Diplomatic Vacuum: Global Powers' Hands-Off Approach In India-Pakistan Conflict
As tensions escalate between nuclear-armed India and Pakistan, the international community's muted response marks a stark departure from the active diplomatic interventions seen during recent conflicts in Gaza and Ukraine. This troubling shift has raised concerns about conflict containment in the absence of credible mediation.
Renowned geopolitical analyst Fareed Zakaria, in an exclusive interview with India Today, emphasized that the United States under President Donald Trump has effectively removed itself as a potential intermediary—a role it traditionally fulfilled during previous India-Pakistan confrontations.
"We have lost the United States as a useful intermediary," Zakaria stated. "You saw Marco Rubio, the Secretary of State, lean into that role initially. But then, just hours later, Vice President JD Vance essentially washes his hands of the whole situation, declaring the US doesn't want to get involved."
This conflicting messaging reveals deep divisions within the American administration. While Secretary Rubio has urged maximum restraint during conversations with both nations, Vice President Vance explicitly stated that America wouldn't engage in a conflict that's "fundamentally none of our business." President Trump, who previously characterized India's Operation Sindoor against Pakistani terror camps as a "shame," has avoided direct engagement with leadership on either side.
Zakaria noted this reflects the tension between America's traditional role as an engaged superpower and the Republican Party's growing isolationist wing. He added that Pakistan increasingly views the US as "entirely pro-Indian," further complicating Washington's potential as a trusted mediator—a stark contrast to 2016 and 2019, when American diplomacy helped de-escalate tensions following the Uri and Pulwama attacks.
Alternative international mediators appear equally problematic. Zakaria dismissed China as untrustworthy despite its influence with Pakistan, noted India's historical reluctance toward United Nations involvement, and pointed to the European Union's limited geopolitical-military presence as factors leaving India with few external support options.
"This is the post-American world that I am worried about," Zakaria warned. "The dangers of conflict spiraling out of control are real. India is trying to signal a more measured approach, and you have to hope that at some point Pakistan realizes this is not a conflict they can win."
Beijing's response has been notably cautious. Despite calling Pakistan its "all-weather friend," China has refrained from offering strong support, merely expressing willingness to play a "constructive role" while characterizing both nations as "neighbors."
Zakaria concluded that this "fortress America" mentality—prioritizing tariffs and trade over international stability—creates dangerous conditions for regional conflicts to intensify without the diplomatic guardrails previously provided by American moral authority and diplomatic engagement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
32 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Indian govt report in 2022 foresaw China rare earth export crisis
As Indian manufacturers are scrambling to deal with supply-chain disruptions caused by China's restrictive policies on the export of rare earth metals, in many of which it has a near monopoly, experts are pointing to an early warning of this — in a 2012 strategy paper prepared by a steering committee headed by the then mines secretary Vishwapati Trivedi after a similar crisis caused after Beijing restricted supplies of the critical materials that are needed in the auto, space and clean energy industries. Also Read: 'China deal done': US to lower tariffs to 55%, allow Chinese students for higher ed Back then, they added, India felt the heat of Chinese squeeze and on August 9, 2011, the government set up an 11-member steering committee to develop a strategy paper on status and availability of rare earth elements (REE) and energy critical elements (ECE). The committee was chaired by the mines secretary and co-chaired by chairman of the Centre for Study of Science Technology (C-STEP). Members included senior officials and experts from the Department of Science & Technology (DST), the Geological Survey of India, the Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC), the Department of Atomic Energy, the Defence Research & Development Organization (DRDO) and the chairman of India Rare Earth Ltd. Also Read: China can't afford double standards in fight against terror: S Jaishankar The forward of the committee's report titled ''Rare Earths and Energy Critical Elements: a Roadmap and Strategy for India', published in July 2012, said: 'In view of the increased demand of REE and near monopoly of supply from China, there is a need to develop national policies and implementation strategies for ensuring indigenous supply of REE… A Steering Committee was constituted by the ministry of mines with the ultimate intention of preparing a strategy paper for the government, providing short, medium and long term options along with proposals for specific policy & legislative interventions.' Also Read: 'Gratitude to Indian Navy': China on rescue of crew aboard cargo ship which caught fire off Kerala coast The report was blunt about Beijing's approach. 