Blown diesel generators the latest hitch for electric Wolfe Island ferry
A union official says blown generators are plaguing ferry service to Wolfe Island near Kingston, Ont., as what's supposed to be an electric vessel continues to run on diesel while waiting for its charging infrastructure to be set up.
The problem came to a head this past weekend when mechanical issues again knocked the Wolfe Islander IV (WI4) out of service, stranding frustrated residents with no way to cross between the island and mainland for hours.
"What's happening is we're running it on its backup power source," explained Lee MacLaren, a ferry captain and president of OPSEU Local 428, which represents crew members.
"These generators are continually going down on us, and with the lack of spare parts and running it in a manner that it's not designed [for], we're putting a lot of stress on it."
Unscheduled maintenance took the WI4 out of service last Thursday, with the old ferry brought in to carry passengers until the new boat returned Saturday morning.
But just a few hours after the WI4 started ferrying passengers once again, Ontario's Ministry of Transportation (MTO) announced on social media that it had run into "mechanical issues" around 8:18 a.m.
A second service outage was posted about at 3:13 p.m., again due to an unspecified mechanical issue, before the vessel was back in action shortly before 7 p.m.
Internal note says generators cause outages
CBC first started asking MTO about the maintenance issues on the morning of July 17, but did not receive a response to questions about the cause.
The ministry also did not reply by deadline to a separate request for comment about the weekend disruptions and whether the diesel generators were to blame.
A ferry service update sent out by email from MTO during the disruption Saturday afternoon said the ministry "recognizes the vital connection the ferry provides, and we thank you for your patience and understanding."
As CBC previously reported, despite different Ontario governments using the WI4 as an example of the province leading by example in the fight against climate change, the ferry — which was designed to run on electricity — continues to burn diesel, with monthly fuel bills ranging from $150,000 to $200,000.
The maintenance issues are just the latest in a series of headaches and delays for the new boat, which finally entered service last August before a gash was torn in its hull and it was towed away for repairs in early December.
An internal MTO information note, obtained through freedom of information legislating, said some of that work on the boat focused on its generators in order to "mitigate wear on the units and prevent future outages."
It also said modifications to the exhaust system had been completed to prevent the generators from overheating.
MPP says residents are frustrated
Kingston and the Islands MPP Ted Hsu visited the Kingston dock Saturday and said he found people upset by the outages.
"They expect a ferry service that isn't being disrupted as often as this ferry is," he said in an interview Monday morning.
Hsu said generator breakdowns are happening "often" because the boat is meant to be running on electricity stored in batteries, but their charging stations have yet to be installed on shore.
In the meantime, the generators are "not supposed to be running all the time" and so keep blowing out, he said.
Construction on the Kingston dock was initially supposed to be finished in 2023, but that deadline has since been pushed into 2026, with the possibility of work continuing into 2027.
Hsu said he's been in contact with the ministry and is in the process of setting up a briefing to find ways to cut down on the disruptions in the meantime.
One possibility he proposed is for spare parts to be stored on the ferry itself, so repairs can be made more quickly if a generator breaks down.
Union calls outages a safety issue
The Liberal MPP also said he wants to see if there's some sort of compromise where the chargers are set up before the dock is finished.
"If the charging infrastructure is not completed soon, the generators will continue, probably, to to have problems," said Hsu.
MacLaren, the union president, said if the ferry disruptions do continue, the ministry should be quicker to bring the older Wolfe Islander III into service to avoid situations like Saturday where the island's only lifeline is cut off.
