
‘I spent 12 hours a day for 16 months with Gene Hackman – but never met him': The Conversation's Walter Murch pays tribute
I never formally met Gene Hackman. I glimpsed him once, in November 1972, when he bounded upstairs to the offices of American Zoetrope in San Francisco, but I didn't recognise him until he told the receptionist that he was here to see Mona Skager.
Francis Ford Coppola's film The Conversation was about to start shooting in two weeks, and Mona was Francis's associate producer. I was to be the film's editor. That brief and solitary glimpse of Gene in real life was counterbalanced by 16 months of daily screen contact with Harry Caul, the character brought to life by Hackman.
This was my first job as editor of a feature film, and I was in alternating states of excitement and terror. Previously, I had edited some commercials, a couple of short documentaries and one educational film. I had also done the sound design for The Rain People and The Godfather, Coppola's two previous feature films, as well as the sound design for George Lucas's feature THX 1138.
But editing The Conversation was a big turn up the spiral for me, which explained the excitement. The terror was induced by the fact that this was the next film by the director who had just transfixed the world with The Godfather. If The Conversation failed, for whatever reason, much of the blame would fall on the shoulders of this young and inexperienced editor.
The relationship between actors and film editors is a classic case of asymmetry: editors stare at actors 10 to 12 hours a day, sometimes more, and we microscopically study their every move, flinch, blink, gesture and inflection. We become actor-anthropologists, students of this strange tribe, and we inhale their rhythms which become second nature to us, and then translate them into the editing style and pacing of the film.
In a certain sense, we know this narrow spectrum of an actor better than anyone – perhaps in some cases better than the actors themselves. If we later meet them in person, this asymmetry really makes itself felt; they frequently have no idea who we are, other than appendages of the director, but we have all that secret and microscopic knowledge: how they prefer to turn left rather than right, their characteristic way of hesitating before opening a door, how often they blink …
There were many times, often at 3am in the morning, when Harry would push a button on his tape recorder, stopping it, and so closely did I identify with him that I would be amazed to find my KEM editing machine still running, having not obeyed Harry's command.
During one session, another all-nighter, I finally noticed that very close to where I would decide to make a cut, Harry would blink. Was I controlling Harry, or was he controlling me? This confusion was ultimately resolved: the cut is a blink, and this realisation, triggered by Gene's performance, became one of the foundational ideas of my book on film editing, In the Blink of an Eye, first published in 1992.
So in a very real sense, the integrity of Hackman's performance provided the metronomic spine which supported and guided me, often without my knowing it, to find the correct pacing for each scene, and then the right structure of the collection of those scenes in the finished film. I shudder to think what would have happened if Harry had been performed by someone else.
So I was hit hard by the news of Gene's death for all kinds of reasons – I am a huge fan of his work across five decades of American cinema – but particularly because of the guidance and inspiration he gave me implicitly during the editing of The Conversation. I never had the opportunity to thank him personally for helping me to become the film-maker that I am today. So I do that now: 'Thank you, Gene.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mirror
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Chaos hits Love Island with Hideaway passion, couple swap and liar caught out
It was all kicking off on Love Island 2025 on Wednesday, with multiple couples swapping it seemed, hidden kisses, two Islanders caught up in a lie and two visits to the Hideaway There was plenty of drama on Love Island on Wednesday night, with two Islanders sharing a secret kiss, while other cast members got to know people outside of their pairing. It looked as though there was some couple swapping on the cards, while there were also two visits to the steamy Hideaway where Islanders tend to give into passion. We saw one pairing who are not currently a couple making a secret visit with another planned. We then saw two others, again not paired up, sharing a steamy smooch in the private bedroom. That wasn't all though as a row sparked a split, leading to one girl grafting hard and one boy being rather awkwardly rejected. There was also a "lie", as two islanders shared different versions of the same events and it risked tearing apart a couple it involved. As the two Islanders caught up in it confronted each other, another Islander took the moment to get to know someone else behind their backs. It's save to say the latest episode was the most chaotic yet of the series, while we are barely a week in. As Toni and Ben clash, leading to them calling it a day, both Islanders graft with other cast members looking for a new connection. Toni was seen telling Conor she thinks he's hot, while not long after she told Dejon she had her eye on him. he told her getting to know people is what they're here to do so should Meg be worried? As for Ben, it didn't go to plan for him when his first thought was to go running back to Shakira. She wasn't interested amid her partnering up with Harry, telling Ben it's Harry she's keen on but she is still happy to chat with him and get to know him. Another male soon made a play for Shakira as Blu pulled her for a flirty chat, while Shakira was initially unaware that Harry had snuck off to the Hideaway with co-star Helena. They joked about waiting until everyone was asleep before revisiting the room for some fun. Harry couldn't take the "lying" though, telling Shakira about their chats leaving her stunned but almost impressed by Helena saying "fair play". With the double bombshell arrival came a game of dares though, with Islanders getting steamy with people they're not paired up with, and a moment during the proceedings left Shakira annoyed. She was told that Harry had his hands on both hers and Helena's legs during the game after the lap dance. He denied this claiming that's not how he remembered it, but it clearly rattled Shakira. Not only that but Harry whispered to Helena about the Hideaway when she was right there. He was also visibly furious when Ben kissed Shakira during the dares. With Harry later questioning the claim about the lapdance and asking Helena what she said and why, things got a little awkward as Shakira told him off. As for Shakira, she snuck off to the Hideaway with Blu and they shared a secret kiss behind Harry's back.


