Labour blocks proposal for ‘swift bricks' in all new homes in England
The amendment to the bill to ask every developer to provide a £35 hollow brick for swifts, house martins, sparrows and starlings, which was tabled by Labour MP Barry Gardiner, has been rejected by the Labour-dominated committee.
Despite the Labour party having supported the swift brick amendment when it was tabled on Conservative government legislation in 2023, housing minister, Matthew Pennycook, told the House of Commons committee: 'We are not convinced that legislating to mandate the use of specific wildlife features is the right approach, whether that is done through building regulations or a freestanding legal requirement.'
A new petition calling for swift bricks to be made mandatory for new homes has rapidly reached 80,000 signatures in recent days, two years after activist Hannah Bourne-Taylor won a parliamentary debate to help the rapidly declining migratory birds after 109,896 voters signed a government petition.
Bourne-Taylor said there appeared to be 'no logic' to the government's opposition to swift bricks when they precisely meet its ambition of creating win-wins for the economy and nature.
'They are going to be building millions of bricks into walls. I don't understand why there's such a problem with a brick with a hole in it. It seems ludicrous,' she said. 'Why say your new legislation is a win-win for new homes and the environment and exclude the only measure that is a true win-win?
'They are tone-deaf. This is such a tiny thing they could do, but it's brewing such a distrust and sense of betrayal among the people who voted for them.'
Although some housebuilders are incorporating swift bricks in new builds, a recent University of Sheffield study found that 75% of bird and bat boxes demanded as a condition of planning permission for new housing developments had failed to materialise when the housing estates were complete.
Asked if he would meet MPs to discuss how to encourage the building industry to adopt swift bricks more widely, Pennycook said he would be happy to have conversations with MPs despite claiming his correctly reported opposition to mandatory cavity-nesting bricks had been 'spun' in a Guardian report.
These comments follow Pennycook's recent defence of the planning bill's proposed amendments to the Protection of Badgers Act that MPs warned would lead to 'hostile treatment' of the much-persecuted animal in which the minister joked: 'I would just like to make very clear, for the Guardian article that will no doubt appear tomorrow, that I have no particular animus against badgers in whatever form.'
Bourne-Taylor said she hoped that the swift brick amendment would now be championed by the House of Lords.
If that fails, Bourne-Taylor hopes to take her campaign to the wider public once again. The rising new petition for swift bricks 'just goes to show the public concern,' she said. 'The government are not listening to the public or the experts.'
• The headline and text of this article were amended on 29 May 2025 to make clear that the proposed amendment had applied only to England.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Call to close iconic former Crossroads TV motel at centre of asylum seekers row
It was the memorable setting for the iconic Crossroads TV series and in its hotel heyday the Ramada in Sutton Coldfield was a highly rated haven for tourists and business customers, lured in by its pool, gym, gardens and conference facilities. Now there is a clamour for it to be shut down after it spent its recent life as a temporary home for asylum seekers desperate to start a new life in the UK. Local residents and the area's MP Sir Andrew Mitchell wants it closed with immediate effect, claiming it is an unsuitable location. READ MORE: Consultation launched into parking charges at major Birmingham parks and some say 'it's wrong' Mitchell, Conservative MP for Sutton Coldfield, wants the venue to shut amid community tension and protest. He has now announced that a delegation from the Home Office and Serco will join him and immediate neighbours to the hotel for a fact finding visit next month. He says the hotel is in the 'wrong place' for asylum seekers, who he claims would be better off placed 'in inner city Birmingham ' close to refugee support services. Birmingham Live inquiries have revealed the owners raked in more than £4 million in net profits in a year as a result of its contract to host asylum seekers sent to the region by the Home Office. Some local residents agree with their MP, with the local Facebook group full of claims and comments from some neighbours who say they feel 'intimidated and fearful'. One claimed that the hotel residents had 'trashed' the venue and residents were 'wary' of using a new walkway that cuts in front of the venue, with claims of 'loitering', litter and damage. Others say the fears are rooted in misinformation and prejudice. They point out that the residents of the hotel have little choice but to hang around the venue, playing football and chatting, as they receive only a tiny weekly allowance and few have a right to work. In a post shared with his constituents yesterday evening, Friday August 15, he wrote: 'I am acutely aware of the concerns the asylum hostel at the former Ramada Hotel is causing - which is why I have been seeking its closure since it opened. 