"Shutting down the ferry for the better part of a day is incredibly dangerous," he said. "Aside from getting to and from work ... there's a real safety concern with emergency response ... should someone need an ambulance or police service."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
10 minutes ago
- CBC
Partners in Thunder Bay, Ont., launch campaign to help meet summer food demands
Social Sharing While people are often reminded about food drives around Thanksgiving and the winter holidays, Volker Kromm said the need for donations is especially high when school's out for the summer. "The demand is up because people are home," said Kromm, the executive director of the Regional Food Distribution Association (RFDA) in Thunder Bay, Ont. "We want to stock the shelves." But with the rising cost of living and concerns about U.S. tariffs raising prices even higher, "there's a general tightening of the waistbelt that is happening out there, and I think it's also the interpretation of what's to come." "They give, but less is coming in — and also the type of food [that] is coming in. If they're donating, they're donating the less expensive items, and so we're struggling trying to match demand with what's coming in," Kromm explained. On Friday, the RFDA launched its Stronger Together 2.0 campaign alongside the United Way of Thunder Bay in hopes of raising awareness about year-round food insecurity and boosting food bank stock across northwestern Ontario. All donations made through the United Way are being matched dollar for dollar. "It's important that we get the community behind this because we realized many years ago, we can't do this by ourselves," said Kromm. "We have to reach out and ask people for their help, whether it be a food drive or fund matching or something." 'We can only give what we get' It cost just under $1,200 a month to feed a family of four in the Thunder Bay district last year, and more than $1,500 a month for a family of four in the Northwestern Health Unit's catchment area, according to the latest Cost of Eating Well reports. However, with rising food prices and fewer donations coming in, Kromm said, "we can only give what we get or we can purchase." "We would like to meet the health requirements of the individuals that ask for help with their allergies and their nutrient requirements, but it is one of those points," he said. The RFDA provides food to 37 partner organizations and 47 First Nations across the region, all of which will benefit from donations made through Stronger Together 2.0, he said. In the summer, food banks and cooling centres are seeing more requests for donations of water bottles, as well as cereal, peanut butter and fruit cups for children at home. Families are also looking for children's clothes to prepare for the new school year in the fall, Kromm added. "That puts an extra demand on our family budget," he said. For those who aren't in a position to donate, Kromm said organizations are always in need of volunteers. People can also assist by spreading awareness through social media. Stronger Together 2.0 runs until Sept. 12. Meanwhile, the United Way of Thunder Bay is also involved in a campaign called Period Promise, which is collecting menstrual product donations at the Shoppers Drug Mart at 640 River St. until Friday.
CBC
7 hours ago
- CBC
'What is it doing to our bodies?': Norfolk residents urge fast action on toxic gas leaks in Ontario county
Paula Jongerden says she and her neighbours have been living a nightmare for the last decade. On days when the wind doesn't co-operate, a thick rotten egg-like stench wafts up the valley bordering their Norfolk County properties — a putrid reminder of the inactive and unfiltered wells that have been pumping massive amounts of hydrogen sulfide and methane into the air and water since 2015. "It's nauseating. Burning eyes, sore throat, like rotten eggs but with a burn to it," Jongerden said. If it's not the smell that reminds her, it's the otherwise peaceful days that are interrupted by the staccato of distant alarms from a monitoring station that detects high concentrations of toxic gas. It's a problem locals call the Big Stink and an expert says is the worst of its kind in the province — one Jongerden says needs to be rectified now. Big Creek, a watercourse that runs through Norfolk County and empties into Lake Erie, has been locked in a struggle with natural gas dating back to 1968. A well that had been open since 1910 was plugged, causing pressure to build and five new wells to erupt before a relief well was drilled to ease the pressure. In 2015, the Ministry of the Environment ordered that the relief well be plugged, which caused a half-dozen new wells to open up. In 2017, the pressure and higher water levels caused gas to push its way through a layer of clay in the ground, causing it to bubble up through area waterways from newly formed gas springs. The county used provincial money in 2024 to commission a study from environmental consulting firm Montrose Environmental. The report was presented to council on July 22 by Montrose geochemist Stewart Hamilton, who said the situation unfolding along Big Creek, especially near Forestry Farm Road where the neighbours live, is "by far the largest problem in Ontario" of its kind. He said the amount of hydrogen sulfide leaking into the environment from the wells on county-owned land is tens of thousands of times higher than what's legally allowed. Jongerden said she knew it all along. "I have metal objects on my property that have turned black because of the corrosion," Jongerden said. "If it's doing that to metal, what is it doing to our bodies?" She's not the only one affected. One of the springs that opened in 2017 is a stone's throw away from John Spanjers's home. Water near the creek behind his home is covered in a black film. Sometimes, he said, it can be seen bubbling up to the surface. It smells strongly of rotten eggs, but the smell isn't the main concern. The longtime resident of the property believes high concentrations of the chemical killed dozens of trees that once stood tall in the marsh behind his home. He also believes it's affected his health directly. "I've never had headaches. Now I wake up with them frequently. I have been very patient, but my patience is getting very thin," said Spanjers. But