Scottish Sun
36 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Love Island fans can't believe the age gap between Shakira and Harry as they can't keep their hands off each other
LOVE Island fans are stunned after realising the age gap between Shakira Khan and Harry Cooksley. In tonight's episode of Love Island, things continued to heat up between model Shakira and semi-professional footballer Harry. 2 Shakira and Harry got close in tonight's episode Credit: Eroteme 2 But fans had a strong reaction after realising the age gap between them Credit: Eroteme But as they explored their potential romance, viewers took to social media to share their thoughts on the fact Shakira is 22 while Harry is 30. One wrote: 'Shakira is 22??? Get her away from Harry and his 30 year old ass immediately!!' Someone else said: 'I just deeped the age gap with Shakira and Harry…' And another commented: 'Harry and Shakira look good together but he is 30.' But the age gap doesn't seem to be an issue for Harry and Shakira, who made their attraction to each other very clear. Last night Harry found himself caught up in the brutal first dumping of the series. During the first recoupling, Shakira picked Harry - meaning Sophie Lee was left single and immediately sent packing. But fans are convinced that Shakira isn't into Harry and actually has her eye on Blu Chegini. Many insisted that she only picked Harry so her pal Helena Ford wouldn't be sent home. One fan wrote: 'Shakira well wanted to pick Conor but didn't wanna send Helena home and for that I kinda respect it. First person dumped from Love Island revealed 'But also she'd suit Conor well better.' Another viewer added: 'No way she picked Harry for any reason other than she wanted the other women to stay… I simply don't believe it.'


Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Love Island fans demand change as they fume brutal twist was 'for nothing'
Love Island 2025 viewers were not impressed by the shenanigans during Wednesday's episode as they said it meant one brutal twist 'was for nothing' and didn't need to happen It's safe to say many Love Island fans wanted a change to the show, after a brutal dumping the day before. But it was the actions of some Islanders in particular that left viewers fuming, suggesting a twist "had been for nothing". On Tuesday night we saw fan favourite Sophie Lee axed from the show. Her partner Harry had been stolen by Shakira, leaving her single and dropped from the villa. But in the latest episode on Wednesday we saw hints that both Harry and Shakira were interested in others. Not only did Shakira hear out Ben, but a teaser revealed scenes with Blu. Then there was Harry who was keen to get to know Helena, leaving fans convinced both Harry and Shakira would not stay together. This would mean, according to viewers, poor Sophie went home for nothing. She only left because Shakira chosen Harry, and now it seems she might not even want to stay with him. Viewers raced to X over the scenes calling out the dumping twist, saying the wrong person left. They also claimed the twist was "for nothing" and Sophie didn't even need to leave. One fan said: "Shakira is not feeling Harry, Sophie went home for nothing." Another fan said: "Producers were wrong for dumping Sophie idc," as a third posted: "So what was the point of sending Sophie home if you will end up kissing Blu?" Another post said: "So Shakira chose Harry who actually likes Helena, but Shakira then kisses Blu anyway, so Sophie left for nothing?" A further fan wrote: "So basically Sophie went for no reason at all...." It comes as viewers confessed they think they already know which former Love Island star is set to enter the famous second villa, Casa Amor. Some viewers are now convinced Sophie's time on the show isn't over. With a recent series seeing a dumped girl return to the villa for Casa Amor, viewers are now speculating Sophie will be back on the show in a matter of weeks, as a bombshell in the second villa. Taking to X, fans guessed the twist would happen with one fan writing: "I reckon Sophie will re-enter the villa as a bombshell by the end of next week at the latest or she will re-enter in Casa Amor." Another said: "Dw Sophie you'll be back in 4 weeks for Casa Amor." A third viewer begged: "Nah bring Sophie back for Casa Amor she deserves a chance." A fourth fan agreed: "Bring her back for casa amor!!" as a fifth viewer posted: "Gutted for her and bring back Sophie as a bombshell or Casa Amor." The comments kept on coming with one reading: "They better bring Sophie back as a Casa bombshell. Justice for Sophie." Another said: "BRING SOPHIE BACK FOR CASA AMOR!" It comes after Sophie was axed from the show in the latest episode. Despite not initially being at risk of an early exit, the motivational speaker and author was abruptly booted out of the villa after her man Harry was chosen by newly single Shakira. Love Island 2025 airs every night at 9PM on ITV2 and ITVX. * Follow Mirror Celebs and TV on TikTok, Snapchat, Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and Threads.