Man who used AI lawyer explains why he did so after judge got angry
(NewsNation) — A cancer survivor's attempt to use an AI-generated avatar during a New York appeals court hearing was quickly shut down by a judge last month, highlighting tensions as new technology enters courtrooms.
Jerome Dewald, who experienced throat cancer 25 years ago, told NewsNation he sought to use the AI avatar because his 'throat tends to give out' during extended speaking, making articulation difficult. The avatar would have delivered his prepared arguments without the physical limitations he faces.
'I got advanced approval for the video,' Dewald said Tuesday on NewsNation's 'Banfield' about the March 26 hearing. 'I intended to use a replica of myself, but I had some technical difficulties getting it completed.'
Lori Vallow uses same manipulation tactics in courtroom: Cousin
Dewald, representing himself in an employment dispute before the New York State Supreme Court Appellate Division's First Judicial Department, said he was also having stage fright.
'Then there's the pressure and the intimidation that a pro se feels in the courtroom by himself,' he said, referring to individuals who represent themselves without an attorney.
Justice Sallie Manzanet-Daniels abruptly halted the presentation when she realized the person on the screen wasn't real.
The avatar, a young man with styled hair wearing a button-down shirt and sweater, had begun with 'May it please the court. I come here today a humble pro se before a panel of five distinguished justices.'
'I don't appreciate being misled,' Manzanet-Daniels told Dewald before allowing him to continue his arguments personally. She also said Dewald was attempting to 'launch his business' in the courtroom, which he later clarified as 'an innocent mistake.'
Cassie Ventura to be named at Diddy's trial despite NDA
'I'm not really promoting a business at all,' Dewald said.
Dewald maintains he received prior approval for his presentation method, though not specifically for an AI-generated speaker.
'I had some technical difficulties getting it completed. It was the first time we ever tried it, a very new technology,' he told NewsNation.
Instead of his own likeness, Dewald used a generic avatar he referred to as 'James,' joking that the digital representation was 'much more handsome than I am.'
Following the hearing, Dewald sent a letter of apology to the court.
Mother of man rescued from Connecticut 'House of Horrors': 'I love you'
'I trust that the panel would not be influenced by this too much,' he said. 'I noticed that the Presiding Justice was the one who shut the TV up. Later when I was giving the argument, she acted as though she maybe felt she had been a little bit harsh with me.'
The incident adds to a growing list of AI-related complications in legal settings. In June 2023, two attorneys and a law firm were each fined $5,000 by a federal judge after using an AI tool that cited fictitious legal cases. Later that year, Michael Cohen, former personal lawyer for President Donald Trump, submitted legal papers containing AI-invented court rulings.
Dewald's employment dispute case remained pending before the appeals court as of press time. He said a ruling might be expected in approximately four weeks.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Justin Baldoni countersuit against Blake Lively, Ryan Reynolds dismissed
(NewsNation) — Justin Baldoni's countersuit against 'It Ends With Us' co-star Blake Lively, her husband, Ryan Reynolds, and their publicist has been dropped by a judge, according to court documents. The judge also reportedly dropped Baldoni's $250 million lawsuit against The New York Times. Judge Lewis J. Liman granted a motion to drop the $400 million lawsuit, which alleged defamation and extortion by Lively and her husband. The judge said that Baldoni's team could amend part of the claims if they wanted, but they had to do so by June 23. Blake Lively withdraws emotional distress claims against Justin Baldoni Liman said that Baldoni's team had not alleged that Lively is responsible for any statements outside of her CRD complaint, which he said is privileged. The decision said, in part: 'The Wayfarer Parties have alleged that Reynolds and (publicist Leslie) Sloane made additional statements accusing Baldoni of sexual misconduct and that the Times made additional statements accusing the Wayfarer Parties of engaging in a smear campaign. But the Wayfarer Parties have not alleged that Reynolds, Sloane or the Times would have seriously doubted these statements were true based on the information available to them, as is required for them to be liable for defamation under applicable law.' Diddy's legal team again asks for a mistrial Read the full document below: Credit: United States District Court – Southern District of New YorkDownload Lively recently withdrew some of the emotional distress claims she made against Baldoni, according to a court filing. Streaming services next steps: What are Mubi, Tubi and more? Lively's claims had led Baldoni's lawyers to request her medical information. This included therapy notes and information on her mental health providers. Liman wrote that Baldoni's motion to get Lively's medical information was denied 'based on (Lively's) representation that the relevant claims will be withdrawn.' Liman claimed that Lively didn't want to disclose information but wanted to keep her right to re-file her claims. However, the judge decided that Lively 'cannot have it both ways,' and he closed the claims. Lively's attorneys will now not be able to use evidence regarding her alleged emotional distress. Her lawyers said that Baldoni team's request of her medical information was a 'press stunt,' leading them to urge the court to sanction Baldoni's attorneys for allegedly abusing the docket. 