'China has been the major supplier of rare earths all over the world. Even though it has only 37% of global RE resources, it has captured the worldwide market to the extent of 97%. The low cost and efficient production process enabled China to monopolize the rare-earth market, forcing rare earth operations around the world to close down. Indian Rare Earths Ltd (IREL), which was once a leader in export of rare earth compounds had to shut down its operation in 2008,' the report added. 'Over the last couple of years China has imposed restrictions and curtailed its export by over 30% citing domestic demands as the reason. This unexpected decline has restarted rare earth operations once again throughout the world,' the report said. The same thing is happening again. Indian industries are suffering due to shortage of the critical minerals. According to a Reuters report published in Hindustan Times on Wednesday, automobile majors such as Maruti Suzuki have cut near-term production targets because of rare earth shortages. 'Government departments, particularly the ministry of commerce and industry, are holding hectic meetings with industry and other stakeholders to resolve the supply crisis. Government is using diplomatic channels asking Beijing to relax supply curbs for the Indian industries,' one of the people mentioned in the first instance said. The ministries of mines, commerce and external affairs did not respond to an email query on this matter. China's curbs on exports of rare earth materials have been officially raised through diplomatic channels by India, especially in view of the impact on manufacturers of electric vehicles, people familiar with the matter said. The issue reportedly figured in a meeting between Indian ambassador Pradeep Rawat and China's vice foreign minister Sun Weidong in Beijing on June 5. 'China's move was primarily aimed at the US and the impact on India was collateral damage. We are hopeful that the matter will be resolved soon,' one of the people said. It is not clear how China's deal with the US —the two countries reached a framework agreement that will now have to be approved by their respective Presidents —will affect this. The matter is expected to figure in discussions during a visit to India by Sun Weidong, a former Chinese ambassador to New Delhi, beginning on Thursday, the people said. Sun is visiting India to continue discussions with foreign secretary Vikram Misri aimed at normalising bilateral ties following the end of the military face-off in the Ladakh sector of the Line of Actual Control (LAC) last October. Auto manufacturers affected by the curbs on rare earth exports too have sought to reach out to Chinese authorities but without much success so far, the people said. Two days after India and China reached an understanding on withdrawing forces from the two remaining 'friction points' on the LAC last October, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and President Xi Jinping met in the Russian city of Kazan and agreed to revive several mechanisms to restore normalcy in ties and to address the long-standing border dispute.
Hindustan Times
39 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
PM Modi lays out governance roadmap for Delhi leadership
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Wednesday offered the Bharatiya Janata Party's newly elected Delhi leadership a blend of administrative direction and personal wisdom, laying out a roadmap for effective governance, as he held a marathon three-hour meeting with Delhi chief minister Rekha Gupta, her cabinet, all seven BJP Members of Parliament (MPs) from Delhi, party MLAs, and senior leaders of the city unit. Also Read: BJP hails 11 'golden'years of Modi as PM In the meeting at 7 Lok Kalyan Marg, which began at 6.30pm and continued till 9.30pm, the Prime Minister emphasised that good governance is not only about schemes and performance metrics but also about conduct, accessibility, and genuine connection with the people. The gathering was described by those present as both strategic and motivational in nature. Also Read: Mallikarjun Kharge's dig at PM Modi: 'There has been no one like him' 'Interacted with Delhi BJP MPs, MLAs and other leaders. We had extensive discussions on ways to improve quality of life for the people of Delhi,' Modi posted on X after the meeting. CM Gupta posted on X: 'Every meeting with Honourable Prime Minister Shri @narendramodi ji is a wonderful experience. Today I