'I want to reassure Sutton residents that I will soon be taking representatives from the Home Office and accommodation provider Serco on a visit to the site, prompted by questions raised by constituents. 'I will also be meeting a group of local people living nearby ahead of the visit, which will allow me not only to see how the hostel is being run, but also specifically to raise their concerns. 'It is clear that the Ramada is a totally inappropriate location for an asylum hostel; it would be far better for it to be located in the centre of Birmingham, where the relevant services would be located nearby. 'The last government committed to closing it, however I have so far been unable to extract a promise of closure from the current Labour government. 'I aim to persuade the Home Secretary that it should be closed as soon as possible.' A protest was held at the gates to the venue last Friday, drawing a crowd of up to 50 people, with more planned. Critics also claim that the asylum seekers are 'making it more difficult' for people to access health services, get council homes and live in peace and this was concerning. But one resident posted: "I'm just as concerned about how successful the right wing politicians and media have been in brainwashing people. Some of the utter tripe on this post is shameful." They also said it was ludicrous to suggest the asylum seeker population was responsible for local issues like a lack of GP appointments, crumbling infrastructure and a housing shortage. "If someone's causing genuine issues locally, absolutely deal with it so we can all live harmoniously. But let's aim our frustration at the people actually pulling the strings and work together for a community that's fair, welcoming, and strong," they added. Amid fears of more local protests at this and other hotels housing asylum seekers, West Midlands Police urged residents to keep the peace. Assistant Chief Constable Paul Drover said: "We understand the concerns people have about their communities and will always balance the right to freedom of expression with the need to tackle crime. "We have strong relationships with our communities and continue to build trust with them to come and speak to us. We urge communities to carefully consider information that they read, share and trust and if in doubt we would always encourage them to speak to us or their community leaders. "In the West Midlands, we have seen a small number of peaceful protests - (last weekend) we saw very low numbers at two protests in Wolverhampton and Solihull that passed off peacefully. However, we have assisted in providing support to other forces as part of national contingency plans. "Our priority is always to keep people safe and in every decision around policing, public order and protests we must balance the right to freedom of expression with the right to tackle crime so we can ensure public safety. "The right to peaceful and lawful protest is a fundamental element of any democracy, and we are committed to upholding and facilitating this." Who owns and runs the former Ramada venue? The Johal family including directors Iqbal, Balkar, Balraj, Jasbir and Sarnpal, own the hotel through their company Sutton Coldfield Hotel Ltd. In their most recent published accounts, for 2023-24, the company made after-tax profits of £4,583,509, off the back of a turnover of £9.5 million. In their notes to the accounts, the owners say they plan to continue to provide asylum accommodation services and expect to continue to see demand grow in the coming years 'as there is still significant demand to accommodate asylum seekers on a short term basis'. The accounts also note that as a result 'the company is undergoing a period of growing profits. The funds have been invested in reducing a significant amount of the company debt, meaning liquidity risk has diminished significantly.' The report also adds: "Maintaining strong relationships with the government contract provider, whilst maintaining the quality of service, has mitigated the risk of competitive bids who may look to undercut the current agreed rates." We have tried in vain to get hold of the Johal family or their representatives. The Ramada Hotel in Sutton Coldfield, previously known as Penns Hall Hotel, was a hotel and country club situated on Penns Lane, Walmley. It's a Grade B locally listed building, originally a private residence, and later became part of Ramada International. It is located on 14 acres of mature grounds, featuring a tree-lined driveway and a lake. During the 1980s, the hotel became famous as the location for exterior filming of the TV soap opera Crossroads. The hotel filled in as the Crossroads Motel, later known as the Kings Oak Country Hotel, and the entrance to the real hotel's conference facilities was dressed to look like the main entrance to the fictional hotel. A shot of some of the hotel rooms overlooking Penns Lake, which is on the hotel's land, were used as part of the closing credits to the show.
