. This team have carriers who will be responsible for thrusting them on to the front foot, and creating a platform for Jamison Gibson-Park and Finn Russell. The pack blends industry, dynamism and power, with Ellis Genge, Dan Sheehan and Furlong in the front row, with Maro Itoje packing down for the first time with Joe McCarthy in the second row. Bundee Aki and Garry Ringrose form an all-Ireland midfield, which appears to have edged ahead of the Scottish pair of Sione Tuipolotu and Huw Jones. Tuipolotu is a triple threat at inside centre but he has not used his power enough to generate momentum for the Lions. Aki did that well in the second half against Queensland Reds, as the Lions scored 45 unanswered points. Tommy Freeman and James Lowe are the clear Test wing options either side of Kinghorn. Farrell has criticised his players at times on this tour for being too desperate to impress. If they are to respond to the challenge of seizing a Test jersey, what exactly is he looking for? 'You want to see them stay in every single moment of the game,' he said. 'I know that sounds harsh and almost impossible to do but they understand 100 per cent now, and have done for a week or so, what is expected of them. That's what we're judging them on.' It is how Curry has always judged his own performances. He is capable of showcase moments but almost happier when playing the kind of role that allows others to shine. Farrell appreciates those characters. Back in Perth, he highlighted a lung-bursting defensive contribution from Mack Hansen as his moment of an eight-try, 50-point win. ''The first and foremost thing is to win,' Curry said. 'To do that, people have to be putting their best foot forward. Do what you have to do to win. I don't really care if you stand out. 'I judge my game on how hard I work and that is how I get my enjoyment out of the game; getting off the floor and running and that sort of stuff. That puts me in the best spot to do what I want to do. 'I don't do stats and numbers. It's just, if you are on the floor, how quickly you get up and if the ball is in the air, how quickly you run. 'I've done that but I feel like I can definitely add [to my performances]. There are moments when I've not been at my best, but I feel like it's building and when I'm back in games like this, the best is yet to come.' The backs cover on bench includes Alex Mitchell, who will make his fifth appearance of the tour, plus Marcus Smith and Hansen. Smith has had a curious tour, used as a bits-and-pieces player to fill in gaps. But his selection in this squad could well be a stopgap until Owen Farrell is over his jet lag. If Farrell was on the bench along with Hansen, the Lions would have natural cover for fly half, inside centre and the whole back three. This team has no inside centre cover. Farrell Jr will play against an Australia/New Zealand invitational XV on Saturday. Farrell Sr was speaking in the Binara room at the team hotel, named after a plant with a four-sided stem. The Lions are also four-sided entity, representing England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland. However, with Morgan rested, they are down to three. This team to play the Brumbies does not include any Wales players. According to the statistician Russ Petty, this will be the first time since 1889 that the Lions have gone into a game against opposition from Australia, South Africa or New Zealand without a Welshman in the side. That should not matter, for they are all Lions out here. But it comes just days after Wales, who were almost at full strength, lost to a very inexperienced Japan side in Kitakyushu; a dark era for a proud nation, who have provided more Lions to the famous jersey than any other.
BBC News
7 hours ago
- BBC News
Farrell shows his hand - but who needs a big game?
The latest Nations Pod is out from Rugby Union Weekly as we discuss Andy Farrell's selection for the Brumbies on Wednesday. Four games in, and it looks like Farrell has declared his hand, but could some players still force their way into - and out of - the Test team?How much do the Lions need a statement victory on Wednesday? And should we be worried about the Test series given Australia's performance against Fiji?We also praise England's resounding victory in Argentina but it was a different story for Wales in Japan. Where do Wales go from here?