getting politicians to act, especially quickly, has been an uphill battle, the neighbours said. "The people in our local administration, they will disagree, but I don't think they really care. If they did, something would have happened before now," Spanjers said. During the last meeting of county council, municipal politicians resolved to urge the provincial government to take the lead in dealing with the issue and paying for the solution. Among the recommendations in the Montrose report are measures like installing a temporary relief well at a cost near $500,000, and installing filters to improve air quality and to treat water, at a price near $1 million. While municipal politicians seek provincial support for the plan, Spanjers and Jongerden said they believe more urgent action is needed. "I love Norfolk County. I don't want to be a complainer, but this isn't right," Jongerden said. "Norfolk can afford the $1.5 million to make this right." Independent MPP and council at odds Haldimand-Norfolk Independent MPP Bobbi Ann Brady said the wells will be her top priority when provincial politicians return to Queen's Park in October. "If [these wells] were on private property, it wouldn't have taken 10 years." Brady accused councillors of "playing politics with a dangerous situation," saying that for the past decade, multiple studies funded by provincial dollars have been done, but the gas still flows just the same. "Monitoring is good, but it's been ten years. I support this new call to the province, but it's too little, too late," Brady said. Norfolk Mayor Amy Martin said the county has done what it can by securing over $1 million in provincial funding, much of which went to the recent study and the province's Abandoned Works Program. She said gas wells are a provincial responsibility that require a response from multiple ministries and residential taxpayers shouldn't have to foot the bill. "Meanwhile, the Independent MPP has provided no solutions, no technical support — just theatrics at Queen's Park and criticism of her municipal counterparts," Martin wrote in a statement to CBC News. "That certainly doesn't help the residents of Forestry Farm Road or the taxpayers of Norfolk County but it is an easy position to take when you lack influence." County bureaucrats say meetings are scheduled with the province in August, and Martin said she will advocate for the issue during the Association of Municipalities of Ontario meeting this month.
CBC
20 hours ago
- CBC
Residents waiting for answers after suspicious fire at London community housing apartment
Social Sharing Several people are waiting to return to their homes following a Monday morning fire at a community housing complex that fire crews are calling suspicious. Just before 9 a.m., crews were called to an apartment fire at 349 Wharncliffe Rd. N., where they encountered heavy smoke and fire coming from a third-floor unit, platoon chief Gary Mosburger said. Fire crews were able to contain the fire to the one unit in less than 10 minutes, he said, but there was damage to others. "The fire consumed the main apartment unit, and then smoke migration throughout the rest of the building occurred as well," Mosburger said. "HVAC piping as well as general water lines that are coming in to provide water to your sinks can get hot enough that it will melt or break. With that, comes the need to shut off the water." Residents told CBC News they saw thick smoke, flames and shattered glass coming from the third floor. "It was thick black smoke. It smelled very chemically, like burnt rubber almost," said eighth-floor resident Mackenzie Lavalliere, who had been outside with her dogs since the fire broke out. "Everything's charred on the balcony and the whole window blew off." The eight-floor high-rise building, located just off Western Road, has 145 units and is owned by London Middlesex Community Housing (LMCH). "I woke up, looked out the balcony and saw thick black smoke with some dude on the [third floor] balcony," said Cheryl Ann Linekar, who was staying over at the apartment building the night before. "As time went on, it got hotter and glass was exploding literally all over the place. At one point, he was ducking down and the fireman had to put the ladder up to rescue him," she said. Fire crews rescued one person who was living in the unit where the fire started, Mosburger said, and that person is being treated for smoke inhalation. "It's really situational, due to the fact that the smoke was coming out of the west side of the building so if people had windows open or smoke was being sucked in by HVAC units, it obviously affected their units," Mosburger said. "It was a little bit all over the place." About 50 people were told to exit the building this morning, though many have now returned to their units. Mosburger said it is unclear how many people will not be able to return to the apartment tonight. Red Cross, London police and LMCH will help people find temporary accommodations if necessary, Mosburger said. "We are working with emergency services and supporting tenants affected by the incident. The safety and well-being of our tenants is our top priority," LMCH spokesperson Matt Senechal said in a statement. Linekar was staying two floors up from the fire and said that while she is allowed to return to the unit, she plans to stay outdoors until more smoke clears. "It smells so bad. You can smell it out here, but it's way worse in there," she said. Crews are continuing to monitor air quality, Mosburger said. Fires common at apartment building, residents say Mosburger would not comment on the cause of Monday's fire, but said that it is believed to be suspicious. Fire prevention investigators and London police will continue investigating. Damage is estimated at over $200,000, Mosburger said. Some building residents and neighbours say fires are a common sight at the community housing apartment. "When I moved in here in April of 2024, there was a fire alarm every other day or every other week, so we just got used to it," said Lavalliere, adding that she always checks the London fire scanner before leaving the building to ensure it's not a false alarm. Linekar, who visits the apartment building often, said she has seen fires four separate times. "I don't even know what or how I feel. It's just stressful," she said.