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Schwarzenegger taunts Newsom with message targeting Dem redistricting push
Former California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger is pumping up for a new fight. The longtime Hollywood action star, the last Republican governor in Democrat-dominated California, says he's mobilizing to oppose the push by current Gov. Gavin Newsom to temporarily scrap the state's nonpartisan redistricting commission. 'I'm getting ready for the gerrymandering battle,' Schwarzenegger wrote in a social media post Friday, which included a photo of the former professional bodybuilding champion lifting weights. Schwarzenegger, who rose to worldwide fame as the star of the film 'The Terminator' four decades ago, wore a T-shirt in the photo that said 'terminate gerrymandering.' The social media post by Schwarzenegger comes as Democratic leaders in the Democrat- dominated California legislature are moving forward with new proposed congressional district maps that would create up to five more blue-leaning US House seats in the nation's most populous state. Newsom on Thursday teamed up in Los Angeles with congressional Democrats and legislative leaders in the heavily blue state to unveil their redistricting playbook. 4 Arnold Schwarzenegger wears a 'F*** The Politicians. Terminate Gerrymandering' shirt while working out. Arnold Schwarzenegger/X Newsom and the Democrats are aiming to counter the ongoing effort by President Donald Trump and Republicans to create up to five GOP-friendly congressional districts in red state Texas at the expense of Democrat-controlled seats. 'Today is liberation day in the state of California,' Newsom said. 'Donald Trump, you have poked the bear, and we will punch back.' Newsom vowed to 'meet fire with fire' with his push for a rare — but not unheard of — mid-decade redistricting. 4 California Gov. Gavin Newsom embraces former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger at a news conference in Los Angeles, Calif. on March 22, 2024. Los Angeles Times via Getty Imag The Republican push in Texas, which comes at Trump's urging, is part of a broader effort by the GOP across the country to pad its razor-thin House majority to keep control of the chamber in the 2026 midterms, when the party in power traditionally faces political headwinds and loses seats. Trump and his political team are aiming to prevent what happened during his first term in the White House, when Democrats stormed back to grab the House majority in the 2018 midterms. While the Republican push in Texas to upend the current congressional maps doesn't face constitutional constraints, Newsom's path in California is much more complicated. The governor is pushing to hold a special election this year to get voter approval to undo the constitutional amendments that created the nonpartisan redistricting commission. A two-thirds majority vote in the Democrat-dominated California legislature as early as next week would be needed to hold the referendum. Democratic Party leaders are confident they'll have the votes to push the constitutional amendment and the new proposed congressional maps through the legislature. 'Here we are in open and plain sight before one vote is cast in the 2026 midterm election, and here [Trump] is once again trying to rig the system,' Newsom charged. Newsom said his plan is 'not complicated. We're doing this in reaction to a president of the United States that called a sitting governor in the state of Texas and said, 'Find me five seats.' We're doing it in reaction to that act.' 4 The proposed Congressional district map of California. California State Assembly The National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC) said 'Newsom's made it clear: he'll shred California's Constitution and trample over democracy — running a cynical, self-serving playbook where Californians are an afterthought, and power is the only priority.' But Newsom defended his actions, saying 'we're working through a very transparent, temporary and public process. We're putting the maps on the ballot and putting the power to the people.' Thursday's appearance by Newsom, considered a likely contender for the 2028 Democratic presidential nomination, also served as a fundraising kickoff to raise massive amounts of campaign cash needed to sell the redistricting push statewide in California. The nonpartisan redistricting commission, created over 15 years ago, remains popular among most Californians, according to public opinion polling. That's why Newsom and California Democratic lawmakers are promising not to scrap the commission entirely, but rather replace it temporarily by the legislature for the next three election cycles. 'We will affirm our commitment to the state independent redistricting after the 2030 census, but we are asking the voters for their consent to do midterm redistricting,' Newsom said. Their efforts are opposed by a number of people supportive of the nonpartisan commission. 4 Calif. Gov. Gavin Newsom speaks during a rally about redistricting at the Democracy Center, Japanese American National Museum in Los Angeles on Aug. 14, 2025. Getty Images Among the most visible members is likely to be Schwarzenegger. 'He calls gerrymandering evil, and he means that. He thinks it's truly evil for politicians to take power from people,' Schwarzenegger spokesperson Daniel Ketchell told Politico earlier this month. 'He's opposed to what Texas is doing, and he's opposed to the idea that California would race to the bottom to do the same thing.' Schwarzenegger, during his tenure as governor, had a starring role in the passage of constitutional amendments in California in 2008 and 2010 that took the power to draw state legislative and congressional districts away from politicians and placed it in the hands of an independent commission. 'Most people don't really think about an independent commission much, one way or another. And that's both an opportunity and a challenge for Newsom,' Jack Pitney, an American politics professor at California's Claremont McKenna College, told Fox News. 'It's going to take a lot of effort and money to energize Democrats and motivate them to show up at the polls,' Pitney said, adding Newsom's effort 'is all about motivating people who don't like Trump.' Fox News' Lee Ross contributed to this report
Bloomberg
2 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Italians as Well Off as Brits Expose UK's Era of Stagnation
The UK economy has lost its edge over Italy and slipped further behind France over the past decade, according to per head gross domestic product figures that reveal a stark underperformance fueled by a population surge, high inflation and tepid growth. The findings will ring alarm bells in Keir Starmer's government, which is looking at how much the economy generates for each resident rather than aggregate output as a gauge of the living standards it has pledged to improve. GDP per capita was stagnant last year when Labour took office and fell in 2023.