met the honourable MPs, MLAs and senior party leaders of Delhi and received their guidance. His commitment towards Delhi gives a clear direction and new energy to 'Team Delhi'. The life of the Prime Minister and his complete dedication to the nation is an inspiration for all of us. Under his leadership, we are working with full dedication towards making Delhi a developed capital.' Also Read: 'Proud': PM meets Tharoor, other members of key Operation Sindoor outreach delegations According to multiple people in attendance, the Prime Minister guided the party leadership on ensuring last-mile delivery of government schemes, strengthening public outreach, and maintaining personal integrity and humility in public life. He urged the leaders to stay grounded, be responsive to people's concerns, and work with energy and empathy. 'The Prime Minister told us that 'vyavhaar (personal conduct)' and 'lokachar (public etiquette)' are what truly connect a leader with people. He asked us to be accessible, patient, and focused on the welfare of every Delhiite,' said a BJP MLA who attended the meeting, asking not to be identified. Another BJP leader, also requesting anonymity, said Modi's address focused not just on policy implementation but also on mindset. 'He encouraged us to be among the people and use every ounce of energy in service. We were reminded that governance isn't a checklist—it's a daily responsibility to improve lives,' the leader said. The BJP returned to power in Delhi after 27 years with a sweeping win in the February 2025 assembly elections. The party won 48 of the 70 seats, unseating the Arvind Kejriwal-led Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), which had ruled the Capital since 2015. Both Kejriwal and his former deputy Manish Sisodia lost their seats. Since forming the government, chief minister Rekha Gupta has moved quickly to align Delhi's governance with central schemes. The Ayushman Bharat Yojana, the Centre's flagship health insurance scheme, was among the first to be implemented. The Prime Minister has also reviewed progress on the cleaning of the Yamuna—a major campaign priority for the BJP. The meeting came as the BJP marked the 11th anniversary of its National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government and the first year of its third consecutive term at the Centre. In Delhi, the party is celebrating 100 days of its return to power. Ahead of the interaction, BJP MLA from Uttam Nagar Pawan Sharma told PTI, 'PM Modi had envisioned a 'Viksit Bharat, Viksit Delhi' before the elections. That vision is now becoming a reality. Issues such as drinking water, sewage systems and cleanliness that were long ignored are being actively addressed. We met PM Modi to seek his blessings and renew our commitment.'
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
SC junks Pakistani Christian's plea for citizenship ignoring CAA cut-off
Supreme Court NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Wednesday refused to entertain the plea of a Goa-born Pakistani Catholic man, who sought a direction to the Centre to allow him citizenship under Citizenship Amendment Act , 2019 citing religious persecution in Pakistan even though he arrived in India six years after the Jan 2014 cutoff date. Jude Mendes, who was born in Goa to a Pakistani national in 1987 but completed his studies at Karachi in Pakistan, arrived in India in 2016 on a long-term visa which has been extended till June this year and even got his Aadhaar card made in 2020. He married an Indian woman in February this year. Three days after the Pahalgam terror attack on tourists by Pak-backed terrorists, India on April 25 cancelled all kinds of visas given to Pakistani nationals. However, long term visas, which Mendes has, have not been revoked. Mendes' visa expires on June 20. Advocate Raghav Awasthi told a partial working day bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Manmohan that "the Petitioner is born in India and is a Roman Catholic which being a minority community is heavily persecuted in Pakistan. He cannot travel to Pakistan to renew his passport which is expiring on 20.06.2025 due to the threat to his life and that therefore, he ought to be granted extension of his long-term visa. " The petitioner said in the event of his deportation to Pakistan, the petitioner who was born in India and now lawfully married to an Indian citizen, would face imminent threat to his life because of extreme religious persecution in Pakistan. At present he works as a chef in Goa. But the bench said that he would have to move the Bombay HC for the relief he is seeking. The petitioner's lawyer withdrew the plea to move the HC. Under CAA, India had resolved to grant citizenship to those individuals from minority communities who have been persecuted in neighbouring countries on the ground of religion. However, the law stipulated that they should have entered India prior to Jan 1, 2014.
