Athens couple out $9,000 after contractor never finishes job

Yahoo

07-05-2025

ATHENS, Tenn. (WATE) — A couple in Athens has taken every step possible to get the contractor they hired to return and finish the work he started three months ago.
Johnny and Amy Guillot realize now that they made a mistake by paying their contractor upfront. They paid the contractor more than $9,000, but the couple says he's never worked a full day and has come up with a lot of excuses. He did start the job, which was supposed to take less than a week, but then he quit and hasn't returned.
Bean Station sewer project gets $1.5 million in state funding
Amy Guillot and her husband operate a canine obedience and training business. The couple also boards dogs of all sizes at their home. They hired a contractor to lay flooring in their hallway, but it is now coming apart. They also paid him to install a new ceiling in their basement, add four new light fixtures and add structures to level the floor above their basement. None of this work was done.
Dip in the Guillot's basement celling (WATE)
'He was supposed to relevel the entire upper floor of the house. So we got gaps up there. Here you can see that there is a dip. And significantly, this dips really good. This area is part of the main concern on both sides of the basement,' said Amy Guillot.
There is new flooring in the bedroom and down the hallway. The workmanship is questionable, though. Amy Guillot pointed to incomplete work.
Gov. Bill Lee issues first-ever veto to reject bill making it easier to deny parole
'We're missing baseboards. Not done, not complete. In here, well, we've got a hole in the wall. He never put all of the baseboards up. All these baseboards are lying all over the place. It's kind of like a jigsaw puzzle of baseboards that belong everywhere,' said Amy Guillot.
Missing baseboards on Guillot's floors (WATE)
Gap in the Guillot's flooring (WATE)
Hole in the wall of the Guillot's home (WATE)
Baseboards stacked inside the Guillot's home (WATE)
Baseboards stacked inside the Guillot's home (WATE)
Flooring popping up at the Guillot's home (WATE)
'We just wanted someone to put some flooring in for us and have the job done. That was it. It was that simple. He said he could do it in three to four days,' said Johnny Guillot.
The contract was signed in February and the couple paid him everything upfront.
'He hasn't been here in over a month,' said Amy Guillot. 'Unfortunately, this floor here is coming apart already because it is not complete. There is supposed to be some trim work right there. He did not put a transition at the top of the stairs. Since he never did that there is nothing pushing against the floor to keep it in place, so it is popping up pretty good.'
The contractor is Jerry Gardner from Decatur. He calls his business Home Improvement.
'Amy sent many messages to him and said, 'Hey, are you coming today?' 'Yes, I'm on my way.' Never shows up and that's happened numerous times,' said Johnny Guillot.
Buddy's Bar-B-Q reopens on East Magnolia Avenue after 2024 fire
The couple said Gardner claims to be licensed and insured.
'Amy Guillot explained,' Amy Guillot explained. 'He will not furnish the insurance. When I asked him about the license, he said he has a business license.'
They sent a demand letter on April 14, giving Gardner 10 days to respond. He didn't.
Demand letter sent to Gardner by Amy and Johnny Guillot.
'At this point, I don't know anymore. I don't know, I want him to come finish the job, considering that it is not even good work,' said Amy Guillot.
She wrote about her experience with Gardner on Facebook.
'I have had several people who have come forward after I made a post on social media. I was shocked because numerous people came forward to tell me they were having the same problem,' she said.
She has tried to get in touch with Gardner for weeks.
'I'm blocked. He will not take my call. He will not answer my messages,' said Amy Guillot.
So, we called Jerry Gardner on our phone, thinking maybe he'll answer. He didn't. We left a message on Gardner's other phone. There's been no response.
'I really prefer that we just get the materials so we can move on and hire someone else. Maybe some part of a reimbursement, so we can pay someone else to do the job correctly,' said Amy Guillot.
READ: More top stories on WATE.com
The Guillots have filed a complaint against Gardner with the state Department of Commerce and Insurance. They have also sent one more demand letter to him. When hiring a home improvement contractor, payments are made in stages, with a deposit upfront ranging from 10% to 25% to secure the contractor's services and materials. Remaining payments are made at specific project milestones, and the final payment is typically due after the project is complete. In this case, the project is far from being finished.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to WATE 6 On Your Side.