'It is based on two brazenly false assertions. First, they claim that Ms. Lively has 'refused' to disclose medical and mental health information, but as counsel for the Wayfarer Parties concede, that information is relevant only to Ms. Lively's stand-alone tort-based emotional distress claims that she indicated she was withdrawing,' the Lively filing claimed. Lively originally brought the lawsuit against Baldoni for alleged sexual harassment. One insider told NewsNation's Paula Froelich in February that Lively and Reynolds 'have no idea what's coming down the pike.' Tony Awards laud android rom-com 'Maybe Happy Ending' and history-making 'Purpose' Another source said that no one wanted to work with Lively since the lawsuits. A trial for Lively's suit against Baldoni has been scheduled for March 2026. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
The Hill
2 hours ago
- The Hill
Justin Baldoni countersuit against Blake Lively, Ryan Reynolds dismissed
(NewsNation) — Justin Baldoni's countersuit against 'It Ends With Us' co-star Blake Lively, her husband, Ryan Reynolds, and their publicist has been dropped by a judge, according to court documents. The judge also reportedly dropped Baldoni's $250 million lawsuit against The New York Times. Judge Lewis J. Liman granted a motion to drop the $400 million lawsuit, which alleged defamation and extortion by Lively and her husband. The judge said that Baldoni's team could amend part of the claims if they wanted, but they had to do so by June 23. Liman said that Baldoni's team had not alleged that Lively is responsible for any statements outside of her CRD complaint, which he said is privileged. The decision said, in part: 'The Wayfarer Parties have alleged that Reynolds and (publicist Leslie) Sloane made additional statements accusing Baldoni of sexual misconduct and that the Times made additional statements accusing the Wayfarer Parties of engaging in a smear campaign. But the Wayfarer Parties have not alleged that Reynolds, Sloane or the Times would have seriously doubted these statements were true based on the information available to them, as is required for them to be liable for defamation under applicable law.' Read the full document below: Lively recently withdrew some of the emotional distress claims she made against Baldoni, according to a court filing. Lively's claims had led Baldoni's lawyers to request her medical information. This included therapy notes and information on her mental health providers. Liman wrote that Baldoni's motion to get Lively's medical information was denied 'based on (Lively's) representation that the relevant claims will be withdrawn.' Liman claimed that Lively didn't want to disclose information but wanted to keep her right to re-file her claims. However, the judge decided that Lively 'cannot have it both ways,' and he closed the claims. Lively's attorneys will now not be able to use evidence regarding her alleged emotional distress. Her lawyers said that Baldoni team's request of her medical information was a 'press stunt,' leading them to urge the court to sanction Baldoni's attorneys for allegedly abusing the docket. 'It is based on two brazenly false assertions. First, they claim that Ms. Lively has 'refused' to disclose medical and mental health information, but as counsel for the Wayfarer Parties concede, that information is relevant only to Ms. Lively's stand-alone tort-based emotional distress claims that she indicated she was withdrawing,' the Lively filing claimed. Lively originally brought the lawsuit against Baldoni for alleged sexual harassment. One insider told NewsNation's Paula Froelich in February that Lively and Reynolds 'have no idea what's coming down the pike.' Another source said that no one wanted to work with Lively since the lawsuits. A trial for Lively's suit against Baldoni has been scheduled for March 2026.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
English mother's ashes thrown to sea to travel the world
(NewsNation) — A woman is on a mission to send her late mother's ashes across the world by sea, but in a humorous twist of events, she hadn't gone very far after the first 'trip.' Cara Melia's mother, Wendy Chadwick, unexpectedly died in February at age 51. Melia hoped to help her mother achieve her goal of traveling the world, so she had an idea: Put her ashes in a bottle and throw them out to sea. Melia threw the ash-filled bottle into the water on a beach in the English town of Skegness on June 3. Less than 24 hours, the bottle washed ashore — on the same beach. 'I thought, 'No way has she come back already,'' Melia told the Oldham Times. 'I was expecting her to be out in the water and get found by someone in a different country, or somewhere further down the line. Instead, she washed back to Skegness.' Illinois 12 year-old's goal: Own a Chick-fil-A by 25 A family visiting the coastal town discovered the bottle halfway buried in the sand. Inside were two handwritten notes with a 'treasure map' for the ashes to follow and a message to the finder of the bottle. The note said, 'This is my mum. Throw her back in. She's travelling the world. Thanks – Cara, Oldham, UK.' The family posted a video to Facebook of them throwing the bottle back to sea with the caption, 'She's been thrown back in the sea as requested.. happy travels Cara's Mum.' Melia said her mom 'would be absolutely laughing' at what happened and would 'love the fact that she is getting to travel.' She said she hopes her mom, who never had the chance to travel, will end up on a beach in Barbados or Spain. 'Hopefully, she's gone out with the tide,' Melia told the outlet. 'She's dearly missed, and we hope that she has fun on her travels.' Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
